Rob tries to stay awake at the Liazzzzzzon committee On some distant future date, Keir Starmer will have to read the audiobook of his own memoirs. Whatever other literary qualities they may have, they’re sure to be a boon for insomniacs. There is something about his slightly flat tones and his instinctive political caution that soothes even the most agitated mind, lulling the listener into the arms of Morpheus and sending them off to the land of nod.
Robert Hutton
Verified
Political sketches and film columnist for @TheCriticMag, co-host of classic cinema love-in @WarMovieTheatre. Only posting updates here. Find me on Bluesky.
Articles by Robert Hutton
Tinker Tailor Soldier Prince
Is he simply a desperate chancer, or a genuine threat to British interests? There’s a mole, right at the top of the Palace. He’s been there for years. In Westminster MPs were in a tizzy at the news that Chinese intelligence had infiltrated the inner circle of Prince Andrew, a man so famously choosy about his friends that they previously included America’s most notorious sex offender. The scandal will have ripples that go far and wide.
Idiot voters | Robert Hutton | The Critic Magazine
Badenoch’s team aren’t idiots. Not like the voters One of the things a leader of the opposition needs is a theory about why their party lost the last election. Tony Blair thought Labour had seemed anti-aspiration; David Cameron thought the Tories had seemed weird. Keir Starmer had, well, Jeremy Corbyn. Kemi Badenoch, it is becoming clear, has concluded that the voters are morons.
The Candy Man can
The people’s party: now bankrolled by one of the country’s richest property developers There were twin Christmas trees outside 4 Millbank, the block of offices where broadcasters have their Westminster studios. On the pavement was a large group of photographers and a smaller group of hacks, waiting for one of the great seasonal traditions: the unveiling of the political sugar daddy.
Their work here is done
British politicians are very proud of their role in Syria, whatever it was “The Conservative government,” Priti Patel informed the House of Commons, “called for President Assad to go over a decade ago.” And now it had come to pass. She wasn’t taking credit, as such, though if it’s offered, she might not refuse it. In politics you have to grab your victories where you can. It was an afternoon of friends and enemies.
Not a relaunch | Robert Hutton | The Critic Magazine
“I’m delighted to be here,” the prime minister declared. But where was “here”? He was standing in front of a muted red background with the words “PLAN FOR CHANGE” printed on it. He could have been in central London, or on Mars, if the Red Planet had built a chilly hall in which to hold political meetings and, on the weekends, children’s parties. I can reveal that we were in fact at Pinewood Studios.
Leader of the year™
Kemi Badenoch strode into the House of Commons, flush from being named “Leader Of The Year” by The Spectator, a lifestyle weekly. This was a particularly impressive given that she has been in the job for four weeks. Indeed it’s awe-inspiring when you consider that three of the other candidates, Keir Starmer, Ed Davey and Nigel Farage, all led their parties to separate triumphs in this year’s election.
More than one way to skin a cat
This article is taken from the December-January 2025 issue of The Critic. To get the full magazine why not subscribe? Right now we’re offering five issues for just £10. The screenwriter Blake Snyder, who died in 2009, was one of those creatives who taught more successfully than he did. He’s credited with writing just two films, of which the most successful is 1992’s cop comedy Stop! Or My Mom Will Shoot.
A life of indulgence
Jacob Rees-Mogg has a major persona and a minor career Around the middle of the first episode of Meet The Rees-Moggs, its main subject comments that, as the younger son, he was indulged as a baby. “I’ve been indulged the rest of my life,” Sir Jacob Rees-Mogg goes on, cheerfully. This is unarguable, including in this show. The very fact that he is getting a six-episode reality show, even one in the obscurity of whatever Discovery+ might be, is indulgent.
Killing time | Robert Hutton | The Critic Magazine
It was a freezing morning, the sort on which our ancestors would check to see which of the elderly relatives eased away from the warmth of the fire during the night were still going to be wanting a bit of woolly mammoth for breakfast. Those of us wondering where Keir Starmer stood on the issue of assisted suicide woke to learn that he definitely backs it for Cabinet ministers. Louise Haigh had been swiftly dispatched, though doubtless there had been a formal process involving two spin doctors.
A broken Reed | Robert Hutton | The Critic Magazine
Who did Steve Reed MP annoy to be sent to face the outrage of the farmers? Steve Reed, Secretary of State for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, clutched the lectern like it was a riot shield. There was a chance he might need it. All week, he’d been telling farmers that their accountants had got it all wrong, that their fields were worth far less than they thought, that all this money was going to be raised from Other People.
Kemi’s men of mystery
Just after midday on Wednesday, the section of the nation that has Prime Minister’s Questions on in the background was united in a single thought: who’s that chap in the glasses? Keir Starmer was on his way back from one of the summits that have crowded his diary in the last couple of months, and so his place was taken by his deputy, Angela Rayner. Opposite her was… well.
Reaping a bitter harvest
Labour are struggling to justify their own policies The weather had changed suddenly in central London, and so had the colours. Most days, walking down Whitehall from Trafalgar Square to Parliament, people’s coats are navy or charcoal grey. On Tuesday, the sleet was falling onto a sea of jackets the shade of murky green that is only sold outside the M25.
Kemi Badenoch’s bad spell
There is a plant that grows in the mountains of southern India which the Tamils call the Neelakurinji. It blossoms just once every 12 years, an event so rare that the locals use it to measure their age. And in Parliament on Wednesday, Nigel Farage turned up. He was sitting on the bench that Reform MPs have claimed, next to the DUP, in front of Jeremy Corbyn, wearing a blue suit and a tan that we are supposed to believe he picked up in his constituency of Clacton, the Palm Beach of Essex.
Who Should Be The Next Archbishop of Canterbury?
With the shock resignation of Justin Welby, who will the Great British Public select to lead the Church of England? The Church of England is in turmoil following Justin Welby’s shock resignation. Who will take over Britain’s top church? The Critic is proud to bring you a list of the runners and riders.
Back in the arena
If you liked Gladiator, you’ll like Gladiator II ★★★★☆ Sequels are tricky beasts. A great film should be a complete story in itself, so how do you extend it? The sequel to Ridley Scott’s 2000 epic Gladiator faced an even trickier problem: most of the key characters were dead at the end of the first film. All of which meant that a lot of us approached Gladiator II with trepidation, especially given Scott’s somewhat patchy output of late.
Kemi goes postal
“I am being amicable.” Kemi Badenoch was before the Post Office Inquiry, explaining her language in a transcript of a phone call. As this was a call in which she was sacking the person on the other end, there turns out to be limits to her amicability, but perhaps Badenoch struggles with the concept. It may be that, in the words of Terry Pratchett, the closest she can get to the idea of a friend is an enemy who’s still alive.
Making a mockery of Labour
This article is taken from the November 2024 issue of The Critic. To get the full magazine why not subscribe? Right now we’re offering five issues for just £10. “You must,” people say to me, “miss the Tories. They were so much easier to sketch.” Behind my back, they are blunter. “When is Hutton going to get a fix on Starmer?” someone asked the editor. It’s a fair enough question.
A constructive opposition
The age of Badenoch is off to a suitably farcical start Kemi Badenoch took her seat in the Commons to cheers from her own side, and gave a little wave to her husband Hamish, who was watching up in the gallery. She would, in the ensuing 30 minutes, be offering plenty more gestures to the room, but this was the last friendly one. The atmosphere in the chamber was a little strained. MPs had woken to the news that angry orange toddler Donald Trump was going to be leading the free world again.
Boris: the PM who could do no wrong
This article is taken from the November 2024 issue of The Critic. To get the full magazine why not subscribe? Right now we’re offering five issues for just £10. “I beg readers to forgive the tone of what follows,” Boris Johnson writes on page 708 of his autobiography, “since it falls firmly into the category of blowing your own trumpet.” It is a little late in the book for such becoming modesty.
Still knocking on the door
For all the promises, subpostmasters are still waiting for compensation In his years as an anarchist, my late uncle used to have a bumper sticker that read: “Whoever you vote for, the government gets in.” (He later joined the Liberal Democrats, who would prove this point in 2010.) On Tuesday afternoon, subpostmasters explained how this principle worked in practice.
You reap what you sow
Poor Daniel Zeichner was left to face the outrage that the Budget had caused We plough the fields and scatter the good seed on the land. But then it’s confiscated by Rachel Reeves’s hand. The farmers were furious. Well, farmers are always furious. It’s a life that combines working in freezing rain with handling impenetrable paperwork and following arbitrary rules set by distant bureaucrats. If you did it, you’d want to shoot something on the weekends, too.
Cardinal win | Robert Hutton | The Critic Magazine
This article is taken from the November 2024 issue of The Critic. To get the full magazine why not subscribe? Right now we’re offering five issues for just £10. Sometimes a lesser book can make a greater film. Robert Harris’s 2016 novel Conclave was a gripping beach read, but a slight work compared to his best. Brought to the screen, it is a perfect two-hour thriller. The pope is dead, and Cardinal Lawrence is in charge of organising the election of his successor.
Pandæmonium | Robert Hutton | The Critic Magazine
“The task that stands before us is tough.” We were in a basement room of a central London hotel. Outside it was a grey November morning, but we had gathered for the greatest show on earth: the election of the next former leader of the Conservative Party, a successor to Rishi Sunak. The winner, Kemi Badenoch, was addressing her troops. Labour leadership announcements generally happen in huge halls full of supporters, with votes tallied on screen.
Invalid email address
This article is taken from the November 2024 issue of The Critic. To get the full magazine why not subscribe? Right now we’re offering five issues for just £10. From: Morgan McSweeney Subject: Desk Hi Sue, hope you’re enjoying your regional tour. You left in such a hurry that you didn’t have time to clear your desk. There’s O’Neill’s Music Of Ireland and The Good Pub Guide 1987. Where shall I send them? I’ve completely lost track of where your desk is these days.
Riddle of the Pylons
“Lincolnshire faces an invasion!” Sir John Hayes had come to the House of Commons with grave news. Not since the publication of The Riddle of the Sands had the Fens faced such a threat. Was it the Angles again? The Dutch? You will have to wait to find out. Hayes was speaking at the end of Deputy Prime Minister’s Questions, a joyous, historic occasion, as it was both Angela Rayner’s first session in the hot seat and Oliver Dowden’s last on the front bench — there will be a new deputy Tory leader soon.
Humble pie? | Robert Hutton | The Critic Magazine
Ric Holden is painfully aware that he is only just Holden on to his seat Ric Holden, sitting alone in a large room in Parliament, bent over to tie his shoelace. He was waiting to raise an issue of national importance: pie and mash. A few months ago, Holden was the chairman of the greatest election-winning machine in history, the British Conservative Party. Now he is just a humble opposition backbencher. Some might say his demotion was deserved.
Ministry of Silly Thoughts
“The best ideas aren’t going to come from politicians in Whitehall!” It was a Monday morning in October, but Wes Streeting, Britain’s perkiest secretary of state, was full of zip. He had a plan to fix the National Health Service, using the creative spirit and drive of the British people. What could go wrong? You could see where he was coming from, you really could. Anyone who’s sat in a hospital for any length of time has found themselves contemplating the ways in which it could be better organised.
Soporific Starmer
The Prime Minister appears to be making a virtue of his own dullness There is a school of thought that Prime Minister’s Questions is the most important half-hour in the week of our democracy: an opportunity to hold the government to account as it steers the ship of state across the ocean of history; a moment when the lowliest backbencher can challenge the highest in the land. But for most of us, it’s a chance to take the piss.
Office politics | Robert Hutton | The Critic Magazine
It tells you a lot about the state of politics that the best Prime Minister’s Questions joke about FreebieGate, the scandal that we keep being told has destroyed the government, came from Keir Starmer. It was right at the end of a session that had largely served to remind us how much Parliament has been changed by the election. The government benches are so packed that some Labour MPs were unable even to get into the chamber, instead crowding outside the doors leading in.
Boris the Innocent
The Johnsonian lexicon has yet to incorporate the word “responsibility” “It was one of his family’s birthdays that day and blah blah fishcakes.” We were listening, of course, to a Boris Johnson interview. He was talking, I think, about Dominic Cummings and the Barnard Castle Eye Test. Though he could also have been talking about Emmanuel Macron and the hydrogen-powered Concorde, or Joe Biden and the unwanted bottle of wine. After a while, the stories all merge.
Some picture-perfect restorations
This article is taken from the October 2024 issue of The Critic. To get the full magazine why not subscribe? Right now we’re offering five issues for just £10. I first watched The Terminator on a 12-inch black and white TV, some time in the late Eighties. It’s a reflection of the quality of the film that it still managed to be terrifying.
Look on our works, ye voters, and despair
We now go live to Birmingham, where four of the Conservative Party’s best and brightest are vying for the honour of being knifed by colleagues after the next election. “Frankly Camilla, people have taken my words completely out of context. Well, when I said those things, I didn’t think anyone was writing them down.
Non-euclidean Toryism
“I had a really good media round,” Kemi Badenoch announced on Sunday afternoon, which is certainly one way of looking at a day that ended with her rejecting the position she’d appeared to be taking in the morning. The Conservative conference in Birmingham has a surprisingly optimistic tone. The party is still very much in the denial phase of grief, a perspective only encouraged by the government’s recent troubles.
BoJo’s Life of Johnson
Exclusive extracts of perhaps the best autobiography by a former Conservative prime minister called Boris From not sending the SAS to snatch Covid vaccines from the Dutch to not persuading Prince Harry to stay in Britain, Boris Johnson has got the nation gripped with his new memoir Unchecked, the tales of all the things he didn’t do while he was in office.
Fabian fry-up | Robert Hutton | The Critic Magazine
“I’m a Labour student who enjoyed the disco a bit too much last night.” Finally, Labour conference had found someone who spoke for the entire hall. Wednesday morning had a distinct air of the morning after the night before: the feeling of fragile heads and delicate stomachs, of enhanced sensitivity to one’s surroundings somehow combined with numbness in the limbs.
Hot desking | Robert Hutton | The Critic Magazine
This article is taken from the October 2024 issue of The Critic. To get the full magazine why not subscribe? Right now we’re offering five issues for just £10. From: Morgan McSweeney Subject: Desk Look, I take your point about the shortage of space, but the place you’ve got me now isn’t even in the same postcode as the boss. Any chance of a rethink?
Sausage to fortune
Vague promises might haunt Starmer more than an embarrassing gaffe Up on the screen over the Labour conference stage, the names of the constituencies the party now held scrolled away from us, like the opening crawl of a Star Wars film. Basingstoke. Bournemouth East. Bournemouth West. Bracknell. Buckingham and Bletchley. It is a dark time for the Conservative Party. Although if you were to listen to some of the chatter around Liverpool, you’d be tempted to think it was Labour that had lost the election.
Nothing to declare
Labour have done nothing wrong, but they’re going to stop it “All MPs do it.” Angela Rayner’s contribution to Operation Change The Subject To The Work Of Change wasn’t starting very well. As answers to the criticism that you’re all as bad as each other go, this is really about the worst one you can give. Rayner had been sent out to face the BBC’s Laura Kuenssberg at the start of the Labour conference in Liverpool.
The Critic | Robert Hutton | The Critic Magazine
★★★★☆ The Critic is not, I’m sad to say, the film of the magazine. Our time will come, and what a tale it will be. While you wait, here is a Jacobean tragedy remade for our Carolean age and set in Edwardian London. Ian McKellen plays Jimmy Erskine, a theatre writer known to his fans as “The Beast”. He can play me when they come to make the film of the magazine He works for The Chronicle, whose headquarters very much resemble those of The Express in its great days.
Dress code | Robert Hutton | The Critic Magazine
How did Starmer not know how it would look? (The donation, not the clothes) Ciao! Benvenuti to Rome, the eternal city, the home of alleged saints and confirmed sinners. Keir Starmer, fresh from Washington DC, had come to a previous imperial capital, to meet his Italian counterpart Giorgia Meloni. It wasn’t set to be a meeting of minds: he’s a lifelong campaigner on the left, she was a teenage fascist.
Rite of autumn | Robert Hutton | The Critic Magazine
Labour is celebrating the harvest and definitely not sacrificing pensioners in the hopes that the gods grant us plenty in the coming fiscal year Next to the speaker’s chair, Gen Kitchen was handing out wheatsheaves. This is a sentence that probably needs unpacking. Gen is short for Genevieve, and she is the Labour MP for Wellingborough, after the by-election prompted by Peter Bone’s ejection, an event that was at once seven months ago and ancient history.
One small step for Jenrick…
“There is a sense of disappointment,” Graham Stuart, a veteran Conservative MP, told parliament in a tone of sadness. Was he talking about the dismal test match at the Oval? Had he been hoping for more from Beetlejuice Beetlejuice? No, it turns out that the thing which was failing to live up to his high expectations was a Labour government.
Beetlejuice Beetlejuice
★★★☆☆ There is a shot about halfway through Beetlejuice Beetlejuice that reminds you what cinema can do. Teenager Astrid, played by Jenna Ortega, breaks off from her first kiss with a look of wonder in her eyes. It’s a tender moment, bursting with adolescent delight, a reminder of director Tim Burton’s gift for capturing sensations on film. Sadly, the rest of the movie fails to live up to it.
The Birth of Britain’s “Commando” Units
If Dudley Clarke had done nothing else in the war, his final job in London in 1940 would have secured him a place in history. On his return from Ireland he’d been appointed as military assistant to Sir John Dill, the new Chief of the Imperial General Staff. Dill and Clarke were old comrades. In Palestine a couple of years earlier, they’d been flying in a plane together and Clarke had leaned out to point to something, only to be thrown from his seat in the open cockpit by a moment of turbulence.
False Front
People believe that with magic, it’s the quickness the hand that deceives the eye. They’re wrong. The eye is drawn to sudden movements. If you don’t want people to notice what you’re doing, do it slowly and calmly while they’re looking somewhere else. I learned about stage magic while I was researching one of the least understood aspects of World War II: the deception war and the eccentric British soldier behind it, Dudley Clarke.
Disaster zone | Robert Hutton | The Critic Magazine
“There’s no way of repeating this that won’t be painful,” Keir Starmer said, opening his statement on the Grenfell fire. Above and behind him, in the public gallery, some of those affected by the tragedy looked on. “The simple truth is that the deaths that occurred were all avoidable.” The report he was presenting to parliament had nothing in it to make anyone involved proud. Every institution, private and public, had failed the residents of the tower block before the fire and afterwards.
Action Tom | Robert Hutton | The Critic Magazine
“It is an honour to introduce the next leader of our party and the next prime minister of our country … Tom Tugendhat!” Harriet Cross, the newly elected Tory MP for Gordon and Buchan invited the crowd to go wild, which they duly did. But of the candidate, there was no sign. On the applause went. We looked around. Was Tugendhat, an ex-soldier (though he doesn’t like to talk about it) helicoptering in?
To Trick the Nazis, This Master of Deception Invented Fake Fleets and Armies
History | During World War II, British officer Dudley Clarke led A Force, a Cairo-based military unit that fed false information to the Germans The officer commanding the British garrison on Cyprus was worried. It was 1941, and another Mediterranean island, Crete, had just fallen to a daring airborne attack by the Nazis. Cyprus was far less well defended than Crete had been. Was Brigadier Reginald Rodwell going to be next?
A leadership bid you can’t refuse
“Kemi is approachable!” Kemi Badenoch, a woman who was, just two months ago, the Secretary Of State Most Likely To Punch You In The Face For Looking At Her Funny was attempting a rebrand. The glasses were gone, and she arrived on stage with a sustained playful giggle. It was disconcerting, like stumbling across Genghis Khan taking part in a pillow fight. The words had come in a video that showed us what a friendly, calm, not-permanently seething person Badenoch is.
Show More
loading
Actions
Get in touch with Robert
Contact Robert, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack