Since at least the early twentieth century, universities have flirted with America’s penchant for “running things like a business.” But like government, non-profits, and other non-businesses that try to be something they are not, universities’ scattershot copycatting of business practices creates new harms to the institutions and the people within them.
Articles by George Perry
Domains and Dossiers Are the New Weapons of Cancelation Digital vigilantes are going to new lengths to ensure immediate impact and permanent harm.
Few people take their cues from Letitia James or Kathy Hochul. A fair bit more people take theirs from Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. But whether we admit it or not, we all take our cues from the Feed. It might not tell you what to think, but it tells you what to think about and provides a strong first impression to get you started. And then when people want to know more, they go to Google or ChatGPT.
Domains and Dossiers Are the New Weapons of Cancelation Digital vigilantes are going to new lengths to ensure immediate impact and permanent harm.
Few people take their cues from Letitia James or Kathy Hochul. A fair bit more people take theirs from Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. But whether we admit it or not, we all take our cues from the Feed. It might not tell you what to think, but it tells you what to think about and provides a strong first impression to get you started. And then when people want to know more, they go to Google or ChatGPT.
NYT Legal Loss Underscores SCOTUS’s Need To Fix Defamation Doctrine
All winning streaks must come to an end. The New York Times brought an over 50-year win streak of defending defamation suits into a federal courtroom in Alabama. The underdog plaintiff was former University of Alabama basketball player Kai Spears. The Times published an article in 2023 that incorrectly said Spears was in a car with a teammate at the scene of a fatal shooting. Spears sued for libel over these “untrue statements linking him to a criminal event,” and prevailed on Thursday.
Why Justices Thomas and Gorsuch Want to Revisit New York Times v. Sullivan The Supreme Court’s ‘actual malice’ standard for defamation faces renewed scrutiny as two justices argue it has outlived its constitutional and practical foundations.
Justice Clarence Thomas has a few items remaining on his originalist to-do list. Moving up the list with each passing term is revisiting New York Times v. Sullivan and, presumably, purging the “actual malice” standard the Court conjured in 1964. Justice Gorsuch is up for the challenge, but they need to convince two more of their colleagues to hear a case. At the end of the most recent term, Gorsuch joined Thomas’ dissent to the Court’s denial of certiorari in Dershowitz v. CNN.
For Some Social Watchdogs, Success is not an Option
Some scammers run pyramid schemes. The DoJ’s indictment against the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) outlines a circular scheme: use donor money to fuel hate groups and then leverage the hate groups to solicit donors for more money. This is not uncommon among advocacy-oriented nonprofits. Success is their biggest threat. If the organization slays their dragons -- racism, poverty, homophobia, environmental destruction, drug abuse and addiction -- they face an existential decision.
The “World” of College Sports — The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal
International student-athletes account for about 13 percent of NCAA Division I participants and about seven percent of Division II. Yet, despite their small numbers, international student-athletes may be bellwethers for the consequences of professionalizing American collegiate sports. Many of the student-athletes in question know where that road leads: It’s the system they rejected when they decided to study and compete at an American university.
Gymnasts’ Lawsuits Show That Safeguarding Protocols Are No Substitute for Justice – The American Spectator | USA News and Politics
Two gymnasts are suing USA Gymnastics, the U.S. Center for SafeSport, their former training facility, and the facility’s owners after their former coach was indicted on multiple counts of child pornography. The gymnasts allege that USA Gymnastics and the Center received complaints about Sean Gardner’s sexualized behavior towards minor athletes as early as 2017.
The Coming “Spot-Fixing” Threat — The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal
Match-fixing is difficult and expensive, even in an individual sport. The enticement—or threat—needs to be so great that the athlete will cast aside everything he’s ever known and believed about himself and about sport in order to do the one thing he has dedicated his life to avoiding: losing. Spot-fixing is much easier, logistically and financially, for the criminal behind the scheme and easier for an athlete to justify.
Prepare For State Court Battles Over Men In Women’s Sports Original
With the federal route closed under the Trump administration, transgender males seeking admission to women’s sports are turning to state courts. There, fuzzy and sometimes absurd definitions in state and local policies might still force sports organizations to deny the reality of male advantage and surrender competitive fairness and safety for female athletes.
Maintain the Separation Between Sport and State – The American Spectator | USA News and Politics
Americans have traditionally been quite good about keeping our sense of what’s “national” distinct from the state. Until recently, the people who represent us in Washington were far removed from the people who represent us culturally. That change has been to our detriment culturally and politically. Americans should hold the line by keeping political control away from sports — even the national teams. The United States is an outlier for not having a secretary or minister of sport.
Fast-tracking Misgivings About Sports Betting
Sportsbooks in the United States could not have dreamt a better launch window than the easy-money-and-isolation era of the COVID lockdowns. Sports gambling is now another of the many social and political overhauls of those years that is getting the "Maybe these consequences were, in fact, foreseeable" treatment. The Supreme Court's ruling in Murphy v. NCAA overturned the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA) in 2018.
Call Her Lawyer: Costs of Cancelation Rising for the Accusers
Alex Cooper’s podcast, “Call Her Daddy,” finished 2024 in second place between “The Joe Rogan Experience” and “The Huberman Lab” in Spotify’s annual rankings. At the Tribeca Film Festival in June, Cooper premiered an autobiographical documentary, in which she accused her college soccer coach of sexual harassment between 2013 and 2015. The stakes of such an accusation are higher for Cooper than they would have been even just a year ago.
Cooper's Accusations Show Shift In College Coach Cancelations Original
College coach cancelations have shifted from Title IX courts to other avenues: universities commissioning law firms to perform “independent” investigations, Congress chartering the U.S. Center for SafeSport, and direct-to-media accusations, ranging from student newspapers to the host of Spotify’s #2 podcast. Podcaster Alex Cooper accused her college soccer coach of persistent sexual harassment in a Hulu documentary, “Call Her Alex,” that premiered earlier this month.
British Sports Scoop the NCAA in Protecting Female Athletes
Sports organizations on both sides of the Atlantic seem to have adapted an apocryphal Winston Churchill quote into their modus operandi: only after exhausting all other options will they do the right thing and protect women’s sports. The clock started ticking for British sports on April 16, when the United Kingdom Supreme Court ruled that “man,” “woman,” and “sex” — as used in the Equality Act of 2010 — refer to biological sex.
Should the NCAA’s Transgender Records Stand? — The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal
Rule changes in sports have the potential to rewrite the record books. Usually, a change in how the game is played—to improve player safety or to speed up the action on the field—shifts the incentives for certain actions, resulting in unprecedented numbers of those moves. But when the rule changes are at the level of policy and affect who plays the game, the consequences not only rewrite the record books going forward but may require a revision of the sport’s history books.
The Limits of Delegation to the Private Sector
A recurring theme — or trope — around President Donald Trump’s second term is the administration’s putative goal to outsource governmental functions to the private sector. In light of oral arguments in FCC v. Consumers’ Research last month, it’s worth looking at a bill that Trump signed into law during his first term, delegating government powers to a private entity.
Center Shows Dangers Of Delegating Power To Private Entities
Sen. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, is raising the pressure on the U.S. Center for SafeSport, the nonprofit organization that Congress empowered in 2018 to protect youth athletes from sexual abuse in sport. Yet he is limited in what he can do, because the center was authorized by Congress to set and enforce its own rules without any government review.
Congress's Sex Abuse Enforcement Body Nailed For Fraud
Congress chartered the U.S. Center for SafeSport in 2018 in response to the sexual abuse scandal of Larry Nassar and USA Gymnastics, with its original mission to protect youth athletes from sexual abuse in sports environments.
Defending Reputation From Defamation-by-Blacklist
Most people don’t know they are on a government watchlist until they find that they cannot do something mundane like board a plane, purchase a firearm, or access their bank account. For most people, discovering this is dismaying and disconcerting — and, if other people learn about it, potentially defamatory. The government’s easy propensity to place people on watchlists traces to the 1975 Supreme Court case of Paul v. Davis. Davis is a companion case to New York Times v. Sullivan.
Snowflake or strategy: Rethinking coaches and athletes in modern sport
“Would you describe me as soft?” Even though the person was asking me through a screen from a few thousand miles away, I froze, then started shifting in my seat. That conversation, like my first with him, had already gone deep into topics of mental health and emotional openness. But Tom Short still has that aura — through the screen, over the distance — of someone you wouldn’t want to cross in a gym or outside a pub.
Niche Sports Should Leave Colleges — The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal
The May 2024 settlement in House v. NCAA was the most recent significant step towards an employee model for collegiate athletes. Reactions to the settlement varied widely across sports and stakeholders. One feature that is particularly worrying within smaller sports is the settlement’s elimination of scholarship limits and establishment of roster limits. If the House settlement is adopted, schools will have complete discretion over how they allocate and award athletic scholarships.
New LPGA Policy Lets Men Compete As Women If They Look Girly
While Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson compared sex mutilation surgeries for minors to racial segregation and Justice Sonia Sotomayor mused about girls who “don’t want … breasts” last week, some women’s sports advocates applauded the Ladies Professional Golf Association’s new “gender eligibility” policy. Even a golf clap is more than the LPGA deserves, as the new policy is riddled with bogeys.
New York Narcissism
A review of Ghost Chilli by Nikkitha Bakshani, 288 pages, Fleet (July 2024) In Ghost Chilli, the debut novel by London-based American writer Nikkitha Bakshani, progressive systems of belief compete for primacy in the disorganised personality of protagonist Muskan, an anxious psychobabbler and hyper-race-conscious Indian expat working for foodie magazines in New York.
Podcast #247: Should Imane Khelif Be Allowed to Box Against Women?
Introduction [00:00] Jonathan Kay: Welcome to the Quillette podcast. I’m your host, Jonathan Kay, a senior editor at Quillette. Quillette is where free thought lives. We are an independent, grassroots platform for heterodox ideas and fearless commentary. If you’d like to support the podcast, you can do so by going to Quillette.com and becoming a paid subscriber. This subscription will also give you access to all our articles and early access to Quillette social events.
Killing for a Quiet Life
Though I’m a happily terrorised fan of John Krasinski’s dystopian films, A Quiet Place (2018) and A Quiet Place, Part II (2020), a question has been stalking me since their premieres. In these first two films, giant, human-gobbling praying mantises fall to earth and begin annihilating humankind. They cannot see, so they navigate and hunt by sound, their acute hearing provoking them to attack even the faintest sound. But why are they doing this? This remains a maddening mystery. Hunger? Malice? Revenge?
The Chauvinist/Gender Theorist Alliance
When International Olympic Committee (IOC) president Thomas Bach declared that his organisation can’t define a woman, it wasn’t a huge surprise to those who have followed this issue closely. But more casual observers will probably need an explanation. At the heart of that explanation is a peculiar alliance between academic advocates of gender theory and old-fashioned male chauvinists in sports governance. But how has this alliance come about?
Scaling the Heights of Physics: James D. Bjorken 1934–2024
James Bjorken—or Bj, as his friends and fellow physicists knew him—was probably not known to many people outside the particle physics community. But his impact on that field may have been as great as that of the recently deceased Peter Higgs. Like Higgs, only more successfully, Bjorken shied away from the limelight, didn’t care about honours, and preferred to simply do the work, rather than talk about it.
For Competitive US Runners, a ‘Non-Binary’ Identity Has Become a Lucrative Asset
While modern Olympic Games feature many well-paid professional athletes—especially in such popular spectator sports as basketball and soccer—their presence is something of a modern innovation. The International Olympic Committee originally idealised their events as competitions among non-professionals whose love of sport was unsullied by commercial motivations.
The Pillory, the Stock, and Cancel Culture
Getting fired is only the end of the beginning for victims of cancelation. It’s the transition from the “acute” to the “chronic” stage, as a canceled colleague describes it. Life in the chronic stage may sound familiar: triggers and flashbacks, depression, drug and alcohol abuse, unexplained physical pain, prolonged unemployment, social withdrawal, self-exclusion — and, frequently, suicidality.
The Cancel-Your-College-Coach Playbook — The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal
Corporate media owes a lot of its ideological conformity and hubris to journalism schools. Media critics and advocates for reform suggest that journalism needs to return to being a trade that one learns on the ground—through apprenticeships, beat reporting, and small-market outlets—rather than a profession where an advanced degree from the right institution is a cheat code to a high level of influence and access.
Scientists Refute Olympics' Misguided 'Gender Identity' Policies
The International Olympic Committee (IOC) developed its 2021 framework on sex and “gender” around the concepts of fairness, inclusion, and non-discrimination.
Lia Thomas' Suit Is The Latest Lawfare Against Women's Sports
Sports governing bodies keep trying to have a female category without committing to the objective, sex-based definition of a female. Each successive attempt to delineate a female category without defining female athletes shows the way for activists and mediocre male athletes to self-identify their way into competing against females in nearly every sport and level, from collegiate swimming to adult recreational soccer, from high school volleyball to pro rugby, disc golf, and boxing.
Why We (Sadly) Need To Prove the Obvious About Sex in Sports
I helped bring some holiday cheer to the Internet with the research paper I co-authored demonstrating that sex differences in sports performance persist regardless of gender self-identification. “Obvious” was probably the most used word in tweets and headlines related to our study, closely followed by “duh” on X. With the festive mirth behind us, it’s time for a serious look at the why and so what of our work.
USA Cycling Attempts to Justify Men Racing Against Women
No matter how sincere the efforts to make sports “inclusive,” every inclusion initiative ends with the reality that sports exclude. USA Cycling wanted to “prioritize the balance between fairness and inclusion” when developing its latest Transgender Participation Policy. Its solution was not so much a balance but a Solomonic division that gave a bit more fairness to some and pushed more inclusion on others. Competition is necessarily an exclusionary process.
How Pro Athletes Are Rewriting The Anti-Cancellation Playbook
The Los Angeles Dodgers didn’t know what they didn’t know when they cut major-league pitcher Trevor Bauer from their roster in January 2023. The Dodgers started the process of exiling Bauer 18 months earlier, three days after the Pasadena Police Department confirmed they were investigating a sexual assault accusation against him.
Gender Ideology in Sports Harms Men, Too
Sports' acquiescence to gender ideology pits men against men, when it's not pitting men against women. No, men are not being knocked off podiums or national teams because of transgender athletes. We don't and won't have our own Riley Gaines. But separate categories and prize money for non-binary athletes, like the New York Road Runners and Boston Athletics Association offer, undermine men who fit a certain profile.
UK Criminalizing Speech Through Culture, Media, and Sport
Anyone surprised by the letter Rumble CEO Chris Pavlovski received from the United Kingdom’s Chair of the Culture, Media, and Sport Committee needs to watch more soccer. Several days after The Times and Channel 4 revealed the rape and sexual assault allegations against Russell Brand, Dame Caroline Dinenage wrote to Pavlovski of her “[concern] that [Brand] may be able to profit from his content on the platform.
The Non-Binary Athletic Category Hurts Female Athletes
“Woman competes in women’s sports” should be a dog-bites-man story. Instead, it’s become a game of who’s burying what lede. American runner Nikki Hiltz and Canada’s mononymic soccer player Quinn should have been feted for winning the USA Track & Field Outdoor National Championship in the 1500 meters a few weeks before setting an American record in the mile (Hiltz) and playing all but 13 minutes of Canada’s World Cup run while closing on 100 senior national team appearances (Quinn).
Navigating day 1 in a new job: Advice from 3 experts
Season openers, first day of the play-offs, opening ceremonies, first day of preseason… sports give us plenty of Day 1s to organize our lives around, whether we’re coming at them as fans or practitioners. These are on the calendar well in advance, and if you somehow miss the memo you’re not going to miss the marketing campaign nor the “did ya see?” texts from colleagues, athletes and maybe their parents.
Are coaches being influenced or informed by researchers?
Even high-performance athletes have low-performance influences. Family members, agents, school coaches, friends, “this guy that started showing me a few things at the gym, he said he’s a trainer” – some well-meaning, some overbearing, many or most truly clueless. And then there’s the other way they answer our patience-at-the-breaking-point “What made you think that was a good idea?” “Saw it on Insta.” Now turn it 180.
Choosing the work over the job: S&C coaches finding more opportunity outside of pro sport
Sports performance practitioners often refer to themselves as “the team behind the team.” With a growing number of strength & conditioning coaches working privately with professional athletes, performance specialists are becoming each athlete’s “team away from the team.” Pick up any strength & conditioning text book and open it to the first page. What does it say is the most important thing, the most fundamental principle of S&C? Individuality or specificity.
Understanding the Unidentified
Email sent! Check your inbox to complete your signup. An advantage of having worked in the skeptical business for 30 years is institutional memory that enables me to place current claims and controversies into historical context.
Candace Owens Is Dangerously Misinformed about Vaccines
Email sent! Check your inbox to complete your signup.
Chelsea player ratings at the Women’s World Cup: Norway, Lionesses on top
Use your ← → (arrows) to browse NICE, FRANCE – JUNE 09: Erin Cuthbert of Scotland is challenged by Fran Kirby of England during the 2019 FIFA Women’s World Cup France group D match between England and Scotland at Stade de Nice on June 09, 2019 in Nice, France. (Photo by Marc Atkins/Getty Images) Chelsea’s stand-out player of the Women’s World Cup has yet to wear Blue. Guro Reiten was one of the revelations of the tournament and leads our player ratings.
Chelsea player ratings: Fran Kirby’s brilliance stands out in defeat
Magdalena Eriksson and Jonna Andersson will bring third-place medals back to Chelsea later this summer. The Blues’ Lionesses put in better individual performances in the Women’s World Cup third-place game, but Sweden had a better team showing. About half of Chelsea FC Women’s contingent in the Women’s World Cup were in the third-place game – even more when you include the two ex-Blues in Sweden’s starting XI. And we do include them in our player ratings.
Chelsea can square accounts by selling Kalas and Dasilva to Bristol City
BRISTOL, ENGLAND - APRIL 19: Jay Dasilva of Bristol City shoots while under pressure from Chris Gunter of Reading during the Sky Bet Championship match between Bristol City and Reading at Ashton Gate on April 19, 2019 in Bristol, England. (Photo by Dan Mullan/Getty Images) Tomas Kalas and Jay Dasilva continued their time in the loan army as regulars in Bristol City’s squad last season. Chelsea can settle several accounts by letting the pair become permanent Robins this summer.
Chelsea vs. Napoli: Maurizio Sarri relying more than ever on subs’ late goals
Chelsea are getting more goals from their substitutes this season than Maurizio Sarri did in any of his years at Napoli. His teams often leave it late, but these Blues more than ever. Chelsea hired Maurizio Sarri – and fans quickly threw their support behind him – because of the wide-open, fluid, pass-and-attack nature of his trademark tactics.
Chelsea preparing final tranche of loans as deadline day approaches
With all the competing rumour mongers proclaiming their anonymous sources’ insights, a club’s official website is a decidedly unsexy place to go for hints about loans and transfers. Before things become official on the home page, the team pages can offer insight into what at least one actual insider – that is, someone who works within Stamford Bridge, if not privy to these conversations – thinks is about to happen to Chelsea’s fringe players.
Chelsea and Anthony Martial can rescue each other’s hopes with a transfer
MANCHESTER, ENGLAND - FEBRUARY 25: Eden Hazard of Chelsea is helped up by Anthony Martial of Manchester United during the Premier League match between Manchester United and Chelsea at Old Trafford on February 25, 2018 in Manchester, England. (Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images) Anthony Martial has something Jose Mourinho disdains and the modern Premier League demands: speed.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with George
Contact George, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack