The first episode of our three-part series on Afghanistan lessons discussed building armies. This episode focuses exclusively on assessing them. In the studio for this second episode are LTG (R) Eric Wesley, who brings experience from both the National Security Council Staff and the International Security Assistance Force, and Dr. Ben Connable, author of a RAND monograph entitled, Embracing the Fog of War: Assessment and Metrics in Counterinsurgency.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Ben Connable
Understanding the People Behind the Fight
Sign up now and start listening to "Marine Pulse!" Already a member? Sign In to have access to our podcasts Episode Notes: Gary sits down with retired Marine intelligence officer and foreign area officer Ben Connable to explore how his military service influenced his research on ground combat.
Ground Combat: Puncturing the Myths of Modern War
Connable, a former U.S. Marine Corps officer, provides a comprehensive and meticulous analysis of ground force combat that shows how war has—and hasn’t—changed. To do so, he examines 468 major land battles across eight decades: 20 from World War II, 25 from 1946 to 2002, and an impressive 423 from 2003 through 2022. He places each in its proper context and looks at a selection of characteristics, including different types of tactics, weapons, equipment, munitions, and technologies.
Ukrainian and Russian Will to Fight: An Early-War Assessment
Editor’s Note: Russia has a large army and clear superiority in firepower, but is experiencing many setbacks in its invasion of Ukraine. Russia's experience is far from unusual: Military success depends on much more than just material factors. Ben Connable of the Atlantic Council, who has worked extensively on armies' wills to fight, evaluates both militaries to explain why, so far at least, the Ukrainian military is exceeding expectations while the Russian military has faced many problems.
Putting Operation Spider’s Web in Context
Editor’s Note: this article is being republished with the permission of the Irregular Warfare Initiative as part of a republishing arrangement between SWJ and IWI. The original article was published on June 20, 2025 and is available here. On June 1, 2025, the Ukrainian special intelligence services launched Operation Spider’s Web, a remotely triggered drone attack that may have damaged or destroyed over 40 Russian strategic aircraft at four air bases deep inside the Russian Federation’s borders.
Putting Operation Spider’s Web in Context
nothing about Operation Spider’s Web changes either the nature or character of warfare
We Need a Marine Corps, Part III: A Corps Recentered
Commandant Eric Smith clearly articulated his vision for the future of the Marine Corps: While retaining focus on the China threat, the service will recenter on global crisis response Read Full Article » Show comments Hide Comments Related Articles
We Need a Marine Corps, Part III: A Corps Recentered – War on the Rocks
Editor’s Note: This is the third in a series of three articles on the U.S. Marine Corps. The first article was published on June 16, 2025, and the second article was published on June 19, 2025. Commandant Eric Smith clearly articulated his vision for the future of the Marine Corps: While retaining focus on the China threat, the service will recenter on global crisis response. This means getting more marines — and more of their combat gear — on ship and deployed around the world.
We Need a Marine Corps: A Corps Confounded
In just over 20 years, the Marine Corps has gone from being America’s reliable middleweight force in readiness to more of a secondary, general purpose backup force Read Full Article » Show comments Hide Comments Related Articles
We Need a Marine Corps, Part II: A Corps Confounded – War on the Rocks
Editor’s Note: This is the second in a series of three articles on the U.S. Marine Corps. The first article was published on June 16, 2025. In just over 20 years, the Marine Corps has gone from being America’s reliable middleweight force in readiness to more of a secondary, general purpose backup force. Today, marines are more likely to find themselves assisting special operations teams and U.S. Army crisis response task forces than spearheading operations.
We Need a Marine Corps, Part I: A Corps in Crisis – War on the Rocks
Marines have spent too much energy in the past five years debating the merits of former Commandant David H. Berger’s Force Design 2030 plan. Force Design is now part of the Marine Corps. It is time for all marines on and off active duty to set aside their disagreements and focus forward, towards the vision articulated by current Commandant Eric M. Smith. And it is time for the allies of the Marine Corps to lean in and support this reorientation.
Russians Do Break: Historical and Cultural Context for a Prospective Ukrainian Victory
For major wars like the one being fought between Russia and Ukraine, the military, the people, and the state interact with one another to constitute a collective national will to fight. In most wars, one side loses its will to fight and is forced into an unfavorable negotiating position; it accepts a defeat short of annihilation. Russia can be broken in Ukraine and thereby forced to accept this kind of negotiated defeat.
The Information Warfighter Exercise Wargame
Rulebook FormatFile SizeNotes PDF file 5.9 MB Use Adobe Acrobat Reader version 10 or higher for the best experience. Player's Guide FormatFile SizeNotes PDF file 1.4 MB Use Adobe Acrobat Reader version 10 or higher for the best experience. Game Aids FormatFile SizeNotes zip file 0.5 MB The file(s) provided above are ZIP-formatted archives, which most modern systems can natively unpack.
Russia's Limit of Advance
Key Findings Russia's deployment capability near its western and southwestern borders is significantly better than elsewhere, a product of robust lines of communication, transport infrastructure, and air defense, as well as easier-to-negotiate terrain.
Improving U.S. Disaster Relief at Reduced Risk and Cost
Editor’s Note: The United States and its allies respond to humanitarian disasters frequently, but their actions are often uncoordinated and face many barriers. Security experts Sam Mundy, Mick Mulroy, and Ben Connable detail the most pressing problems facing the United States and offer models and recommendations for how to improve U.S. crisis response.
Give NATO’s Eastern Flank Countries and Ukraine All the M1 Tanks
Editor’s Note: As Ukraine’s offensive makes only limited progress, the United States and other allies of Ukraine are asking what can be done to make success more likely in the future. My Georgetown University colleague Ben Connable argues that the United States should transfer all of its Cold War equipment to allies, not only helping Ukraine today but also making Europe in general far stronger in the future.
National Security
Informal Institute for National Security Thinkers and Practitioners Quotes of the Day: 1. Russian Offensive Campaign Assessment, March 20, 2023 2. 2022 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices 3. U.S. Human-Rights Report Cites Allies and Adversaries 4. Japanese leader arrives in Kyiv as China's Xi visits Russia 5. World on 'thin ice' as UN climate report gives stark warning 6. The doomers are wrong about humanity’s future — and its past 7. Don’t Panic About Taiwan 8.
The End of an Insurgency
Sign in and save to read later Print this article Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Share on LinkedIn Get a link Page url Request Reprint Permissions By the start of next year, the Obama administration will unveil its plan for ending U.S. counterinsurgency operations in Afghanistan.
Kurdistan positioned in prominent role in global gas markets
Economy & Business Energy & Environment Iraq Middle East Kurdistan positioned in prominent role in global gas markets A new report, The Kurdistan Region of Iraq’s Gas-Export Potential: Deja Vu All Over Again, authored by Atlantic Council senior fellow Ahmed Tabaqchali, considers the Kurdistan Region of Iraq’s (KRI) proved and probable gas reserves having the potential to nearly triple production by 2030 and more than sextuple by 2040.
Optimizing and aligning the US-Iraq relationship
Economy & Business Energy & Environment Iraq Middle East Politics & Diplomacy Security & Defense United States and Canada Optimizing and aligning the US-Iraq relationship The relationship between the United States and Iraq remains the Schrödinger’s cat of US foreign relations.
Amman-Baghdad-Cairo (ABC) Agreement: A new path for economic integration
In-Depth Research & Reports Jun 17, 2020 Assessing Saudi Vision 2030: A 2020 review By Stephen Grand, Katherine Wolff Executive summary When global oil prices collapsed in summer 2014, Saudi Arabia confronted one of the most daunting economic challenges of its modern history. Upon ascending to the throne the following year, King Salman bin Abdulaziz Al Saud and his son Mohammed bin Salman Al Saud (now the crown prince) responded by developing an ambitious […]
Russia’s 'Demonstration Army' Is a Red Flag for U.S. Security Force Assistance
Editor’s Note: Russia’s poor military performance in Ukraine came as a surprise to me and to many observers. Ben Connable of the Atlantic Council argues that one important factor explaining Russia’s failures was the lack of realistic military exercises. Too often, the Russian military tried to script its exercises to assure higher-ups that all was well, and as a result it failed to learn to fight effectively when a real war occurred.
Russia’s 'Demonstration Army' Is a Red Flag for U.S. Security Force Assistance
Published by The Lawfare Institute in Cooperation With Editor’s Note: Russia’s poor military performance in Ukraine came as a surprise to me and to many observers. Ben Connable of the Atlantic Council argues that one important factor explaining Russia’s failures was the lack of realistic military exercises. Too often, the Russian military tried to script its exercises to assure higher-ups that all was well, and as a result it failed to learn to fight effectively when a real war occurred.
Ukrainian pensioners present “biological weapon” to fight against Russia
Biological weapons were presented (Photo:Biden's unit/YouTube) Ukrainian retirees, who call themselves the “Biden Division”, after U.S. President Joe Biden, presented a new “biological weapon” that is supposed to help Ukraine’s Armed Forces in their fight against Russia, in asatirical video published on YouTube on June 1. The Russian Defense Ministry had previously released disinformation about so called “biological weapons labs” that exist in Ukraine.
Western weapon already helps Ukrainian troops, but there’s never enough during war
Armed Forces of Ukraine learn how to use the US-made М-777 howitzers (Photo:Valeriy Zaluzhny) The amount of feedback in the public space from our soldiers who have gained experience in using foreign-made heavy artillery is growing. I am glad that a lion’s share of this feedback is extremely positive. Thanks to the skill of our defenders, the Russian occupiers are receiving a rebuff they did not expect.
Swedish Stockholm International Peace Research Institute report outlines risks to human civilization
26 May, 08:26 PM Mariupol in April (Photo:Pavel Klimov / Reuters) The coming decades are going to be increasingly difficult for the human civilization on Earth, the Swedish Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) said in a report published on May 23. While we’re unlikely to go extinct, human societies should adapt to the new realities of a rapidly changing world.
Ukraine War Diary: Everyday life is slowly returning to Fortress Kyiv
More than two months after I hastily departed Kyiv with my family on the first day of the war, I returned to the Ukrainian capital for a few days from my temporary base in Lviv. Travelling in wartime Ukraine is no simple task, even in areas far from the front lines. Due to Russian airstrikes on Ukraine’s major oil refineries and storage facilities, petrol has become a precious commodity. You typically have to wait in line for hours to get just 20 liters.
Ukrainian and Russian Will to Fight: An Early-War Assessment
Editor’s Note: Russia has a large army and clear superiority in firepower, but is experiencing many setbacks in its invasion of Ukraine. Russia's experience is far from unusual: Military success depends on much more than just material factors. Ben Connable of the Atlantic Council, who has worked extensively on armies' wills to fight, evaluates both militaries to explain why, so far at least, the Ukrainian military is exceeding expectations while the Russian military has faced many problems.
Russia can win the war, but lose the occupation | Russian tanks [Editor's note: This story originally was published by Real Clear Defense.] By Ben Connable Real Clear Defense Russia’s inartfully veiled invasion of Ukraine is underway. Within days or hours
February 25, 2022 Constitutional Nobody US News [Editor’s note: This story originally was published by Real Clear Defense.] By Ben Connable Real Clear Defense Russia’s inartfully veiled invasion of Ukraine is underway. Within days or hours—perhaps by the time this article is published—well over 100,000 Russian troops may be smashing their way through Ukraine’s heartland. Much hangs in the balance. One of Europe’s newest democracies may be destroyed.
Building Iraqi Army Will to Fight to Prevent Another Disaster
Editor’s Note: As the United States draws down in the Middle East and seeks to counter Russia and China, it will rely heavily on partner military forces. Too often, however, U.S. efforts to train these forces have achieved little or at times ended in disaster. Ben Connable of the Atlantic Council examines one of the worst such U.S. efforts—the effort to train the Iraqi army since 2003—and describes the primary problem as one of brittleness: The forces simply fall apart when hit hard.
Building Iraqi Army Will to Fight to Prevent Another Disaster
Published by The Lawfare Institute in Cooperation With Editor’s Note: As the United States draws down in the Middle East and seeks to counter Russia and China, it will rely heavily on partner military forces. Too often, however, U.S. efforts to train these forces have achieved little or at times ended in disaster.
Iraqi Army Will to Fight
In summer 2014, less than three years after the United States withdrew its military forces from Iraq, the Iraqi Army imploded, breaking and scattering in the face of attacks from Islamic State fighters. A consensus emerged that the Iraqi Army collapsed because it had no will to fight. But why did the Iraqi Army lack will to fight? And, going forward, what can U.S. advisors do to help strengthen Iraqi Army will to fight and overall combat effectiveness?
Putin Can Take Eastern Ukraine . . . But
Putin Can Take Eastern Ukraine . . . But
Putin Can Take Eastern Ukraine, But He Won’t Like What He Gets
Russia appears poised to invade Ukraine. Probably over 100,000 troops are already crouched in position along the country’s northeastern and southeastern borders, ready to punch into woefully unprepared and undermanned Ukrainian defensive positions.
Will to Fight: Are Americans and Chinese Ready to Die for Taiwan?
We do not understand our own (or China’s) will to fight. A war with China over Taiwan would generate high casualties, destabilize the global economy, and destroy billions of dollars worth of American military equipment. A strategic defeat for the United States in a war with China would be a very real possibility, though Chinese leaders face similar risks. Nonetheless, both the United States and the People’s Republic of China (PRC) are posturing for war.
Are Americans and Chinese Ready to Die for Taiwan?
Are Americans and Chinese Ready to Die for Taiwan?
Afghanistan: What Now, Marine?
Many formerly-serving U.S. Marines have watched the unfolding disaster in Afghanistan with some mix of emotions. I have experienced, and also read and heard from my fellow Marines, a mix of cynicism, disgust, anger, sadness, betrayal, and a sense of injustice. Regardless of their opinions on U.S. policy, many feel a call to act. Some Marines did not hesitate. They jumped right in and organized themselves to save thousands of Afghans from Kabul.
Russia, mercenaries, military | Homeland Security Newswire
The Russia connectionRussian Mercenaries in Great-Power Competition: Strategic Supermen or Weak Link? By Molly Dunigan and Ben Connable Published 5 May 2021 Russia’s worst-kept secret is its increasingly heavy reliance on private security contractors—really, mercenaries—to maintain a Russia-favorable global status quo and to undermine its competitors’ interests. This reliance on mercenaries stems from a known capability gap.
Why Is America Still in Iraq?
Ben Connable & James Dobbins, RAND June 12, 2020 (AP Photo/Ali Abdul Hassan) Tensions between the United States and Iran reached a boiling point in January 2020 when Iranian-backed forces attacked American military and diplomatic facilities on Iraqi soil, and the United States retaliated. As it appeared that the United States and Iran were teetering towards all-out war, policymakers and experts again asked a recurring series of questions: Why are we in Iraq? Why can't we just leave?
Weighing U.S. Troop Withdrawal from Iraq
The authors assess options for military withdrawal in Iraq in 2020 in the context of stated U.S. strategies and policy objectives since 2005.
It's Time to Make a Full and Enduring Commitment to Iraq
The author of this Perspective argues that the United States should make a full and enduring commitment to Iraq by providing robust, long-term assistance to the Iraqi Army. A clear-eyed look at the current situation in Iraq suggests that early 2020 could represent a potential turning point for U.S. policy. U.S. military and diplomatic influence is arguably as strong as it has been since the 2011 withdrawal, but Iraq's urgent need for U.S. military assistance may not endure.
Opinion: Iraq's vote to expel U.S. troops is Iran's true victory
Ben Connable Published 10:37 p.m. ET Jan. 8, 2020 Iran appears to have executed a devastating revenge attack against the United States for the killing of Gen. Qassem Soleimani. Using Iraq's democratic process, Iranian-influenced members of parliament on Sunday voted to expel American soldiers from Iraq. With that, Iran may have effectively won the battle of influence in Iraq.
Commentary: Iraq’s vote to expel U.S. troops is Iran’s true victory
Without firing a shot, Iran appears to have executed a devastating revenge attack against the United States for the killing of Gen. Qassem Suleimani. Using Iraq’s democratic process, Iranian-influenced members of parliament on Sunday voted to expel American soldiers from Iraq. With that, Iran may have effectively won the battle of influence in Iraq. This strategic coup de grace was delivered not by rockets or suicide vests, but by legitimate votes in a democracy built by the United States.
Understanding Russia's Hostile Measures and How to Counter Them
Research Questions What hostile measures has Russia employed historically, and in what circumstances? What motivates Russia's use of hostile measures, and what are the warning signs of their use? How does the history of Soviet power dynamics inform Russia's use of hostile measures in the post-Soviet era? Where have hostile measures been successful in helping Russia achieve its tactical and strategic objectives, and where have they fallen short?
After Soleimani killing, Iraq’s vote to expel U.S. troops is Iran’s true victory | Opinion
Without firing a shot, Iran appears to have executed a devastating revenge attack against the United States for the killing of Gen. Qassem Soleimani. Using Iraq’s democratic process, Iranian-influenced members of parliament on Sunday voted to expel American soldiers from Iraq. With that, Iran may have effectively won the battle of influence in Iraq. This strategic coup de grace was delivered not by rockets or suicide vests, but by legitimate votes in a democracy built by the United States.
After Soleimani killing, Iraq’s vote to expel U.S. troops is Iran’s true victory | Opinion
Iraqi Prime Minister Adel Abdul Mahdi, left, attends a parliamentary session regarding the ouster of U.S. troops in Baghdad. Getty Images Without firing a shot, Iran appears to have executed a devastating revenge attack against the United States for the killing of Gen. Qassem Soleimani. Using Iraq’s democratic process, Iranian-influenced members of parliament on Sunday voted to expel American soldiers from Iraq. With that, Iran may have effectively won the battle of influence in Iraq.
Iraq's vote to expel U.S. troops is Iran's true victory
Without firing a shot, Iran appears to have executed a devastating revenge attack against the United States for the killing of Gen. Qassem Soleimani. Using Iraq’s democratic process, Iranian-influenced members of parliament on Sunday voted to expel American soldiers from Iraq. With that, Iran may have effectively won the battle of influence in Iraq. This strategic coup de grace was delivered not by rockets or suicide vests, but by legitimate votes in a democracy built by the United States.
Iraq's Vote to Expel U.S. Troops Is Iran's True Victory
by Ben Connable Without firing a shot, Iran appears to have executed a devastating revenge attack against the United States for the killing of Gen. Qassem Soleimani. Using Iraq's democratic process, Iranian-influenced members of parliament on Sunday voted to expel American soldiers from Iraq. With that, Iran may have effectively won the battle of influence in Iraq.
Will to Fight and the Fate of Nations
Ben Connable & Michael McNerney, War on the Rocks December 21, 2018 “Distilled to its essence, war is a violent struggle between two (or more) hostile and independent wills, each trying to impose itself on the other.” - S. Joint Publication 1, 2017 “[War] is mostly a matter of wills…Whose will is going to break first? Ours or the enemy's?” - Gen. James N. Mattis, 2006 There is a dangerous misalignment between American theories of war and American military practice.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Ben
Contact Ben, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack