In an opinion yesterday, Judge McMahon denied a preliminary injunction to the online exchange that does business as Novig and that sells “event contracts” tied to sporting events. Novig sued the New York Attorney General and the State Gaming Commission to stop them from enforcing New York’s gambling and mobile sports-wagering laws against it. New York had already moved against other operators of these markets, including Kalshi, Coinbase, and Gemini. Novig’s theory was preemption.
Charles Michael
New York
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Charles Michael
Judge Kaplan: Evasion Of YouTube’s Anti-Scraping Measures By AI Firm Can Violate DMCA, Even For Free Public Videos
In an opinion Friday, Judge Kaplan denied a motion by AI video developer Runway AI to dismiss a putative class action brought by YouTube creators. The creators allege that Runway got around YouTube’s technological protections to “scrape” their videos to train its AI models.
Judge Kaplan: Evasion Of YouTube’s Anti-Scraping Measures By AI Firm Can Violate DMCA, Even For Free Public Videos
In an opinion Friday, Judge Kaplan denied a motion by AI video developer Runway AI to dismiss a putative class action brought by YouTube creators. The creators allege that Runway got around YouTube’s technological protections to “scrape” their videos to train its AI models.
Judge Furman: Article II Does Not Allow AUSAs To Be Fired At Will
In an opinion yesterday, Judge Furman held that the summary firing of former AUSA Maurene Comey was unlawful. He rejected the government’s argument that Article II bars Congress from protecting federal prosecutors against at-will removal (see our prior coverage here). Comey was terminated in July 2025 by a one-page memo citing only “Article II of the United States Constitution and the laws of the United States.” She received no notice, no reasons and no hearing.
Judge Subramanian: “Hula Hoop” May Be A Generic Descriptor Of The “Thing Itself,” Not Protectible As A Trademark
In an opinion Friday, Judge Subramanian denied toymaker Wham-O’s renewed motion for an ex parte temporary restraining order against a slate of anonymous online sellers marketing “Hula Hoop”-labeled products, holding for the second time that Wham-O hadn’t shown a likelihood of success on its trademark claims given evidence in its own record suggesting the mark is generic.
Judge Furman: New Practice Of “Article II” Firings Can Be Challenged In Federal Court Instead Of Before MSRB
In an opinion yesterday, Judge Furman allowed former AUSA Maurene Comey to pursue her wrongful termination claims in federal court, denying DOJ’s argument that the claim belonged exclusively before the MSRB. Comey’s main allegation is that she was fired because her father is former FBI Director James Comey, a political foe of President Trump. Comey was told that she was being fired under Article II of the Constitution, without further explanation.
DoorDash and Uber Eats Seeks To Enjoin City Law Requiring Upfront Tipping Option
Earlier this month, DoorDash and Uber Eats filed a motion to preliminarily enjoin New York City’s new law requiring that online food ordering services provide an option to tip before the order is placed and to include an option for a tip of at least 10%.
In Corporate Raiding Case, Judge Abrams Enjoins Poaching Clients But Not Servicing Ones That Have Already Left
MMA has emphasized that Alliant has engaged in a pattern of tortious interference with MMA: moving clients over quickly, before MMA (or other rival insurers) even have a chance to file for an injunction. . . . But this alone is not the basis for injunctive relief. There are other mechanisms by which the judicial system deters egregious conduct . . . .
In Case Over Allegedly Infringing Teen Romance Book Series, Judge McMahon Asks Counsel: How To Efficiently Try A Case With 10,000-Plus Pages Of Allegedly Infringing Material?
In an Order last week, Judge McMahon asked the lawyers in a copyright infringement case over the young adult book series Crave (see the operative complaint here) how they planned to conduct a forthcoming jury trial, given the massive volume of evidence—both the book series itself and, separately, the plaintiff’s unpublished manuscripts from which the series was allegedly stolen.
Court Clarifies Boundaries Of Defamation Liability For Legal Professionals
Steptoe LLP are most popular: within Transport, Accounting and Audit and Immigration topic(s) On October 16, 2025, the US District Court for the District of Columbia issued a significant ruling in Shapley v. Lowell, dismissing with prejudice a politically charged defamation lawsuit brought against Steptoe's client, attorney Abbe Lowell.
[2504.03991] Algorithmic Prompt Generation for Diverse Human-like Teaming and Communication with Large Language Models
[Submitted on 4 Apr 2025] Title:Algorithmic Prompt Generation for Diverse Human-like Teaming and Communication with Large Language Models View a PDF of the paper titled Algorithmic Prompt Generation for Diverse Human-like Teaming and Communication with Large Language Models, by Siddharth Srikanth and 7 other authors View PDF HTML (experimental) Abstract:Understanding how humans collaborate and communicate in teams is essential for improving human-agent teaming and AI-assisted decision-making.
Judge Gardephe: Better Call Saul's Fictional
In an opinion yesterday, Judge Gardephe dismissed a complaint (see our prior coverage here) brought by Liberty Tax Service against the makers of the TV show "Better Call Saul" for depicting an allegedly similar business, "Sweet Liberty Tax Services," as a criminal enterprise. In the show, the business is run by Craig Kettleman, who had been convicted of embezzlement in an earlier season but then opened "Sweet Liberty Tax Services" with his wife after being released from prison.
Judge Gardephe: Better Call Saul’s Fictional “Sweet Liberty” Tax Firm Does Not Infringe Rights of Similarly-Named, Real Business
In an opinion yesterday, Judge Gardephe dismissed a complaint (see our prior coverage here) brought by Liberty Tax Service against the makers of the TV show “Better Call Saul” for depicting an allegedly similar business, “Sweet Liberty Tax Services,” as a criminal enterprise. In the show, the business is run by Craig Kettleman, who had been convicted of embezzlement in an earlier season but then opened “Sweet Liberty Tax Services” with his wife after being released from prison.
Judge Castel Denies Summary Judgment To Netflix In Defamation Case Over Central Park Five
In an opinion yesterday, Judge Castel denied a summary judgment motion that sought to dismiss the defamation action brought by former prosecutor Linda Fairstein against Netflix and others over a "docudrama" called "When They See Us" about the Central Park Five. Our coverage of the denial of the motion to dismiss is here.
Judge Castel Denies Summary Judgment to Netflix in Defamation Case Over Central Park Five “Docudrama"
In an opinion yesterday, Judge Castel denied a summary judgment motion that sought to dismiss the defamation action brought by former prosecutor Linda Fairstein against Netflix and others over a “docudrama” called “When They See Us” about the Central Park Five. Our coverage of the denial of the motion to dismiss is here.
Judge Torres: Sales Of Ripple's Crypto Tokens On Exchanges Are Not Securities Transactions
In the SEC's closely-watched action against the crypto firm Ripple, Judge Torres on Thursday issued a summary judgment decision finding that some types of sales of Ripple's crypto token, XRP, were governed by the securities laws while others were not. The decision is a notable counterweight to the SEC's effort to broadly categorize crypto transactions as falling under the securities laws.
Judge Torres: Sales of Ripple’s Crypto Tokens on Exchanges Are Not Securities Transactions
In the SEC’s closely-watched action against the crypto firm Ripple, Judge Torres on Thursday issued a summary judgment decision finding that some types of sales of Ripple’s crypto token, XRP, were governed by the securities laws while others were not. The decision is a notable counterweight to the SEC’s effort to broadly categorize crypto transactions as falling under the securities laws.
Magistrate Judge Figueredo: Defendant Who Skipped Deposition Must Pay $5,850 For Wasting Two Hours Of Opposing Lawyers' Time
In an Order yesterday, Judge Figueredo sanctioned a defendant for failing to show up for his deposition and thereby causing two lawyers for the plaintiff to waste two hours of their time, until they learned he was not coming. The sanction amount is notable for approving the hourly rate of $1,285.50 for a commercial litigation partner at a large law firm (Proskauer Rose) and also for approving an $800 rate for an associate (reduced from the requested $1,102.50).
Magistrate Judge Figueredo: Defendant Who Skipped Deposition Must Pay $5,850 For Wasting Two Hours Of Opposing Lawyers' Time
In an Order yesterday, Judge Figueredo sanctioned a defendant for failing to show up for his deposition and thereby causing two lawyers for the plaintiff to waste two hours of their time, until they learned he was not coming. The sanction amount is notable for approving the hourly rate of $1,285.50 for a commercial litigation partner at a large law firm (Proskauer Rose) and also for approving an $800 rate for an associate (reduced from the requested $1,102.50).
What Happened to the Push for a Multicultural Center?
For decades, activists at Ivy League schools have pushed for the establishment of multicultural centers — physical spaces on campus to foster inclusion for diverse groups of students. Many of Harvard’s peer schools — including Princeton, Columbia, and Yale — ultimately established these spaces, either for individual groups or diverse identities as a whole. Still, since the 1960s, Harvard administrators have rejected undergraduate proposals for a multicultural center.
Judge Carter Enjoins New York’s New Online Hate Speech Law on First Amendment Grounds
In an opinion Tuesday, Judge Carter issued an injunction against New York’s newly-enacted online hate speech law (see our prior coverage here).
Jury: “MetaBirkins” NFTs Violate Trademark Rights of Handbag Maker Hermés
A jury returned a verdict yesterday of approximately $130,000 against Mason Rothschild, the creator of a series of non-fungible tokens, or NFTs, associated with digital images of Hermés’s “Birkin” handbags covered in fake fur (see our prior coverage here). Rothschild argued that the NFTs were protected artistic expression under the First Amendment.
Jury: “MetaBirkins” NFTs Violate Trademark Rights of Handbag Maker Hermés
A jury returned a verdict yesterday of approximately $130,000 against Mason Rothschild, the creator of a series of non-fungible tokens, or NFTs, associated with digital images of Hermés’s “Birkin” handbags covered in fake fur (see our prior coverage here). Rothschild argued that the NFTs were protected artistic expression under the First Amendment.
Judge McMahon Ahead of Bench Trial: “Last Thing I Need Is Opening Statements”
Judge McMahon issued a written Order on Friday, answering the parties’ questions ahead of a bench trial in an ERISA case, and, in doing so, offered helpful guidance as to her practices in bench trials. First, she was clear she does not want opening statements, and perhaps not even closing statements: The last thing I need is opening statements. You have been “opening” on this case for two years.
Judge McMahon Ahead of Bench Trial: “Last Thing I Need Is Opening Statements”
Judge McMahon issued a written Order on Friday, answering the parties’ questions ahead of a bench trial in an ERISA case, and, in doing so, offered helpful guidance as to her practices in bench trials. First, she was clear she does not want opening statements, and perhaps not even closing statements: The last thing I need is opening statements. You have been “opening” on this case for two years.
Judge Carter to Hold Hearing Next Week on Whether to Enjoin New York's New Online Hate Speech Law
Judge Carter will hold a preliminary injunction hearing next week in a case challenging, on First Amendment grounds, a new New York law (N.Y. Gen. Bus. L. § 394-ccc) that requires social media platforms to develop policies for addressing, and for responding to user complaints about, “hateful conduct.” The challengers are operators of online platforms who argue that they should not be forced to police what the state vaguely defines as “hateful” conduct.
Judge Liman Laments Supreme Court Precedent Barring Damages Remedy For DOJ's Retaliation Against Michael Cohen For Planned Book About Trump
In an opinion yesterday, Judge Liman granted - albeit with clear reluctance - the government's motion to dismiss a case brought by former Trump attorney Michael Cohen against various government offices who allegedly retaliated against him for planning to publish a book critical of former President Trump. Cohen was placed on furlough during his prison sentence, but then suddenly, while negotiating the terms of a transition to home confinement with probation officials, was remanded to prison.
Judge Liman Laments Supreme Court Precedent Barring Damages Remedy For DOJ's Retaliation Against Michael Cohen for Planned Book About Trump
In an opinion yesterday, Judge Liman granted — albeit with clear reluctance — the government’s motion to dismiss a case brought by former Trump attorney Michael Cohen against various government offices who allegedly retaliated against him for planning to publish a book critical of former President Trump. Cohen was placed on furlough during his prison sentence, but then suddenly, while negotiating the terms of a transition to home confinement with probation officials, was remanded to prison.
Judge Abrams Harshly Criticizes SEC’s “Lifetime Gag” Settlement Requirement
The threat held over the head of defendants by this so-called “No-Admit-No-Deny Provision” (the “Provision”) is not easily overstated. Should they ever publicly refute the accusations against them, or even so much as “create the impression” that the SEC got something wrong, the Commission may reopen their cases or seek to hold them in contempt, thereby subjecting them to the risk of enormous financial and professional penalties, if not imprisonment. Truth is no defense.
Judge McMahon: "Most" Discovery Designated Confidential is Not; Oral Argument on Summary Judgment "Rarely" Necessary
In an Order Monday, Judge McMahon chided a group of defendants for “asking for permission to file almost everything in support of their motion for summary judgment and motions to exclude testimony of plaintiff’s various experts under seal.” Referring to the required confidentiality stipulation “addendum” in her Individual Practices — which states “that confidentiality stipulations are abused by parties and that much material that is not truly confidential is designated as such” — Judge...
Judge Schofield: Firm With "Ample" Resources Cannot Delay Trial, Despite Lead Counsel's COVID Diagnosis
In an endorsement today, Judge Schofield declined to postpose a major antitrust trial, despite lead counsel for a bank testing positive for COVID, given that counsel’s firm had several other lawyers available. The endorsement, in full, reads: It is unfortunate that defense counsel has tested positive for COVID, but the circumstances warrant proceeding with the trial as scheduled. This case has been pending since 2013, and the Court’s next available trial date is in the second quarter of 2023.
Second Circuit: Citibank Can Recoup $500 Million Accidental Debt Repayment
In an last week, the Second Circuit, reversing a decision by Judge Furman (covered here), held that Citibank could sue to recoup almost $500 million that it had sent, in error, to certain lenders of a struggling borrower, Revlon. Citibank was the administrative agent for the loans, and, based on a technical error, wired the full principal balance (nearly $900 million) before the maturity date.
Susman Godfrey Litigator Arun Subramanian Nominated for Southern District Bench
Charles Michael is an accomplished commercial litigator who resolutely defends clients in high stakes disputes and arbitrations. He is also experienced in regulatory and criminal investigations, and represents clients under investigation by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority… Charles Michael is an accomplished commercial litigator who resolutely defends clients in high stakes disputes and arbitrations.
Judge Woods: Retweets Are Not Endorsements
In an opinion today, Judge Woods ruled, in essence, that retweets are not endorsements. The ruling came in connection with a denial of CNN’s motion for reconsideration in a case brought by two family members of former National Security Advisor Michael Flynn. The court had previously ruled that the plaintiffs’ false light claim against CNN could proceed, based on a CNN report that suggested the plaintiffs were followers of the conspiracy group QAnon.
Tax Preparation Firm Sues the Makers of "Better Caul Saul" For Depiction of Similarly-Named, but Crooked, Fictional Firm
In a trademark infringement complaint filed on Monday, Liberty Tax Service sued the makers of the TV show “Better Caul Saul” for depicting an allegedly similar business, “Sweet Liberty Tax Services,” as essentially a criminal enterprise: The complaint included images from the show and images of actual Liberty Tax locations (such as the examples below) in support of its allegations that the fictional business could be confused as a depiction of the real one.
Judge Engelmayer Slashes Requested Fee Award Based on “Anemic” Lawyering
In an opinion last week in a Fair Labor Standards Case, Judge Engelmayer reduced the requested fee award for plaintiffs’ counsel from $155,000 down to approximately $5,000. The plaintiffs had prevailed, but only as to a narrow aspect of the claim. After the liability verdict in the plaintiffs’ favor (in part), their counsel asked for a fee award without bothering, until prompted by Judge Engelmayer, to request damages for the plaintiffs themselves.
Judge Cote Concludes That the Concept of “Hiring a Homegirl” for Help in Social Situations Is Not Protectable Under Copyright Laws
In an opinion last week, Judge Cote dismissed a copyright infringement case brought by the maker of certain “HomeGirl Hotline” TikTok videos against the comedian Michael Che, arising out of sketches on Che’s television show involving a fictional mobile app called “homegrrl.” Both the plaintiff’s videos and Che’s sketches generally involved calling upon a “homegirl” to help in social situations, the former via phone call (the “HomeGirl Hotline”) and the latter via mobile app (“homegrrl”).
Judge Marrero: First Amendment Allows Attorney Grievance Complainants to Publish Their Own Complaints, Notwithstanding Confidentiality Statute
In an opinion Monday, Judge Marrero ruled that the First Amendment protected the right of a group of law professors to publish online their attorney grievance complaints against prosecutors in Queens who had been involved in alleged prosecutorial misconduct. The professors received a letter from New York City’s Corporation Counsel claiming that the disclosure of their complaints violated a statute protecting the confidentiality of grievance proceedings.
Judge Crotty: Non-Profit’s Advice on Dealing With Debt Collection Actions Is Protected by First Amendment Against “Unauthorized Practice of Law” Regulations
In an opinion Tuesday, Judge Crotty preliminarily enjoined New York State from enforcing unauthorized practice of law (“UPL”) regulations against a non-profit that counsels New Yorkers facing debt-collection actions (see our prior coverage here).
Judge Rakoff: Hermés Can Enforce Its "Birkin" Trademark Against Maker of “MetaBirkin” NFTs
In an opinion Wednesday, Judge Rakoff allowed the handbag maker Hermés to proceed with a trademark suit against the individual responsible for a series of non-fungible tokens (“NFTs”) associated with digital images of “faux-fur-covered versions” of Hermés’s “Birkin” handbag. An example of a “MetaBirkin” image is below: The defendant argued that he has a First Amendment right to title his work after the famous bag, relying on , 875 F.2d 994 (2d Cir.
Judge Swain: Musical Parodying the Misogyny of Grease is “Fair Use”
In an opinion Thursday, Judge Swain granted judgement on the pleadings to the makers of the musical Vape, declaring that under the “fair use” doctrine, Vape does not infringe on the copyright in the classic theatrical work Grease. Vape holds itself out as a parody of Grease.
Judge Buchwald Warns Counsel Against “Irrelevant Invective” and Fruitless Motion Practice
In an order yesterday, in a case involving two people who were formerly in a relationship and who now accuse one another of battery (among many other things), Judge Buchwald resolved various discovery disputes with a warning against “irrelevant invective”: Later the same day, defense counsel wrote a letter that began, “Plaintiff seems to continually misapprehend the Court’s rules, the local rules and the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure” and urged that one count be severed and that the case...
Judge Hellerstein Dismisses Girls Scouts’ Trademark Case Against Boy Scouts Over Gender-Neutral Term “Scouting”
In an opinion yesterday, Judge Hellerstein granted summary judgment to the Boy Scouts, and against the Girl Scouts, in a case arising from the Boy Scouts’ decision to use gender-neutral terms like “scout,” to account for its new policy of allowing girls to participate. The Girl Scouts alleged, in essence, that the Boy Scouts’ use of gender-neutral terms would create public confusion about the two organizations (see our prior coverage here).
Second Circuit: COVID-19 Pandemic Triggers Contractual Force Majeure Clause for Circumstances Beyond the Parties' "Reasonable Control"
In an opinion last week, the Second Circuit affirmed Judge Cote’s decision (covered here) finding that the force majeure clause in a contract relating to an art auction was triggered by the COVID-19 pandemic.
In an opinion this week, the Second Circuit upheld Judge Rakoff’s ruling that Major League Baseball’s sign-stealing scandals did not give rise to a right to sue the league or the offending teams: At its core, this action is nothing more than claims brought by disgruntled fantasy sports participants, unhappy with the effect that cheating in MLB games may have had on their level of success in fantasy sports contests.
In an opinion Friday, Judge Kaplan denied a motion by former President Donald Trump to amend his answer to add a counterclaim against the plaintiff, E. Jean Carroll, who accuses Trump of defamation based on his public statements alleging that she fabricated sexual assault allegations against him (see our prior coverage here). The proposed counterclaim would have sought attorney fees and other relief under New York’s anti-SLAPP law.
Judge McMahon’s Trial Memo: Argue Objections In “25 Words or Less” And Other Guidance
Judge McMahon issued a memo today to the parties scheduled for a forthcoming civil trial, and the memo sets forth various rules reflecting her efforts to keep trials running efficiently. Highlights of the memo include: If you run out of witnesses prior to the end of the trial day, the next words you should be prepared to say are, “We rest.” Plan accordingly. Because this is a civil trial, we listen to witnesses once and once only.
Judge Rakoff: It Would “Chill Protected Speech” To Hold NY Times Liable for Careless, Quickly-Corrected Editorial About Sarah Palin
In the long-running defamation case brought by Sarah Palin against the New York Times (see our prior coverage here), Judge Rakoff issued an opinion yesterday explaining his ruling from the bench granting judgment as a matter of law to the Times. The ruling was announced orally to counsel at the close of trial, before the jury returned its verdict. The jury subsequently ruled in the Times’ favor, as well.
Judge Engelmayer Shows Willingness to Preliminarily Assess Contract Dispute, to Help Foster Settlement
It is rare for a judge to express views on the merits of a case ahead of a trial, but last week Judge Engelmayer did so, apparently at the urging of the parties who both thought that it would foster settlement. The views were set forth in an Order last week denying summary judgment in a case over escrowed funds following a corporate acquisition (see an earlier ruling here with more background).
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Charles
Contact Charles, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack