Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Ashley Simonsen
NJ Supreme Court to Rule on Whether Class Action Waiver is Enforceable Absent an Arbitration Clause
The ever increasing threats of mass arbitration have led many companies to re-examine the terms of their contracts with consumers and to include provisions intended to guard against such threats. One of the options some companies may find themselves considering is doing away with the arbitration clause but keeping the class action waiver. A class action waiver with an agreement to arbitrate is enforceable under the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in AT&T Mobility LLC v.
NJ Supreme Court to Rule on Whether Class Action Waiver is Enforceable Absent an Arbitration Clause
The ever increasing threats of mass arbitration have led many companies to re-examine the terms of their contracts with consumers and to include provisions intended to guard against such threats. One of the options some companies may find themselves considering is doing away with the arbitration clause but keeping the class action waiver. A class action waiver with an agreement to arbitrate is enforceable under the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in AT&T Mobility LLC v.
Bank Partnership Defeats Motion for Preliminary Injunction in “True Lender” Suit
A bank partnership that has recently been the target of a series of “true lender” attacks has defeated a California regulator’s motion for a preliminary injunction. The regulator sought the inunction as part of a lawsuit that seeks to hold the fintech firm Opportunity Financial LLC (“OppFi”) liable for violations of California’s usury laws. The court’s decision is a significant victory for companies that follow the bank partnership lending model to provide consumer loans.
NY Rulings Show Tough Odds For 'Made With' Class Actions
Hello! I'm Law360's automated support bot. How can I help you today? For example, you can type: I forgot my password I took a free trial but didn't get a verification email How do I sign up for a newsletter? Ask a question! Get instant access to the one-stop news source for business lawyers Register Now! Start your free 7-day trial To continue reading, fill out the form below to activate a free 7-day trial of Law360.
Illinois Federal Court Dismisses One False Advertising Suit Based on Malic Acid, While Sustaining Another
A pair of malic acid decisions recently issued by Judge Coleman in the Northern District Court of Illinois reaffirmed that the statements “natural flavors with other natural flavors” and “no artificial flavors” receive different treatment under state false advertising laws, at least in that district. In Boss v.
Michigan Supreme Court Refuses to Enforce “Usury Savings Clause”
In a decision that will likely have ramifications for lenders and borrowers in the state, the Michigan Supreme Court recently issued a decision clarifying that lenders cannot rely on a “usury savings clause” to circumvent Michigan’s usury statute. But it also held that a lender’s effort to enforce a usurious loan, by itself, is not enough to trigger criminal liability.
Michigan Supreme Court Refuses to Enforce “Usury Savings Clause”
In a decision that will likely have ramifications for lenders and borrowers in the state, the Michigan Supreme Court recently issued a decision clarifying that lenders cannot rely on a “usury savings clause” to circumvent Michigan’s usury statute. But it also held that a lender’s effort to enforce a usurious loan, by itself, is not enough to trigger criminal liability.
Court Dismisses Class Action Seeking to Hold Cryptocurrency Exchange Coinbase Liable for Sale of Unregistered Securities
A federal district court recently dismissed with prejudice a putative class action against the cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase, where the plaintiffs sought to hold the exchange liable for the sale of unregistered securities on behalf a nationwide class. The court held that Coinbase neither directly sold the accused tokens to plaintiffs nor actively solicited their sale, and thus plaintiffs’ federal claims must be dismissed.
Court Dismisses Class Action Seeking to Hold Cryptocurrency Exchange Coinbase Liable for Sale of Unregistered Securities
A federal district court recently dismissed with prejudice a putative class action against the cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase, where the plaintiffs sought to hold the exchange liable for the sale of unregistered securities on behalf a nationwide class. The court held that Coinbase neither directly sold the accused tokens to plaintiffs nor actively solicited their sale, and thus plaintiffs’ federal claims must be dismissed.
Two Federal Courts Arrive at Opposite Conclusions in Suits Claiming “Natural Flavor with Other Natural Flavors” Is Misleading
A court in the Northern District of Illinois and a court in the Middle District of Florida recently arrived at opposite conclusions in two very similar putative class actions, both of which alleged that the claim “natural flavor with other natural flavors” on drink labels was misleading because synthetic malic acid was present in the product. In Gouwens v. Target Corp., No. 3:22-cv-50016 (N.D. Ill. Dec.
Two Federal Courts Arrive at Opposite Conclusions in Suits Claiming “Natural Flavor with Other Natural Flavors” Is Misleading
A court in the Northern District of Illinois and a court in the Middle District of Florida recently arrived at opposite conclusions in two very similar putative class actions, both of which alleged that the claim “natural flavor with other natural flavors” on drink labels was misleading because synthetic malic acid was present in the product. In Gouwens v. Target Corp., No. 3:22-cv-50016 (N.D. Ill. Dec.
Leaving a Bitter Taste: Class Action Lawsuits Alleging Lead and Cadmium in Dark Chocolate
Dark chocolate manufacturers have recently been hit with a wave of putative class action complaints in New York and California federal courts, alleging that the confectioners breached an implied warranty of merchantability and engaged in misleading advertising by failing to disclose the levels of lead and cadmium in their dark chocolate products. According to the complaints filed against The Hershey Company, Trader Joe’s, Mars, Inc., and most recently Godiva Chocolatier, Inc.
Leaving a Bitter Taste: Class Action Lawsuits Alleging Lead and Cadmium in Dark Chocolate
Dark chocolate manufacturers have recently been hit with a wave of putative class action complaints in New York and California federal courts, alleging that the confectioners breached an implied warranty of merchantability and engaged in misleading advertising by failing to disclose the levels of lead and cadmium in their dark chocolate products. According to the complaints filed against The Hershey Company, Trader Joe’s, Mars, Inc., and most recently Godiva Chocolatier, Inc.
“100% Recyclable” Labels Are Not False Just Because Not All Plastic Bottles Are Recycled
A court in the Northern District of California recently dismissed a complaint brought against several beverage companies, including Coca-Cola, on behalf of a putative class of consumers and the Sierra Club. Swartz v. Coca-Cola Co., No. 21-cv-04643-JD, 2022 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 209641 (N.D. Cal. Nov. 18, 2022).
“100% Recyclable” Labels Are Not False Just Because Not All Plastic Bottles Are Recycled
A court in the Northern District of California recently dismissed a complaint brought against several beverage companies, including Coca-Cola, on behalf of a putative class of consumers and the Sierra Club. Swartz v. Coca-Cola Co., No. 21-cv-04643-JD, 2022 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 209641 (N.D. Cal. Nov. 18, 2022).
Aspirational Statements of “Sustainability” Not Actionable Under D.C. Consumer Protection Statute
As plaintiffs continue to rely on the District of Columbia Consumer Protection Procedures Act (“CPPA”) to bring greenwashing suits, a recent D.C. Superior Court decision imposes limits on their ability to allege that a company’s general commitments to “sustainability” can constitute actionable misrepresentations. In Earth Island Institute v. The Coca-Cola Company, No. 2021 CA 001846 B (Nov.
S.E.C. Wins Summary Judgment Determination That Cryptocurrency Token Qualifies as a Security
In a recent decision, a federal judge granted summary judgment for the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) finding that the LBC cryptocurrency token qualifies as a security. While the ruling is confined to this specific token, it represents a victory for the SEC’s assertions that many cryptocurrencies, including so called “utility tokens,” represent securities that need to be registered with the agency.
District of New Jersey Continues Third Circuit Trend of Finding Mere Exposure to Toxic Substances in Consumer Products Insufficient for Standing
The District Court for the District of New Jersey recently dismissed a putative class action alleging that defendants sold baby foods with high levels of heavy metals, holding that plaintiffs failed to plead an injury sufficient to support standing. In re Plum Baby Food Litigation, No. 1:21-cv-02417-NLH-SAK, 2022 WL 16552786 (D.N.J. Oct. 31, 2022).
California Court Applies “Substance Over Form,” Allows True Lender Claim to Proceed
May courts look beyond the face of a loan transaction to identify the “true lender”? In a lawsuit filed by California’s financial regulator, a California state court recently answered yes in Opportunity Fin., LLC v. Hewlett, No. 22STCV08163 (Cal. Super. Ct. Sept. 30, 2022), finding that a fact-intensive inquiry into the “substance” of a loan transaction was necessary to determine who the “true lender” is and declining to dismiss a lawsuit.
California Court of Appeal Allows “White Baking” Chips Claims to Proceed
The California Court of Appeal recently reversed trial court judgments sustaining demurrers in two class action cases involving false advertising claims. In both cases the plaintiff alleged that he was misled to believe that “White Baking Morsels” or “White Baking Chips” contain white chocolate. The defendants demurred on the ground that no reasonable consumer would believe that “White Baking” chips or morsels contain real white chocolate.
Is the Supreme Court Having Second Thoughts About Arbitration?
The Supreme Court in Washington on June 9, 2022. Photographer: Eric Lee/Bloomberg By Sonya Winner and Ashley Simonsen June 27, 2022, 8:00 AM The US Supreme Court’s recent rulings in cases involving arbitration reinforce the core of its historic arbitration jurisprudence: the principle that an arbitration contract must be enforced like any other contract, Covington & Burling LLP attorneys Sonya Winner and Ashley Simonsen write.
Litigation Between FinTech Companies Follows Class Action Over Cryptocurrency Theft
This past week, co-defendants in a class action related to the theft of cryptocurrency engaged in their own lawsuit over alleged security failures. IRA Financial Trust, a retirement account provider offering crypto-assets, sued class action co-defendant Gemini Trust Company, LLC, a crypto-asset exchange owned by the Winklevoss twins, following a breach of IRA customer accounts.
Litigation Between FinTech Companies Follows Class Action Over Cryptocurrency Theft
This past week, co-defendants in a class action related to the theft of cryptocurrency engaged in their own lawsuit over alleged security failures. IRA Financial Trust, a retirement account provider offering crypto-assets, sued class action co-defendant Gemini Trust Company, LLC, a crypto-asset exchange owned by the Winklevoss twins, following a breach of IRA customer accounts.
Court Allows False Advertising Claims Over Kroger’s “Smoked Gouda” to Proceed
An Illinois federal court recently ruled that a Kroger shopper’s proposed class action lawsuit over “SMOKED GOUDA” cheese could proceed, holding that plaintiff’s interpretation of the label to mean the cheese was smoked over hardwood was not “inherently fanciful or unreasonable.” The complaint, brought by Valerie Kinman under the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Trade Practices Act (“ICFA”), alleges that the front label of the “SMOKED GOUDA” product is misleading because it “does not...
Bank Partnership Attacked (Again) Under True Lender Theory
A bank partnership is the target of yet another “true lender” attack in a new class action filed last week. Michael v. Opportunity Fin., LLC, No. 1:22-cv-00529 (W.D. Tex. June 1, 2022). The lawsuit is aimed at the lending partnership between OppFi (a fintech) and FinWise Bank (its bank partner), which was also the target of a recent investigation by California’s banking regulator and another class action earlier this year.
YouTube Hit with Auto-Renewal Suit Over Its Online Subscriptions Services
A recent class action filed in federal court against YouTube is the latest in a growing list of class actions against companies regarding their automatic renewal practices.
Kellogg Beats Pop-Tarts Class Actions
On May 24, Kellogg Sales Co. defeated a third putative class action alleging that Strawberry Pop-Tarts mislead consumers, having defeated two other putative class actions in March. Represented by prolific plaintiffs’ firm, Sheehan & Associates, Stacy Chiappetta, Kelvin Brown, and Anita Harris each sued Kellogg after realizing that the filling in Strawberry Pop-Tarts contains not just strawberries, but also small amounts of dried pears, dried apples, and the food dye red 40.
Consumer Survey Did Not Constitute Common Proof of Deception or Materiality
Cortlin Lannin is a litigator who defends clients in high-stakes complex matters, specializing in class action cases implicating consumer protection and competition claims. He approaches his matters with efficiency and creativity, developing thoughtful strategies to resolve cases and investigations early and on favorable… Cortlin Lannin is a litigator who defends clients in high-stakes complex matters, specializing in class action cases implicating consumer protection and competition claims.
Companies Increasingly Facing Class Actions Connected To Cryptocurrency Theft
A recent class action refiled in federal court against Shopify highlights a growing trend of lawsuits against companies related to the theft of cryptocurrency, particularly as a result of internal company threats. See Forsberg et al v. Shopify, Inc. et al, 1:22-cv-00436 (D. Del.).
Companies Increasingly Facing Class Actions Connected to Cryptocurrency Theft
A recent class action refiled in federal court against Shopify highlights a growing trend of lawsuits against companies related to the theft of cryptocurrency, particularly as a result of internal company threats. See Forsberg et al v. Shopify, Inc. et al, 1:22-cv-00436 (D. Del.).
9th Circuit Upholds Preliminary Injunction Against Prop. 65 Acrylamide Lawsuits
In a major victory for manufacturers of food and beverage products fighting acrylamide litigation under California’s Proposition 65 statute, the Ninth Circuit on March 17 upheld a preliminary injunction barring new lawsuits to enforce Prop. 65’s warning requirement for cancer as applied to acrylamide in food and beverage products, finding that the statute’s compulsory warnings are “likely misleading” and “controversial.” Prop.
Fintech Lawsuit Highlights True Lender Risk For Bank Partnership Lending Model
United States: Fintech Lawsuit Highlights True Lender Risk For Bank Partnership Lending Model 17 March 2022 by Ashley M. Simonsen , Andrew Soukup and Matthew Q. Verdin Covington & Burling To print this article, all you need is to be registered or login on Mondaq.com.
Fintech Lawsuit Highlights True Lender Risk for Bank Partnership Lending Model
In the wake of rulings upholding federal regulators’ “valid when made” rules, a new lawsuit serves as a reminder that state regulators and class-action plaintiffs’ lawyers may continue to challenge the bank partnership lending model under the “true lender” doctrine. In early March, the fintech OppFi filed suit to stop California’s banking commissioner from enforcing the state’s interest rate caps on loans made in partnership with FinWise Bank. See Opportunity Fin., LLC v.
Fintech Lawsuit Highlights True Lender Risk for Bank Partnership Lending Model
In the wake of rulings upholding federal regulators’ “valid when made” rules, a new lawsuit serves as a reminder that state regulators and class-action plaintiffs’ lawyers may continue to challenge the bank partnership lending model under the “true lender” doctrine. In early March, the fintech OppFi filed suit to stop California’s banking commissioner from enforcing the state’s interest rate caps on loans made in partnership with FinWise Bank. See Opportunity Fin., LLC v.
A Closer Look: D.C. Court of Appeals Endorses Broad Organizational Standing to Bring Consumer Protection Lawsuits
We previously reported on a surge of mislabeling suits filed in District of Columbia Superior Court, following lower court decisions that purported to grant “tester” plaintiffs—individuals and organizations that purchase products simply to test whether the representations about a product are true—a right to sue on behalf of the general public under the District of Columbia Consumer Protection Procedures Act (“CPPA”).
Keurig Settles K-Cup Recycling Claims
Keurig has agreed to settle on a nationwide class basis a lawsuit alleging that the labeling of its K-Cup pods misleads consumers into believing that K-Cups are more widely recyclable than the coffee pods actually are.
A CLOSER LOOK: AVOIDING A “MASS”-IVE ARBITRATION PROBLEM
Arbitration agreements have become a fixture of American contracts, and companies have turned to them as a strategy for reducing class action exposure. In recent years, plaintiffs have responded by initiating “mass arbitrations” – individual arbitrations filed on behalf of hundreds or thousands of customers or employees, which may immediately threaten companies with millions of dollars in arbitration-initiating fees alone.
Rejecting CDA 230 Defense, District Court Allows TVPRA Claims to Proceed Against Pornhub
Last week, in Doe #1 et al. v. MG Freesites Ltd. et al., No. 7:21-cv-00220-LSC, 2022 WL 407147 (N.D. Ala. Feb. 9, 2022), the Northern District of Alabama permitted plaintiffs to proceed with a proposed class action against Pornhub for allegedly profiting from child sex trafficking and exploitation videos uploaded to its platform. The claims were brought under the Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act (“TVPRA”) and federal child sexual abuse material statutes. U.S. District Judge L.
A Closer Look: Federal Court Upholds OCC’s & FDIC’s Valid-When-Made Rules
Delivering a significant win for the financial services industry, a California federal judge upheld “valid when made” rules promulgated by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) in California v. OCC, No. 4:20-cv-05200 (N.D. Cal. Feb. 8, 2022) and California v. FDIC, No. 4:20-cv-05860 (N.D. Cal. Feb. 8, 2022).Those rules sought to undo the Second Circuit’s 2015 decision in Madden v.
Calif. Ruling Will Help Cos. Fight Fraud-By-Implication Suits
Law360 (July 2, 2020, 3:09 PM EDT) -- What you don't say may be used against you in a court of law. For almost a decade, the plaintiffs bar has been taking to heart this fractured spin on the familiar Miranda warning, working the aisles of grocery stores and shopping for purported label infractions, then suing over what the labels say. But with the stock of supposedly offending labels dwindling, class counsel have now taken to suing over what labels don't say.
Public Injunctive Relief Vs. Arbitration: An Ongoing Debate
Law360 (May 13, 2020, 3:48 PM EDT) -- Twenty years ago, in Broughton v.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Ashley
Contact Ashley, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack