How to Build Mental Toughness in High School Athletes: A Coach’s Guide Madison Hunt, Courtney Novak and Leilani Madrigal March 10, 2020 Research, Sport & Coaching Mental toughness in sport can help coaches and athletes maintain consistency and motivation to achieve goals. And, especially at the high school level, coaches play a crucial role in helping athletes develop mental toughness. At this critical developmental stage, coaches can shape their athletes physically, socially and psychologically.