High Court declines opportunity to consider "contracting out" misleading and deceptive conduct under Australian Consumer Law; hears important case on proportionate liability and arbitrations On 9 November 2023, the High Court of Australia dismissed Viterra Malt Pty Ltd's Special Leave application in relation to proceedings decided against them by the Victorian Court of Appeal in Viterra Malt Pty Ltd v Cargill Australia Limited [2023] VSCA 157.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Jonathan McTigue
Major projects & construction 5 Minute Fix 121: Unfair contract terms and the potential impact of legislative amendments on construction contracts
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Greg Midgley, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
Unfair contract terms and the potential impact of legislative amendments on construction contracts On 9 November 2023, the final amendments from the Treasury Laws Amendment (More Competition, Better Prices) Act 2022 (Cth) came into effect, expanding the unfair contract terms (UCT) regime under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL).
Major projects & construction 5 Minute Fix 121: Federal Court confirms an objective, contextual approach to ACT Payment Claims
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Greg Midgley, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
In Bloc Constructions (ACT) Pty LTD v ABS Facade (ACT) Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 1282, the Federal Court refused an application to overturn an adjudicator's determination. These types of security of payment applications usually run in state courts; it came to the Federal Court from the ACT via its cross-vesting jurisdiction for that jurisdiction, offering the Court an opportunity to provide a detailed review of the legislation.
"Conditional" certificate of practical completion not valid resulting in large liability for liquidated damages
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Greg Midgley, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
The New South Wales Supreme Court has provided a salient reminder that superintendents (and parties) must understand the requirements of the terms of the contract, particularly when granting practical completion. If the parties desire a course of action not permitted under the contract, they will need to agree on that separate process or amend the contract.
Relying on new reasons to justify non-payment after the fact
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Greg Midgley, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
In Digga Excavations Tas Pty Ltd v Linear Capital Pty Ltd [2023] TASSC 22, the Tasmanian Supreme Court confirmed that parties can rely on a contractual right to refuse payment of a progress claim, even though the right was not raised at the time payment was refused. In August 2016, the parties agreed to suspend works so Linear Capital could source alternative funding for the project. At the time, Linear Capital had paid three of six progress claims submitted by Digga Excavations.
No termination for works outside of scope
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Greg Midgley, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
In RW & ME Smith Pty Ltd v Boral Resources (Vic) Pty Ltd [2023] VSCA 182, the Victorian Court of Appeal held that a termination right had not been validly exercised because the unsafe works relied upon were not required by the contract. The proceedings related to a cartage agreement with the applicant, RW & ME Smith (operated by Robert Smith). Boral had requested Mr Smith assist replacement of a broken drive chain at Boral's concrete plant.
Arbitration agreement no impediment to joinder in court proceedings
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Greg Midgley, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
A recent decision of the Court of Appeal of Western Australia, North West Pilots Pty Ltd v Daniel [2023] WASCA 122, has upheld a primary judge's order for joinder of a party in circumstances where the plaintiff and the joined second respondent were parties to an arbitration agreement.
Major Projects & Construction 5 Minute Fix 113: Queensland Government pauses its statutory trust roll-out until 2025
The Queensland Government has announced that the expansion of the statutory trust scheme will be "paused" for up to two years. According to the Government's media release, further work is required to ensure accounting software packages keep pace with the trust account compliance and audit requirements. This change won't affect contracts where a project trust is already required.
Major Projects & Construction 5 Minute Fix 113: Conditional notices of practical completion invalid in the absence of contractual separable portions
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, Andrew Leece, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
Parkview Constructions Pty Ltd v Futuroscop Enterprises Pty Ltd [2023] NSWSC 178 offers a useful reminder from the NSW Supreme Court that unless a contract expressly divides work under the contract into separable portions, a superintendent cannot issue a certificate of practical completion for some of the Works. The case concerned the design and construction of two buildings, a hotel and a carpark, under an AS4902-2000 contract.
Major Projects & Construction 5 Minute Fix 113: Court declines stay application despite concurrent proceedings under Residential Apartment Buildings (Compliance & Enforcement Powers) Act
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, Andrew Leece, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
In Strata Plan 99576 v Central Construct Pty Ltd [2023] NSWSC 212, the NSW Supreme Court has rejected a contractor and developer's (Builder) application to stay proceedings for 12 months, commenced against the Builder in relation to building defects the subject of an investigation by the Department of Fair Trading's "Project Intervene" – an initiative under the Residential Apartment Buildings (Compliance & Enforcement Powers) Act 2020 (NSW) (RAB Act).
Major Projects & Construction 5 Minute Fix 113: Enforcement of international arbitral award
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, Andrew Leece, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
Australia is considered a “pro-arbitration” jurisdiction including because, courts generally enforce domestic and foreign arbitration awards. This was illustrated in Guoao Holding Group Co Ltd v Xue (No 2) [2022] FCA 1584, which involved an unsuccessful attempt to set aside a Chinese arbitral award under section 8(7)(b) of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth). Section 8(7)(b) permits a court to decline to enforce an international arbitral award on public policy grounds.
Major Projects & Construction 5 Minute Fix 113: Security of payment wrap-up
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, Andrew Leece, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
Key issues arising from four recent judgments regarding adjudication determinations under security of payment legislation in NSW and Queensland are below. In NSW, three adjudication determinations were set aside (in part or in full), while in Queensland an adjudication determination was left in place.
Major Projects & Construction 5 Minute Fix 112: Hopelessly insolvent? There is hope
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Gavin Phillips Verified, Chris Slocombe, James Kendal, Andrew Leece, Steve O'Reilly, Joanna Pugsley, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
In Kennedy Civil Contracting Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) v Richard Crookes Constructing Pty Ltd v Richard Crookes Construction Pty Ltd; In the matter of Kennedy Civil Contracting Pty Ltd [2023] NSWSC 99, the NSW Supreme Court considered whether a company on the brink of liquidation can take action to enforce a payment claim under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) (SOP Act).
Major Projects & Construction 5 Minute Fix 112: Certificate of Practical Completion no passing matter
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, Andrew Leece, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
An appeal of an adjudication determination under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2002 (Vic), J Hutchinson Pty Ltd v Transcend Plumbing and Gasfitting Pty Ltd [2023] VSC 39 examines the importance of a Certificate of Practical Completion and its significance when determining reference dates for payment claims.
Major Projects & Construction 5 Minute Fix 112: Make every day count: align your contractual progress claim process with the statutory process
|
By Graham Read, Frank Bannon, Dale Brackin, Sergio Capelli, Alison Close, Stuart Cosgriff, Lina Fischer, Andrew Fry, James Kendal, Andrew Leece, David Lester, Jonathan McTigue, Margaret Davy Michaels, Steven Murray, Steve O'Reilly, Gavin Phillips Verified, Joanna Pugsley, Chris Slocombe, Natalie Speranza, Joanne Teagle
|
Lexology
Verified
Make every day count: align your contractual progress claim process with the statutory process There is no obligation to align contractual timeframes for giving payment certificates and the statutory time frame for giving payment schedules under security of payment (SOP) legislation but, if they are not aligned, the recent Queensland Court of Appeal decision of Allencon Pty Ltd v Palmgrove Holdings Pty Ltd trading as Carruthers Contracting [2023] QCA 6 highlights what can go wrong for a...
Considering a joint venture? What duties will you owe your business partners?
Recent judgments from the South Australia and New South Wales Supreme Courts illustrate how the imposition by the Courts of fiduciary duties can be a double-edged sword in the joint venture context. This article provides some practical guidance for parties wishing to regulate or exclude fiduciary duties from their relationship. Joint ventures (JV) are commercial arrangements between two or more parties to exploit a business opportunity.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Jonathan
Contact Jonathan, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack