I'm just here so I don't get fined.
Articles by Eli Steinberg
Opinion | Conflating anti-Zionism with antisemitism erases the violence Orthodox Jews like me face
A lot of antisemitism — perhaps even most — has little or nothing to do with the State of Israel. While anti-Zionism often serves as a helpful cover for overt bigots, conflating the two not only misunderstands and misstates the problem, but is also dangerous.
Many Orthodox Americans feel more in common with Republicans than with fellow Jews
Generally speaking, American Jews are liberal and identify with the Democratic Party. That is, apparently, unless you are Orthodox. The new Pew study released this week found that 75% of Orthodox Jews identify as Republican, up from 57% in 2013, the last time a similar survey was conducted. None of this, I would venture, is news to anyone. What is new, however, is that Orthodox Jews have begun to feel as though they are at "home" in the Republican Party and in the conservative movement.
Opinion | How to get Haredim to stop wearing blackface on Purim
Six months ago, in a September interview with The New York Times, Chris Rock was asked about the effort then underway to expunge all uses of blackface in TV and movies. Specifically, the interviewer wanted to know whether Rock thought society was taking things too far. “If I say they are, then I’m the worst guy in the world,” Rock responded. “There’s literally one answer that ends my whole career. Blackface ain’t cool, OK? That’s my quote.
Americans Are Sick Of Placebo Government
The extreme disconnect between the political class and the people they ostensibly serve is by now extremely clear. It was the primary factor behind Donald Trump’s ascendance to the presidency, as the left largely abandoned the working class in favor of woke ideologies and their special interests. At a certain point, the lip service politicians pay to the working class’s needs and concerns was not enough, and they lost their votes.
Opinion | The Orthodox community is more than Heshy Tischler — let us tell our own stories
. Back in the summer of 2016, five police officers were killed in Dallas as ostensible “payback” for police shootings of unarmed Black men around the country. Former President George W. Bush, speaking at the officers’ memorial service, accurately summed up precisely what it was about that moment in time that made the massacre possible.
I voted for Donald Trump, but I didn’t sign up for this
For my children, Wednesday felt like any other day. I picked my 12-year-old up from his yeshiva at the same time a mob of President Trump’s supporters was making its way through the Capitol building. Wondering whether he knew what was going on, I asked him about it. He had an idea — he’d heard about it from his teacher — but I filled in the details. “I don’t get it,” he said.
Opinion | Uncertainty is the new normal - and the best possible election outcome
A week ago, all of the experts and pundits and polls were telling us the same thing: The election was a done deal, and it would be a blowout. Vice President Joe Biden and the Democrats were winning big. They were going to make gains in the House, win the Senate, and possibly turning Texas and Georgia blue while they were at it, giving them a mandate to go big on their agenda. That agenda was a radical one.
Is Trump good or bad for the Jews?
The U.S. presidential election has divided Jews as it has the whole country. While recent surveys show that some three-quarters of Jewish voters support former Vice President Joe Biden, as they have largely backed Democrats for the last century, a sizable portion of our communities are siding with the incumbent Republican President Donald Trump.
Opinion | Amy Coney Barrett reminds me of all the Haredi mothers I admire
On Monday night the Senate will of Judge Amy Coney Barrett, who will be voted in to replace Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg on the Supreme Court. It’s a good time to pause and recognize something astonishing about the confirmation proceedings: For a time as politically riven as ours, Judge Barrett’s confirmation process just wasn’t that contentious. The contrast with Justice Kavanaugh yelling at the Committee, righteously indignant, was a stark reminder for how things could have gone.
Opinion | Protip for journalists covering Haredi protests: Your job is not to judge but to understand us.
The images and videos coming out of Brooklyn this week of Haredi Jews protesting new Covid strictures are striking: Streets crowded with protesters, fires set in the middle of the street, loud chanting and jeering at those in “power,” journalists driven from the street. This was hardly the first time New York has seen something like this. It isn’t even the first time it has happened this year.
Opinion | Yes, there’s an Orthodox COVID uptick. De Blasio and Cuomo are making it worse.
Orthodox communities in New York and New Jersey are in the midst of a COVID uptick. That much is undeniable. But what is also undeniable is that New York Mayor Bill de Blasio and Gov. Andrew Cuomo are botching the response, singling out Jews for the convenience and pleasure of antisemites. These are politicians with long-standing relationships and a deep familiarity with the communities suffering from the uptick — relationships that if they wanted, could serve them in good stead.
Opinion | Of course we should care about who rabbis think we should vote for
Presidential campaigns, especially in the age of President Trump, tend to dominate the conversation. Everyone seems to have an opinion on the election, on who they will – and who everyone else should – be voting for. But there is a specific subset of Jews who are forbidden by popular decree from voicing their opinions on this matter: members of Haredi Rabbinic leadership.
Opinion | Don’t call Orthodox Jews close minded. Our consensus is achieved through debate.
There is a recurring trend I’ve been noticing in both private conversations as well as articles and OpEds discussing “issues” in the Orthodox world: Engaging in equal parts paternalism and dismissiveness – often with an extra serving of condescension – people often accuse adherents to traditional values of being closed-minded, and of “silencing” “nonconformist” perspectives when it comes to issues of religion when we choose not to engage with them.
Opinion | Amar’e Stoudemire is sparking joy for Haredi Jews like me
In a world that continues to produce social media celebrities and superstars at a dizzying pace, it’s hard for me to bring myself to get excited about anyone’s social media posts. Increasingly, social media has become a toxic sphere, filled with self-centered shallowness and one-upmanship, with extraordinarily little else. I can always pass on that. But there is always an exception which proves the rule.
Opinion | What the world can learn from the Orthodox response to COVID
In what we now know as the “early days” of the COVID-19 pandemic, as the waves of the virus washed over New York and New Jersey, the Haredi communities in the area seemed to get hit disproportionately hard. While no hard data exists to either validate or disprove this perception, it continues to persist both within and without Haredi communities. I came down with COVID-19 in the latter part of March and early April.
Opinion | I’m a Jewish conservative. We’re also furious about George Floyd’s murder.
I’m a Jewish conservative. And I’m furious about George Floyd’s murder. Not just Floyd’s murder, either. Despite what people think about those of us who don’t identify as “progressive,” we recognize that George Floyd’s murder wasn’t an isolated incident but rather part of something much bigger that we really need to change. This was not always the case. We used to ignore these issues. We used to tell the left they were overreacting. We were wrong.
Opinion | Why Trump, warrior of the faithful, has my vote
Last Friday, President Donald Trump issued an executive order deeming houses of worship providers of essential services. “Some governors have deemed liquor stores and abortion clinics as essential, but have left out churches and other houses of worship,” the president said, echoing the thoughts of many people of faith throughout the COVID-19 Pandemic. “It’s not right.” It was a welcome statement.
After Corona | Everything we relied on has failed us. Where can we turn but to God?
There is a section of the morning prayers that not everyone says. I myself, in a pre-coronavirus world, found myself often omitting it, a casualty of hectic schedules and a busy world that would just not stop. Until it did. The prayer is sourced in a Midrashic text (Tana Dvei Eliyahu, chapter 21), and it provides some much-needed perspective for man as he stands before God: “What are we?” we say, addressing God. “What is our strength? What is our might?
Opinion | Blacks and Orthodox Jews are being unfairly targeted. It’s a reminder that we’re in this together.
There are some aspects of life which are constants, as reliable as the sun rising each morning in the east and setting each evening in the west. Hatred of the other is one such constant. Even during a pandemic, prejudice against my community and racism against the Black community just doesn’t take a break. Of course, with social distancing mandates, hatred needs to find a more creative way to manifest.
Opinion | The loss of the Novominsker Rebbe, Rabbi Yaakov Perlow, leaves a gaping hole in our community
I will not write about Rabbi Yaakov Perlow, the Novominsker Rebbe, who passed away suddenly this morning. I will not write about him because I simply cannot, for several reasons. First of all, my personal interactions with him were limited, to just a handful of private conversations. But more importantly, to describe him accurately would be to understand him, and I cannot claim to comprehend this man who epitomized greatness.
Opinion | In the face of coronavirus, our homes must become shuls and yeshivas
On Wednesday, March 18th, I stood in the street, and I cried. No, I wasn’t at a funeral (back when we even were able to hold those). I’m not usually one to express my emotions that way anyway, even in that sort of setting. There was virtually nobody else around me when it happened, and I have to admit that the tears streaming down my face unnerved me. Just twenty minutes earlier, I’d spoken with my rabbi on the phone. We had struggled valiantly to keep our shul open in a responsible way.
Opinion | How not to talk about coronavirus in the Orthodox community
Tuesday was the COVID-19 tipping point for New York’s Hasidic communities. Rumors began circulating that morning that in Boro Park, at one clinic alone, there were hundreds of new positive test results, marking an extreme jump in cases of the virus. While it later turned out that rumor was overblown, it was true that well over 100 new cases were confirmed — across Brooklyn’s entire Hasidic community.
Opinion | How can we trust the media when they lie about our community?
We’re living in an age where public trust in the media is at an all-time low. Just 21% of Americans say they have “a lot of trust in the information from national news organizations.” In my community, it’s probably much lower. Routinely, Orthodox and haredi Jews are forced to read news reports about us that have very little correlation to reality. A perfect example of this happened this past Tuesday, when Attorney General William P.
The re-ghettoizing of the Jews
Reporters and politicians finally noticed the yearslong wave of anti-Semitic violence in and around New York City. Yet even after the deadly shooting of visibly Orthodox Jews in Jersey City and the machete attack in Monsey, New York, there’s been little curiosity for scrutinizing how we got here. In fact, there’s a bizarre consensus beginning to form that casts the victims in this tragedy as the aggressors — for simply living near others.
STEINBERG: Attacks On Orthodox Jewish Education Ought To Frighten Everyone
Over the past few weeks, the stories of how visibly Orthodox Jews have been getting physically assaulted with regularity on the streets of New York have finally broken through, and people are now becoming aware of what these people have been contending with for no other reason than the fact that they are identifiable people of faith.
How this anti-Semitism came to be: The virulent hatred snowballed over the years
By Eli Steinberg New York Daily News | Dec 31, 2019 | 5:00 AM More attacks, more blood. (Vic Nicastro for New York Daily News) Orthodox Jews around the country — and specifically in the tri-state area — were still reeling from the shooting at a kosher deli earlier this month when we gathered with our families to celebrate the holiday of Chanukah.
Anti-Semitism Isn't Blacks Vs. Jews. Saying So Hurts Us All.
Hanukkah of 2019 will be remembered as the week that the anti-Semitic violence that has become the new normal for us Orthodox Jews finally made it into mainstream consciousness. According to the Anti-Defamation League, at least 10 attacks took place over Hanukkah alone, reinforcing what we in the community have known for a while now: It's open season on visibly Orthodox Jews.
The Violence Faced by Orthodox Jews
The Violence Faced by Orthodox Jews It isn't anything that has to do with ant-Semitism which bothers these people, it is all about politics. Read Full Article »
Opinion | The Silence Surrounding Violence Against Us Orthodox Jews Is Deafening
Yesterday was one of those days Jews are becoming more and more familiar with. It was a day we wish we could forget, but we know we will remember forever. With two murderers deliberately targeting a Jewish store in Jersey City, killing three innocent people, two of them Jews, the confidence we can have in our own safety and security seems more and more tenuous by the day. It feels like we will be the only people who will remember it, though.
Opinion | I’m An Orthodox Jew. Why Is Bernie Sanders Whitewashing Violence Against Us?
If any of my fellow Orthodox Jews were naïve enough to expect presidential candidate and Vermont senator Bernie Sanders’ recent essay entitled “How to Fight anti-Semitism” to have a single word about how to combat the daily violent attacks we are facing, they would be sorely mistaken. Indeed, while purporting to hold the key to fighting anti-Semitism, Senator Sanders has written a guide for how to blame others for the problem while simultaneously erasing it.
No One Cares About Attacks Against The Orthodox Because You've Been Dehumanizing Us For Decades
You've all heard the story: A Haredi Jew violently assaulted in broad daylight somewhere in New York City. It happens so often now, with what is almost a chilling regularity, it's virtually impossible to miss. According to the NYPD, anti-Semitic hate crimes have skyrocketed in the past year; the 145 complaints so far in 2019 alone are sharply up from 88 in that same time frame a year earlier - a year which itself saw a 22% increase from 2017.
Anti-Semitism Is Bi-Partisan. Why Isn't Fighting It?
On Monday afternoon, House Democratic leaders decided to put a resolution on the floor in response to more remarks from Minnesota Congresswoman Ilhan Omar. The decision came after Omar's accusations that some have sworn allegiance to a foreign country, a claim viewed by many as an anti-Semitic stereotype. This time, she did not apologize but doubled down on Twitter on Sunday.
Opinion | Why Accusing Jews Of White Nationalism Is Not OK
In the aftermath of the Pittsburgh massacre, Jews all over the world sought to make sense of the horror that was the single greatest act of violence targeting Jews in the history of the United States of America. For some people, that meant expressions of solidarity. For some it meant turning to religion, engaging in various religious practicesin memory of those who were viciously murdered. But for others, a form of mourning took them down a different path.
Opinion | I Believe Dr. Ford. But I Hope Brett Kavanaugh Is Confirmed.
If the point of last Thursday’s Senate Judiciary Committee hearing was to figure out if Dr. Christine Blasey Ford’s allegation, that she was sexually assaulted by a teenaged Judge Brett Kavanaugh, was true, the hearing was a complete and utter failure. Both Ford and Kavanaugh, President Trump’s Supreme Court nominee, came across as credible, her in her allegation and him in his denial, leaving the committee in the same place they had been before the hearing.
Opinion | Anti-Orthodox Is The New Anti-Semitism
I’ve recently come to a shocking realization about American society. Over the past few years, it has become increasingly clear that it’s okay to hate Jews. I’m not talking about the abhorrent anti-Semitism of the “alt-right,” where wannabe politicians stoke the flames of bigotry just so that they can get the fleeting feeling of relevance. Thankfully, that sort of thing gets soundly condemned by people of goodwill from across the political and societal spectrums.
Rubashkin Was Put On Trial - But So Were We
Last Wednesday President Trump unexpectedly commuted the sentence of Sholom Mordechai Rubashkin. Rubashkin had been the executive of Agriprocessors, which was, at one point, the largest Kosher meatpacking plant in the United States. At the time of his commuted sentence, Rubashkin was eight years into a 27-year sentence for financial crimes he committed as he tried to keep his business afloat in the aftermath of a massive Immigration and Customs Enforcement raid on his plant in 2008.
The “Death” of “Virtue”
Despite the insistence of the Trump supporters that the conservatives who refuse to support him will be to blame for his inevitable loss, the reality is that we remain too small a minority to be able to make that kind of a difference.
The GOP Convention Should Give Trump An Anti-Trump Veep
While delegates may be required to vote for Trump on the first ballot, making him the nominee, that is the extent to which they are bound to him. They are under no obligation to vote for his chosen running mate. The months of work Ted Cruz (and to a lesser extent, John Kasich) put into the ground in securing people who have a fealty to the conservative movement for those slots, while not denying Trump the nomination, could pay off, albeit not in the way they anticipated.
Trying To Win - Soapbox DC - Medium
There really isn’t much of a question as to who is going to win the New York Primary. In just about every poll taken in the past week, Donald Trump leads the rest of the field by at least 27 points. Texas Senator Ted Cruz and Ohio Governor John Kasich are both far behind Trump, in the low 20’s to the high teens. But the candidates not named Trump are still doing some campaigning in the Empire State, with an emphasis on New York City.
Trying To Win - Medium
There really isn’t much of a question as to who is going to win the New York Primary. In just about every poll taken in the past week, Donald Trump leads the rest of the field by at least 27 points. Texas Senator Ted Cruz and Ohio Governor John Kasich are both far behind Trump, in the low 20’s to the high teens. But the candidates not named Trump are still doing some campaigning in the Empire State, with an emphasis on New York City.
What Trump Has Really Exposed About The Conservative Movement
There has been a lot of talk of late about what is to blame for the Trump phenomenon. Everyone, it seems, has an opinion about this, and everyone is happy to share their opinions. What those opinions happen to be was put best by Yuval Levin. In an appearance on The Federalist Radio Hour with Ben Domenech, he said: Hardly anyone has come up with a brand new thought as to what it is about the GOP that has caused Trump to “happen”.
Liberalism And Jewish Values Are Not Synonymous
There are few things I find more frustrating than when liberals misrepresent facts in order to advance their agenda. It takes a special kind of intellectual laziness to sell a policy to an uninformed public with an argument predicated on untruths presented as undisputable facts.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Eli
Contact Eli, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack