Sixty cents. That's how much of every new gross profit dollar the average independent tire dealership earned this year went straight to payroll - not the 42 cents to 45 cents cents most benchmarks call healthy and not even the 49 cents where the typical shop already sits. Sixty. Here's how we got there. The figures below are per-store averages, year-to-date through August 2026, from representative data on independent tire and service shops throughout North America.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Randy O'Connor
O'Connor: You See it, Read It and Repeat It - That's Not Learning
Picture a kid who's just finished her first week of gymnastics class. She comes home and does exactly what every parent has seen a hundred times — a wobbly cartwheel in the living room, narrated the whole way through: "You put your hands down like this, then your legs go over and you have to keep your arms straight or you'll fall." She isn't just showing the move. She's teaching it to whoever's standing there. For a full week, she'd been told what to do. She'd been shown what to do.
Solving the Tire Tech Shortage Puzzle
Skip to main content In this episode of The Modern Tire Dealer Show, Randy O'Connor says recruiting and retaining technicians can be easy. You just have to know what to say. 'The question is not, 'Who are you using to find help?' It's 'What are you doing with your help?,'' says O'Connor. "The question is not, 'Who are you using to find help?' It's 'What are you doing with your help?,'" says O'Connor.
O'Connor: How to Bridge the Mentorship Gap
Almost every meeting I sit in, someone brings up the same problem: ‘We can’t find good techs, and when we do, we can’t keep them. We’ve tried signing bonuses, higher flat rate and free lunches on Fridays.’ Six months later, another tech is gone to a competitor down the street or out of the industry altogether. We blame the labor market, the younger generation — anything except the real answer sitting in front of us.
O'Connor: Where Real Improvement Begins
For a lot of dealers, peer-to-peer groups are one of those things that sounds simple from the outside, but as we are often forced to realize, simple is not easy. A group of non-competing dealers gets together, compares numbers, talks about what’s working and what’s not and everyone goes home a little better-equipped. That is the basic idea. But in practice, a good peer-to-peer group can become much more than a benchmarking exercise. For many dealers, it becomes a source of operating discipline.
O'Connor: Why Commitments Become Behavior, Culture
I will always believe independent businesses win when they do the things that larger, more complex organizations either can’t do, won’t do or have forgotten how to do. Independent businesses know the customer, the employee and the market. But underneath all of that is something even more important: commitments. A business isn’t valuable simply because it has equipment, inventory, locations, revenue, a customer list or a solid net.
O'Connor: Catch Someone Doing Something Right
On a long drive recently, we came over the crest of a hill. Sitting quietly off to the side of the road was a state trooper, lurking in the shadows. Someone in our car said, “Well, they’re certainly not trying to catch someone doing something right today, are they?” It was funny because it was true. Nobody sees a police car and thinks, “I bet he’s looking for people maintaining the speed limit, using their signal and driving responsibly.” We assume he’s there to catch someone making a mistake.
O'Connor: How to Design Operational Triggers
“Triggered” isn’t usually a positive word. In today’s culture, it suggests emotional reaction, loss of control or sometimes impulsive behavior. It’s a word often associated with overreaction. But in high-performing tire and service dealerships, the right triggers don’t create chaos. They create consistency. An operational trigger is simply a designed moment. When this happens, a door opens and the customer experience activates.
O'Connor: Focused on Legacy
Succession is quickly becoming one of the most defining decisions facing tire dealers today — and not just because of timing, but because of what’s at stake long after the deal is done. With aging ownership, rapid consolidation and increasing operational complexity, more shop owners are facing a clear reality: Transition is coming. The real question isn’t if, but how and more specifically, to whom.
O'Connor: Letter to a Future Employer
What are employees looking for? Check out this letter from a prospective employee to a prospective boss: "Dear Future Boss, I hope you don’t mind me writing candidly. I’ve been thinking a great deal about what it would mean to join your team — not just as another entry-level hire, but as someone who intends to build a career, contribute meaningfully and grow into greater responsibility over time.
O'Connor: The Power of Perspective
I'd like to invite you to take a walk back in time. If you close your eyes and visualize yourself in most any space or event from decades ago, you’ll notice that everything was big. Walk back into your old high school gym decades after graduation and we all notice something immediately: it's small.The ceiling seems lower than you remember. The bleachers feel closer together.
O'Connor: What AI Can (And Can't) Do for Your Business
I’ve always believed independent tire dealers win when they do the things that big box stores and other retailers either can’t or simply won’t do. I’m talking about personal relationships, local knowledge, flexibility and the ability to make decisions and implement solutions quickly without waiting for a corporate playbook or approval chain. That belief extends into how I think about artificial intelligence (AI) and its role in independent tire dealerships.
How to Build Your Talent Engine
As we step into a new year, I’ve been thinking a lot about the conversations that shaped 2025 and the ones that will define 2026. One of them came late last year, when I sat across from a master technician who had just been offered a job at a competitor’s dealership. The offer was for more money — a significant amount more. I braced myself for the resignation speech. Instead, he surprised me. “Honestly,” he said, “I’d rather stay here. My days make sense. I know where I’m going.
Customer Service as a 'Craft'
As we turn the calendar to the New Year and set aside a moment of peace amid a fresh transition to a new beginning, I find myself reflecting - not just on tires sold or hours billed, but on something much deeper: the journey our customers take through our service experience as much more than a job, but rather as craft. Previously, I’ve written about understanding the purchase path and the importance of systemizing customer touchpoints.
O'Connor: Which Staffing Structure Really Drives Profit?
Tire dealers are always looking for ways to improve shop efficiency, reduce technician downtime and deliver a better customer experience. But one area that’s often overlooked is how we structure our front-of-house team — specifically, the balance between sales associates and service management. Lately, especially as payroll growth year-over-year is outpacing gross profit increases year-over-year, this topic has surfaced quite a bit.
O'Connor: How to Understand the Customer's Journey
Let’s say you’re the proud parent of two teenage kids. You and your partner are both grinding away, working full-time to set aside as much money as you can for your children and your retirement. Life’s good, but things are a bit tight, with setting aside as much money as possible for the future. On your way home from work, hoping for a nice family dinner and a bit of time to relax, your check engine light comes on.
O'Connor: Time to Review Your Payroll Profitability Equation
Flat rate pay has long been a foundational compensation structure in tire dealerships. Designed to reward productivity, it operates as a form of informal profit sharing — anchored in the principle of quid pro quo: you produce, you earn. This system incentivizes technicians to work efficiently and delivers a win-win outcome when implemented correctly.
Digital Tools Enhance Service and Customer Engagement
In today’s increasingly customer-centric, digital world, there’s a growing need to embrace new — or newish — technologies. And the tire industry is no exception. As customer expectations evolve, tire dealers must adapt by integrating digital tools to enhance customer engagement and improve service efficiency.
Tire Dealer Survival Guide: How to Understand the Purchase Path
What’s the most effective way to understand the customer’s purchase path? It’s all about identifying segments, touchpoints, timeframes, expectations and the system or process. You’re also going to identify stressors and friction points. Because your view, just like mine, is limited, the more views you have, the broader the perspective you’ll get. And remember: everyone’s expectations differ.
How to Thrive in a Down Economy
The past few months have kept phones ringing — just not for the reasons we like. In my 20-group, Dealer Development, many members are asking each other, “Is your business as slow as my business has been?” If we’re being honest with ourselves, it’s been quite some time since we’ve seen this measure of consumer pullback. Hopefully, you’ve made the most of the last three to four years and have recently dusted off your notes and the playbook you used a few years ago to keep your business healthy.
How to Create a Customer-Centric Culture
In my first MTD column of 2025, we explored the importance of guiding and motivating ourselves to create exceptional customer experiences. Now, let's delve deeper into how we can take that vision even further — transforming not just individual interactions, but the entire perception of an industry. The goal is to not only meet but exceed expectations, turning every customer into an advocate who sees the value and integrity of our industry as a whole.
How to Take Your Business to the Next Level
It's easy to believe there's a fast track or easy pass to the next level. Believe it or not, getting ahead is much more complicated than applying best-of-the best-strategies. Best-in-class demands simplicity. Here's my argument. Simplicity, at its core, requires a significant amount of effort and careful consideration. We've all become really good at complicating things and we need to stop. So stop! If things are complicated, they get diluted with other complications.
How to Outperform the Status Quo
Not long after starting my career in the retail tire and auto service industry, I began wondering why the customer experience in our industry was so stressful and why our customers don’t connect with or speak highly of their experiences when compared with other retail industry segments. Sure, I had poor experiences of my own with my first couple of cars and as a consumer, really didn’t like the experiences I had, but I chalked it up to a few poor performers.
The Benefits of Reflection as It Pertains to Career Development
This time of year, we are all reminded to take stock and reflect on the year now nearly behind us. Generally speaking, a year in reflection involves reminiscing about the highs and lows. Those interested in career development also take time to reflect, both personally and professionally. It's an important practice that helps us improve our skills, make better decisions and grow in our careers. A long time ago, I had a boss. Let's call him Doug, He was heavily interested and invested in my success.
How to Create a Five-Star Customer Experience
When it comes to creating a five-star customer experience, can your dealership take a few cues from the restaurant business? Curious? Read on. In a restaurant, the owner is the final mile between source, distributor and execution for the customer. The way a restaurant markets, organizes, receives, prepares, cooks and delivers its product is paramount. Your dealership isn’t any different. You have to master your business and that starts with your menu. Once you've mastered the menu, you work on speed.
How to Avoid Tire Store Nightmares
If you’re at all interested in delivering the best possible customer experience, you should at the minimum be a student of what an outstanding customer experience looks and feels like. I'm speaking directly to you and every team member in your dealership. This is for you — regardless of whether you’re the owner, a regional/district manager, a store manager, a service manager, a sales advisor, a technician or the chief errand runner.
How to Scale Your Business
During a recent seminar, I heard a training and peer support group provider say that 50% of the tire dealership owners listening to his presentation would be out of the business in two to three years. And he said there’s nothing they could do about it. That didn’t sit well with everything I know about the spirit and strength of independent tire dealers.
Best Practices to Help Your Dealership Stand Out
Rewind a few years and I'm willing to bet that you looked at your best practices a bit differently than today. It’s one of the many essentials COVID-19 brought forward - at least in part. The workforce was different then. So were hiring practices. Pay scales were different, as were budgets. Training looked different and for many, not in a positive way. Market share was different, too, and so probably was your level of comfort.
Two Chapel Hill Locations Earn ASE Blue Seal
Chapel Hill Tire announced two locations have earned the National Institute for Automotive Service Excellence (ASE) Blue Seal of Excellence. The Franklin Street and Carrboro, N.C., locations now bring Chapel Hill to six of its eleven locations holding the Blue Seal of Excellence. To achieve Blue Seal status, at least 75% of a shop’s technicians must be ASE-certified, with each service area covered by a certified professional.
Scott's U-Save Tires Acquires Knight Automotive
Scott’s U-Save Tires & Auto Repair has acquired Knight Automotive in Crown Point, Ind. The southern Chicago-based dealership now has two locations in Indiana and brings the total auto repair store count to four stores. “Scott’s U-Save has been serving Chicago’s Southland for over 40 years, and we’re committed to expanding our brand and customer focus to Indiana,” says Sheri Templin, president and CEO of Scott’s U-Save Tires.
Goodyear Launches Cooper Discoverer Stronghold AT Tire
Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. has launched its newest addition to the Cooper Discoverer line of tires with the Cooper Discoverer Stronghold AT tire. The new all-terrain tire is designed to deliver traction regardless of the terrain. The tire features 3D sipe technology on the shoulders, wide and open grooves in the tread and it carries the 3 Peak Mountain Snowflake certification.
Retail Sellout Starts to Soften
Our recent check-ins with tire dealers indicate that retail sellout trends were somewhat softer in May 2024 following a robust April. Independent dealers highlighted average sellout declines of 1.3% in May compared to gains of 5.1% in April, with trends flat to slightly down during the first quarter of 2024. Looking more closely at volume for the month of May on a regional basis, the Midwest and the Northeast saw negative volumes.
Yokohama's Geolandar A/T4 G018 on Sale in U.S.
Yokohama Tire Corp. has released the new Geolandar A/T4 G018 for sale in the United States. The tire, engineered for SUVs and CUVs, is expected to be available in over 50 LT-metric sizes by the end of the year, and more than 130 Euro-metric and LT-metric sizes ranging from 15- to 22-inch wheel diameters are planned to come out. The Geolandar A/T4 G018 replaces the Geolandar A/T G015, according to Yokohama officials.
Is Your Shop Emergency-Ready?
It was 12:34 on a Friday afternoon and our team was cranking out a solid day. We were dialed in on making sure we knew our customers’ expectations and what we needed to do to exceed them. We were paying attention to our “promise times,” customers’ requested services and providing our customers with thorough vehicle inspections to help them and their families stay safe today and plan for tomorrow. Everything was going smoothly, until it wasn’t.
22 Tips to Perfect Tire Balancing
Do you know the most common cause of vehicle vibration complaints in modern automobiles? Greg Meyer at Hunter Engineering Co. says it’s wheels and tires. And that means the proper balancing of wheel and tire assemblies has never been more important. “Even drivers of pickup trucks demand a smooth ride today,” says Meyer, a senior product manager for Hunter. The training team at Snap-on Inc.
'Tires' TV Show Vulgar, Insulting - and Thought-Provoking?
By the time the journalist in the first episode of the new Netflix series, "Tires," said, "No. Look I have my story, OK?" I knew I had mine, too. Admittedly, I wasn't as excited about the launch of a satire centered on a tire shop as other people were. I pretty much knew the stereotypes presented on the show would enrage me. And at first, they did - until they didn't. Some scenes were blown out of proportion and were offensive, profane and vulgar, which sadly, is all-too common on TV today.
Tire Dealer Survival Guide: How to Define the Value You Deliver
Raise your hand if someone has ever suggested raising your rates because your dealership provides its customers with more value than the competition offers. Someone has! (That’s what I thought.) This also means someone probably convinced you to do one of any number of things you could have or should have done long before. Yes, the validation and encouragement we get when our colleagues help us take a step forward is awesome.
Why Independent, Locally-Owned Businesses Are So Important
I appreciate being in front of you all more today than any time in my entire career. We're in an interesting time. The return to normalcy is about as close as we're going to get for the moment, but it's a new normal. The consistent month-over-month and year-over-year growth we've seen in the last two years has calmed. We have significant private equity consolidation and as much, if not more, manufacturer vertical integration happening at the same time. Our industry is volatile, to say the least.
The Details Matter More to Customers in a Downturn
We're all accustomed to calling our colleagues to get info on the industry’s pulse. We also commiserate with our colleagues in an effort to feel better about what is or is not happening within our own walls. From time to time — certainly not always — the chatter we gather is actually a result of widespread symptoms that span markets.
Sun Auto Tire Expands in Texas
Sun Auto Tire & Service Inc. has acquired another store to expand its market presence in Texas. Carrollton Complete Automotive is a 13-year-old business located in Carrollton, a community in the greater Dallas-Fort Worth metro area. Sun Auto Tire & Service CEO Tony Puckett said, “The addition of Carrollton Complete Automotive is another step in our commitment to be the leading automotive service and tire provider in the great state of Texas.
DOJ, FTC Comments Show Support for Right to Repair
The U.S. Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission have submitted comments to the U.S. Copyright Office to support exemptions that ultimately support Right to Repair efforts.
Dealers Say Tier-One Tire Prices Are 'Too High'
Retail sellout trends in January were slightly negative following positive sellout trends in the month of December. On average, dealers saw retail unit sales fall 0.4% year-over-year in January following a 1.1% gain in December. Regionally, the Northwest saw the strongest trends, up double digits compared to a year ago. That growth was driven by weather, and specifically, heavy snowfall.
How to Create Customer Loyalty
Moving into the new year, it's likely that you paused to evaluate the balance you have in your life. Balance is important — not only in our personal lives, but in our businesses, as well. Unless companies can balance customer expectations and business needs, they are likely to either disappoint customers or create unnecessary business losses.
You’re Responsible for Training, Culture at Your Tire Dealership
Though long overdue, there's been a solid push throughout our industry to step up to the plate as it pertains to compensating the team members who deliver our customers’ service. Whether by intentional design or market necessity, the industry has finally recognized the fact that some staffing struggles are self-imposed.
How to Help Your Employees Get Ahead
In the past, you've heard me speak about how our habits either help or hinder the results we see on a daily basis. The minutiae of our day-to-day tends to blind us a bit. We see what's right in front of us and tend to bypass the greater perspective of what's around us. Throughout the past few years, one of the top challenges facing owners has been the technician shortage.
Creating a More Professionalized Customer Experience
I once heard that our customers’ heart rates peak as they enter our facilities. Given that we know purchases in our industry are largely viewed as stressful, that comment doesn’t seem inconceivable. And for professional leaders in our industry, that fact should sting — a lot! By and large, our homes are our largest investment, with our vehicles coming in second.
Kerridge Commercial Systems Upgrades to Vast Online
Kerridge Commercial Systems (KCS) updated its point of sales system with its Vast Online cloud solution. The system is an update from the company’s Vast point-of-sales system – the updated version puts all data in the cloud. The new system was showcased at the 2023 Specialty Equipment Market Association Show. According to John Fisher, vice president of sales and marketing for KCS, the Vast program was completely rewritten to make it into a true cloud solution.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Randy
Contact Randy, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack