Sharing is caring! This recipe for peanut butter cookies is the perfect combination of soft in the middle and crispy on the outside. To me that is the perfect peanut butter cookie. I don’t like a super thin cookie, and I don’t like it so chewy that my jaw starts to hurt. 🙂 Plus these cookies are delicious! The recipe makes about 4 dozen cookies. I like to roll the dough and press with a fork, and then freeze. That way I can pull out a dough and make a pan whenever I need to.