When Shameless premiered in 2011, Emmy Rossum understood the pay disparity between her and costar William H. Macy. He was, after all, No. 1 on the call sheet. But by Season 3, Rossum, who famously starred as Fiona Gallagher on the series, felt she had earned the right to be paid equally to Macy. Her request was ultimately denied. During contract negotiations for Season 8, Rossum was ready to rehash the conversation.