When does a university become responsible for a risk it didn’t create? A decision handed down by the Supreme Court of the State of Washington, in the Pacific Northwest, raises a question with surprising relevance to the continuing “duty of care debate” about university responsibility in Britain. Before asking what duty of care a higher education provider might owe its students, we should first address a more fundamental premise – what, in law, is the relationship between them?
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Robert Abrahart
There is a student-staff divide in health and safety law. Why?
A familiar reassurance is offered whenever concerns are raised about student wellbeing, safeguarding, or preventable harm in higher education. We’re told that the law already has this covered – that universities are already subject to an extensive set of legal duties and responsibilities. From there, the debate is gently redirected. If harm occurs, the problem is said to lie not in law but in culture, resourcing, or implementation.
Universities need standards, not role models
The debate about duty of care in higher education has been obscured by the repeated collapse of distinct legal questions into a single, unresolved argument. In particular, discussion of whether a duty of care exists is routinely conflated with questions about what responsibility would require in practice. That confusion has prevented sustained analysis of the standards by which conduct should be judged, which is where responsibility acquires real content.
Duty of care isn't about mental health, it's about preventing harm
When people talk about a “duty of care” in higher education, the conversation almost always circles back to mental health – to counselling services, wellbeing strategies, or suicide prevention. It’s understandable. Those are visible, urgent needs. But the phrase “duty of care” carries far more weight than any one policy or pastoral initiative. It reaches into every space where universities hold power over students’ lives, and every context where harm is foreseeable and preventable.
Everyone cares until someone asks for a statute
Parliament will soon return to the question of a statutory duty of care in higher education, because the first debate did not deliver the clarity or action that was needed. The Post-16 education and skills white paper flags the issue – noting that a new Higher Education Student Support Champion will work to address the recommendations from the National Review into Higher Education Student Suicides. More than three university students in England and Wales die by suicide every week.
How to learn from cases of student death by suicide
The Department for Education’s Higher education mental health implementation taskforce intends to publish its long-awaited “second stage report” in November. This article discusses death by suicide. If you are affected in any way by reading this, please call Samaritans for free on 116 123 (UK and Republic of Ireland).
Does the government have any legal basis for asserting a duty of care to students in higher education under Common Law?
This HEPI blog was kindly authored by Dr Robert Abrahart, Lead Campaigner at ForThe100, and Balwant Kaur, Independent Suicide Prevention Researcher. Forthe100 is a national group campaigning for higher education students to be owed a minimum standard of legal protection enshrined in a statutory duty of care.
How to support disabled staff to thrive
Recent data from HESA shows 233,930 academic staff members declared a disability in 2021/22. Given that the data is only based on declaration of disability the figure is probably much higher – as people don’t always feel comfortable to disclose for example due to fears that it may impact their career progression.
New UCAS data is a great opportunity to support student parents
The start of the 2023-24 academic year will mark a watershed moment. Thanks to the new tick-box question on UCAS forms, institutions will be starting the year armed with hard data on which of their incoming students have parental responsibility. But why does this matter – and how can we use the data? The invisible cohort Nobody knows how many student parents are currently in UK higher education because this data has never been collected in any organised way.
Comparing students with the general population is misleading when it comes to suicide
The Office for National Statistics (ONS) has published new estimates of suicides among higher education students, linking mortality records with student data between 2016 and 2023. The findings are stark – 1,108 student deaths by suicide over seven years – an average of 160 each year, or more than three every week. The headline takeaway, however, is that the suicide rate among students is lower than that of the general population of similar age.
There's nothing certain about the circumstances when a duty of care applies to students
The Secretary of State for Education was recently asked in Parliament if she would meet with campaigners to discuss the “duty of care” owed by higher education providers to their students. Janet Daby – the Minister for Children, Families and Wellbeing in the Department for Education (DfE) responded on her behalf, and also outlined the department’s current view on the law for holding negligent institutions to account.
Rejection of legal duty of care marks a bad day for students’ rights
Last Monday, closing a Westminster Hall debate, skills, FE and HE minister Robert Halfon announced that he would not, currently, be bringing in a statutory duty of care for university students – despite unilateral cross-party support for the motion. In doing so, he has denied 2.8 million higher education students the minimum standard of legal protection afforded to most other adults – and enjoyed by 913k adult students in further education and by every member of staff at a university.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Robert
Contact Robert, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack