Review Overview Matthew Rhys is exceptional in this funny, atmospheric, surprising and properly scary horror comedy. | On 04, May 2026 You know how the story goes. A small-town mayor wants to open up to tourists, just as the community becomes threatened by an unspoken danger. Naturally, the town authorities don’t listen to the warnings and bad things start to happen. Maybe it’s a shark or maybe, in the case of Widow’s Bay, it’s an eerie fog.