Queensland Government pauses rollout of statutory trust accounts The Queensland Government has paused the commencement of the next phases rolling out the trust account framework under the Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (BIF Act). Phase 3 and 4, originally scheduled for 1 March 2025 and 1 October 2025, would have expanded the range of eligible construction contracts covered by the framework. Read more about what this means for you in our earlier Alert.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Graham Read
Security of payment wrap
Claim in New South Wales not for “construction work” In EnerMech Pty Ltd v Acciona Infrastructure Projects Australia Pty Ltd [2024] NSWCA 162, the NSW Court of Appeal held that a payment claim under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payments Act 1999 (NSW) (NSW Act) is not limited to claims "for construction work" and may extend to different entitlement under a construction contract.
No intention to be legally bound to subcontract work
In Cirrus Real Time Processing Systems Pty Limited v Hawker Pacific Pty Ltd [2024] FCA 763, the Federal Court rejected Cirrus’s claim that it had a binding agreement to supply Hawker with training software and associated services. Prior to Hawker submitting its bid for a New Zealand Defence Force (NZDF) contract, Cirrus provided a series of quotes during confidential negotiations with Hawker. Hawker sought Cirrus's permission to disclose its quote to NZDF.
High Court considers duty to avoid causing pure economic loss
The High Court has found that a seed producer did not owe a duty of care to farmers to avoid causing pure economic loss, where one party does not have a contractual relationship with another. The extent of such a duty (which may be owed depending on the salient features of that relationship) is an important issue in construction disputes, as recently illustrated in Raymond v Lewis [2024] QCA 43.
Prevention principle enlivened for failure to grant access to valuers
In Brightman v Royal Pines Projects Pty Ltd [2024] QSC 149, Brightman and other buyers entered into off-the-plan apartment contracts with Royal Pines. Prior to the settlement date, the buyers sought access for valuers to inspect the apartments. Royal Pines denied access to the valuers for a week and the buyers were unable to obtain finance prior to the nominated settlement date for the apartments.
Federal Court considers contractual regime for interim payment of liquidated damages
In Rimfire Energy Pty Ltd v BSF Co Pty Ltd [2024] FCA 602, the Federal Court applied a contractual interim payment regime to a claim for liquidated damages. The case considered two power purchase agreements between a buyer (Rimfire) and supplier (BSF), which provided that a party must pay 50% of a disputed invoice amount pending resolution of the disputed invoice, at which point any overpayment must be refunded (interim payment clauses).
High Court rules on proportionate liability in arbitrations
In Tesseract International Pty Ltd v Pascale Construction Pty Ltd [2024] HCA 24, a majority of the High Court has confirmed that proportionate liability regimes can apply in arbitration in South Australia. Pascale engaged Tesseract to perform engineering work for Pascale’s construction of a Bunnings Warehouse. Pascale commenced an arbitration about Tesseract’s allegedly defective work. As part of its defence, Tesseract sought to attribute liability to a third party designer engaged by Pascale.
NSW's Energy Security Corporation established
The Energy Security Corporation Act 2024 (NSW) came into effect on 24 June and, consequently, the NSW Energy Security Corporation has also now been established.
Court confirms personal liability for defect rectification costs
Court confirms personal liability for defect rectification costs In Kazzi v KR Properties Global Pty Ltd t/as AK Properties Group [2024] NSWCA 143, the NSW Court of Appeal found the sole director of a building company personally liable for defect rectification costs via s 37 of the Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW) in relation to a residential building project.
Role of Infrastructure NSW expanded to deliver infrastructure in Western Sydney
The NSW Government recently expanded the role of Infrastructure NSW (INSW) and its Infrastructure Co-ordinator General (and CEO), to improve the coordination and delivery of infrastructure projects in Western Sydney.
Australian Anti-Slavery Commissioner to be established
The Australian Parliament has this week passed the Modern Slavery Amendment (Australian Anti-Slavery Commissioner) Bill 2023 which will establish the Australian Anti-Slavery Commissioner. The function of the Commissioner will be to work with Government, business and the wider community to support compliance with the Modern Slavery Act 2018.
Importance of procedural fairness in an adjudication
Ingeteam Australia Pty Ltd v Susan River Solar Pty Limited & Ors [2024] QSC 30 illustrates that an adjudicator's choice to deny procedural fairness can turn a small issue (a claim of $294.24 for a piece of plywood and materials bought at Bunnings) into a material jurisdictional error. In this case, an adjudicator made a finding that Ingeteam had engaged in unlicensed building work when it undertook a minor floor repair by taping the plywood over an existing shed floor.
No jurisdictional error: adjudicator's reasons brief, but adequate
A New South Wales Supreme Court decision draws attention to the challenges parties face in seeking to establish jurisdictional error in adjudication determinations. In Bega Valley Shire Council v Kenpass Pty Ltd [2024] NSWSC 399, Justice Nixon declined to overturn an adjudication determination on the grounds of alleged jurisdictional error.
Overpayments and bank guarantees: who's out of pocket?
In Sun Engineering (Qld) Pty Ltd v Ravenswood Gold Pty Ltd [2024] QSC 68, the Court construed the contractual provisions governing recourse to and retention of a bank guarantee to give effect to its commercial purpose – that of a risk allocation device.
Buyer beware: no duty of care in negligence to subsequent purchasers if they are not "vulnerable"
The Queensland Court of Appeal has provided a reminder that the original builder of a defective building, including where that building is a dwelling house, owes no duty of care in negligence against pure economic loss to subsequent purchasers of the building unless the subsequent purchasers are "vulnerable" in the relevant sense. In Raymond v Lewis [2024] QCA 43, Ms Lewis purchased a residential property in Paddington after being the successful bidder at an auction.
High Court gives guidance on wasted expenditure damages
A recent High Court decision (Cessnock City Council v 123 259 932 Pty Ltd [2024] HCA 17) navigates the legal principles relevant to damages for breach of contract, particularly the ability to recover wasted expenditure incurred in reliance upon an expectation that the other party would honour its contractual obligations ("reliance damages").
Mistakes happen: when will the Court intervene?
In SSABR Pty Ltd v AMA Group Ltd [2023] NSWSC 1551, the NSW Supreme Court ordered the rectification of a business sale agreement to make the document conform to the parties' true agreement. Although not specifically a construction law case, it recaps the requirements for rectification of contract and is of broad application. It also illustrates how courts can look at evidence of prior negotiations with a claim for rectification.
Principal permitted to call on bank guarantee in the face of arbitral proceedings
A recent NSW Supreme Court decision reinforces the Australian position that the courts will allow a party to call upon a bank guarantee even where the parties have agreed to arbitration where the guarantee serves as a "risk allocation device".
Court adopts a practical approach when considering who is authorised to receive a payment claim
The Queensland Supreme Court has adopted a practical approach to consider who was authorised to receive a payment claim. In Canadian Solar Construction Pty Ltd v Re Oakey Pty Ltd [2023] QSC 288, Canadian Solar Construction Pty Ltd (Claimant) sent an email to a director of Re Oakey Pty Ltd (Respondent), as well a number of others who were employed in various capacities by the Respondent's agent and project manager (Foresight).
Proportionate liability scheme does not apply to liability under NSW statutory duty of care
Proportionate liability scheme does not apply to liability under NSW statutory duty of care The NSW Court of Appeal has confirmed that the proportionate liability regime cannot be used to defend a claim for a breach of the statutory duty of care under section 37 of the Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW) (DBP Act).
Major projects & construction 5 Minute Fix 121: High Court declines opportunity to consider "contracting out" misleading and deceptive conduct under Australian Consumer Law; hears important case on proportionate liability and arbitrations
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Greg Midgley, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
High Court declines opportunity to consider "contracting out" misleading and deceptive conduct under Australian Consumer Law; hears important case on proportionate liability and arbitrations On 9 November 2023, the High Court of Australia dismissed Viterra Malt Pty Ltd's Special Leave application in relation to proceedings decided against them by the Victorian Court of Appeal in Viterra Malt Pty Ltd v Cargill Australia Limited [2023] VSCA 157.
Major projects & construction 5 Minute Fix 121: Federal Court confirms an objective, contextual approach to ACT Payment Claims
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Greg Midgley, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
In Bloc Constructions (ACT) Pty LTD v ABS Facade (ACT) Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 1282, the Federal Court refused an application to overturn an adjudicator's determination. These types of security of payment applications usually run in state courts; it came to the Federal Court from the ACT via its cross-vesting jurisdiction for that jurisdiction, offering the Court an opportunity to provide a detailed review of the legislation.
Major projects & construction 5 Minute Fix 121: Unfair contract terms and the potential impact of legislative amendments on construction contracts
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Greg Midgley, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
Unfair contract terms and the potential impact of legislative amendments on construction contracts On 9 November 2023, the final amendments from the Treasury Laws Amendment (More Competition, Better Prices) Act 2022 (Cth) came into effect, expanding the unfair contract terms (UCT) regime under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL).
"Conditional" certificate of practical completion not valid resulting in large liability for liquidated damages
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Greg Midgley, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
The New South Wales Supreme Court has provided a salient reminder that superintendents (and parties) must understand the requirements of the terms of the contract, particularly when granting practical completion. If the parties desire a course of action not permitted under the contract, they will need to agree on that separate process or amend the contract.
No termination for works outside of scope
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Greg Midgley, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
In RW & ME Smith Pty Ltd v Boral Resources (Vic) Pty Ltd [2023] VSCA 182, the Victorian Court of Appeal held that a termination right had not been validly exercised because the unsafe works relied upon were not required by the contract. The proceedings related to a cartage agreement with the applicant, RW & ME Smith (operated by Robert Smith). Boral had requested Mr Smith assist replacement of a broken drive chain at Boral's concrete plant.
Relying on new reasons to justify non-payment after the fact
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Greg Midgley, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
In Digga Excavations Tas Pty Ltd v Linear Capital Pty Ltd [2023] TASSC 22, the Tasmanian Supreme Court confirmed that parties can rely on a contractual right to refuse payment of a progress claim, even though the right was not raised at the time payment was refused. In August 2016, the parties agreed to suspend works so Linear Capital could source alternative funding for the project. At the time, Linear Capital had paid three of six progress claims submitted by Digga Excavations.
Arbitration agreement no impediment to joinder in court proceedings
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Greg Midgley, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
A recent decision of the Court of Appeal of Western Australia, North West Pilots Pty Ltd v Daniel [2023] WASCA 122, has upheld a primary judge's order for joinder of a party in circumstances where the plaintiff and the joined second respondent were parties to an arbitration agreement.
Major Projects & Construction 5 Minute Fix 113: Court declines stay application despite concurrent proceedings under Residential Apartment Buildings (Compliance & Enforcement Powers) Act
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, Andrew Leece, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
In Strata Plan 99576 v Central Construct Pty Ltd [2023] NSWSC 212, the NSW Supreme Court has rejected a contractor and developer's (Builder) application to stay proceedings for 12 months, commenced against the Builder in relation to building defects the subject of an investigation by the Department of Fair Trading's "Project Intervene" – an initiative under the Residential Apartment Buildings (Compliance & Enforcement Powers) Act 2020 (NSW) (RAB Act).
Major Projects & Construction 5 Minute Fix 113: Conditional notices of practical completion invalid in the absence of contractual separable portions
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, Andrew Leece, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
Parkview Constructions Pty Ltd v Futuroscop Enterprises Pty Ltd [2023] NSWSC 178 offers a useful reminder from the NSW Supreme Court that unless a contract expressly divides work under the contract into separable portions, a superintendent cannot issue a certificate of practical completion for some of the Works. The case concerned the design and construction of two buildings, a hotel and a carpark, under an AS4902-2000 contract.
Major Projects & Construction 5 Minute Fix 113: Enforcement of international arbitral award
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, Andrew Leece, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
Australia is considered a “pro-arbitration” jurisdiction including because, courts generally enforce domestic and foreign arbitration awards. This was illustrated in Guoao Holding Group Co Ltd v Xue (No 2) [2022] FCA 1584, which involved an unsuccessful attempt to set aside a Chinese arbitral award under section 8(7)(b) of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth). Section 8(7)(b) permits a court to decline to enforce an international arbitral award on public policy grounds.
Major Projects & Construction 5 Minute Fix 113: Security of payment wrap-up
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, Andrew Leece, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
Key issues arising from four recent judgments regarding adjudication determinations under security of payment legislation in NSW and Queensland are below. In NSW, three adjudication determinations were set aside (in part or in full), while in Queensland an adjudication determination was left in place.
Major Projects & Construction 5 Minute Fix 112: Hopelessly insolvent? There is hope
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Gavin Phillips Verified, Chris Slocombe, James Kendal, Andrew Leece, Steve O'Reilly, Joanna Pugsley, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
In Kennedy Civil Contracting Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) v Richard Crookes Constructing Pty Ltd v Richard Crookes Construction Pty Ltd; In the matter of Kennedy Civil Contracting Pty Ltd [2023] NSWSC 99, the NSW Supreme Court considered whether a company on the brink of liquidation can take action to enforce a payment claim under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) (SOP Act).
Major Projects & Construction 5 Minute Fix 112: Certificate of Practical Completion no passing matter
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, Andrew Leece, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
An appeal of an adjudication determination under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2002 (Vic), J Hutchinson Pty Ltd v Transcend Plumbing and Gasfitting Pty Ltd [2023] VSC 39 examines the importance of a Certificate of Practical Completion and its significance when determining reference dates for payment claims.
Major Projects & Construction 5 Minute Fix 112: Make every day count: align your contractual progress claim process with the statutory process
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, Andrew Leece, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
Make every day count: align your contractual progress claim process with the statutory process There is no obligation to align contractual timeframes for giving payment certificates and the statutory time frame for giving payment schedules under security of payment (SOP) legislation but, if they are not aligned, the recent Queensland Court of Appeal decision of Allencon Pty Ltd v Palmgrove Holdings Pty Ltd trading as Carruthers Contracting [2023] QCA 6 highlights what can go wrong for a...
What are the economic impacts of making more space for walking and cycling?
As seen on our Space to move map, many local authorities are announcing new measures to make it safer for people to walk and cycle during the COVID-19 crisis. As they do, we are starting to hear the inevitable questions about the impact that pedestrianisation and removing car parking spaces will have on the local economy. Here, our Director for England South, James Cleeton, answers those important questions.
2019’s First New Formula 1 Car Is Revealed By Haas
2019’s First New Formula 1 Car Is Revealed By Haas Graham Read, Formula 1 Correspondent The 2019 Rich Energy Haas F1 team’s new car The first new Formula 1 car for the 2019 season has been revealed by American owned team Haas, whose operational sites are split between Banbury in the UK and Kannapolis in the USA. The car sports an attractive black and gold livery to reflect the corporate colours of its new title sponsor Rich Energy, a British-based energy drink company.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Graham
Contact Graham, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack