The Navy Is In Serious Trouble And the Clown Show in Charge Will Not Improve Things By Bryan McGrath
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Bryan McGrath
Bryan McGrath on Leadership in the Navy, Writing, Retirement, and His 'Own Walden'
Welcome to Solvitur Ambulando, which means “Solve It By Walking.” On this journey, we explore the alchemic potency of walking for sorting through life’s puzzles, exploring our world, and transforming ourselves. Like a good walk, you will encounter distinctive ideas, remarkable people and gorgeous scenery. I hope you will take a beautiful walk today. And if you like what you read and hear, please Welcome to Walks of Life, the podcast companion to Solvitur Ambulando.
The End of This Road
Yesterday, Sunday 30 November 2025, was my last day of work. Ever. The final month of my final two consulting contracts was marked by the issuing of the final two invoices. I am retired, save for some paperwork associated with closing down my LLC. I retired once before--from the Navy (01 May 2008), but because I was considerably younger and clearly not at the end of a working life, it felt very different.
Why We Should Not Be Destroying Suspected Drug Boats in the Caribbean
As I prepared to write this essay, rare moments of intellectual modesty crept into my consciousness, moments that reminded me that I was not an expert in Constitutional law, the Law of Armed Conflict, International Law, the Law of War, or the theories of Just (recourse to) War and the Just (conduct of) War. Some of you may be deeper in one or more of these subjects than I, and it is not my aim to purposely run afoul of that expertise.
The Conservative Wahoo
This site requires JavaScript to run correctly. Please turn on JavaScript or unblock scripts
National Security is Hard
Hoping for Success from the Inexperienced is Not a Sound Strategy
National Security is Hard
The daydream goes something like this. It is early December, 2024, and I am sitting by the fire sipping coffee and reading a history of the hurricane that nearly destroyed Galveston, Texas. Just then, my phone starts a-buzzin’, and I see an unfamiliar DC area-coded number come up. I answer. “Bryan, it’s Paul Ryan”. “Good morning, Mr. Vice President Elect. This is a surprise.” “Thank you for the support in our campaign and for your advice along the way.
The Navy Is Too Damn Small...
I apologize once again to readers coming here for pithy social commentary or saccharine musings on life and death. We’ve got one topic today, and it is our ever-loving U.S. Navy. It all started innocently enough this morning: The next thing I knew, I was sitting here percolating another screed manifesto designed to poke SOME people in the chest and motivate others.
The U.S. Is Not Serious About Aircraft Carriers-Or Their Industrial Base
The U.S. Is Not Serious About Aircraft Carriers—Or Their Industrial Base
The US is not serious about aircraft carriers-or their industrial base
Last October, Hamas terrorists—acting with the sanction of their Iranian puppeteers—murdered over a thousand innocent Israelis (and Americans), taking hundreds captive. This attack was made against the backdrop of Iranian-backed attacks on U.S. forces elsewhere in the theater, attacks that had become routine. In response, the defense secretary ordered the carrier Gerald R. Ford to take station in the eastern Mediterranean as part of measures to deter further regional aggression.
The Mystery of the Vanishing Naval Amphibious Force
Readers seeking glimpses of everyday life and pithy social commentary (which you have become to be used to here at The Conservative Wahoo) will be disappointed in today’s offering, which is once again an example of author prerogative. My professional life is spent in the advocacy of American Seapower, and I occasionally use this platform to advance my thinking on that subject.
We Will Live To Regret It
The clown-car that is our legislative branch federal government continues to serve up healthy heapings of failure, delivering unto the American people exactly what they want (and deserve)—good and hard. That last part—the “deserve” line—is a direct response to those I hear/read saying that the American people deserve better than the government they have. This is of course, merde, as we have EXACTLY what we deserve.
A Healthy Serving of Crow...
The rock I have chosen to push up the hill is that of warning my fellow citizens of the considerable mismatch between the size and capability of our Navy and the things we ask of it. I am considered by some to be an alarmist and by others as lacking strategic acumen, but that is okay, because they don’t know what they are talking about.
SURFACE WARFARE: The Nucleus of American Naval Power
By Bryan McGrath The U.S. Navy is too small for what is asked of it, and what is asked of it is insufficient to meet the nation’s needs. We have too few ships, submarines, aircraft, aircraft carriers, people, sensors, weapons and networks. China’s People’s Liberation Army Navy(PLAN) is growing faster than any navy has since the U.S. buildup to the Second World War, while the U.S. remains committed to efficient peacetime production levels that ignore the reality of this competition.
The Navy’s Moves in the Eastern Mediterranean, Explained
Earlier this week, Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin ordered the USS Gerald R. Ford carrier strike group (CSG) to the Eastern Mediterranean to “strengthen Department of Defense posture in the region to bolster regional deterrence efforts…” in response to the terror attacks on Israel. It wasn’t an uncommon move. Moving aircraft carriers and escort ships to trouble spots around the world has been a preferred response option for U.S. presidents since carrier aviation debuted in World War II.
Less bad does not mean good: Why the budget deal is bad for defense
As the defense community digests the impact of the debt ceiling deal on national security spending, there are differing opinions about whether the agreement should count as a win or a loss for the Pentagon. Last week, former Pentagon comptroller Elaine McCusker argued that the agreement, while imperfect, could have been much worse. In the following response, Bryan McGrath, managing director of The FerryBridge Group, says the reality is much worse than that initial assessment.
What I Believe
Earlier this week, I received notification that I was nominated to serve on the National Commission on the Future of the Navy, a body created in the 2023 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) with the mandate to report (by 1 July 2024) on two broad topics.
Navy Force Structure and Shipbuilding: There is Still Time to Get it Right
The latest Shipbuilding Plan is not quite what it should or needs to be. Why? To answer that question and to give a call to action to help correct it is the irreplaceable Bryan McGrath. Bryan, over to you.
Three Cheers For Larry Hogan
I was met this morning with news of my former governor’s decision not to run for president. This is a good decision, the decision of a grown-ass man who understands consequences. Larry Hogan has been a good Republican governor in a deeply blue state. He stuck to his principles, and he worked with the majority to get things done. He worked hard, his ego was the least noticeable thing about him, and residents of the state irrespective of their party or ideology could be proud of him.
U.S. Marines: America Needs Its 911 Force More Than Ever
https://bonginoreport.com/national-security-global-affairs/u-s-marines-america-needs-its-911-force-more-than-ever The United States has had numerous opportunities since its founding to ponder the existence of its Marine Corps, and there have been several near-death moments. Statute and custom now serve to guarantee the Marines, but necessity has always been the best argument.
U.S. Marines: America Needs Its 911 Force More Than Ever
The United States has had numerous opportunities since its founding to ponder the existence of its Marine Corps, and there have been several near-death moments. Statute and custom now serve to guarantee the Marines, but necessity has always been the best argument.
U.S. Marines: America Needs Its 911 Force More Than Ever
The United States has had numerous opportunities since its founding to ponder the existence of its Marine Corps, and there have been several near-death moments. Statute and custom now serve to guarantee the Marines, but necessity has always been the best argument.
General Irresponsibility
Over the weekend, a leaked memo from the four star Air Force General in command of the Air Mobility Command caused quite a stir. Here is the memo. The memo has elicited a good deal of comment in the echo chambers of social media, and so this addition to that din will likely not create any new understanding or insight. That said, I have some thoughts for Conservative Wahoo readers to chew on. I am content to know that a four star Air Force general thinks this way and is leaning forward in the saddle.
We Are Not Serious About War
Readers who subscribe for light-hearted essays about the world around us will be disappointed in today’s offering, but I urge you (them) to read on anyway. My professional life is devoted to the naval strength of the United States, and I occasionally use this space to advance ideas in that pursuit. Also—I am releasing this piece earlier than I intended because the good folks at the Center for Strategic and International Studies put out a big report today (1/23) that my essay reinforces.
This NDAA Is Crucial To The Navy
Author’s Note: Every now and then I use this platform to air my views on important Navy matters. Although I try and use other more targeted sites for this kind of work, I waited too long to get to this piece, and if it is going to have any impact, it needed to get online inside of a lot of other site’s editorial turnaround time (I’m starting this less than twelve hours before I will post it). I would be grateful to interested readers who forward this along as you are able.
Could the U.S. Navy Buy 5 Columbia-Class SSBN Submarines at Once?
19FortyFive reached out to two world-class experts: What’s better than purchasing one submarine at a time? How about buying five at once? That’s what the U.S. Navy wants to do with the Columbia-class ballistic missile submarine that aims to replace the older Ohio-class submarine. Navy brass believes that if Congress approves of the “block buy” the order could save billions of dollars rather than ordering one sub at a time, which is the traditional acquisition practice.
Zumwalt-Class Can Become a Dominant 21st Century Destroyer
Yes, the Zumwalt-class can be rebooted: Months after the terror attacks of September 2001, the Navy announced a new three-vessel “Family of Ships” reflecting a post-Cold War sense of blue-water dominance. Those ships—the Littoral Combat Ship (LCS), the 21st-century destroyer (DD21, now the DDG 1000), and the 21st-century cruiser (CG(X))—emphasized operations in the littorals and in support of land campaigns, in addition to high-end Integrated Air and Missile Defense (IAMD).
Carrier Air Power is Essential to Distributed Maritime Operations
The Navy talks a good deal about how the fleet will fight in the future, and the current top-level description is a concept known as “Distributed Maritime Operations” (DMO). The concept exists only in classified form, and the Navy has not issued an authoritative unclassified summary. From various news reports, it seems clear that geographic distribution of forces, longer range and more energetic weapons, persistent sensors, and operational deception are all key enablers of the concept.
The Mission of the Navy
Share History Section 8062(a) of USC Title 10 describes the composition and functions (often colloquially referred to as the “mission”) of the U.S. Navy thusly: The important parts of this mission statement are “…primarily for prompt and sustained combat incident to operations at sea…” and “…responsible for the preparation of naval forces necessary for the effective prosecution of war…” The law of the land says the Navy is for “war” and for “combat”, and to anyone who has thought deeply about...
Ending Production of This Warship Is a Mistake
Observers have rightly criticized the recent release of the “Report to Congress on the Annual Long-Range Plan for Construction of Naval Vessels for Fiscal Year 2023” (“annual” of late more honored in the breach than the observance) for its insufficiency and inconsistency with the requirements of great power competition.
On the Sinking of the Moskva
The Russian Navy ship MOSKVA listing to port, soon to sink. Some readers know I spent a few years in the U.S. Navy. During that time (21 years), I was a Surface Warfare Officer, which means I spent my operational time in ships (as opposed to submarines or flying). My final sea tour (2004-6) was as Commanding Officer of the USS BULKELEY (DDG 84), two incomparable years for which I will always be grateful to this country.
War in Our Time
(AP Photo/Efrem Lukatsky) What we all knew was coming, what was developing before our very eyes, has come. Russia has invaded Ukraine and appears to be making its way methodically toward whatever objective it wishes. There are reports of gallant resistance, at least one of which turns out to be true, although I pretty much restrict my information on this war to well-established media organizations in order to sift out some of the disinformation.
The Problems of Politics and Posture Are Baked into the System
The competition for resources within the Department of Defense seems to be at a historic high. Nowhere is that competition more apparent than in the tension between the priorities and desires of the armed services and those of the combatant commanders.
What Is The Navy For?
I apologize in advance to everyone receiving this in their inboxes who are used to more light-hearted political and social commentary. My day job is in the national security field, and an article has appeared that elicits a timely response. Having this platform at my disposal, I have chosen to put it here. If you are uninterested in naval strategy and concepts, please carry on with your busy life.
Never Trump Does Not Mean Always Democrat
Share I take a backseat to no one in anti-Trump credentials. I recognized him as a threat to national security and political stability from the get-go, I got a few of my friends together to declare this loudly, and I have lost friends because of my choices.
China Doesn't Care How Woke We Are
Share The Rise of Woke National Security Over the last week, one of the truly tectonic shifts in the American national security scene has emerged to take its place atop Biden Administration slow-to-develop concept of grand strategy and our role in the world. No, it isn’t nuclear strategy, nor is it relations with key allies, or the re-emergence of great power contention. No, it is the rise of National Security Wokeness, and anyone who didn’t see this coming hasn’t been paying attention.
Space Bros
Share Space Bros As these words are written, Amazon Founder and tight-shirt-titan Jeff Bezos is preparing for the launch of his sixty-foot Blue Origin rocket, a short, sub-orbital flight in which he, his brother, a wealthy teenager, and a truly deserving octogenarian will partake. This follows close on the heels of fellow billionaire Richard Branson’s recent flight in his Virgin Galactic spaceplane.
Briefing Books or Word Salads?
On Briefing Books Much ado has been made about President Biden’s news conference last week, with predictable reactions coming from the various teams. One criticism worth delving into a bit was the thunder on the right about Biden’s use of a briefing book for the event. I rise in support of the briefing book. I get it.
American Suckers
Share American Suckers News broke Monday evening that Sidney Powell, the former President’s lawyer, then not lawyer, then lawyer again, had responded to a billion dollar defamation suit by the company who made the voting machines that she, said corrupt ex-President, and myriad other lawyers representing him, claimed were part of a looney world-wide conspiracy to deny the true and righteous of his electoral destiny.
Musings from the Goose Blind
I got a late start this morning (Wednesday 13 Jan) and so the sun was already well above the horizon when I got to my blind. The gents upriver greeted the sun with a thunderous volley, sending a considerable number of birds my way. But as I was late, walking, and unloaded, they passed noisily overhead—unmolested.
Trump's Naval Plan Came Too Late. That's Too Bad.
President Trump speaks to workers during a visit to a shipyard on June 25, 2020 in Marinette, Wisconsin. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images.) In a recent op-ed in the Wall Street Journal, National Security Adviser Robert C. O’Brien and Russ Vought, director of the Office of Management and Budget, laid out a plan to dramatically increase the size of the Navy.
To Infinity and Beyond: Battle Force 2045
October 29, 2020 Bryan McGrath rejoins the Net Assessment team to discuss the U.S. Navy’s Battle Force 2045 proposal. Bryan, Melanie, Chris, and Zack agree that the proposed 500 ship force is a fantasy that will not be fully funded. But they express optimism that these plans will provide useful starting points for deeper thinking about the Navy’s future force.
Unconstrained Grand Strategy
How grand is grand strategy? Frank Hoffman, a friend and WOTR contributing editor, wrote an article titled “Grand Strategy: The Fundamental Considerations,” available behind the paywall at Orbis, the journal of the Foreign Policy Research Institute. Like all of Hoffman’s work, it is well written, sensible, and meticulously sourced. Should you have the means, I urge you to read it.
Implications of the Bonhomme Richard Catastrophe
As I write this, the USS Bonhomme Richard — a Wasp-class amphibious assault ship — burns at Pier 2, Naval Station San Diego. Scores of Navy and civilian firefighters have fought the blaze for over 72 hours and it is difficult to tell from afar how much progress is being made. One thing is clear: The ship will likely be, at best, out of action for years or, at worst, stricken from Navy rolls.
More Than Just a Fire: The Implications of the Bonhomme Richard Catastrophe
As I write this, the USS Bonhomme Richard — a Wasp-class amphibious assault ship — burns at Pier 2, Naval Station San Diego. Scores of Navy and civilian firefighters have fought the blaze for over 72 hours and it is difficult to tell from afar how much progress is being made. One thing is clear: The ship will likely be, at best, out of action for years or, at worst, stricken from Navy rolls.
Center for American Seapower
Hudson’s Center for American Seapower aims to promote public dialogue on ebbing U.S. maritime power where today there is no such dialogue. The Center will offer intellectual arguments and detailed policy recommendations for a robust U.S. Navy and Marine Corps, and a more effective U.S. Coast Guard as well as shipbuilding industrial base. The U.S. is by geography, commerce, security, and tradition a maritime nation.
Congress and the Navy: Forty Years of Dysfunction
Paul E. Pedisich, Congress Buys a Navy: Politics, Economics, and the Rise of American Naval Power, 1881-1921 (Naval Institute Press, 2016) How large should the fleet be? What capabilities should the prevailing fleet architecture reflect? What is the Navy’s role in national defense? To what extent should parochial, political concerns stand in the way of national objectives?
For a Larger Fleet: An Open Letter to the President
A larger fleet will not build itself - especially a reach through the headwinds of the next decade to 355. To do so will not just take words, it will take vision, leadership, and substantial investment. Nothing will happen without strong consistent Presidential leadership, supporting senior personnel, and emphasis that this is a priority. How to get there? Regular guest Bryan McGrath has offered us the opportunity to post an open letter to President Trump on that exact topic. Bryan, over to you.
We Know How China Plans To Use Its Aircraft Carriers In A Conflict
Key Point: China understands that in a maritime conflict with virtually any nation but the United States, its carriers would be would be a powerful combat advantage. China’s recent release of its first strategic white paper signals its official emergence as a maritime—and therefore global—power.
Calculated Risk: This Is How China Will Use Its Aircraft Carriers Against America
Key Point: China understands that its carrier force would be a pivotal and influential capability, essential to its quest for regional dominance. China’s recent release of its first strategic white paper signals its official emergence as a maritime—and therefore global—power. Little in the document should surprise those who have monitored China’s rise, though it remains to be seen whether China watchers will discern nuance and inscrutability instead of taking Beijing at its word.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Bryan
Contact Bryan, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack