A statue of Albert Einstein holding a scientific manuscript sits outside the US National Academy of Sciences building in Washington DC.Credit: Paul J. Richards/AFP via Getty Science publishers take too long to retract or correct research papers, a report by the US National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine (NASEM) finds. Standards for fixing errors are also inconsistently applied across research journals, it says.
Richard Van Noorden
Verified
Features editor, Nature. E: r⟦dot⟧vannoorden⟦at⟧nature⟦dot⟧com or richardvannoorden⟦at⟧protonmail⟦dot⟧com. Also @richvn on mastodon and bluesky.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Richard Van Noorden
Can you name the women who have won a science Nobel prize?
Illustration: DAQ Here is a link to the video file . Since the Nobel prizes were first awarded in 1901, few women have been recognized in the categories of physics, chemistry and physiology or medicine. The academies that award the prizes have acknowledged that women are under-represented among Nobel laureates, and have changed their nomination procedures to diversify the pool of winners. But men still dominate the 125-year history of the awards.
Prozac use for childhood depression skewed by single flawed medical trial
Access options Get Nature+, our best-value online-access subscription $39.99 / 30 days cancel any time Receive 51 print issues and online access $199.00 per year only $3.90 per issue Prices vary by article type Prices may be subject to local taxes which are calculated during checkout
AI-detection tools have made huge leaps forward — how good are they?
References She, R. Preprint at bioRxiv https://doi.org/10.64898/2026.01.01.697311 (2026). Emi, B. & Spero, M. Preprint at arXiv https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2402.14873 (2024). Russel, J., Karpinska, M. & Iyyer, M. In Proc. 63rd Annu. Meet. Assoc. Comput. Linguist. (Vol. 1: Long Papers), 5342–5373 (Association for Computational Linguistics, 2025). Glickenhaus, B. et al. Preprint at arXiv https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2607.27183 (2026). Alexandru Adam, G.
AI-detection tools have made huge leaps forward — how good are they?
Apple Store 1 hour ago How to preorder Apple's new supercharged Mac minis with M5 Pro and M6 chips Mashable - Christina Buff • 1h Secure one of these pint-sized powerhouses, which will likely be in high demand. So the rumors are definitely true: there's new Mac minis on the market.
Exclusive: the science papers that patents cite the most
Half a century ago, biochemists Georges Köhler and César Milstein kicked off a revolution in medicine. Their 1975 paper described how to mass-produce monoclonal antibodies: proteins that can be designed to recognize and bind specifically to almost any protein target1. These antibodies have since become a workhorse of biological research and the basis of blockbuster treatments for cancer, autoimmune conditions and infectious diseases.
Exclusive: the science papers that patents cite the most
Trucks 1 hour ago 5 Car Brands With Plans To Bring Back The Mid-Gate Pickup slashgear.com - Mike Garrett • 1h It's hard to understate the importance of the pickup truck in America as both an economic and cultural force.
These are the most-cited research papers of all time
What is the most highly cited paper in the scientific literature? Chances are slim that most researchers know the answer. It turns out to be a 1951 publication in the Journal of Biological Chemistry describing an assay to determine the amount of protein in a solution1. That has been cited more than 350,000 times in the Web of Science (WoS), a database that includes 98 million papers dating back to 1900.
Science’s golden oldies: the decades-old research papers still heavily cited today
Researchers advance by standing on the shoulders of giants, to paraphrase Isaac Newton. So, which research giants are still getting cited frequently today? One way of answering that is to determine which articles appear most often in the reference lists of today’s research papers. Nature asked three bibliometricians who study patterns of references in scientific publications to dig into the data.
Exclusive: These universities have the most retracted scientific articles
Two days before the end of 2021, administrators at Jining First People’s Hospital in Shandong, China, issued a highly unusual report. The hospital announced that it had disciplined some 35 researchers who had been linked to fraud in publications, such as fabricating data. These sanctions were part of a countrywide crackdown motivated by concerns about a flood of sham medical papers emanating from hospitals.
Controversial COVID study that promoted unproven treatment retracted after four-year saga
A study that stoked enthusiasm for the now-disproven idea that a cheap malaria drug can treat COVID-19 has been retracted — more than four-and-a-half years after it was published1. Access the most recent journalism from Nature's award-winning team Explore the latest features & opinion covering groundbreaking research or
Giant study finds untrustworthy trials pollute gold-standard medical reviews
A huge collaboration has confirmed growing concerns that fake or flawed research is polluting medical systematic reviews, which summarize evidence from multiple clinical trials and shape treatment guidelines worldwide. The study is part of an effort to address the problem by creating a short checklist that will help researchers to spot untrustworthy trials.
The US is the world’s science superpower - but for how long?
Science in the United States has never been stronger by most measures. Over the past five years, the nation has won more scientific Nobel prizes than the rest of the world combined — in line with its domination of the prizes since the middle of the twentieth century. In 2020, two US drug companies spearheaded the development of vaccines that helped to contain a pandemic.
Journals with high rates of suspicious papers flagged by science-integrity start-up
Which scientific publishers and journals are worst affected by fraudulent or dubious research papers — and which have done least to clean up their portfolio? A technology start-up founded to help publishers spot potentially problematic papers says that it has some answers, and has shared its early findings with Nature.
Exclusive: the papers that most heavily cite retracted studies
In January, a review paper1 about ways to detect human illnesses by examining the eye appeared in a conference proceedings published by the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in New York City. But neither its authors nor its editors noticed that 60% of the papers it cited had already been retracted. The case is one of the most extreme spotted by a giant project to find papers whose results might be in question because they cite retracted or problematic research.
Publishing negative results is good for science
Studies with positive results are greatly more represented in literature than studies with negative results, producing so-called publication bias. This review aims to discuss occurring problems around negative results and to emphasize the importance of reporting negative results. Underreporting of negative results introduces bias into meta-analysis, which consequently misinforms researchers, doctors and policymakers.
ChatGPT and science: the AI system was a force in 2023 - for good and bad
This story is part of Nature’s 10, an annual list compiled by Nature’s editors exploring key developments in science and the individuals who contributed to them. It co-wrote scientific papers — sometimes surreptitiously. It drafted outlines for presentations, grant proposals and classes, churned out computer code, and served as a sounding board for research ideas. It also invented references, made up facts and regurgitated hate speech.
More than 10,000 research papers were retracted in 2023 - a new record
NEWS 12 December 2023 The number of articles being retracted rose sharply this year. Integrity experts say that this is only the tip of the iceberg. The number of retractions issued for research articles in 2023 has passed 10,000 — smashing annual records — as publishers struggle to clean up a slew of sham papers and peer-review fraud.
How big is science’s fake-paper problem?
NEWS 06 November 2023 An unpublished analysis suggests that there are hundreds of thousands of bogus ‘paper-mill’ articles lurking in the literature. The scientific literature is polluted with fake manuscripts churned out by paper mills — businesses that sell bogus work and authorships to researchers who need journal publications for their CVs. But just how large is this paper-mill problem?
AI and science: what 1,600 researchers think
Nature (Nature) ISSN 1476-4687 (online) ISSN 0028-0836 (print)
Attribution problem of generative AI: a view from US copyright law
Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems, a term that is used to describe AI systems, can generate content in response to a given prompt.1 Users can request generative AI to create a certain type of output or to edit a text or a picture submitted by the user. The output can be in various formats including text, images, audio or code. Today, technology companies are rushing to invest in generative AI.
ChatGPT & Co: KI-Systeme sollen wissenschaftliche Suchmaschinen unterstützen
News Lesedauer ca. 5 Minuten Drucken Teilen ChatGPT & Co: KI-Systeme sollen wissenschaftliche Suchmaschinen unterstützen Wissenschaftliche Fachverlage wie Elsevier und Springer Nature beginnen, ihre Artikel- und Bucharchive mit KI-Suchfunktionen auszustatten. Die Projekte befinden sich allerdings noch in der Erprobung.
ChatGPT-like AIs are coming to major science search engines
The conversational AI-powered chatbots that have come to Internet search engines, such as Google’s Bard and Microsoft’s Bing, look increasingly set to change scientific search too. On 1 August, Dutch publishing giant Elsevier released a ChatGPT-powered AI interface for some users of its Scopus database, while British firm Digital Science announced a closed trial of an AI large language model (LLM) assistant for its Dimensions database.
Medicine is plagued by untrustworthy clinical trials. How many studies are faked or flawed?
Save citation to file Format: Add to My Bibliography Your saved search Name of saved search: Search terms: Frequency: Which day? Which day? Report format: Send at most: Send even when there aren't any new results Optional text in email: Create a file for external citation management software
Medicine is plagued by untrustworthy clinical trials. How many studies are faked or flawed?
How many clinical-trial studies in medical journals are fake or fatally flawed? In October 2020, John Carlisle reported a startling estimate1. Carlisle, an anaesthetist who works for England’s National Health Service, is renowned for his ability to spot dodgy data in medical trials. He is also an editor at the journal Anaesthesia, and in 2017, he decided to scour all the manuscripts he handled that reported a randomized controlled trial (RCT) — the gold standard of medical research.
LHC physicists resolve stalemate over Russian authors
Save citation to file Format: Add to My Bibliography Your saved search Name of saved search: Search terms: Frequency: Which day? Which day? Report format: Send at most: Send even when there aren't any new results Optional text in email: Create a file for external citation management software
Data hint at Russia’s shifting science collaborations after year of war
A year into Russia’s war on Ukraine, its effects on global research collaborations might be starting to show up in the scientific literature. Nature analysed co-authorship patterns on papers in the Scopus database. The results suggest that, in 2022, an increased share of Russia’s internationally collaborative papers had co-authors from China and India, whereas the proportion co-written with US or German authors fell.
LHC physicists resolve stalemate over Russian authors
Physicists working at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) say they have settled a dispute over how to acknowledge authorship of Russian and Belarusian scientists on their research papers — one of the tensions that has affected global physics collaborations since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. Since March 2022, more than 250 manuscripts reporting LHC results have been posted on preprint servers without any author names, affiliations or funder details.
What ChatGPT and generative AI mean for science
We use cookies to make sure that our website works properly, as well as some optional cookies to personalise content and advertising, provide social media features and analyse how people use our site. By accepting some or all optional cookies you give consent to the processing of your personal data, including transfer to third parties, some in countries outside of the European Economic Area that do not offer the same data protection standards as the country where you live.
COVID research is free to access - but for how long? Original
At the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, scientific journals rushed to make related research free to read — temporarily, at least. Work on the disease or the virus SARS-CoV-2 would be free “at least for the duration of the outbreak”, publishers of subscription journals declared in a statement issued on 31 January 2020, the day after the World Health Organization declared the new coronavirus outbreak a ‘public-health emergency of international concern’, or PHEIC.
Nature's Take: how the war in Ukraine is impacting science
Your browser does not support the audio element. The ongoing war in Ukraine has devastated the global economy, rocked geopolitics, killed thousands of people and displaced millions. Science too has been affected and the impacts on research are being felt more widely than just in Ukraine and Russia. In this episode of 's we discuss the war's impact on publishing, international collaborations, climate change and energy, as well as the destructive impacts on scientists themselves.
The researchers using AI to analyse peer review
Do more-highly cited journals have higher-quality peer review? Reviews are generally confidential and the definition of ‘quality’ is elusive, so this is a difficult question to answer. But researchers who used machine learning to study 10,000 peer-review reports in biomedical journals have tried. They invented proxy measures for quality, which they term thoroughness and helpfulness.
US government reveals big changes to open-access policy
US research agencies should make the results of federally funded research free to read as soon as they are published, the administration of President Joe Biden has announced. This is a momentous shift from current policies that permit a delay of up to a year before papers must be posted outside paywalls.
Will war in Ukraine mark a new era for European defence research? Original
Some time in the next decade, solar-powered European airships might hover 20 kilometres above battlefields, relaying crucial details about the movement of troops below. These extremely high-altitude drones, or pseudo-satellites, haven’t yet taken flight. They’re one of scores of research and development (R&D) projects supported by the European Defence Fund (EDF), a European Union fund that this July announced the winners of its first set of grants, worth €1.2 billion (US$1.24 billion).
Exclusive: investigators found plagiarism and data falsification in work from prominent cancer lab
Over the past decade, questions have swirled around the work coming out of a prominent US cancer-research laboratory run by Carlo Croce at the Ohio State University (OSU). Croce, a member of the US National Academy of Sciences, made his name with his work on the role of genes in cancer. But for years, he has faced allegations of plagiarism and falsified images in studies from his group. All told, 11 papers he has co-authored have been retracted, and 21 have required corrections.
Seven ways the war in Ukraine is changing global science
|
By Nisha Gaind, Alison Abbott Verified, Elizabeth Gibney Verified, Jeff Tollefson, Richard Van Noorden Verified
|
Nature
Verified
In just five months, Russia’s war on Ukraine has killed thousands of people, displaced millions and ruptured global geopolitics and economics. It is marking science, too. The heaviest impacts are in Ukraine, where researchers have seen their institutions bombed and are facing upheaval and threats to their livelihoods. In Russia, scientists are contending with boycotts and sanctions in response to their country’s actions.
COVID death tolls: scientists acknowledge errors in WHO estimates
Scientists working with the World Health Organization (WHO) have corrected some surprising errors in its estimates of how many deaths the pandemic has caused, after a flurry of questions about the original WHO report, issued in early May. In a revision to a technical paper on their methods, researchers cut Germany’s pandemic-related deaths estimate by 37%, pulling its excess death rate below those of the United Kingdom and Spain1.
The number of researchers with dual US-China affiliations is falling
The number of scholars who declare affiliations in both China and the United States on research papers has dropped by more than 20% over the past 3 years, an analysis conducted for Nature has found. That slump seems to be part of a pattern of waning US–China collaboration that is starting to show up in research databases.
How Language-Generation AIs Could Transform Science
Machine-learning algorithms that generate fluent language from vast amounts of text could change how science is done — but not necessarily for the better, says Shobita Parthasarathy, a specialist in the governance of emerging technologies at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor. In a report published on 27 April, Parthasarathy and other researchers try to anticipate societal impacts of emerging artificial-intelligence (AI) technologies called large language models (LLMs).
How Language-Generation AIs Could Transform Science
Machine-learning algorithms that generate fluent language from vast amounts of text could change how science is done — but not necessarily for the better, says Shobita Parthasarathy, a specialist in the governance of emerging technologies at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor. In a report published on 27 April, Parthasarathy and other researchers try to anticipate societal impacts of emerging artificial-intelligence (AI) technologies called large language models (LLMs).
How language-generation AIs could transform science
We use cookies to make sure that our website works properly, as well as some ‘optional’ cookies to personalise content and advertising, provide social media features and analyse how people use our site. By accepting some or all optional cookies you give consent to the processing of your personal data, including transfer to third parties, some in countries outside of the European Economic Area that do not offer the same data protection standards as the country where you live.
The countries maintaining research ties with Russia despite Ukraine
NEWS 06 April 2022 Many Western nations are severing scientific links — but it’s a different story in China, India and South Africa. Is Russia’s invasion of Ukraine redrawing the map of international scientific cooperation? Whereas Europe and the United States are swiftly moving to cut long-standing ties, the governments of China, India and South Africa are maintaining links.
Higher-profile COVID experts more likely to get online abuse
Virologist Christian Drosten (left) German health minister Karl Lauterbach (centre) and Lothar Wieler, the president of the Robert Koch Institute in Berlin, speaking at a press conference on COVID-19.
Journals adopt AI to spot duplicated images in manuscripts
Just before a study appears in any of ten journals published by the American Association for Cancer Research (AACR), it undergoes an unusual extra check. Since January 2021, the AACR has been using artificial intelligence (AI) software on all manuscripts it has provisionally accepted after peer review. The aim is to automatically alert editors to duplicated images, including those in which parts have been rotated, filtered, flipped or stretched.
Raising concern over intimidation of scientists in the pandemic
R Research Publishing By: Richard Van Noorden, Tue Oct 19 2021 Author: Richard Van Noorden Features editor, Nature In July Helen Pearson, Chief Magazine Editor at Nature, and Magdalena Skipper, Editor in Chief of Nature, wrote about the harassment being experienced by journalists, particularly those reporting on the COVD-19 pandemic. They highlighted how journalists are being subjected to numerous abusive messages on social media and email, as well as inaccurate and disparaging pieces online.
Podcast: Starting up in science
Every year, thousands of scientists struggle to launch their own labs. For three years, a reporting team from Nature documented the lives of married couple Alison Twelvetrees and Daniel Bose as they worked to get their fledgling research groups off the ground. Frustrations over funding, a global pandemic, and a personal trauma have made this journey anything but simple for Ali and Dan. Listen to their story in Starting up in science. Episode 1 What does it take to start up in science?
Starting up in science
Part 3: Crisis point By Kerri Smith, Heidi Ledford and Richard Van Noorden Photography by Chris Maddaloni 29 September 2021 Alison Twelvetrees and Daniel Bose are newly minted lab heads at the University of Sheffield, UK, and they need to win grants to keep their operations going. The financial pressure is off for Dan, who won a large fellowship at the end of 2018. But, by 2019, Ali still doesn’t have the money to support her lab’s future.
Gibberish Papers Still Lurk in the LIterature
Nonsensical research papers generated by a computer program are still popping up in the scientific literature many years after the problem was first seen, a study has revealed1. Some publishers have told Nature they will take down the papers, which could result in more than 200 retractions. Read Full Article »
Hundreds of gibberish papers still lurk in the scientific literature
Nonsensical research papers generated by a computer program are still popping up in the scientific literature many years after the problem was first seen, a study has revealed1. Some publishers have told Nature they will take down the papers, which could result in more than 200 retractions. The issue began in 2005, when three PhD students created paper-generating software called SCIgen for “maximum amusement”, and to show that some conferences would accept meaningless papers.
Do you obey public-access mandates? Google Scholar is watching
Google Scholar, the popular free search engine for scholarly literature, revealed an unexpected feature on 23 March: it is keeping track of whether research papers covered by funders’ public-access mandates are free to read. A scientist’s Google Scholar profile now displays how many of their papers should be free to read because a funder requires it; how many actually are; and how many are not.
Show More
loading
Actions
Get in touch with Richard
Contact Richard, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack