Behavioral economists Nick Chater and George Loewenstein, a Brit and an American, have both had a revelation. In their new book, It’s On You, they reconsider an idea they once enthusiastically embraced. A 2008 book by Cass Sunstein and Richard Thaler called Nudge applied principles from behavioral economics to get people to act against their irrational biases. “Nudge” practices were embraced.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by John Staddon
Rara Avis : Professor Finds Harvard’s Faults
Harvey Mansfield is the William R. Kenan Jr. Professor of Government at Harvard University. Still teaching at the age of 94, he has just published a collection of essays, Where Harvard Went Wrong: Fifty Years of Commentary that Fell on Deaf Ears. The book is a collection of his articles, speeches, and book reviews going as far back as 1975.
An Answer to an 'Excruciating Question' — Minding The Campus
The temptation to twist logic for racist ends is almost irresistible. I encountered an almost humorous example a few months ago in an article in the Chronicle of Higher Education by a professor of religious studies and philosophy. Richard Amesbury’s claim is that criticism of “diversity, equity, and inclusion” (DEI) policies is racist. Which is bizarre, given that DEI is itself racist, since it means treating different races differently.
Edinburgh University Smears Its Own Legacy With ‘Racist Foundations’ Report — Minding The Campus
Editor’s Note: The following is a short excerpt of a much longer article originally published by the author on his Substack, Possum’s Substack, on July 30, 2025. With edits to match MTC’s style guidelines, it is cross-posted here with permission. The University of Edinburgh, founded in 1582, has an illustrious history.
Duke Turns Scientists into Salesmen — Minding The Campus
Duke Turns Scientists into Salesmen Duke University’s School of Medicine is preparing to dock the salaries of tenured faculty who fail to bring in enough research grant money—a move that undermines one of academia’s most sacred job protections. Under the policy, basic science professors who fall short of “minimum expectations” for external funding could see their pay reduced to as little as $50,000 a year, Duke Chronicle recently reported.
Helen Lewis’s Dumb Attack on Smart People — Minding The Campus
Atlantic writer Helen Lewis was recently interviewed by respected journalist Bari Weiss about her provocatively titled new book, The Genius Myth: A Curious History of a Dangerous Idea. The title is provocative because it contains two fallacies. First, she says, there is no such thing as exceptional talent.
All Men Are Created Equal but They Are Not Equal in Any Other Way — Minding The Campus
“What Is Replacing DEI? Racism” is the title of a recent article in the Chronicle of Higher Education by Arizona State University professor Richard Amesbury. It is provocative, for sure, but also comes across as ignorant since racism is to many people a feature of “diversity, equity, and inclusion” (DEI) itself. How can abolishing DEI be racist if DEI is itself racist? After all, DEI demands equity—equal outcomes. Equity refers not just to individuals but to averages.
Duke University Press Stays Woke — The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal
I recently came across an alarming 2014 article on academic freedom in the Harvard Crimson. “Let’s give up on academic freedom in favor of justice” was the subtitle. The author was an obviously very bright female student. Academic freedom exists to allow a university to be unimpeded in its search for truth. It has been known since the 18th-century philosopher David Hume, if not before, that justice depends on first getting the facts right. A just conviction depends on true evidence.
Is Trump Destroying Science or Saving It? — The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal
Apparently, some 75 percent of U.S. scientists are planning to emigrate to Canada and Europe “in light of President Donald Trump’s sweeping changes to federal science policy.” Is this a joke or just a bad poll? According to my omniscient AI “Copilot,” the U.S. spends 3.4 percent of GDP on science and Canada only 1.8 percent. Is Canada really a better deal for scientists? Of course, we need to know more details. What kind of science do these two nations favor?
How to Judge a Basic-Research Proposal — The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal
Tech megastar Peter Thiel, in a recent interview, said that he no longer trusts science. Lesser luminaries and no small segment of the public have said much the same. The reasons for this distrust are many: fraud (Thiel mentioned a particularly involving the president of Stanford University); thousands of retracted papers (most justified, some not); massive failure to replicate studies; and weak experimental and analytic methods.
No Borders, No Merit, No Justice: The Bizarre Philosophy of Our Intellectual Elite — Minding The Campus
“Is there any good principled reason not to have open borders?” That is a quote from Harvard professor Michael Sandel in “Two of the World’s Leading Thinkers on How the Left Went Astray,” a New York Times article published on Jan 18. The piece promotes two stars in the progressive pantheon: Sandel and French economist Thomas Piketty, known for his lengthy bestseller on income inequality, Capital in the Twenty-First Century (2013).
Grading and Moral Hazard — The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal
As political pressures for equity—equality of outcome—have grown in recent years, traditional methods of evaluating college students have come under threat. As the proportion of the population going to college has increased, the proportion of students who are not equipped to succeed has also increased. Dealing with an increasing number of marginal students in an equity-charged environment is one factor that has favored grade inflation.
Larry Chavis and the Decay of the Academy — The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal
Larry Chavis is clinical professor of strategy and entrepreneurship at the Kenan-Flagler Business School at UNC. He has taught there for 18 years on a renewable contract. He has now been told that his contract will not be renewed this year. The university has apparently acted in a totally legal way, but Chavis and his supporters are upset: Because of his long service, which seemed to promise some job security. Because a few of his lectures were apparently recorded, by built-in security camera.
Diversity be Damned! — Minding The Campus
zero comment “If critics have a problem with the goal of diversity, they should say so,” writes law professor Stacy Hawkins in a vigorous counterattack against critics of “diversity, equity, and inclusion” (DEI) mandates. Well, here I am. Hawkins notes that even some DEI critics acknowledge the value of racial and ethnic diversity. But they are wrong: diversity does not confer real benefits.
Is a New Campus Speech Initiative For Real? | Eastern North Carolina Now
Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of The James G. Martin Center. The author of this post is John Staddon. Thirteen college presidents, including those of Duke, Cornell, and Rutgers, have signed on to the "Campus Call for Free Expression" (CCFE), a project organized by a low-profile Princeton-and-Woodrow-Wilson-related group called the Institute for Citizens & Scholars.
Equity is Not Science — Minding The Campus
zero comment Suppose I were to tell you that in a North Carolina county, neighborhoods with a “lower percentage of White individuals … lower economic and racial spatial advantage, and higher area deprivation” and “higher reported violent crimes, evictions, poverty, unemployment, uninsurance, and child care center density, as well as lower election participation, income, and education,” are areas that also had a higher incidence of three chronic diseases. What would you conclude?
Early Warnings Were Ignored: DEI Trainings and Social Pressure — Minding The Campus
zero comment I know of no country in which there is so little independence of mind and freedom of discussion as in America — Alexis de Tocqueville From 1991 to 1994, at Duke University, I edited a publication called the Faculty Newsletter. The Newsletter had a short and rather erratic history and folded a couple of years after I quit.
Net Zero: Three Graphs That Might Make You Skeptical
Despite North Carolina slowly injuring itself by trying to eliminate oil, coal, and natural gas as energy sources, the scientific basis for “net zero” (the complete elimination of fossil-fuel usage) is based more on “general agreement” than hard data. Climate scientists nevertheless sound optimistic about the progress that is being made in destroying society’s carbon-energy base.
This is What Decolonisation Looks Like – The Daily Sceptic
“This is what decolonisation looks like!” yelled a gleeful online activist the day after the October 7th Hamas massacre of 1,200 Israelis. He was not alone and he was right: horror and suffering very often are what ‘decolonisation’ looks like. The decolonisation and subsequent partition of India in 1947, for example, led to excess mortality of around one million says the occasionally reliable Wikipedia. Other sources put the number much higher.
Three Graphs That Show There Is No ‘Climate Crisis’
By John Staddon As the West fitfully weakens industrial civilisation by trying to eliminate oil, coal and natural gas as energy sources, the scientific basis for Net Zero is based more on ‘general agreement’ than hard data. Climate scientists nevertheless sound optimistic about the progress that’s being made in destroying society’s carbon energy base.
Three Graphs That Show There Is No ‘Climate Crisis’ – The Daily Sceptic
As the West fitfully weakens industrial civilisation by trying to eliminate oil, coal and natural gas as energy sources, the scientific basis for Net Zero is based more on ‘general agreement’ than hard data. Climate scientists nevertheless sound optimistic about the progress that’s being made in destroying society’s carbon energy base.
Is a New Campus Speech Initiative For Real? — The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal
Thirteen college presidents, including those of Duke, Cornell, and Rutgers, have signed on to the “Campus Call for Free Expression” (CCFE), a project organized by a low-profile Princeton-and-Woodrow-Wilson-related group called the Institute for Citizens & Scholars.
Actions Matter: The IAT's Fallacious Arguments — Minding The Campus
zero comment Mahzarin Banaji and Frank Dobbin, a Harvard psychologist and sociologist, explain in a recent Wall Street Journal article, “Why DEI Training Doesn’t Work—and How to Fix It.” The article is based on something called the Implicit Association Test (IAT), invented in 1998 and available to all on a Harvard University website. The IAT is a major topic of Banaji’s research.
Minding the Sciences — DEI Takes the NIH — Minding The Campus
Affirmative-action peer review The National Institutes of Health (NIH) has supported extramural biomedical research since the end of WWII. This year, the program spent close to $40 billion. The basic concept is simple.
Science is Rotting from the Top
Science leadership has forgotten … science The texts for today are from Dr. Marcia McNutt, editor-in-chief of Science from 2013–2016 and current president of the National Academy of Sciences. First, we have an interview with the Columbia University Center on Global Energy Policy from 2018: Interviewer: I want to touch on a topic that’s another of your priorities here at the Academy, and that’s diversity. What are you trying to do and why?
DEI is a Wolf in Sheep’s Clothing
A law school dean tries to square the circle The ruckus at Stanford Law School surrounding the March 9 shout-down of Judge Kyle Duncan has abated. But we can learn much from four documents that have since emerged: Associate Dean for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Tirien Steinbach’s placatory speech, statements by two ‘marginalized’ student groups, and a 5,000-word account defending Stanford’s position by Stanford Law Dean Jennifer Martinez.
WikiBias: How Wikipedia erases “fringe theories” and enforces conformity — Minding The Campus
Wikipedia is probably the most widely used encyclopedia in the world. If you’re looking for facts, it is pretty reliable. For example, if you want to compare the number of traffic roundabouts per capita in the US and other countries, Wikipedia will provide a nice graph from the World Economic Forum showing that the UK has about thirteen times as many as the US. On the other hand, Wikipedia is not a reliable source for some controversial topics.
Social Scientism
How social science has become social commentary It is well known that social science—psychology, sociology, and economics—has devolved into more than one hundred sub-specialties. Less well known is the result: criticism, which is essential to science, is increasingly restricted to bubbles of the like-minded. This has allowed critical criteria to diverge to the point that some areas of social science have ceased to be scientific at all.
The Corruption of Science by Social Justice
Western civilization depends on science, but science, especially social science, is now under threat. Until WWII, science was mostly a vocation. Scientists were motivated by curiosity and the search for verifiable truth. Since the growth of centralized, largely governmental funding, science has become not so much a vocation as a profession. Career incentives now increasingly compete with disinterested inquiry.
Are Robots Better at Churning Out Woke Gobbledegook than University EDI Officers? – The Daily Sceptic
Last year I wrote an article for the Daily Sceptic on the draft Vision statement of University College, London. I was not impressed by the level of thought reflected in the document. The Vision statement struck me as possibly the output of some kind of bot. In the meantime, just such a bot, chatGPT, has become publicly available. So I thought it might be interesting to see what it comes up with when fed with my suggested botwords.
Kendi’s Fallacy and Its Consequences
Human beings are not all the same. People vary by height, hair color, skin tone, sex, and along any other dimension you care to measure: strength, size, beauty, cognitive abilities—such as intelligence and verbal and mathematical ability—musical ability and so on. From a biological point of view, this variation is positive and contributes to humans’ ability to survive in a wide variety of environments. These individual differences are often also correlated.
Diversity Is a Trojan Horse
How ‘Identity Science’ Canceled an Editor The U.S. Supreme Court, in its 1978 Bakke decision, shoehorned racial preferences into legality by identifying (racial and ethnic) diversity as an intrinsic good, a non-merit factor that may be legally used to tilt hiring and college admissions. Now, diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) have become part of the science establishment, with predictably destructive results.
Taking David Horowitz Seriously
The Academic Bill of Rights revisited David Horowitz is a controversial fellow. Born into a communist family in New York and involved early on with the Black Panthers, he remained on the Left until he was repulsed by the murder of a woman friend, a killing for which he held the Panthers responsible. He describes this transition in his book Radical Son (1997).
Has The Chronicle of Higher Education Become an Organ of the Democratic Party?
The Chronicle of Higher Education (CHE) remains steadfast in its support of social justice and liberal politics. In a typical op-ed entitled “The Right-Wing Attempt to Control Higher Ed: Demolishing independent expertise is a central goal of the Republican Party,” education professors Brendan Cantwell and Barrett J. Taylor showed their antipathy toward Republicans and linked to a number of other sites that agree: Republicans bad, anti-science, and anti-expert.
A Failure to Communicate?
Science versus Sentimentality “What we’ve got here is failure to communicate!” Thus spake prison guard Strother Martin in the movie Cool Hand Luke, and so it is now between the woke and their opponents. In a recent dispute over affirmative action that got some publicity, one party affirms that, despite her best efforts, she has been misunderstood.
Stratification Economics?
Print Science is naturally subdivided into specialties and sub-specialties. In the physical sciences isolation of one specialty from another isn’t too much of a problem, because all share a common framework. Chemistry acknowledges the laws of physics and vice versa. There is also a shared framework in biology in the form of species classification, evolution, genetics, and the like. Social science is without this kind of common understanding.
Science in an Age of Unreason
Science in an Age of Unreason By John Staddon (Regnery Gateway, 256 pages, $27) “Science is about is not ought,” John Staddon repeats in variation throughout his new book, Science in an Age of Unreason. But people who are so obsessed with the best world possible that they dismiss what exists around them do not always hear reason. They believe the dream must subsume everything — comedy, awards shows, sports, social media, late-night television — for its glorious ends.
The Ideological Capture of Nature and Why it Matters
“Science must overcome its racist legacy“, is the headline of an article in Nature that appeared last month, followed by a commitment from four guest editors of colour to “help decolonise research and forge a path towards restorative justice and reconciliation”, a reparations-tinged evocation of South Africa’s post-apartheid experience. It is both embarrassing and disgraceful that Nature, the pre-eminent British scientific journal, should surrender to an explicitly anti-science ideology.
Fact vs. Faith: Science In An Age Of Unreason
By John Staddon Science is in trouble. The symptoms include the bickering and vacillation over COVID, and continuing hysteria about climate change. Science also has internal problems—replicability, for example, the ability to repeat an experiment and get the same result. A scientific fact is a result that is 100% repeatable. Yet, in the last decade and a half as many as 60 percent or more of results in social and biomedical science have turned out to be unrepeatable.
Fact vs. Faith: Science in an Age of Unreason
Print Science is in trouble. The symptoms include the bickering and vacillation over COVID, and continuing hysteria about climate change. Science also has internal problems—replicability, for example, the ability to repeat an experiment and get the same result. A scientific fact is a result that is 100% repeatable. Yet, in the last decade and a half as many as 60 percent or more of results in social and biomedical science have turned out to be unrepeatable. There are yet other internal problems.
In their Desperation to be Woke, Universities are Losing their Way
The term multiversity was coined by respected University of California president Clark Kerr in a famous 1963 lecture. Kerr’s vision was originally received as a prophetic acknowledgement of a splendid technocratic future. But Kerr believed himself to be misunderstood. He was never so sure that the multiversity, inevitable as it seemed to be, was a great idea.
Science Needs Honesty, Not Affirmative Action
Holden Thorp is a very clever fellow. With a PhD in chemistry from Caltech and after some business ventures and a spell teaching at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, he ascended to the chancellorship of the university in 2007 at the young age of 43. He resigned in 2013 amid allegations of widespread academic fraud in the Chapel Hill Department of African and Afro-American studies. Undeterred, Thorp went on to become provost at Washington University in St. Louis.
Science Needs Honesty, Not Affirmative Action — The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal
Holden Thorp is a very clever fellow. With a PhD in chemistry from Caltech and after some business ventures and a spell teaching at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, he ascended to the chancellorship of the university in 2007 at the young age of 43. He resigned in 2013 amid allegations of widespread academic fraud in the Chapel Hill Department of African and Afro-American studies. Undeterred, Thorp went on to become provost at Washington University in St. Louis.
Education and the Absurd Beliefs of the Cult of Anti-Racism
The notion of antiracism now dominates at all levels of education, from infant to university. In a previous piece, I described how the 2017 President of American Educational Research Association (AERA) gave speeches to teachers instructing them that teaching math to kids poses a racist threat, playing a set of video clips to underline her theme that no matter what improvements in rigor, classroom debate, etc.
Math Teachers are Taught that Elementary Math Education is a “Struggle for Justice” — The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal
Does the average person have any idea what is now considered “normal” in the field of K-12 education? I already had some misgivings after reading Jay Schalin’s devastating review of the curricula in education schools: The Politicization of University Schools of Education: The Long March through the Education Schools. Nevertheless, I was unprepared for what I recently heard in a 2019 speech by a leader in math education, Deborah Loewenberg Ball.
There's Nothing Profreedom about "Nudging" People with Government Policy | John Staddon
Home | Wire | There's Nothing Profreedom about "Nudging" People with Government Policy The July/August 2021 Cato Policy Report hosted a friendly debate between Cass Sunstein and Mario Rizzo. Sunstein is a Harvard Law professor, a onetime member of the Obama administration, and coauthor of Nudge and other books advocating public policy applications of behavioral economics. Rizzo is an economist at New York University.
The Multiversity and its Discontents: The Evolution of a Fatal Flaw
A well-known podcaster has the custom of going “off the grid” for a month each summer, to gain some perspective. I can beat that: I have been retired from academic teaching and research for nearly 14 years and have rarely visited my campus during that time. But last year, I finally encountered the university first-hand, as it is now. Like a 21st-century Rip Van Winkle, I found it almost unrecognizable. The Multiversity The seeds were sown long ago.
Why Can’t Academia Tolerate Dissent on Biological Sex? | National Review
|
By John Staddon, Michael B. Dougherty Verified, Kevin D. Williamson Verified, David Bahnsen Verified
|
National Review
Verified
(AMAYRA/iStock/Getty Images) It shouldn’t be controversial to assert that there are only two sexes. We have passed through one or two generations of post-Pill sexual liberation only for sex and gender to once again become topics impossible to discuss in a dispassionate way — even in a supposedly scientific venue, such as a listserv of the American Psychological Association (APA). Recently, I was excluded from an email discussion listserv of the APA.
If All Men are Created Equal, Why Do We Need Grades? — The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal
I just finished a fascinating book, The Recovery of the West, by polymath Englishman Michael Roberts. Roberts became famous as a poet, but was trained as a scientist and spent much of his life as a teacher. Brief history of grading The book was published in 1941. A teacher in a typical English school at that time would be very familiar with individual differences in ability because grading practices were unforgiving.
Why Do American Universities Lead the World in Scientific Research? — The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal
Miguel Urquiola is professor and chair of the department of economics at Columbia University. His special field is education and his book Markets, Minds, and Money: Why America Leads the World in University Research is about American higher education—its history, its relationship to higher education in Europe, and the trajectory it has followed from the first green shoots of the Ivy League.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with John
Contact John, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack