Some studies show the expression of proteins such as caspase-3 (pictured), in cell lines that should not be able to produce them. Credit: Dr Mark J. Winter/Science Photo Library A scientific sleuth has identified more than 220 research papers that describe impossible patterns of protein expression in genetically altered cell lines. In these studies, particular proteins show up in imaging experiments, even though the cells do not have the gene necessary to make them.
Holly Else
Verified
Science and technology journalist. Contact me securely: hollyelse-at-protonmail-dot-com
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Holly Else
Preprint-centric publishing approach gets major boost
The Open Research Europe platform offers 2.5 million researchers full editorial services on the platform at no charge.Credit: Michael Szebor/Nature Science funders and research organizations in Europe are joining forces to expand open-access publishing and make the peer-review process more transparent, with the aim of spurring change in scholarly communication.
Misconduct case dropped against AI expert after claims of AI use in recent book
Sweden’s national committee on research misconduct has dismissed a case against an expert in the social ramifications of artificial intelligence following allegations her recent book contained hallucinated references and other signs of AI use.
Sleuth identifies dozens of studies that used the wrong antibody
NEWS 21 August 2026 The case is the latest example of a scientific workhorse being misused in experiments. More than 50 studies on cell ageing have apparently used the wrong antibody to identify a key protein in experiments, according to a science sleuth.
Three rising stars of nanoscience and nanotechnology
Working at the nanoscale lets researchers tap into unusual physical behaviours and material properties that can underpin more powerful and efficient technologies and systems. But studying and manipulating materials at this scale presents many challenges. Nanomaterials can be extremely delicate, for instance, and often need specialized methods to process and integrate them into devices.
How Europe hopes to lure foreign researchers with massive new grants
The European Union’s push to attract foreign scientific talent took a step forward today, with applications opening for a new supergrant aimed at “outstanding researchers” from around the world. Part of the EU’s Choose Europe for Science initiative launched last year, the 7-year, €7 million grants will be the largest ever provided by the European Research Council (ERC), which funds basic, curiosity-driven research.
Can one parent silence the other’s genes? Natural ‘paramutations’ found in mice
Parents often fight about how to raise their children, but a mouse study suggests an even more basic form of parental conflict starts soon after conception when the chromosomes from each side come together. The new research, published yesterday in Nature Genetics, indicates genes from one parent can sometimes unexpectedly silence those inherited from the other, and that the effect could persist for generations.
Does the PSA test for prostate cancer save lives? New data reverse gold-standard findings
Prostate cancer (cells, artificially coloured) affected 1.5 million people worldwide in 2022.Credit: Dr Gopal Murti/Science Photo Library Does prostate-cancer screening with the common ‘PSA’ blood test save lives? The Cochrane, an influential group renowned for its gold-standard medical reviews, has previously addressed that question twice, and twice the answer was ‘no.’ Now, data from nearly 800,000 people has prompted a U-turn.
After outcry, European funder reverses abrupt rule change restricting resubmissions
Europe’s top research funder has dropped a controversial new policy designed to stem a flood in applications, following an outcry from the bloc’s scientists. The plans would have required unsuccessful applicants for European Research Council (ERC) grants to wait an additional year before reapplying. But many researchers decried the changes as unfair, with some scientists left in the lurch after working for months on proposals that they could no longer submit.
Abrupt change to European funder’s rules leaves researchers shut out
Biochemist María Luisa Romero Romero was in shock when she heard the news. “Even now, it still feels unreal,” she says of recent rule changes at Europe’s biggest research funder that have left her and many other researchers abruptly prevented from submitting grant proposals. “I was already well advanced in preparing the application,” says Romero Romero, who works at the Institute for Advanced Chemistry of Catalonia.
Research assessment: a round-up for early-career researchers
Steve Goodman had just completed a three-page referee’s letter for an academic colleague who was going for promotion in a law department, when he received a bundle of papers that surprised him. The package contained the recommendation letters of other referees. “They were eight to ten pages long,” he says, adding that he had never seen letters like these before.
Early grant success attracts more funding: study of 100,000 applicants hints at why
Perseverance is key when it comes to securing science funding, found an analysis of more than 100,000 grant applicants that looked at how early success affects future prospects. The research shows how the Matthew effect — a phenomenon describing how those with an early advantage or success tend to accumulate more over time — could be driving inequity in academia. Previous work has suggested that those who win funding early in their career are more successful later down the line.
Web of Science delists bioengineering journal in wake of paper mill cleanup
Bioengineered has lost its spot in Clarivate’s Web of Science index, as of its April update. The journal has been working to overcome a flood of paper mill activity, but sleuths have questioned why hundreds of papers with potentially manipulated images have still not been retracted. A spokesperson for Taylor & Francis, which publishes the journal, said it has taken action against the paper mill; the journal has retracted 86 papers since January 2022.
Star ecologist ‘blurred boundaries’ in lab - but colleagues criticize investigation
A university investigation into Thomas Crowther, a prominent tree researcher who ran a large laboratory at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich (ETH Zurich), reveals that he blurred personal and professional relationships in his lab and breached internal rules on financial and hiring compliance. But it clears him of misusing grant funds.
Publishers trial paying peer reviewers - what did they find?
A spate of research findings offer fresh evidence in the debate about whether peer reviewers should be paid for their time and expertise — a fraught topic that has provoked discussion among researchers. This month, two journals released data from their own experiments that suggest that offering payments of around US$250 to researchers who review manuscripts speeds up the process, without affecting the quality of reviews.
Does sharing first authorship on a paper carry a penalty? What the research says
Who gets to be first? The question of whether a paper should have more than one first author can lead to fraught negotiations. And the discussions can be just as thorny when deciding which of two first authors is named in the very first slot. But new results might help to take the edge off such discussions.
Royal Society will meet amid campaign to revoke Elon Musk’s fellowship
The Royal Society in London has called a meeting to discuss the behaviour of fellows following a growing campaign by scientists over the membership of Elon Musk. The 3 March meeting comes after more than 1,300 scientists signed an open letter expressing “deep concerns” about the conduct of billionaire Musk, who is a foreign member.
Top universities warned against unfair research partnerships on their doorstep
‘Helicopter research’ doesn’t happen just when researchers from rich countries swoop in and exploit the resources of low-income ones — rich universities are increasingly taking advantage of poorer institutions in the same country, and often in the same neighbourhood. Marylin Fraser, the head of the Arthur Ashe Institute for Urban Health, a non-profit organization in New York City that focuses on community health and education, has experienced this at first hand.
Star ecologist accused of misconduct loses university post
Prominent ecologist Thomas Crowther, whose research on trees has influenced figures including US President Donald Trump, will depart the prestigious Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich (ETH Zurich) after the institution said that it would not renew his contract. ETH Zurich says it has received “reports of alleged misconduct on a variety of levels” and has lost trust in the assistant professor. Crowther and ETH Zurich declined to comment on the allegations.
Pioneering CERN scheme will pay publishers more if they hit open-science targets
Leaders at CERN, Europe’s particle-physics laboratory in Geneva, Switzerland, will introduce financial incentives for academic publishers to adopt open science policies as part of the organization’s collective agreement with 11 particle-physics journals. Open-access reformers launch next bold publishing plan The current scheme sees those journals publish work from the field openly and at no cost to authors, in exchange for bulk payments.
How a biochemistry department used redacted job applications to achieve gender parity
In 2017, when Sherri Christian returned to her institution after a year-long sabbatical, she looked around the biochemistry department and realized that she was the last female hire, seven years earlier. At the time, there were 19 members, just 6 of them women, including her. Access the most recent journalism from Nature's award-winning team Explore the latest features & opinion covering groundbreaking research or
‘Doing good science is hard’: retraction of high-profile reproducibility study prompts soul-searching
The retraction of a high-profile paper1 that tested ways to improve the soundness of scientific studies has highlighted the challenges of such ‘reproducibility’ research. The retracted paper’s authors include some of the titans in the field. In the study, published in Nature Human Behaviour last November, the authors described a rigorous research protocol involving features such as large sample sizes, with the goal of ensuring the soundness of psychological experiments.
Gender bias might be working at level of whole disciplines
Inequity between men and women in research funding and researcher performance evaluation has been firmly established as a problem in science policy for many years. But an emerging body of research is documenting a new piece of the puzzle, which some think has been hiding in plain sight: that whole research fields might be prone to gender bias.
Budding scientists inherit career success-or the lack of it-from their mentors
Scientists working in a lab may not be sequined socialites attending gin-soaked jazz parties in the 1920s, but according to a new study, they have something in common: They’re more likely to prosper if those who’ve come before are already successful.
As U.K. election nears, major parties reveal their science policies
The United Kingdom’s Labour Party, the likely winner of national elections set for 4 July, has unveiled ambitious science-related plans. It promises to develop decadelong science spending plans, cut net carbon emissions from electricity production to zero by the end of the decade, and reduce the use of animals in some kinds of research if, as many observers predict, it prevails.
As U.K. election nears, major parties reveal their science policies
The United Kingdom’s Labour Party, the likely winner of national elections set for 4 July, has unveiled ambitious science-related plans. It promises to develop decadelong science spending plans, cut net carbon emissions from electricity production to zero by the end of the decade, and reduce the use of animals in some kinds of research if, as many observers predict, it prevails.
What should research funders ask for in grant applications?
Love them or loathe them, grant applications are a way of life for academics—and working out which ones make the cut is far from an exact science. As some funders are experimenting with reforming grant application processes to make them fairer and less onerous for both applicants and reviewers, new research suggests the detailed research proposal document may be one area ripe for change.
Opinion | Science | AAAS
14 Jun 2024 Vol. 384No. 6701
Open access is working - but researchers in lower-income countries enjoy fewer benefits
Open-access publishing can help to drive the flow of academic papers to and from researchers, especially those in resource-poor settings. But for scientists in low-income countries, power imbalances and a lack of visibility are making it harder for them to take full advantage of this access.
Fired chief of Irish science funder in legal battle to keep his job
The dismissed head of one of Ireland’s major funders of scientific research has taken the organization to court in a bid to keep his job. Science Foundation Ireland (SFI) fired physiologist Philip Nolan in late May, after an investigation found he had engaged in inappropriate behavior toward staff at a level “just below bullying,” according to reports in the Irish press. But Nolan, who denies any wrongdoing, launched a legal case against SFI.
Biomedical paper retractions have quadrupled in 20 years - why?
The retraction rate for European biomedical-science papers increased fourfold between 2000 and 2021, a study of thousands of retractions has found. Two-thirds of these papers were withdrawn for reasons relating to research misconduct, such as data and image manipulation or authorship fraud. These factors accounted for an increasing proportion of retractions over the roughly 20-year period, the analysis suggests.
Biomedical paper retractions have quadrupled in 20 years - why?
The retraction rate for European biomedical-science papers increased fourfold between 2000 and 2021, a study of thousands of retractions has found. Two-thirds of these papers were withdrawn for reasons relating to research misconduct, such as data and image manipulation or authorship fraud. These factors accounted for an increasing proportion of retractions over the roughly 20-year period, the analysis suggests.
A study of C-section scars - in women who hadn’t undergone the surgery
A study purportedly of scars left by caesarean sections included women yet to undergo the surgery, say sleuths. But an investigation into the research by the author’s employer and the journal that published it found no evidence of research misconduct.
Nobel-winning neuroscientist faces scrutiny for data discrepancies in more than a dozen papers
Several research articles co-authored by Nobel Prize–winning neuroscientist Thomas Südhof are under scrutiny after online commentators raised concerns about data duplication, discrepancies in images, and other issues. Over the past year, journals have corrected five of the papers flagged on the postpublication peer-review site PubPeer and retracted another. Science has learned that journals are preparing corrections for at least three further articles.
Should researchers use AI to write papers? Group aims for community-driven standards
When and how should text-generating artificial intelligence (AI) programs such as ChatGPT help write research papers? In the coming months, 4000 researchers from a variety of disciplines and countries will weigh in on guidelines that could be adopted widely across academic publishing, which has been grappling with chatbots and other AI issues for the past year and a half.
African academy embarks on ‘aggressive’ fundraising plan
AAS hopes to re-establish policy leadership role after period of governance turmoil The African Academy of Sciences has launched a five-year plan to restore its position as a major science policy player on the continent. The plan comes after a governance crisis rocked the body in recent years, resulting in a loss of funding. This article on Research Professional News is only available to Research Professional or Pivot-RP users.
Science integrity sleuths welcome legal aid fund for whistleblowers
A Silicon Valley investor has pledged $1 million to help pay the legal costs of scientists being sued for flagging fraudulent research. Yun-Fang Juan, an engineer and data scientist by background, hopes the new Scientific Integrity Fund—the first of its kind—will make speaking up about wrongdoing less intimidating. The fund comes after a spate of cases in which high-profile scientists have retracted papers after whistleblowers made allegations of research fraud.
Multimillion-dollar trade in paper authorships alarms publishers Original
Research-integrity sleuths have uncovered hundreds of online advertisements that offer the chance to buy authorship on research papers to be published in reputable journals. Publishers are investigating the claims, and have retracted dozens of articles over suspicions that people have paid to be named as authors, despite not participating in the research. Integrity specialists warn that the problem is growing, and say that other retractions are likely to follow.
Research Summaries Written by AI Fool Scientists
An artificial-intelligence (AI) chatbot can write such convincing fake research-paper abstracts that scientists are often unable to spot them, according to a preprint posted on the bioRxiv server in late December1. Researchers are divided over the implications for science. “I am very worried,” says Sandra Wachter, who studies technology and regulation at the University of Oxford, UK, and was not involved in the research.
Alzheimer’s drug saga prompts journal to scrutinize whistle-blowers Original
A scientific journal has revamped its whistle-blower policy amid a dispute over the integrity of research underlying an experimental Alzheimer’s drug. In a 1 November 2022 editorial in The Journal of Clinical Investigation (JCI), editor-in-chief Elizabeth McNally wrote that whistle-blowers had raised concerns last year about potentially doctored images in a cache of research papers published by multiple journals, including JCI.
Abstracts written by ChatGPT fool scientists
An artificial-intelligence (AI) chatbot can write such convincing fake research-paper abstracts that scientists are often unable to spot them, according to a preprint posted on the bioRxiv server in late December1. Researchers are divided over the implications for science. “I am very worried,” says Sandra Wachter, who studies technology and regulation at the University of Oxford, UK, and was not involved in the research.
Abstracts written by ChatGPT fool scientists
Save citation to file Format: Add to My Bibliography Your saved search Name of saved search: Search terms: Frequency: Which day? Which day? Report format: Send at most: Send even when there aren't any new results Optional text in email: Create a file for external citation management software
Paper-mill detector put to the test in push to stamp out fake science
We use cookies to make sure that our website works properly, as well as some ‘optional’ cookies to personalise content and advertising, provide social media features and analyse how people use our site. By accepting some or all optional cookies you give consent to the processing of your personal data, including transfer to third parties, some in countries outside of the European Economic Area that do not offer the same data protection standards as the country where you live.
Science spared from UK budget cuts amid economic turmoil
The UK finance minister, Jeremy Hunt, has said that the economic crisis will not harm ambitious plans for research spending, much to the relief of researchers. Universities and scientists were concerned that the government might use funds promised for science to plug the multibillion-pound black hole in the country’s finances caused by budgeting decisions of the previous prime minister, Liz Truss.
eLife won’t reject papers once they are under review - what researchers think
The non-profit open-access journal eLife has introduced a raft of changes to the way it publishes research. It will publish all papers that it sends for peer review, along with the reviewers’ reports. The move, announced last month, has had a mixed reception. Lessons learned from open peer review: a publisher’s perspective “This is a significant development for publishing as a whole,” says Bianca Kramer, an open-science analyst at Sesame Open Science, a consultancy based in the Netherlands.
Dozens of papers co-authored by Nobel laureate raise concerns
Several research articles co-authored by Nobel-prizewinning geneticist Gregg Semenza are being investigated by publishers after internet sleuths raised concerns about the integrity of images in the papers. Journals have already retracted, corrected or expressed concerns about 17 papers over the past decade, and others are investigating image- and data-integrity issues in further studies.
Surprise! The UK is spending way more on research than it thought
The UK government has unexpectedly met its research and development (R&D) spending target — an achievement revealed by changes in how industrial investment is calculated. The adjustments were announced on 29 September in a briefing note from the UK Office for National Statistics (ONS), a non-ministerial government body.
Science’s no-fee public-access policy will take effect in 2023
The publisher of the prestigious journal Science will soon allow the authors of its research papers to make public an almost-final version of their manuscript in a repository of their choice immediately on publication, without paying any fees. This approach differs from that taken by the publishers of similarly high-impact journals Cell and Nature, which charge most authors fees called article-processing charges (APCs) to make the final, published versions of their articles open access.
UK government appoints science minister after three-month vacancy
The UK government has finally announced the name of its next science minister. Nusrat Ghani, a member of parliament in the southeast of England, will fill the role, which had been vacant for the past three months. The delay in appointing a minister to oversee research and innovation has unsettled many UK scientists, who fear that new Prime Minister Liz Truss does not see science as a priority.
‘Papermill alarm’ software flags potentially fake papers
A software tool that analyses the titles and abstracts of scientific papers and detects text similar to that found in bogus articles is gaining interest from publishers. The tool, called the Papermill Alarm, was developed by Adam Day, who is director of scholarly data-services company Clear Skies in London.
Show More
loading
Actions
Get in touch with Holly
Contact Holly, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack