Where Peter Is
Blog
This site was conceived by a group of faithful Catholics who have become increasingly concerned about the attacks from within the Church on Pope Francis and his teachings. Over the entirety of his pontificate, he has been accused by radical traditionalists and dogmatic rigorists of deliberately spreading confusion, teaching error, and even being a heretic.
While the group challenging Francis’ pontificate is relatively small, their ranks include prominent laypeople, priests, bishops, and even cardinals. Many of Francis’ fiercest critics have strong voices in the media: in print, on television, and on the web. In many cases, these critics have anointed themselves as the arbiters of orthodoxy, and have accused those who continue to stand with the pope of holding views that dissent from the teaching of the Church.
Because Francis’s critics are such a small faction, many of their accusations and assertions have gone unchecked. They complain that their concerns are serious, but they are dismissed and their points are not addressed by those who support the pope.
The authors at this site have decided to take up their challenge, both by providing links to resources from other sites and by providing original essays that argue in favor of the orthodoxy and faithfulness of the Holy Father. Additionally, we’ll write about the major themes and important topics that surround the Church, especially in light of the pontificate of Pope Francis.
Where Peter is, there is the Church. Source
Actions
Media Outlet details
| Scope | International |
|---|---|
| Language | English |
| Country | United States of America |
|
Similarweb UVM |
Request pricing |
|
Comscore UVM |
Request pricing |
Recent Articles
Search ArticlesThe Pope is a Shepherd, Not Just Head of State
The Vatican has clarified the role of the Pope in the wake of a controversial statement by US Ambassador to the Holy See, Brian Burch. The Holy Father’s “one true mission” is to be a spiritual shepherd who proclaims the Gospel. Any other roles he plays, including his position as a head of state, are in service to this mission and must not be interpreted as superseding it.
Traddyland: A Memoir the Church Needs Now
Compared with other high-demand and fundamentalist religious movements, radical Catholic traditionalism has produced remarkably few memoirs by those who have experienced it from within.
Spiritual Abuse Workshop
Through the Scriptures, Tradition, liturgies, and devotions, people can encounter the living Christ and experience his love, healing, and freedom. But what happens when the women and men in the Church who are tasked with teaching doctrine, preaching God’s word, or presiding over the sacraments, do so with carelessness or coercion? What harm is done when the place of healing becomes a source of harm?
Canon Law or Church History? The SSPX Schism
Concerning the July 1 Society of St Pius X (SSPX) episcopal consecrations and the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith’s (DDF) decree declaring excommunication, many have reached out to me as a retired canonist and Catholic apologist — one who once specialized in the SSPX’s 1988 consecrations and excommunication.
Free Will Is Not Enough
Between 2018 and 2024 I worked intermittently on writing an ambitious series of essays in moral theology, which was eventually serialized on Where Peter Is. I think I made an important argument, but I am not sure in retrospect that I made it well; I wish I were not vain enough for that to bother me as much as it does.
The Context to Cardinal Koch's SSPX "Schism" comments
In a recent podcast, Cardinal Kurt Koch, the Vatican’s Prefect for Promoting Christian Unity, said of the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX), “I’m not entirely sure one can already speak of schism.” The interview was conducted on July 2, 2026, and published that day on the website of the German edition of Communio — the same day that the official excommunication decree and explanatory note were published by the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith (DDF).
Blame the Rooster: The SSPX's Post Hoc Fallacy
The core traditionalist indictment of the Second Vatican Council is easier to state than the people making it usually realize. The argument, in its everyday form, is this: the crisis in the Catholic Church happened after Vatican II, therefore it happened because of Vatican II. Empty pews after 1965. Collapsing Mass attendance in Europe and North America. Vocations in freefall through the 1970s and 1980s. Catechesis unraveling. A visible drop in reverence. Ergo, the Council did it.
Was the SSPX Already in Schism and Excommunicated?
[Editor’s note: Republished with permission from the author’s Substack.] In the wake of Rome’s response to the SSPX’s illicit consecrations, the objection we all were expecting has emerged.
On the question of SSPX and Schism
[Editor’s note: Republished with permission from the author’s Substack.] I made the call to redact a recent article written about the SSPX and the decrees from the DDF. WPI graciously offered to republish it, for which I am very grateful. Though I stand by my conclusions, I realized I had written it in the heat of frustration with the deluge of online rebuttals over the last few days, which seemed to me to be so poor that it would be easy to respond to them and clear things up for people.
Pope Leo Sends Letter to Mark US 250th
Pope Leo XIV, the first pope born and raised in the United States, sent a letter to mark the 250th Anniversary of the United States’ founding.