Madeleine Cleary’s ‘The Butterfly Women’ brings colonial Melbourne to life in a gripping tale of murder, resilience and the women who refused to be forgotten, writes Anne Layton-Bennett. INITIALLY, THIS NOVEL seemed to be a Jack the Ripper-type whodunit set in colonial Melbourne during the 1860s. While it’s certainly a murder mystery involving a serial killer, the book is also a social history of that period, albeit one that focuses on women's stories rather than men's.