The Supreme Court has now clarified the position in relation to uncontroverted evidence. After nine years, TUI Ltd v Griffiths [2023] UKSC 48 has reached a conclusion which most practitioners were expecting. Subject to certain important exceptions, evidence which is not agreed must be challenged by cross-examination. This is an essential feature of our adversarial system and is required to ensure fairness to the parties, the witness (whose evidence a judge is invited to reject) and the court.