Benn Bathgate
Verified
Fairfaxmedia journalist
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Benn Bathgate
Day in the Dock: Bridge burglars and a sticky situation for a Honey firm
More from the Waikato Times Coalition predictions and the council boss’s pay: Letters to the editor, November 14, 2026 With the final vote count about a fortnight away, one writer’s ready to lay out the likely scenario now.Check out today’s letters. If you’re planning to pervert the course of justice to wriggle out of a gun possession charge, you probably shouldn’t do that planning over the phone from Waikeria Prison.
Whitianga Indian restaurant owners liable for $113,000 unpaid wages bill
He also claimed the company failed to reimburse him for a vehicle he had been encouraged to purchase after a company vehicle was repossessed. Staff were informed during an April 2024 meeting that the restaurant was experiencing financial difficulties and could not pay wages normally, Sharma told the authority. Workers were assured the money would eventually be paid, particularly when they left the company, but the debts kept mounting.
Phone a friend fail for Waikeria prison gun plot
“Hmmmm. Quite serious,” was Judge Anna Skellern’s view of the offending. The Waikato Times can now reveal details of the perversion plot after obtaining the police summary of facts, which notes the saga began on August 12 this year when police found a loaded sawn-off shotgun and modified double barrel shotgun at a Tokoroa address. The resident, a member of the Crips gang, was subsequently arrested and charged with unlawful possession of a firearm and remanded in custody.
Residents consider court action over $57m water reservoir plans for Hillcrest
Resident Jane Geoghegan, who is rallying neighbours against the project, described the proposed structures as unreasonable for such a confined site. "It will take the sunlight, decrease the property values," she said. Geoghegan said residents would consider legal representation to challenge the plans. "Does feel like a done deal," she said.
Baby discharged from Waikato Hospital hours after birth dies next day
Baby discharged from Waikato Hospital hours after birth dies next day Baby Remedy died just 34 hours after being born at Waikato Hospital (file photo). A baby boy who died just 34 hours after being born at Waikato Hospital would very likely have survived had he remained in hospital, a coroner's investigation has found.
Day in the Dock: A mother’s drug driving, a crash and a daughter’s shattered teeth
Day in the Dock: A mother’s drug driving, a crash and a daughter’s shattered teeth Karissa Hill’s daughter was left facing ‘life changing dental trauma’ thanks to her drug driving. (file photo). A “lack of consequential thinking”, methamphetamine and an 80kph crash into a tree that left her daughter with “life changing dental trauma” all combined to pave the way to court for Karissa Hill.
Hamilton bike mob assault caught on camera
Bike rider blocks road, dents car door as woman tries to escape Kashiz Kurtis Tihore-Smith's actions in central Hamilton were caught on CCTV, and the Waikato Times has obtained the footage. Seek to live, currently behind live Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. This is a modal window. This modal can be closed by pressing the Escape key or activating the close button.
Police have border alerts on more than 700 people Original
Police have border alerts on more than 700 people Fatan Jalal Khalaf and husband Mohammad Albaher. Police confirmed a border alert is in place for Albaher and he would be arrested if he returned to New Zealand. A Syrian man charged with possessing execution videos is one of hundreds of people who would be arrested if they set foot in New Zealand. More than 700 people have an active Police border alert against their name, according to NZ Police.
Waikato retail spend drops in October
Paymark chief sales officer Bruce Proffit said retailers had endured difficult trading conditions for much of 2026. “Spending on groceries and petrol remained ahead of last year, but spending across most other retail categories was lower than in October 2025,” Proffit said.
Hammer attacker deemed to have ‘high risk of violent offending following release’
There are tight court-ordered suppressions on the case protecting the identity of the victim and some details in the summary of facts also cannot be reported. The incident took place on Thursday, June 27, 2024 when Lim and the victim were both shopping at The Base shopping centre in Hamilton. Lim had gone to The Warehouse and had purchased a number of items, including a hammer. About 1.30pm she returned to her car in the car park. The victim was there, as was a 10-month-old girl.
Jailed drug boss allowed to keep sentimental RX7 in $1m settlement
A Hamilton drug kingpin who declared just $30,000 in income over six years while making 11 overseas trips and accumulating more than $1 million in assets has struck a deal with police allowing him to keep his beloved Mazda RX7. Caleb Malcom Gilchrist, who is serving 14 years in prison for his role in two major drug operations, has agreed to surrender approximately $1.04 million in cars, cash and Bitcoin under a High Court settlement.
Election pushes Potaka to heavyweight status amid the confusion
Meanwhile, Waikato Chamber of Commerce chair Peter Nation said the knife-edge election result had been widely anticipated. With hundreds of thousands of special votes outstanding, Nation said the political landscape could still change substantially. But regardless of which parties eventually form a government, Waikato needs continued investment. "We've got a lot of projects underway in the Waikato," Nation said.
Police call for public help over suspicious park fire
Police call for public help over suspicious park fire Police have revealed witness reports of people “firing fireworks at each other” before a blaze at Discovery Park’s public toilets and changing rooms. Now, police have put out the call for information from the public as they investigate the suspicious fire. Detective Andrew Murphy said at about 11pm on Thursday November 5, emergency services responded to reports of a fire in the park’s public toilets and changing rooms.
'I'm still in it to win it': Dansey eyes special-vote comeback
'I'm still in it to win it': Dansey eyes special-vote comeback Seek to live, currently behind live Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. This is a modal window. This modal can be closed by pressing the Escape key or activating the close button.
Poor weather ‘deciding factor’ for Armistice in Cambridge cancellation
Event organiser Paul Watkins told the Times it was a “gut-wrenching decision because so many have spent so much time planning this thing”. “It's not a little event to plan,” he said. He also said this was only the second time in the event’s quarter-of-a-century history they have been forced to cancel.
Armistice in Cambridge to blast back this weekend
“It’s going to be considerably cheaper for us to operate … therefore the money hasn’t been as hard to raise.” Watkins said organisers had put processes in place to make the event sustainable over the next few years and reiterated that “we’re definitely back”. Held at Mighty River Domain, Karāpiro, the two-day event bills itself as New Zealand’s largest Armistice celebration of its kind, combining military history with battle re-enactments, historic vehicles and family activities.
Day in the Dock: Opium, arson and interpreters at Hamilton District Court
Day in the Dock: Opium, arson and interpreters at Hamilton District Court Balwant Singh faces the rare charge of importing/exporting opium - something he is alleged to have done eight times (file photo). Charges of wounds with intent to cause grievous bodily harm and possession of prohibited ammunition landed Geovani Wharekawa his day in the dock - and saw him miss the birth of his daughter.
Fridge mistake proves costly for Hamilton tenants
They said the kitchen layout left nowhere else to put the fridge. "The tenants could have placed something under the fridge to ensure that the carpet was not damaged," the decision said. It was also reasonable to assume that placing a fridge directly on carpet could damage the material underneath. But the fridge was only one of several problems identified after the tenancy ended.
Another woman recounts indecent exposure on river path
A woman walking her dog along Hamilton's Waikato River was confronted by a lycra-clad cyclist who exposed himself and asked, "What do you think of this?" But by the time police arrived, he had vanished. The New Year's Day incident in 2022 happened along a central city section of the river walkway in an incident similar that of another woman who reported an indecent exposure that police subsequently failed to follow up on.
Supervision order for man who raped former partner and her mother
Supervision order for man who raped former partner and her mother Rowland Hawkins latest offending saw him expose himself to a woman at Hamilton Lake. A convicted rapist who repeatedly raped his former partner before breaking into her mother's home and raping her too has been placed under another two years of supervision after a High Court judge ruled he remains a high risk to women.
Cambridge 137-bed new hotel takes step forward
Cambridge is a step closer to a new 137-bed hotel in a move hailed by Waipā Mayor Mike Pettit as “another great sign of a growing, welcoming district”. Waipā District Council announced on Tuesday that resource consent has been granted for the proposed Victoria Rd development. Pettit said the hotel was fantastic news for Cambridge and the wider district.
Woman fires broadside at cops after ‘bullet’ fired through window
Woman fires broadside at cops after ‘bullet’ fired through window The bullet hole one Waikato resident found through their lounge window on their return home on Thursday. A Waikato woman who says a bullet tore through her lounge window has slammed police after she was told to clean up the mess and replace the glass before officers examined the scene.
Hamilton construction company director banned for six years
McKenna also failed to create company and accounting records and lent company funds to a related business without the required approvals, despite Cootehill being unable to meet its financial obligations. Inland Revenue was among the creditors left out of pocket. Although some payments were made to creditors, a shortfall remained when the company's liquidation was completed. The ban prevents McKenna from acting as a company director or participating in the promotion or management of companies.
Abandoned land: More than 100 forced sales over the past decade Original
Abandoned land: More than 100 forced sales over the past decade This Te Kūiti property was one of five put up for sale this year by Waitomo District Council to claw back rates payments. A little-known, “last resort” law allowing councils to sell abandoned land has been used to dispose of at least 116 properties across New Zealand in the past decade – but dozens of councils have never used it, and experts say there's good reason why.
‘No funds transferred’ from Givealittle to couple wanted by police, page closed
The Givealittle page had a message from Albaher, saying the money would go towards his wife’s cancer treatment and help the family to return from Syria. “A Heartfelt Appeal to My Friends, Brothers, Sisters, and Community,” it said. “Many of you know me personally from my time living in Hamilton, New Zealand...
Police allege woman gave court fake cancer docs
Police allege Fatan Jalal Khalaf provided false documents to the court claiming she has cancer. (file) Police have charged a woman who is the subject of a Givealittle cancer support page with providing false documents claiming she has the illness as she and her husband remain overseas on other charges. The new charges do not relate to the fundraiser page, which has collected more than $8000, but to paperwork supplied to the court seeking an adjournment of an assault trial.
Day in the Dock: ‘Highly offensive markings’ left behind at Goldmine Experience burglary
Day in the Dock: ‘Highly offensive markings’ left behind at Goldmine Experience burglary After a break-in at the Thames Goldmine Experience, ‘highly offensive’ spray painted graffiti was left behind. It wasn’t so much what Bradley Rogers burgled from the Thames Goldmine Experience that annoyed Judge Jo Rielly, but what he left behind.
Man ‘attempted to grab child’ at Pukemokemoke Bush Reserve near Hamilton
Police confirmed they had been contacted about the alleged snatch attempt. “We have received a report after an unknown person approached a child at the Pukemokemoke Bush Reserve on Sunday October 18,” Hamilton City Area Commander Inspector Scott Miller said. “Thankfully, another family member noticed the man had attempted to grab the child, no physical injuries were reported and the man fled the area.
‘Let’s get real for a second’: Economists on what, if anything, politicians can do to tackle cost of living pressures
‘Let’s get real for a second’: Economists on what, if anything, politicians can do to tackle cost of living pressures Leading New Zealand economists Shamubeel Eaqub, Brad Olsen and Ting Huang told the Waikato Times just how limited politicians are when it comes to lowering our soaring cost of living expenses.
Art valuations and arts holes across Waikato’s councils
Works by acclaimed New Zealand artists including the late Ian Scott are amongst the South Waikato District Council's art collection. Waikato councils are sitting on art collections with recorded values totalling more than $44 million– but some admit they don't even know how many artworks they own, let alone what they're worth.
Hamilton cops failed to follow up on river path sex pest
Hamilton cops failed to follow up on river path sex pest Photo taken in 2023 of the man who was alleged to have exposed himself at the same location where a man stalked and sexually assaulted two women earlier this year. A week after a repeat Hamilton sex pest was convicted of harassing women on Hamilton’s river path, police have admitted they failed to follow up a near identical case - despite the victim rushing to report it.
Execution video accused fled NZ – then crowdfunded $8000
Former neighbours at Albaher’s Waipa address told the Times they believed he had returned to Syria, with one neighbour also confirming the property had been raided by armed police on two occasions, and that after the last raid they left. “We are now urgently hoping to return to New Zealand as soon as she is medically able to travel, so she can continue her care and be with our six children,” the Givealittle page said. Attempts to contact Albaher through the page were unsuccessful.
High Court rejects claim 'disturbing' protection order breaches were benign
Prenter, 38, had been subject to a protection order protecting his former partner since June 2024. In January and February last year, he approached her child while she was walking with friends, asking about her mother. On the second occasion he parked a vehicle across the child's path. He also sent the child social media messages and later called her directly while crying, asking her to contact her mother.
Physio’s boundary breaches went from OnlyFans chat to sexual incident
The tribunal found the behaviour exploited the power imbalance inherent in the therapeutic relationship and significantly breached the trust the woman was entitled to place in her physiotherapist. It was particularly serious because the final incident happened in her own home, "where she was entitled to feel safe". Tapara also failed to properly obtain and record informed consent as his treatment changed to include work on the woman's lumbar spine and acupuncture.
Day in the Dock: Community work, not fine requested, to ‘get me out of the house’
Day in the Dock: Community work, not fine requested, to ‘get me out of the house’ Drink driving took up a large amount of the court time on Tuesday. A third-time drink-driver who had given herself “such a fright”, a young man opting for community work to “get me out of the house” and a hearing that had to be rearranged because a complainant was heavily pregnant. Those were among matters dealt with at Waihī District Court on Tuesday by presiding Judge Jo Rielly.
The puff of meth that cost taxpayers almost a quarter-of-a-million
Fire investigation report photo of the entrance to the laundry room where Desiree Hirawani set the Hamilton property alight.supplied The meth-smoking, baby-sitting arsonist who left two children in the Hamilton property she set alight left taxpayers with a repair bill of almost a quarter-of-a-million dollars. The Kāinga Ora property was also vacant for more than a year while repairs were done.
Meth-smoking babysitter ‘ran past the children’ to escape blaze she lit
The Fire Investigation Report included a photograph of the fuel container stored in the laundry room where Desiree Hiwawani decided to light her meth pipe.Photo: supplied Just In 11:00 am 11:00 am 11:00 am 11:00 am The methamphetamine smoking babysitter who abandoned two children in a blazing home “ran past” them to escape the fire she had just lit, leaving them “in the house that was now on fire”.
Behind closed doors: NZ’s incest figures revealed
Ministry of Justice data lifts the lid on incest convictions across New Zealand.KATHRYN GEORGE Almost 100 people have been convicted of incest-related offending in New Zealand in the past decade, but experts warn the court figures represent only a fraction of sexual abuse occurring within families. Ministry of Justice figures released under the Official Information Act show 145 people had incest-related charges finalised between 2015 and 2025, with 96 convicted.
Show More
loading
Actions
Get in touch with Benn
Contact Benn, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack