Berger Lee R

Editors Reviewing Editor George Perry Pennsylvania State University, United States of America Senior Editor George Perry Pennsylvania State University, United States of America Reviewer #1 (Public Review): The discovery of Homo naledi fossils and the rising star cave system is unquestionably important for paleoanthropology. The fossils themselves hold a wealth of information about the diversity and complexity of morphological and evolutionary change on the hominin family tree.

Editors Reviewing Editor Yonatan Sahle University of Cape Town, South Africa Senior Editor George Perry Pennsylvania State University, United States of America Reviewer #1 (Public Review): As this experience as a reviewer has been unusual, it may be helpful to outline some relevant parameters of the task at the outset. While I was invited to review the Fuentes et al.

Editors Reviewing Editor Yonatan Sahle University of Cape Town, South Africa Senior Editor George Perry Pennsylvania State University, United States of America Reviewer #1 (Public Review): I think it is important to note up front that I recognize that the goal of this paper was to announce the discovery of what appear to be intentionally-made marks in Rising Star cave in South Africa. This was not meant to be an in-depth analysis or a declaration of definitive results.