Starkids Musicals very much have a cult following, with a good proportion of each audience established fans who already know the show well, and anticipate each moment, occasionally preempting punchlines. All of this Can be a little disconcerting for the “average theatre goer” who may wonder what they are missing. Thankfully, The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals is well directed, staged and performed, so even if you feel you are missing something, there is some good singing to enjoy.