Those in marketing analytics, research, and academia tend to view experiments as a gold standard. Careful…test vs. control reads are hard work too. I am going to show you how testing can overestimate lift and underestimate advertising ROI. The reasons for this misestimation will also give you avenues to take corrective action and prevent this from happening to your research and testing.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Rubinson Partners
Descriptive Research and Insights are not Enough
Broadly speaking, marketing research studies fall into two classes…descriptive and predictive. Descriptive research includes things like segmentation, A&Us, qual, even brand trackers which are retrospective in nature. One of the biggest challenges to marketing research is when actions from the insights are not clearly indicated to marketing. The reason? We researchers do not try hard enough to flesh out the predictions embedded in the insights by creating a math structure to our findings.
Making Magic Happen with Markov Analytics
First, let me clarify…I’m not talking about MCMC which most of us use. I’m talking about Markov matrices. You will be amazed by the predictive power embedded in a switching matrix like this one. From this matrix you can estimate: 1. Each brand’s market share 2. Each brand’s cumulative penetration In particular, you might be shocked (as I was) to discover you can estimate each brand’s penetration without knowing a brand’s market share. Here is how it all works. What is a Markov switching matrix?
How to Estimate a Brand’s Cumulative Penetration by Analytics
The measures from a survey I trust the most relate to market share. However, sometimes you need to know what percent of consumers engaged in a particular behavior or had a certain need over a given period of time. This is a “cumulative penetration” measure and consumers are bad at recalling this because of telescoping and imperfect memory. So how can you estimate penetration analytically as an alternative approach which can also be used for logic checking survey answers?
How to Prevent Consumers from Being Survey Tricksters
Survey takers don’t mean to be tricksters but remember when someone clicks a link to take a survey their mind was almost certainly somewhere else vs. the topic they will be surveyed about. Also, psychologists know that memory is reconstructive, not like going back through a book of photographs…more like person is recreating what is most likely to have been true based on how they view themselves in the world then. Here are four ways that surveys can go wrong and what you can do about it.
Will customers grow to love Walgreens’ digital cooler doors?
Consumer Marketing Drug Channel In-store analytics In-Store Media Merchandising Retail Tech Shopper Analytics Walgreens If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. That’s the reaction of customers, CNN reports, to the decision by retailers to replace see-through cooler doors with opaque digital alternatives that are activated by the presence of shoppers to provide product information, prices and special deals. Consumers have taken to social media to voice their complaints about the new doors.
Rather than compete, Walmart inks exclusive deal with Netflix
Ada Twist Cuddle Plush, Stranger Things t-shirt, The Witcher Netflix Collectible Statue - Source: Walmart.com Discount Channel Entertainment and Media Merchandising Netflix Online Retail Products Brands Walmart Oct 12, 2021 Walmart has gone from aspiring to compete with Netflix in the digital video subscription market to making a deal to sell merchandise linked to its erstwhile rival’s original programming on its site.
Organized theft is turning San Francisco into retail’s wild west
CVS Operations Shrink & Security Walgreens Worker Issues May 25, 2021 Recent reports depict a battle going on in San Francisco between retailers and organized retail crime, and the thieves are winning so convincingly that stores are closing their doors rather than trying to keep up a losing fight.
New marketing analytics for a new COVID-19 reality
May 22, 2020 Through a special arrangement, presented here for discussion is an excerpt of a current article from the Joel Rubinson on Marketing Research Consulting blog. It certainly isn’t business as usual for marketers navigating COVID-19, and it can’t be business as usual for marketing analytics teams either. Here are three changes that analytics teams need to focus on: Reduce reliance on marketing mix models. No one can (or should) trust any updates to marketing mix models for at least a year.
Are loyalty cards key to online-to-offline attribution?
Consumer Marketing Digital marketing Google Kroger Mobile Marketing Omnichannel Shopper Analytics Feb 20, 2020 Kroger said its self-service advertising platform now leverages three sources — its own customer loyalty program, data science from its media advertising business and Microsoft PromoteIQ — to allow brands for the first time to view in-store and online sales results attributed to advertising campaigns across the grocer’s properties.
Should retail boards include seats for store associates?
Bernie Sanders Discount Channel Human Resources Investor Relations Political Situations PR Issues Walmart Worker Issues May 22, 2019 Bernie Sanders is not a fan of Walmart’s business practices when it comes to how the retailer compensates its hourly workers.
Will shoppable ads help Walmart’s Vudu compete with Amazon and Netflix?
Amazon Consumer Advertising Consumer Marketing Digital marketing Entertainment and Media Netflix Online Retail Vudu Walmart Apr 30, 2019 Walmart’s Vudu video streaming service is following Amazon and Netflix in creating original programming to attract viewers. Unlike its rivals, however, Walmart will continue to offer Vudu as a free, ad-supported service rather than seeking subscription income.
Will America’s love for paper coupons ever die?
Consumer Marketing Coupons Digital marketing Loyalty Marketing Shopper Behavior Apr 18, 2019 by Guest contributor MarketingCharts staff Through a special arrangement, presented here for discussion is a summary of articles from MarketingCharts, which provides up-to-the-minute data and research to marketers. Despite a slight rise in the preference for paperless discounts, more adults still prefer paper coupons, according to the latest annual survey of coupon use from Valassis.
Did Gillette’s rant against toxic masculinity go too far?
Source: Gillette's "We Believe: The Best Men Can Be" Brand Image Consumer Advertising Gillette PR Issues Women's Issues Jan 21, 2019 Gillette’s “Me Too” movement-inspired ad, “Is this the best a man can get?,” has drawn wide praise in some corners and boycotts from others. The nearly two-minute long spot shows men and boys engaging in a wide range of bad behavior, primarily sexual harassment and bullying. The ad calls on men to abandon “the same old excuses” and hold each other accountable.
Does Starbucks have a big delivery opportunity?
Dec 14, 2018 At its investor day on Thursday, Starbucks said that, in a partnership with Uber Eats, the chain will roll out home delivery to nearly one-quarter of company-owned stores in the U.S. by the end of the second quarter. Starbucks has been exploring delivery for years and tested a program in Seattle in 2015 with Postmates. The renewed push comes as McDonald’s recently partnered on delivery with Uber Eats.
Where is market research and analytics falling short?
Through a special arrangement, presented here for discussion is an excerpt of a current article from the Joel Rubinson on Marketing Research Consulting blog. For 10 years or more, big research providers have been forced to accept meager organic growth. Yet, growth is out there.
Will retailers drive the next phase in digital marketing?
Through a special arrangement, presented here for discussion is an excerpt from a current article from the Joel Rubinson on the Marketing Research blog. What are the ingredients of success for an important advertising platform? Reach? Of course. Unified IDs across devices? in a programmatic age, yes. Proven impact? Definitely. So who offers all of this in spades? Amazon. Walmart too. Yes, the folks who redefined retailing are about to redefine marketing as well.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Rubinson
Contact Rubinson, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack