Context: EmblemHealth, Inc., a health insurer, filed a putative class action in April 2025 (see below) accusing Alexion, an AstraZeneca company, of overcharging for its rare disease drug Soliris. EmblemHealth alleged that Alexion enforced five fraudulently obtained patents to keep biosimilars off the U.S. market from at least March 2022 until Amgen and Samsung Bioepis launched in March and April 2025. On December 19, 2025, Judge Brian E.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Mehnaz Khatoon
UPC revokes KeeeX patent in first serious patent case over ChatGPT: comprehensive win for OpenAI, Adobe, Truepic, C2PA
Context: KeeeX, a French company, sued OpenAI, Adobe, Truepic, the Coalition for Content Provenance and Authenticity (C2PA), and its operator Joint Development Foundation Projects at the Paris Local Division (LD) of the UPC over EP2949070 (“Verification process of the integrity of numerical data bloc”), alleging that the C2PA standard for certifying the origin of digital content infringes it (August 2, 2025 ip fray article).
Flinn sues OpenAI and Anthropic over five neural network patents in Delaware: first major patent campaign targeting core AI software
Context: Flinn Artificial Intelligence (AI) Technologies, LLC (Flinn) is a Texas company that owns patents invented by Steven D. Flinn and Naomi Felina Moneypenny. Mr. Flinn founded ManyWorlds, Inc., a machine learning company. Anthropic was sued in July in the same court by the University of Tennessee Research Foundation over two neural network patents (July 21, 2026 ip fray article).
UPC infringement filings reach 2026 high of 40 in October, German divisions’ monthly share falls to 67.5%
In-depth reporting and analytical commentary on intellectual property disputes and debates. No legal advice. November 10, 2026 Context: The UPC publishes monthly statistics, with September bringing 29 new infringement actions, the highest monthly total of 2026 at that point, with the four German Local Divisions (LDs) receiving 82.8% of them (October 12, 2026 ip fray UPC roundup). Continue reading your article with a Membership
Samsung, ASUS seek to dismiss NPE display patent suit, Samsung challenging six of those patents at USPTO
Olivia Sophie Rafferty contributed to this article. Context: In July 2025, NeoLayer LLC, a non-practicing entity, bought 101 display patents from Taiwan’s AUO. Then, in two separate actions, it sued Samsung Electronics and ASUS in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas on December 31, 2025, over six of those patents (case no. 2:25-cv-01259 and 2:25-cv-01260). In April, Judge Rodney Gilstrap, who was assigned the case, consolidated both suits.
South Korean patent fights: court denies LG Chem injunction against JS Energy, mediation takes center stage in Hanmi and Hanwha Semitech case
Context: In August 2024, LG Chem sued JS Energy, the Korean subsidiary of Chinese cathode maker Ningbo Ronbay New Energy Technology, at the Seoul Central District Court. The suit covers five patents on high-nickel nickel-cobalt-manganese (NCM) cathode materials, which largely determine battery capacity and make up about 40% of battery costs.
Munich appeals court overturns coercive detention order against Polytech in Silimed dispute: injunction did not clearly cover nullity action
Context: Silimed, a Brazilian implant maker, sued its former German distributor Polytech in 2017 over EP2581193 (‚ÄúProcess for the manufacture of implants or intermediate products of such implants as well as implants and intermediate products obtained by such process‚ÄĚ). In November 2024, the Frankfurt Higher Regional Court ruled that the invention belonged to Silimed and ordered Polytech to transfer the patent.
UPC Dusseldorf grants Dai Nippon Printing injunction against Zapp over OLED mask foil patent, rejects prior public use defense
Context: Dai Nippon Printing, the Tokyo-based printing and electronics group, sued Zapp AG and Zapp Precision Metals GmbH at the UPC Dusseldorf Local Division (LD) in May 2025 over EP3805415 (“Metal plate for manufacturing deposition mask, method for manufacturing metal plate, deposition mask and method for manufacturing deposition mask”).
Delaware judge reverses course, hands Irish NPE Tir a fourth chance against Comcast over streaming patents
Context: Tir Technologies Limited, an Irish non-practicing entity (NPE) controlled by patent monetization firm Atlantic IP Services Limited, sued Comcast Cable Communications and several of its subsidiaries in the U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware in July 2025. Tir accused Comcast’s Xfinity Stream and NBCUniversal’s Peacock services of infringing four patents related to video delivery and network monitoring.
StayTouch sues Apple over NameDrop feature with patent issued the same day
Context: GG Technologies, Inc., doing business as StayTouch, is a Santa Monica company behind a contact exchange app of the same name. In April, it sued Apple in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas (Case No. 6:26-cv-00237) over U.S. Patent No. 12,022,369 (“Method and system for proximity-based contact transfer”). It also filed a request for a United States International Trade Commission (ITC) investigation (No. 337-TA-1520) (August 28, 2026 USITC notice).
DAZN hit with parallel HEVC patent suits in Munich I Regional Court, UPC
Context: Velos Media has been enforcing its HEVC (H.265) video coding patents on several fronts. It sued Disney in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California after years of bilateral and Avanci Video pool negotiations (March 22, 2026 ip fray article), and it won anti-antisuit relief against TikTok in the Western District of Texas (February 13, 2026 ip fray article).
Rio judge grants InterDigital HEVC injunction against Hisense: defense ‘borders on an insult to the Court’
Context: After Hisense filed a 185-page defense in InterDigital’s Brazilian case over video coding patents, the court ordered it to submit a summary (July 16, 2026 ip fray article). Earlier this week, a different Rio business court granted InterDigital a preliminary injunction (PI) against TCL over the same two patents (October 27, 2026 ip fray article).
UPC Hague LD grants Caelus gut bacterium PI against rivals, then back tracks: overbroad requests ‘should not be rewarded’
Context: Caelus Lifesciences IP B.V., a Dutch company that develops microbiome ingredients from human gut bacteria, co-owns EP2753187 (“Method for preventing and/or treating insulin resistance”) on using certain gut bacteria against insulin resistance with Amsterdam UMC. Pendulum Therapeutics Inc. of San Francisco sells the probiotic products Glucose Control and Metabolic Daily, which iHerb Netherlands B.V. also offers online.
SK Nexilis copper-foil patent dispute highlights U.S.-UPC divide over claim construction
Context: SK Nexilis, the copper foil business of South Korea’s SKC Co., sued local rival Solus Advanced Materials and several Volta Energy Solutions units in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas in November 2023. Solus makes copper foil for electric vehicle batteries, and its Volta units handle European sales and production.
Disney appeals Huawei’s HEVC injunction in Brazil, alleges it has completely disabled HEVC on Disney+
Context: Last week, Judge Simone Gastesi Chevrand of the 6th Business Court of Rio de Janeiro granted Huawei an expert report-based preliminary injunction (PI) against Disney over a Brazilian High Efficiency Video Coding (HEVC) encoding patent, with a R$5 million ($1 million) penalty for non-compliance (October 21, 2026 ip fray article). Continue reading your article with a Membership Appeal court: Court of Justice of the State of Rio de Janeiro.
Taction seeks supplemental damages, interest, ongoing royalties through 2035 on top of $5.7B Apple verdict
Context: On September 25, 2026, a jury in the United States District Court for the Southern District of California found that Apple’s Taptic Engine infringed two Taction Technology patents and awarded it $5,721,961,750 in damages (September 26, 2026 ip fray article). Apple has since asked the court to wipe out the verdict or order a new trial, and Taction’s response to that motion is due November 3, 2026 (October 15, 2026 ip fray article).
Huawei wins expert report-based preliminary injunction against Disney in Brazil over HEVC patent, with $1 million penalty for non-compliance
Context: Huawei, an Avanci Video licensor, has been asserting HEVC patents against Disney in several venues, including the Munich I Regional Court (December 19, 2025 ip fray article) and the UPC’s Mannheim Local Division (LD) (March 10, 2026 ip fray article). Huawei also filed two infringement lawsuits against Disney in Rio de Janeiro in February and March 2026. Both concern patents related to the H.265/HEVC video encoding process.
Comcast must pay WhereverTV $213 million for infringing X1 program guide patent, Florida jury finds
Context: WhereverTV, a Fort Myers, Florida-based over-the-top (OTT) television provider founded in 2006, sued Comcast in August 2018 over the Xfinity X1 platform, accusing its interactive program guide of infringing its patent. During a first trial in 2023, Judge William F. Jung ruled for Comcast as a matter of law before the jury could deliberate, finding that WhereverTV had not shown that X1 meets two limitations of claim 1.
Apple asks court to wipe out Taction’s $5.7B verdict, files JMOL motion three days ahead of deadline
Context: On September 25, 2026, a jury in the United States District Court for the Southern District of California found that Apple’s Taptic Engine infringed three claims of two patents held by Taction Technology, which is funded by Burford Capital. It awarded $5,721,961,750 in damages (September 26, 2026 ip fray article). The jury rejected Apple’s invalidity defenses and found no willful infringement.
InterDigital, Parks Associates claim HDR is becoming a baseline video feature: report lands amid Disney+ feature removals
In-depth reporting and analytical commentary on intellectual property disputes and debates. No legal advice. October 13, 2026 Context: InterDigital has won several injunctions against Disney over video patents (September 2, 2026 ip fray article), and Disney has responded by switching off Disney+ features instead of taking a license (July 28, 2026 ip fray article). A French consumer group recently urged Disney to compensate affected customers (September 25, 2026 ip fray article).
EPO Board of Appeal revokes Novo Nordisk’s cardiovascular semaglutide patent; generics could enter EU as early as 2031
Context: Novo Nordisk, the Danish maker of Ozempic, Wegovy, and Rybelsus, was granted European Patent EP3448416 (“Semaglutide in cardiovascular conditions”) in August 2022 (October 10, 2026, EPO Register, patent register). Eight opponents filed oppositions in May 2023, including Stada, Teva, Sandoz, Adalvo, and Generics (UK).
Halozyme wins Dutch injunction against Merck’s Keytruda SC in eight European countries, court holds patent valid
Context: Halozyme Therapeutics, a San Diego company best known for licensing its ENHANZE technology for subcutaneous drug delivery, which first Merck in the District of New Jersey on April 24, 2025,and is enforcing a separate family of MDASE patents against Merck’s subcutaneous version of Keytruda. The product is sold as Keytruda SC in Europe and as Keytruda Qlex in the U.S. Halozyme previously won a preliminary injunction against it in Germany (December 6, 2025 ip fray article).
Nokia sues Aylo over video encoding patent infringement in Eastern District of Texas
Context: Nokia has been enforcing its video patents against streaming services and device makers for several years. It settled with Amazon in March 2025 through a patent agreement (March 31, 2025 ip fray article), then sued Paramount (August 22, 2025 ip fray article) and Warner Bros. Discovery (November 1, 2025 ip fray article) later that year.
Dolby, MediaTek bought 40% of video codec patent families that changed hands in the U.S. over six months: USPTO records analysis
Context: The video codec market has seen several major transactions and licensing deals, including Nokia’s acquisition of LG Electronics’ video codec portfolio (December 1, 2025 ip fray article), SIM IP’s purchase of Alibaba video coding patents despite its LOT Network membership (May 19, 2026 ip fray article), and Dolby’s acquisition of hundreds of VVC standard-essential patents (SEPs) from Florida Atlantic University and OP Solutions (August 11, 2026 ip fray article).
Federal Circuit dismisses ParkerVision appeal against Qualcomm: Rule 54(b) does not allow partial final judgment on some claims of one patent
Context: ParkerVision, a Florida-based wireless technology company, and Qualcomm have been in court for 15 years. A $173 million jury verdict in ParkerVision’s first case, filed in 2011, was overturned by the district court, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed in 2015.
Mylan seeks declaratory judgment against Novo Nordisk over newly issued Wegovy patent, aiming to preempt a new Delaware lawsuit
Context: Novo Nordisk sued Mylan (a Viatris unit) in the United States District Court for the District of Delaware in January 2023 over five Wegovy patents, after Mylan filed an Abbreviated New Drug Application (ANDA) for a generic version of the weight loss drug. That case, C.A. No. 23-101-CFC, has been narrowing gradually: last year, Judge Colm F.
Federal court dismisses Entresto antitrust suit against Novartis: patent listing in Orange Book was proper
Context: In August 2025, The Iron Workers Local 580 Insurance Fund, a New York health and welfare fund, sued Novartis in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York (SDNY) as a payor of Entresto costs. It alleged that Novartis wrongly listed its U.S. Patent No. 8,101,659 (“Methods of treatment and pharmaceutical composition”) in the FDA’s Orange Book, which let a six-month pediatric extension push generic Entresto entry from January 16, 2025 to July 2025.
Samsung handed third straight win at UPC as Munich LD revokes Maxell’s Galaxy content-casting patent
Context: Maxell and Samsung have been fighting a three-case, multi-patent campaign at the UPC since February 2025, when the Japanese electronics maker sued Samsung’s Korean parent and its German, French, Benelux, and Italian units over a family of patents covering so-called cast technology, the ability to hand off what is showing on a phone screen to a TV set and back again. Samsung has responded with a counterclaim for revocation in each case.
NEC sues Anker’s eufy brand over six more camera patents in East Texas, widening a two-year fight
Context: Japan’s NEC Corporation sued eufy, owned by Chinese consumer electronics maker Anker Innovations, in September 2024 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas over a different set of patents (see below). Anker recently lost a bid to have some of the asserted claims thrown out as ineligible subject matter.
Nike, lululemon settle patent fight over Mirror Home Gym technology
Context: This dispute dates back to January 2022, when Nike sued lululemon and Mirror maker Curiouser Products Inc. in the Southern District of New York, accusing the companies of infringing six patents covering fitness-tracking technology used in the Mirror home gym and its companion app, including features for monitoring a user’s exertion level and performance.
SIM IP acquires QinetiQ cross-domain security patent portfolio rooted in UK defense research
Context: SIM IP, led by Erich Spangenberg, has built out its patent monetization business at a rapid pace over the past year. In the past year, it merged with Garden Intel to form a $150 million IP monetization platform (February 6, 2026 ip fray article), acquired Qord IP’s IoT portfolio (October 21, 2025 ip fray article), and filed UPC and Munich lawsuits against Samsung over that portfolio (June 29, 2026 ip fray articles).
Skysong sues Fortinet, CrowdStrike at UPC over shared AI vulnerability-scoring patent
Context: Skysong Innovations, the patent-licensing arm of Arizona State University, has been suing Fortinet and CrowdStrike in separate Texas federal courts since January 2025 over a family of patents covering machine-learning predictions of which software vulnerabilities hackers are likely to exploit.
MediaTek affiliate HFI Innovation sues Snap over video codec patent: fifth infringement case piles onto Snapchat’s growing UPC docket
Context: Snap Inc., the company behind Snapchat, runs one of the world’s largest video messaging platforms, with users sharing billions of photos and videos daily, most of it compressed using standard video codecs such as HEVC and AV1, yet Snap has not taken a license from Access Advance’s Video Distribution Pool (VDP), the pool that licenses those codecs’ patents to streaming platforms.
Brazilian judge grants IBEX merits-based PI against Disney over HEVC patent: threatens Disney+ suspension through app stores, device manufacturers
Context: In May 2026, IBEX PT Holdings, an Access Advance licensor, sued The Walt Disney Company (Brazil) in a Rio de Janeiro state court over the alleged infringement of Brazilian patent BR112014 004914-9. IBEX alleged that Disney’s HEVC encoders for Disney+ use the patent’s advanced motion vector prediction (AMVP) claims without a license (May 22, 2026 ip fray article).
Sol IP sues AGCO over 4G SEPs in Munich: enforcement now hits second farm equipment maker
Context: Acer and Jingshi have recently sued agricultural vehicle market leader John Deere (August 21, 2026 ip fray article) over cellular standard-essential patents (SEPs). AGCO, the world’s second-largest maker of agricultural machinery behind Deere, sells tractors, combines, and other farm equipment under the Fendt, Massey Ferguson, and Valtra brands, and its newer machines increasingly rely on built-in cellular connectivity.
Patent owner asks USPTO Director to terminate Google-triggered reexam, points to pattern of 21 do-overs after failed IPRs
Context: Ex parte reexamination (EPR) has become a popular fallback for patent challengers who strike out at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB). Unlike an inter partes review (IPR), anyone, not just the original challenger, can request an EPR, and it comes with a much lower bar to get the USPTO to take another look at a patent.
BREAKING: InterDigital wins sixth straight injunction against Disney — UPC Dusseldorf LD
Context: For the past year, InterDigital has been on a winning streak against Disney. The Munich I Regional Court handed down three injunctions on separate patents covering stream overlay technology, high dynamic range (HDR) (November 21, 2025 ip fray article), and HEVC encoding (February 13, 2026 ip fray article).
UPC Dusseldorf grants surgical tool maker patent injunction, includes UK
Anushka Sharma contributed to this story. Context: Aesculap, a German surgical instrument maker, first sued Shanghai International Holding Corporation, the Hamburg-based EU authorized representative for Chinese manufacturer Shanghai Bojin Medical Instrument, in mid-2025.
UPC Roundup (1 week): CoA rules on evidence production and patent revocation; Hamburg LD grants two injunctions; and more
This is a summary of developments in and around the UPC in the calendar week of August 24, 2026. To Read The Full Story Continue reading your article with a Membership
Malikie, Xiaomi settle UPC patent case in Mannheim
Context: Malikie Innovations, the Irish licensing firm that holds a large portfolio of former BlackBerry patents, has been suing Xiaomi in multiple jurisdictions, including a case at the Delhi High Court where Xiaomi was ordered to put up a $28.7 million security deposit (May 4, 2026 ip fray article). Continue reading your article with a Membership Counsel for Malikie: Arnold Ruess’s (ip fray firm profile) Marina Wehler. Counsel for Xiaomi: Clifford Chance’s (ip fray firm profile) David Por.
Access Advance issues call for patents forĀ potential AV1, AV2 pool
Context: Access Advance runs the Video Distribution Patent (VDP) Pool, which covers HEVC, VVC, VP9, and AV1 for video streaming services, and was launched last year (January 16, 2025 ip fray article). It has since grown to include dozens of licensors such as Sharp, ByteDance, and Tencent (March 24, 2026 ip fray article). AV1, developed by the Alliance for Open Media (AOM), is often described as royalty-free, but that label only covers the patents AOM members pledged not to charge for.
InterDigital expands UPC litigation against Disney, says VP9 workaround still infringes its patents
Context: InterDigital and Disney have been fighting over video codec standard-essential patents (SEPs) since February 2025 (February 3, 2025 ip fray article). The Munich I Regional Court previously handed InterDigital three separate injunctions against Disney over patents covering the overlay of a second video stream, such as subtitles, high dynamic range (HDR) (November 21, 2025 ip fray article), and HEVC encoding (February 13, 2026 ip fray article).
German Federal Patent Court leans toward invalidating Malikie patent asserted against Xiaomi in Munich
Context: Xiaomi and Malikie Innovations, which owns a large portfolio of former BlackBerry patents, are fighting each other in patent offices and courts around the world, including in India, where the Delhi High Court ordered Xiaomi to put up a $28.7 million security deposit (May 4, 2026 ip fray article).
UPC Court of Appeal upholds Abbott’s glucose sensor patent: rejects Sibio’s added matter, inventive step attacks
Context: Abbott Diabetes Care and Sibio Technology have been locked in a Europe-wide dispute over Abbott’s EP3831283 (“Analyte sensor devices, connections, and methods”), which covers a continuous glucose monitor, since Sibio’s China-made GS1 device reached the European market through a Dutch distributor.
Federal Circuit affirms invalidation of Nielsen’s audience-measurement patent, backs PTAB’s “reasonably pertinent” prior art finding
Context: TVision Insights, Inc. petitioned for inter partes review (IPR) of U.S. Patent No. 11,470,243 (“Methods and Apparatus to Capture Images”), owned by The Nielsen Company (US), LLC, challenging 14 claims covering audience-measurement systems that use cameras to detect and identify television viewers.
UPC Munich LD flags novel questions on damages law in Edwards v. Meril damages claim, flags novel questions on applicable law and non-infringing substitute profits
Context: Edwards Lifesciences and Meril Life Sciences have fought a multi-front dispute over prosthetic heart valves since the UPC launch, with Edwards having won multiple UPC injunctions against Meril, including a Munich Local Division (LD) ruling that upheld EP3669828 (“Prosthetic heart valve”) and enjoined Meril’s Myval device and Navigator delivery system (April 4, 2025 ip fray article). Meril did not appeal that decision, and infringement is no longer in dispute.
Federal Circuit affirms PTAB invalidation of G+ Communications 5G patent, leaving Samsung’s damages cut intact
Context: G+ Communications, LLC, a licensing firm that owns 5G standard-essential patents (SEPs) formerly held by China’s ZTE, won a retrial verdict against Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. that more than doubled its original damages award to $142 million (April 18, 2024 ip fray article).
Brazilian appeals court rejects Edwards Lifesciences’ trade dress claims against Meril’s heart valve, upholds first-instance ruling
Context: Edwards Lifesciences and Meril Life Sciences have fought a multi-jurisdiction dispute over heart valve technology, with Edwards to date winning multiple UPC injunctions against Meril in Europe, most recently in a Central Division Paris ruling (October 22, 2025 ip fray article) that followed a landmark Munich Local Division decision addressing the proportionality of injunctive relief (April 4, 2025 ip fray article).
Magistrate judge recommends Amazon lose standing fight against Edge Networking despite Cisco, Intel inventor agreements
Context: Cisco’s Vice President and Deputy General Counsel for IP Litigation, Bryan Sinclair, testified at a July 21, 2026 evidentiary hearing in this case about Cisco’s employee invention-assignment practices testimony. ip fray reported on this as part of a separate Proxense v. Cisco Wi-Fi patent suit (July 24, 2026 ip fray article).
ParTec expands supercomputer patent enforcement campaign: sues Hewlett Packard Enterprise at UPC Munich LD
Context: ParTec AG and its licensing agent BF exaQC AG have spent close to two years building a supercomputer patent enforcement campaign that started with a U.S. lawsuit against Microsoft, which settled ahead of trial (May 12, 2026 ip fray article), and has since produced UPC complaints against Nvidia in the Munich Local Division (LD), Lenovo in Dusseldorf LD (May 27, 2026 ip fray article), and Google and AMD/Bull in Mannheim (July 6, 2026 ip fray article).
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Mehnaz
Contact Mehnaz, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack