The recent Cowichan Tribes decision – where the Supreme Court of B.C. ruled they had never surrendered their territory and therefore still have Aboriginal title to it – has stirred confusion and fear about the state of private property rights in Canada. But much of that debate misses what the decision actually means and sometimes falls into the realm of fear-mongering and misinformation.
Freelance journalist, writer, artist
Retweets are facts. Draw your own conclusions.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Victoria Wicks
T. Denny Sanford attempted to block media coverage
SDPB Radio | By Victoria Wicks Published November 18, 2021 at 8:52 AM CST Second Circuit Court files unsealed on Wednesday, Nov. 17, confirm that search warrants served on T. Denny Sanford are part of an investigation into child pornography. Also included in the newly opened files are records of Sanford ’s attempts to kill a story by ProPublica and, failing that, to force the reporters to reveal their sources. When T.
T. Denny Sanford named as 'Implicated Individual'
SDPB Radio | By Victoria Wicks Published November 17, 2021 at 3:50 PM CST Court documents unsealed on Wednesday, Nov. 17, have confirmed that Thomas Denny Sanford is the subject of five search warrants obtained by the South Dakota Division of Criminal Investigation in 2019. Sanford is better known as T. Denny Sanford, a South Dakota billionaire. Identified only as “Implicated Individual,” he appealed to the South Dakota Supreme Court in August to keep his identity hidden.
Unnamed appellant loses bid to keep warrants sealed
SDPB Radio | By Victoria Wicks Published October 28, 2021 at 3:33 PM CDT Stephen Groves / AP Jeffrey Beck argues in front of the South Dakota Supreme Court on behalf of ProPublica on Aug. 24. In the background is former Attorney General Marty Jackley, who represents the unnamed appellant. Ruling that the question was not even close, the South Dakota Supreme Court decided that state law clearly requires making most search warrant information public.
Supreme Court rules in favor of open records in 'mystery appellant' case
SDPB Radio | By Victoria Wicks Published October 28, 2021 at 9:58 AM CDT South Dakota Supreme Court The South Dakota Supreme Court has ruled that news media should have access to five search warrants filed in 2019 in Second Circuit Court in Sioux Falls. The opinion responds to an appeal filed by an appellant whose name was not revealed during arguments in August or in the opinion made public on Thursday, Oct. 28.
Carjacking and assault convictions appealed to 8th Circuit
SDPB Radio | By Victoria Wicks Published October 25, 2021 at 7:53 AM CDT Two federal inmates found guilty of carjacking, beating, and shooting at a Rapid City man have appealed their convictions to the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals. Ranson Long Pumpkin says the trial judge should have allowed his lawyer to ask government witnesses about their drug use.
Fireworks at Mount Rushmore under appeal at Eighth Circuit
SDPB Radio | By Victoria Wicks Published October 22, 2021 at 10:41 AM CDT The State of South Dakota is appealing the denial of a permit for a fireworks show at Mount Rushmore. The National Park Service under the Trump administration approved a permit for 2020, but the next administration denied a 2021 permit. The state sued in federal district court, and when that judge ruled in favor of the National Park Service, the state filed with the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals. That case is pending.
State appeals Flandreau Tribe contractors’ exemption from state excise tax
SDPB Radio | By Victoria Wicks Published October 21, 2021 at 12:11 PM CDT Following a court trial in June 2020, a federal judge ruled that the State of South Dakota does not have the authority to impose contractors’ excise taxes on the companies that renovated the Royal River Casino. The casino is owned by the Flandreau Santee Sioux Tribe and is located on reservation land. The state appealed that opinion to the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals, which heard arguments on Wednesday, Oct. 20.
SD Supreme Court says Yankton man's murder conviction stands
SDPB Radio | By Victoria Wicks Published October 7, 2021 at 11:38 AM CDT A Yankton man serving life for killing his girlfriend was not unduly prejudiced at trial by extensive evidence that he had dismembered the victim’s body. The South Dakota Supreme Court made its opinion public on Thursday, Oct. 7. Stephen Falkenberg committed the murder in March 2019 in Yankton County and then drove the body to his family’s property in Michigan.
S.D. Supreme Court considers liability for pit bull attack
SDPB Radio | By Victoria Wicks Published October 6, 2021 at 3:43 PM CDT A Yankton mother whose child was mauled by a pit bull in a trailer park is appealing a lower court decision that the landlord is not liable. The mother’s attorney says the lower court granted summary judgment to the landlord, but the case should have been heard by a jury. The South Dakota Supreme Court heard arguments on Wednesday, Oct. 6, at the Knudson School of Law at USD.
Eighth Circuit considers constitutionality of state’s prohibiting Israel boycotts
SDPB Radio | By Victoria Wicks Published September 23, 2021 at 7:35 AM CDT The Federalist Society / ACLU Left: ARK Solicitor General Nicholas Bronni / Right: ACLU lawyer Brian Hauss The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals is taking another look at an Arkansas law that supports trade with Israel. The law specifically targets state contractors and requires them to certify that they won’t boycott commerce with Israel.
En banc Eighth Circuit considers 2019 Missouri law against abortions after Down Syndrome diagnoses
SDPB Radio | By Victoria Wicks Published September 22, 2021 at 11:37 AM CDT In 2019, Missouri passed two laws sanctioning doctors who provide abortions after eight weeks of pregnancy or when the patient wants an abortion because the fetus has been diagnosed with Down Syndrome. A federal judge granted a preliminary injunction to stop the law from taking effect. And a three-judge panel of the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that injunction.
U.S. Has Treaty Obligation To Provide Healthcare To Rosebud Sioux Tribe
The United States has an ongoing treaty obligation to provide competent physician-led healthcare to the Rosebud Sioux Tribe. That ruling was issued by South Dakota Federal Circuit Judge Roberto Lange and has now been upheld by the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals. At oral arguments before the Eighth Circuit in March, lawyers argued whether the language of a document more than 150 years old is still valid. Victoria Wicks has this report for SDPB. Feature by Victoria Wicks; intro by Chris Laughery
SD's Deadline For Initiated Measure Petitions Violates Free Speech
A federal judge is ruling that a new state law is invalid and violates the first amendment of the United States Constitution. South Dakota lawmakers passed a bill in 2019 that requires petition circulators to register and Secretary of State create a directory of circulators. In his ruling on Thursday, District Judge Charles Kornmann says HB 1094’s—the law in question—has a primary purpose of severely regulating the process through which those who wish circulate a petition may do so.
Joe Boever's Family: Attorney General's Sentencing Does Not Bring Closure
When 55-year-old Joe Boever died near Highmore on Sept. 12, 2020, his death made headlines across the country. The attention came not because of who he was, but how he died: he was struck and killed by a car driven by the Attorney General for the State of South Dakota. Now, almost a year later, Attorney General Jason Ravnsborg has been sentenced for two Class 2 misdemeanors, using a cell phone while driving and driving outside his lane.
Boever's Family Responds To Ravnsborg's Sentencing
Your browser does not support HTML5 audio. Here is alink to the audioinstead. When 55-year-old Joe Boever died near Highmore on September 12th last year, his death made headlines across the country. The attention came not because of who he was, but how he died: he was struck and killed by a car driven by the Attorney General for the State of South Dakota.
SD Attorney General Sentenced In Absentia
South Dakota Attorney General Jason Ravnsborg was not present on Thursday, Aug. 26, when he was sentenced for committing two misdemeanor driving offenses. Ravnsborg was operating his car last September when he struck and killed Joe Boever near Highmore. That the collision occurred just west of town became a crucial part of Ravnsborg's defense. Victoria Wicks has more of this story for SDPB.
Ravnsborg Takes Plea Deal For Role In Death Of Boever
by Victoria Wicks • Published on August 26, 2021 Attorney General Jason Ravnsborg and his vehicle from the crash. Attorney General's Office / Department of Transportation Attorney General Jason Ravnsborg was absent from the Stanley County Courthouse Thursday when he was sentenced for his role in the death of Joe Boever. Attorney Tim Rensch pleaded no contest on Ravnsborg’s behalf to two Class 2 misdemeanors: using a mobile device while driving and unlawfully changing lanes.
SD Supreme Court: Secrecy Surrounds Appeal... For Now
In a case cloaked in secrecy, the South Dakota Supreme Court heard arguments pitting open records against privacy. Justices held court on Tuesday, Aug. 24, at the Capitol in Pierre. Former Attorney General Marty Jackley represents a person identified as an "implicated individual" who wants a search warrant with his name on it to remain sealed.
8th Circuit Court Issues Opinion On "Ag-Gag" Laws
The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals has issued opinions on two “Ag-Gag” laws, one out of Arkansas and the other from Iowa. Ag-gag laws attempt to keep whistleblowers and animal activists from having access to the inner workings of agricultural processing facilities. Those would include slaughterhouses and concentrated animal feeding operations, or CAFOs. The Arkansas law threatens civil sanctions for whistleblowers and investigators.
Ag Gag Laws Set Precedent For 8th Circuit
The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals held a special session on Thursday, Feb. 25, to hear arguments on the constitutionality of an "ag gag" law in Arkansas. The ensuing decision applies to the states within the Eighth Circuit, which includes South Dakota. Animal rights activists say the Arkansas law chills First-Amendment protected speech of whistleblowers and journalists who expose animal cruelty in agricultural operations. Victoria Wicks has more on this case for SDPB.
Conviction Upheld For Child Pornographer Trafficking On Facebook
by Victoria Wicks • Published on August 3, 2021 The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld the conviction of a South Dakota man who used two Facebook accounts to distribute child pornography. Kevin Lamm was found guilty in Sioux Falls federal court. Lamm claims the trial judge erred by allowing the jury to hear evidence linking him to a fictitious Facebook account. Your browser does not support HTML5 audio. Here is alink to the audioinstead.
Conviction Upheld For Child Pornographer Trafficking On Facebook
The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld the conviction of a South Dakota man who used two Facebook accounts to distribute child pornography. Kevin Lamm was found guilty in Sioux Falls federal court. Lamm claims the trial judge erred by allowing the jury to hear evidence linking him to a fictitious Facebook account. Victoria Wicks has more of this story for SDPB.
SD Supreme Court: Excessive Force Allegations Can Continue To Trial
The South Dakota Supreme Court is allowing a lawsuit to go forward alleging Sioux Falls police officers used excessive force. Nichole Boggs sued in Second Circuit Court for injuries she suffered in 2016 when two police officers took her to the ground. The Supreme Court has upheld the circuit court's refusal to summarily dismiss the claim of excessive force. But the high court says the lower court should have found the warrantless search to be legal. Victoria Wicks has more of this story for SDPB.
Noem Appeals Mt. Rushmore Fireworks Denial
by Victoria Wicks • Published on July 16, 2021 South Dakota Department of Tourism Your browser does not support HTML5 audio. Here is alink to the audioinstead. In early June a federal judge upheld the denial of a permit for a state fireworks display at Mount Rushmore on the Fourth of July. South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem is now challenging that order.
Noem Appeals Mt. Rushmore Fireworks Denial
In early June, a federal judge upheld the denial of a permit for a state fireworks display at Mount Rushmore on the Fourth of July. South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem is now challenging that order. To pave the way for an appeal to the Eighth Circuit, Noem asked Federal Judge Roberto Lange to convert his ruling on a preliminary injunction to a final judgment. Lange did that earlier this week, and the next day Noem filed notice of intent to appeal. Victoria Wicks has more on this case for SDPB.
Prison Porn Policy Under New Scrutiny
In 2014 the warden at the South Dakota State Penitentiary enacted a more stringent policy restricting access to obscene materials. Inmate Charles Sisney sued in U.S. Federal District Court in Sioux Falls, leaving that court to balance an inmate's civil rights against the need to maintain a safe and orderly institution. Under the newest policy, not only pictures are banned, but also prose. And images that can be banned include nudity in any context, including art or modern photography.
Federal Judge Stops S.D. Law Restricting Political Speech
A U.S. District Judge has found South Dakota's 2020 restrictions on petition circulators to be unconstitutional. Judge Lawrence Piersol ruled earlier this week that Senate Bill 180 violates the First Amendment rights of initiated measure proponents, voters, and petition circulators. SB 180 came about after another South Dakota U.S. District Judge, Charles Kornmann, found House Bill 1094 unconstitutional. That 2018 bill made a more aggressive attempt to rein in petition carriers.
Federal Judge Finds State’s 2020 Restrictions On Petition Circulators Unconstitutional
by Victoria Wicks • Published on June 18, 2021 A federal judge has found South Dakota’s 2020 restrictions on petition circulators to be unconstitutional. Judge Lawrence Piersol ruled earlier this week that Senate Bill 180 violates the First Amendment rights of initiated measure proponents, voters, and petition circulators. Senate Bill 180 came about after another South Dakota federal judge, Charles Kornmann, found House Bill 1094 unconstitutional.
Former Black-Metal Marketer Seeks Admission to South Dakota Bar
A lawyer who previously ran a black-metal label that included anti-Semitic and white supremacist music is trying again to be admitted to the South Dakota bar. Aaron Wayne Davis made his pitch to the South Dakota Supreme Court on Monday, May 24. Davis tried for admission in 2019, but the Supreme Court rejected that application. Victoria Wicks has more of this story for SDPB.
Victim's Illegal Status Subject Of Appeal
Two South Dakota penitentiary inmates convicted of robbery and burglary are asking for a new trial. Lawyers for the inmates told the state Supreme Court on Monday, May 24, that they should have been able to tell the jury about the victim's status as an illegal resident and how he might have a reason to lie about the crime. Victoria Wicks has more on this appeal for SDPB.
8th Circuit Hears Forced Catheterization Appeal From S.D.
In 2017, six South Dakota plaintiffs sued law officers in three cities for forcing them to undergo catheterization to get evidence of drug use. After a federal judge declined to grant summary judgment to the officials, five of the plaintiffs received settlements. Bt the sixth plaintiff was denied. He appealed to the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals, which heard arguments in his case on Wednesday, May 12. Victoria Wicks has more details for SDPB.
SD Supreme Court: Sierra Club Challenge To Clay County CAFO Can Continue
The Sierra Club has standing to challenge a confined hog and cattle operation in Clay County. That's the unanimous decision of the South Dakota Supreme Court, who heard arguments in October 2020. A lower court dismissed Sierra Club's lawsuit against the Clay County Board of Adjustment. The high court says that lawsuit can continue. Victoria Wicks has more of this story for SDPB.
Justices Deliberate Marijuana Amendment
On Nov. 3, 2020, South Dakota citizens voted to approve an amendment to the state constitution that legalizes all things cannabis. Voters also approved an initiated measure directing the state to establish a medical marijuana program. After the election, the superintendent of the South Dakota Highway Patrol and the Pennington County Sheriff sued to challenge the constitutionality of Amendment A.
Marijuana Appeal: Justices Deliberate Will Of Voters, Constitutionality Of Amendment A
The South Dakota Supreme Court heard arguments on Wednesday, April 28, on the constitutionality of Amendment A. In the 2020 election, almost 55 percent of the state's voters approved the amendment that legalizes cannabis for both medical and recreational purposes. The law officers who brought this suit say the new amendment violates older amendments, especially one added in 2018. Victoria Wicks has this report for SDPB.
SD Supreme Court Upholds Life Sentence In Murder For Hire
A South Dakota inmate serving life without parole is asking the South Dakota Supreme Court to overturn his sentence. Jonathon Klinetobe was charged with masterminding the plot that resulted in the 2015 murder of his former girlfriend in Rapid City. He agreed to plead guilty to first-degree manslaughter and left it up to the judge to determine his sentence. At oral arguments on Tuesday, Jan.
DAPL: Army Corps Won't Appeal But Dakota Access Will
Opponents to the Dakota Access Pipeline are disappointed that the Biden administration has not shut the pipeline down. Opponents have sued the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, claiming the government permit violated the National Environmental Policy Act. Last summer plaintiffs claimed victory when a District of Columbia federal judge vacated the permit and ordered the pipeline shut down. The D.C. Court of Appeals quickly reversed the shutdown.
DAPL Oil Still Flowing; Biden's Corps Punts
Last month a federal judge ordered that the Dakota Access pipeline should be shut down and drained by Aug. 5. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers quickly appealed, and the D.C. Court of Appeals stayed the order. Now the appeals court has affirmed that the pipeline does not have to be shut down immediately, but it lets stand the lower court's finding that the Corps violated federal law when it failed to complete an environmental impact study. Victoria Wicks has this story for SDPB.
8th Circuit Says Meade County Conviction Stops Short Of Unconstitutionality
In 2001, Oakley Engesser was convicted of vehicular homicide and two counts of vehicular battery resulting from a car crash near Sturgis. Engesser spent 12 years in prison, all the while maintaining he had not been driving. After his conviction was overturned, Engesser sued investigators and prosecutors for ignoring witnesses and mishandling physical evidence, but those efforts failed. Now he has turned to the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals, which heard arguments on Thursday, Oct. 22.
5th Circuit ICWA Opinion Cuts Protections For Native Tribes & Families In Limited Jurisdiction
Earlier this week the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals released an extensive opinion on the Indian Child Welfare Act. Lawyers immediately started to examine its potential effect on legal processes in place for more than 40 years. An attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union says much of the law still stands, but some important protections have been found unconstitutional. The appellate ruling is binding on courts only in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi, the states in the Fifth Circuit.
The Morning Report, April 10
5th Circuit Deems Indian Child Welfare Act Unconstitutional In Part 04/09/21 Victoria Wicks Earlier this week the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals released an extensive opinion on the Indian Child Welfare Act. Lawyers immediately started to examine its potential effect on legal processes in place for more than 40 years. An attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union says much of the law still stands, but some important protections have been found unconstitutional.
5th Circuit Deems Indian Child Welfare Act Unconstitutional In Part
A full panel of judges in the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals will decide if the Indian Child Welfare Act is based on race or politics. The court heard oral arguments on Wednesday, Jan. 22, in New Orleans. In 2018 a Texas lower court found the act known as ICWA to be unconstitutionally race-based. A three-judge panel overturned that finding, but not unanimously. Now all of the appeals judges in the Fifth Circuit will consider the issue. SDPB's Victoria Wicks has this report.
Healy Ranch Feud Goes To Second Appeal
The South Dakota Supreme Court has heard a second appeal stemming from a battle over a family ranch near Pukwana. Attorneys for both sides of the Healy family dispute made their cases before justices on Tuesday, March 23. One issue is whether a lower court erred by not including as costs around $100,000 of attorneys fees. Victoria Wicks has more of this story for SDPB.
The Morning Report, March 20
Noem Wants Transgender Sports Bill Revised 03/19/2021 / By Lee Strubinger Governor Kristi Noem wants the legislature to make some changes to a bill that prevents transgender girls from playing on girls’ sports teams. Noem wants to remove a section of the bill that requires schools collect a written waiver verifying an athlete’s age, sex and whether they’ve taken performance enhancing drugs. Noem also wants to limit the ban to high school athletes. The original bill includes college athletes.
IHS Appeals Ruling That Health Care Is Treaty Obligation To Rosebud Sioux Tribe
Lawyers for the Rosebud Sioux Tribe and the U.S. Department of Justice argued on Thursday, March 18, before the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals. The Rosebud tribe sued Indian Health Services and the Department of Health and Human Services in 2016, claiming that IHS health care is so inadequate, it violates treaty obligations. The tribe prevailed, in part, in a lower court, and the feds appealed. Victoria Wicks has more of this story for SDPB.
Fish Farm Fraud Conviction Upheld
In 2016, public and private officials gathered on a 10-acre tract of land near Brookings to break ground for an indoor aquaponics farm. Investors were told the $11 million enterprise would raise fish and grow hydroponic vegetables and fruit. But it was never built. A year and a half later, the two developers were indicted for fraud. Both were convicted, and one of them is now appealing. Oral arguments were held telephonically on Wednesday, Oct. 21, before the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals.
Legislators Debate "Stand Your Ground" Bill
A Stand Your Ground bill shot down by the Senate Judiciary committee has been resurrected and approved by the full Senate. Supporters of House Bill 1212 say the bill clears up vague and outdated language in current self-defense statutes. But lawyers in the legislature say the bill replaces current self-defense law and wipes out decades of case law that interprets what self defense is and is not.
"Open Fields" Bill Smoked Out And Passed
The "open fields" bill has been resurrected, amended, and passed in the South Dakota Senate. House Bill 1140 puts restrictions on Game Fish & Parks officers entering private land. The Senate Judiciary killed the bill in committee on Tuesday, March 2, but the full Senate smoked the bill out the next day and voted on an amended version on Monday, March 8. Victoria Wicks has been following this legislation for SDPB.
SD Rape Conviction Overturned; Possible Prior Victimization Deemed Relevant
The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals has overturned the rape conviction of a South Dakota man. At trial, the federal prosecutor brought in an expert witness to tell what characteristics a rape victim might display. But the judge would not allow the defense to allege that the victim's trauma might have come from an earlier rape. Victoria Wicks has more of this story for SDPB.
Felony Assault Conviction Holds If Victim Doesn't Know Gun Won't Shoot
A Fall River County woman convicted for brandishing a broken gun at law officers and kicking a deputy has failed to have her conviction overturned. The South Dakota Supreme Court has reaffirmed that a person can be charged with aggravated assault even if she knows her gun doesn't work. Relying on information from the court's opinion, Victoria Wicks reports on this case for SDPB.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Victoria
Contact Victoria, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack