Behavioral Theory of the Firm, organizational change, adaptation, little ideas "The Robust Beauty of “Little Ideas”: The Past and Future of “A Behavioral Theory of the Firm", Journal of Management Inquiry, 2015 Maslach, David; Liu, Chengwei; Madsen, Peter; and Desai, Vinit, "The Robust Beauty of “Little Ideas”: The Past and Future of A Behavioral Theory of the Firm" (2015). Faculty Publications. 9839.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by David Maslach
The Noisy Truth About Success Signals
We like to believe success has clear signals. Good grades. The right school. A glowing letter of recommendation. We cling to these signals because they feel objective, measurable, safe. They give us something to hold onto in a world that feels uncertain. But here’s the uncomfortable truth: most of these signals are noisy. ⸻ The Illusion of Objectivity Grades? They often reflect coaching, resources, or sheer luck.
Why Conflict and Politics Happen in Research
From the outside, research looks simple. Smart people, big problems, endless curiosity. Surely, collaboration should be natural. But if you’ve spent any time inside academia, you know the truth is messier. Projects collapse. Universities fracture. Divisions split apart. Not because the science failed. But because the people involved couldn’t imagine a future together. The Hidden Cost of Uncertainty Research is always uncertain. That’s what makes it exciting. But it’s also what makes it fragile.
Everyone Thinks Professors Are Rich.
When people hear "professor," they picture wealth, stability, and prestige. The reality? Most of us spent our 20s and 30s living like broke students. I did. I carried debt through most of my PhD. Those years shaped how I see academic life. They made me realize: this system is not designed to help people thrive. It quietly eats away at the very people who could change the world.
Your PhD won't feel like "discovery." It will feel like invisibility.
You won't be celebrated for your ideas. Ridicule is the price of doing any meaningful. Many of your ideas will be invisible for decades. Mendel's pea plants were ignored for 35 years. Einstein's theory of gravitational waves wasn't proven for 100 years. Semmelweis told doctors to wash their hands - and was ridiculed until after his death. In management? James March's work on organizational learning sat on the margins for 30 years before becoming foundational. He was old by the time anyone cared.
You Can't Work Harder Forever
Why Boundaries Are the Real Courage in Academia Academic life quietly teaches you one lesson above all else: you can always work harder. Just one more paper. Just one more all-nighter. Just one more weekend. The voice is relentless. And for a while, you believe it. But here's the truth: you can't. There are limits. No matter how angry or insistent that inner voice becomes, physics eventually wins. The Myth of "Weakness" I used to believe burnout was about weakness. That breaks were indulgences.
What Is a Nearly Non-Rejectable Research Paper or Grant?
Most researchers know the feeling: you pour months - or years - into a project. You polish it, you submit it, you wait. Then, without clear explanation, it gets rejected. It's crushing. And it's common. But what if rejection wasn't inevitable? What if we could design a system that made research papers and grants nearly non-rejectable? Notice: not guaranteed acceptance. That's impossible. Science requires disagreement.
Why Boredom Is the Secret Weapon in Research
Most people think boredom is the enemy of good work. They think if they're bored, they're stuck. But in research? In a PhD? In building anything that matters? Boredom isn't a problem. It's the process. ⸻ The Wall Everyone Hits Every serious researcher eventually hits the same wall: * Days where you don't want to do it. * Days where you feel hopeless. * Days where nothing seems to move forward. These aren't signs you're failing. They're signs you're doing it right.
The Most Joyful Researchers Play With Ideas That Don't "Count"
Newton wasn't at a desk when the apple fell. Darwin wasn't in a lab when the Galápagos shook his imagination. Archimedes didn't have a grant when he stepped into the bathtub. Sir Sandford Fleming found inspiration in moldy bread. Most of us? We get our best sparks while walking the dog. ⸻ The Tyranny of What "Counts" Academia trains you to measure everything: * Citations. * Collaborations. * Journal hits. * CV lines. We're told those are the things that matter.
To the Researchers Who Dare to Be Different
In the world of research, it's easy to get caught up in outcomes - the publications, the results, the accolades. Because deep down, we all want " success." But here's the truth nobody likes to say out loud: Nobody is going to care anyway. Your failed experiments? Forgotten. Your "big" publications? Skimmed. Your talks? Attended by a handful, remembered by fewer. And yet the system keeps pushing you toward the same trap: conforming to market expectations and chasing measurable success.
Why the Best Advice in Academia Is Always Whispered
Why is it that the most important advice in academia is never written down? It's whispered. Behind closed doors. Shared only if you find someone seasoned enough - and honest enough - to tell you the truth. Here's one of those whispered truths: Most of your research won't be read. Most of your talks will be ignored. Most of your podcasts will have an audience of one. Nobody tells you this in your PhD.
The Illusion of Wealth (And What Business Professors Actually Know About Money)
Most people assume business professors are wealthy. We're not. At least, not nearly as wealthy as you think. The mistake we make? The same one you do. We buy into the same illusion everyone else does - that wealth comes from shortcuts, "hot" investments, or entrepreneurial gambles. But it doesn't. Real wealth comes from boring discipline. ⸻ The Boring Math of Wealth Wealth isn't built by winning the lottery of ideas.
Why Most Research Isn't Read (And What You Can Do About It)
Here's a quiet truth in academia: Most research isn't cited because it isn't read. That's the uncomfortable reality. Most papers sit unread, unnoticed, invisible. Citations are supposed to measure impact. But in practice, they're often just a proxy for visibility. Who's in the right network. Who's connected to the right mentors. Who's publishing work that "fits" the story the system already wants to tell. It's not that your research isn't good. It's that nobody sees it.
Would You Still Do Your Research If Nobody Ever Knew Your Name?
This is the question I wish more academics asked themselves. Because so much of academia today is about status. About celebrity academics. About building a CV polished enough to get the next job. The currency isn't always truth. Or insight. Or discovery. It's prestige. And yet - the most successful researchers I know don't seem to care about any of that. ⸻ The Quiet Ones The researchers who last, and the ones whose work endures, are rarely the loudest voices in the room. They don't chase prestige.
The Best Advice I Wish Someone Gave Me Before My PhD
When I started my PhD, I thought the key to success was taking everything seriously. Every seminar. Every presentation. Every single word I wrote. I thought it all had to impress someone. I was 25. The only one in my family to ever go to college. I wanted to prove I belonged. So I put on the armor of "seriousness." And it almost broke me. ⸻ Nobody Cares as Much as You Think Here's the advice I wish someone had given me: Don't take yourself too seriously. It sounds simple.
Behind Every PhD Success Story Are Years the System Calls "Failure"
When people look at a professor or a "successful" researcher, they see the polished version. The title. The publications. The job offer. What they don't see are the years when the system calls you a failure. This is my story. ⸻ The Job Market That Didn't Care I was the PhD student who had an unsuccessful job search - twice. In 2009 and again in 2010, I applied to 70 universities each year. Silence. Rejection. Nothing. By 2011, I told myself: If I don't get a job by December 31, I'm done. I'll quit.
The Quiet Power of Caring in Academia
I had a friend who once tried to give back unused grant money. The university and the granting agency laughed. They said they’d never seen that before. I once saw a coordinator send out an email they clearly didn’t want to send. They spent half the message apologizing. It wasn’t polished. It wasn’t professional. But in that moment, I felt seen. Because it reminded me there are still people in this profession who care. In academia — and in many workplaces — caring is often treated like a weakness.
The Hardest Part of Research Isn’t the Science
PhDs know this, but you don’t. Most people think the hardest part of research is the methods, the data, or the writing. The hardest part of research is standing up and saying, out loud, what you care about. Why Most People Never Begin The moment you share your idea, the critics arrive: Sometimes it’s your advisor. Sometimes it’s a funding agency. Sometimes it’s even your own family. And the truth is — it’s terrifying. That’s why most people quit before they begin.
The Real Reason Academics Burn Out (It’s Not Teaching or Writing)
When people outside academia hear “professor burnout,” they assume it comes from teaching heavy course loads, grading late into the night, or struggling to publish papers. But after two decades inside the system, I can tell you: that’s not the real cause. The deepest burnout doesn’t come from teaching or writing. It comes from pretending. Every academic learns the unwritten rules of the profession: the “script of smart.” • Pretend you have read papers you only skimmed.
Why Professors Feel Guilty Every Time They Rest
Yesterday I spent the whole day with my kids — homework, guiding, just being with them. Tomorrow, I step back into the classroom for the first time in four months. And this afternoon? I’m grocery shopping. Prepping dinners. Making sure my family has what it needs for the week. All of it matters. Supporting my wife matters. (She is more successful than me.) Making sure my kids do well matters. Because I’m not in my office.
My Goal: Reach 100 Million Lives by Age 50. Are You One of Them?
By the time I turn 50, I want to have reached 100 million people. Not just “views.” Not vanity metrics. I mean 100 million people who see failure differently. 100 million people who know research, discovery, and innovation are supposed to be hard. 100 million people who learn to disbelieve the Instagram highlight reels and the glossy success stories universities keep selling. When I first started my career, I believed the lies most of us are told: • That success is quick if you’re smart.
17 Motives Why People Get a PhD (Only One Will Last)
After two decades in academia, I’ve seen the truth no glossy brochure or university recruitment campaign will ever admit: Most people don’t get a PhD because they love research. They get it for other reasons — motives that are real, human, and often valid, but also fleeting. Here are the 16 most common motives I’ve seen up close: 8. To get a visa or stay in a country 12. To teach (but not research) 16. To move up in their career And then there’s the rarest motive of all: 17.
Why Most PhDs Don’t Fail (And What Really Breaks Them)
Most PhDs don’t fail because they give up too soon. They fail because they believe the lie that progress should be faster. We live in a culture obsessed with speed. And so, when progress drags, when the experiment stalls, when the draft sits untouched for weeks — you start to believe you’re falling behind. You start to believe you’re the problem. You are not a loser if you’ve tried 10,000 times and it feels like nothing has moved. That’s not a sign of failure — that’s the process.
I Thought My PhD Was Worthless. (But My Family Will Build Real Wealth From Its Hidden Value.)
When I first finished my PhD, I felt discouraged for years. The rejections. The low pay. The constant uncertainty. It was all a mistake. To be brutally honest — I thought my PhD was worthless. And I carried that belief for a long time. But here’s the mistake I made back then: I thought the value of a PhD was measured only in the short-term. In titles. In paychecks. In how “impressive” it looked to others. The truth? The real value of a PhD reveals itself slowly — sometimes decades later.
Why So Many PhDs Regret Their Career Path (But Stay Silent)
Most PhDs will never say this out loud: they regret the career path they chose. Not because they weren’t smart enough. Not because they didn’t work hard enough. But because the system is designed in a way that makes them feel like they can never win. We were told the story: publish, get grants, move up the ladder, prove your worth. But the reality is different. The standards shift the closer you get. The benchmarks are impossible. The comparisons never end. It’s like being in a toxic relationship.
The Real Reason PhDs Stay in Research
(Here’s my story — it’s not what you think) People assume researchers stay in this career because of curiosity. Because we “love knowledge.” Because we’re “passionate about regression models.” Because we want to “cure cancer” or “change the world.” I wish I could say that was true for me. But it’s not. The real reason I stayed is far more human — and far less glamorous. When I first started, I thought the point of all of this was to prove my intelligence. To prove I was worth something. That’s it.
The LinkedIn Bio Game: Truth Edition
Here’s a challenge for you. Scroll LinkedIn for the next hour and count how many times you spot a version of these bios: Truth: Sent 3 emails, joined late to the project Truth: Posts quotes on Canva Truth: One-weekend exec course Truth: Did one Zoom in Dubai Truth: Only contestant in category Truth: Likes to post on Quora Truth: Renamed existing product Truth: Hired one competent person Truth: Made a bar chart in Excel Truth: Sole founder, barely getting by (this is me with R3ciprocity)
Why I No Longer Believe in “Economic Logic” for Life and Work
The longer I’ve been a parent, scholar, and human being, the less I believe in the neat, clean “economic logic” I once thought made the world work. Those tidy models — pick only the “best” people, copy best practices, dial up the traits that matter — work beautifully on paper. But they fall apart when you’re dealing with real people. It looks less like maximizing widgets and more like: • Kindergarten teaching — patiently guiding someone who’s just learning to walk in your world.
Stop Telling Early‑Career Researchers to “Work Harder”
Most PhDs don’t need to work harder. They need to think deeper. You can burn out reading 50 papers in a week and still miss the point. You can publish three rushed studies in a year and have no one care. There’s a difference between publishing a paper in a top journal and publishing a paper people remember. “Work harder” is easy advice. It sounds tough. It sounds fair. It keeps the machine running.
The Day I Realized I’d Outgrown My Academic Heroes
Whose talks I would scribble down phrases I thought might someday matter. Whose articles felt like a different currency — precious, out of reach, proof that they were playing in a league I could barely imagine entering. I thought they had the answers. For years, I tried to mimic their footsteps. I copied the way they spoke at conferences — the cadence, the confidence, the perfectly timed pause before the key point.
Stop Chasing the Thrill of Discovery - It’s a Trap
If you’re in a PhD program or building a startup, you’ve probably been seduced by the same thing that gets all of us at the beginning: The moment when you finally see the pattern no one else sees. The moment you get the big idea in the shower and think: “This is it. I’ve cracked it.” We think it’s what the work will be about. Because the hard part — the real work — isn’t the moment of insight. It’s the long, exhausting, uncertain path after it.
The Smartest Person in the Room Might Be the One Who’s Quiet
I just got back from a 14,000-person academic conference. And for the first time in many years … I felt calm. It was filled with brilliance — researchers, thinkers, people who shaped entire fields. And deep down, I caught myself thinking: But after two decades in academia, I have realized something younger-me wouldn’t have understood: The best response to all of this might be quiet defiance. Taylor Swift was onto something.
The Biggest Red Flag in Research: “You Just Need to Publish More”
But underneath that advice is a dangerous assumption: That productivity in research is mostly about effort. That doing more, faster, equals success. And that’s just not true. It ignores the reality that research productivity often has little to do with individual work ethic. It ignores how networks carry some people forward — while others quietly do the heavy lifting. • And those navigating it alone How some labs write paper after paper by splitting labor across ten hands.
Top 10 Roles Where a PhD Could Actively Hurt You
Why academic prestige might work against you — and what to do about it. Early in my career, a recruiter once told me to remove my PhD from my resume. Not because it didn’t matter. But because it might hurt my chances. I was stunned. I’d spent years earning this degree. Didn’t it signal intelligence? Commitment? Expertise? Apparently not. At least, not everywhere. The hard truth? In many parts of the job market, a PhD doesn’t help you — it works against you.
They Think I’m a Loser. But I’m Quietly Changing the Research World.
I know I’m a world-class researcher. I know the work I do is careful, meaningful — stuff that will matter in 30 years, not just next quarter. And I know I’m building something real with the R3ciprocity Project. Something that helps people feel like they finally belong in the world of research. Something that says: You’re already good enough. Even if the system never tells you that. But most people don’t see any of that. And honestly? That used to hurt. I spent years trying to get a job after my PhD.
Most People Will Never Know What It Took to Write That Paper
But you do. And that’s what matters. They’ll see your name in the journal. Maybe skim the abstract. Maybe cite it once. But they won’t see what came before. They won’t see the five rejections from five different journals. The reviewer who asked you to rewrite everything — again. The three rounds of revisions at each journal. The part where you rewrote the paper so many times, you forgot what the original idea even was. They won’t see the months (or years) you questioned your career.
Doing a PhD Is a Real Job
Stop discounting it. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard it: “That’s not a real job.” “You’re not in the real world.” “When are you going to get a real job?” Sometimes it came from strangers. But the hardest times? It came from people close to me. I remember explaining what I do — The research. The writing. The long days sitting with ideas no one asked me to build. And the response was always some version of: “Must be nice to just sit all day.” What they didn’t see were the 14-hour days.
Successful Teams Ignore ROI
What really kills collaboration isn’t logic. It’s emotional withdrawal. Teams don’t fail because of bad strategy. They fail when someone starts rationalizing their effort. • “I’ve already put in too much time.” • “This isn’t going anywhere.” • “There’s no ROI.” • “I’m not feeling it anymore.” If you’ve ever heard those words — you already know: It’s over. That’s the “time to bail” moment. Because once someone emotionally checks out and starts using financial logic to justify it?
Asks a Researcher: “So what do you even do all summer?”
I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve heard that — from relatives, friends, even neighbors. They think being a professor means a few lectures, long breaks, and a summer off to watch the kids. I teach 4 courses a year. That is 6 hours a week, for 30 weeks. This is a heavy course load for a researcher. I promise. What they don’t see is the revise-and-resubmit that takes 4 months- reading 1000s of pages and weeks analyzing data. The “why the heck is this not working?!” The deadlines to respond to.
Most People Don’t Want to Learn. But You Do.
Let’s be honest. Most people don’t actually want to learn. They want credentials. They want prestige. They want a shortcut that gets them ahead — without the discomfort of actually changing. Education? For many, it’s a means to an end. A hoop to jump through. A box to check. And if you show up wanting more — if you ask questions, stretch yourself, try to build something meaningful — you’re the weird one. People will laugh.
Why Do Overachievers Get So Weird About Money?
It’s not just about income. It’s about identity, fear, and who we think we’re allowed to be. I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about why high achievers — people who seem to “have it together” — get so weird about money. Some freeze up whenever the topic comes up. Others get intense. Hyper-controlling. And then there’s everyone in between — fidgeting their way through dinner bills and silently comparing salaries in their heads. Half the people I know won’t talk about money at all. It’s too awkward.
My Immigrant Dad Never Said ‘I Love You.’ He Just Worked. And That Taught Me Everything.
(The Real Reason I Still Keep Going Even When It Feels Pointless) Real work. The kind that doesn’t show up on social media. The kind that doesn’t get recognized, that feels invisible — until it doesn’t. I come from a family of immigrants. My dad’s family moved from Poland in the 1930s and ended up in the far north of Canada. They were homesteaders — settling into this cold, isolated place that couldn’t have been more different from what they left behind. They didn’t speak the language.
10 Key Things You’ll Give Up if You Innovate in Academia.
(And why people will think you’re wasting your time.) No — this isn’t a gripe about my institution. I study innovation. These stories are far too common. This is what happens everywhere. I have heard some of the most famous professors say this and those that are currently doing it. This happens for large and small projects. Prestige Signaling Most people will assume you’re not “serious.” Because you’re not chasing A-level journals, grants, or traditional tenure-track acolades.
The Case for Investing in Underdogs
Most people assume that those who are more successful must have done something right and, thus, deserve our attention and reward, if not our learning and imitation. For example, firms that happened to have an initial success are more likely to attract talented employees, can more easily attract consumer attention to their products, and can access opportunities and capital that others can only dream of.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with David
Contact David, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack