From An Inquiry Into the Human Mind, by Thomas Reid. It's worth rephrasing and elaborating a bit on this last paragraph: Imagine that it was essentially a coin flip to decide whether anyone speaking to you was telling the truth or not. Imagine, for example, turning on the news in the morning and finding yourself truly skeptical about 50% of what was reported (and of course you don't know which 50%).
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by J Fisher
Intellectual Self-Reliance
More from Epistemic Authority: The idea that one should treat other persons as less trustworthy than oneself occurs repeatedly in modern philosophy, although often without argument. In the practical domain it is reflected in the common aphorism that if you want something done right, do it yourself. The epistemic version of that view is that if you want to make sure your question is answered correctly, find out the answer yourself.
Taking Others at Their Word
Unless testimony is a good source of knowledge—unless it's a legit way to come to beliefs about stuff—none of us knows hardly anything. I mean, really, how much am I going to be able to work out, purely for myself via perception and reasoning, about how science works, about the past, about places and distant parts of the world, about the experiences of other people? We rely on testimony for vast swathes of our beliefs, and this seems increasingly true.
Corroboration
Ibid. Sometimes, however, what others tell us is important as corroboration of what we have already found out (or think we have found out) for ourselves. The Scottish philosopher Thomas Reid makes this point in connection with mathematical research in the belief that, if it applies to the science 'in which, of all sciences, authority is acknowledged to have least weight', it will be even more significant in other areas of thought and practice.
Testimony
Again from Testimony: A Philosophical Study. It's important to understand, when reading the quote below, that this book was first published in 1992 (before internet for the masses). It's also important to understand that the existence of the internet doesn't change the idea below at all. We must confront the suggestion that the neglect of testimony is warranted by the fact that it really plays an insignificant, or not very significant, role in the formation of reasonable belief.
Knowledge From Others
From Testimony: A Philosophical Study, where we start to see how the study of knowledge derived from others, or testimony, has been dismissed and ignored going all the way back to Plato: Socrates uses the example of proceedings in a law case and points out that a jury may be convinced of certain facts about a robbery merely by the persuasive and rhetorical skills of a lawyer and yet they can hardly be said to know these facts even though their beliefs are true.
School Is Very Much the Real World
From Teach Fast: Focused Adaptable Structured Teaching. The most frequently observed reason lessons were not successful was that the teacher attempted to teach too much. How is success judged? By a very simple metric. More than 90% of students should be able to successfully complete independent practice. . . . The reality is that all students, in fact, all human beings, have limitations with respect to the amount of new content which they can attend to and retain during a defined learning episode.
Better Living Through Imitation
Again from Volume 2 of Perspectives on Imitation: From Neuroscience to Social Science. These quotes are from an article in that volume by Ap Dijksterhuis, titled "Why We Are Social Animals: The High Road to Imitation as Social Glue." Recently, Lakin and Chartrand (2003) showed that when people have the goal to affiliate, they imitate more. It is important to note that the degree of imitation was not the result of a strategic, conscious choice.
Love Survives the Truth
From Susan Hurley and Nick Cater's introduction in The imitative mind: Development, evolution, and brain bases: There are two reasons why being defensive about imitation strikes me as bizarre. First, it seems to me that anyone who is even barely aware of intellectual history should be unsurprised by the finding that humans are thoroughly imitative creatures.
The Predisposition to Imitate
From "The role of imitation in body ownership and mental growth," by Marcel Kinsbourne, in The imitative mind: Development, evolution, and brain bases. In certain extreme situations, normal people act in ways that are more often used by people with neuropathology. What is anticipated in the imagination becomes overt when, in an impending traffic emergency, the front-seat passenger performs a vigorous braking movement.
From Imitation to Language
A final set of quotes from The Instruction of Imagination (highly recommended!): Imitation, particularly sophisticated human imitation, does not come up enough in this theory, I think. If you were individual B in the example above, would A have to say anything or even make a sound (i.e., would you need language) in order for you to figure out that he was pointing at prey or a predator and to react accordingly? Probably not.
The Subject
Again from The Instruction of Imagination: Functionalists claim that the syntactic notion of subject can and should be defined in terms of its communicative function—as the topic of the sentence, what the sentence is about, and as its most prominent argument. Generativists contend that this is sometimes true, but not always, and it is definitely not true when the subject seems to have no semantic significance (when it is expletive).
In Your Own Words
Ibid. We saw traces of the Hirschean argument earlier in the same theory. That is, competence in the social-semantic space—knowledge of and facility with socially constructed and shared ideas, such as language in the first place—sets the stage for communicative, and thus academic, success. Now here we see the other side of the educational coin: understanding, not memorization; ownership over learning; and personal relevance are what make learning succeed.
Explain Your Reasoning
So, last time we looked at how language is generated and understood, from the private-experiential to the social-linguistic symbolic space and back. A question that naturally arises from this is whether the social space—where ideas are mutually identified, digitized, organized, and mapped relative to each other semantically—has an effect on the private-experiential. The social-semantic space is like a floating blackboard on which we mutually locate, organize, and connect communal ideas.
From the Private to the Social
I'll see if I can summarize what we have looked at thus far in The Instruction of Imagination: Language is not a general-purpose communication technology. It is a communication technology socially constructed to do a specific job: it "allows speakers to intentionally and systematically instruct their interlocutors in the process of imagining the intended experience—instead of directly experiencing it.
Closing the Gap
Again from The Instruction of Imagination: Every speaker of language, every one of us, walks around with two mismatched worldviews—private-experiential and social-linguistic—and the mismatches themselves are variable. Not only is there an external experiential gap between us as individuals; there is also an internal gap within ourselves, between ourselves as experiential creatures and ourselves as language users. This foundational fact . . .
The Ability to Tell
Ibid (bold emphases mine). Language began to develop the moment it was born, and it still does. But when the Rubicon was crossed, when interlocutors began to systematically construct bridges (always fragile and tentative) over the experiential gaps between them, a new era began in human life. The instruction of imagination changed everything.
Private, Experiential Worlds
Again from The Instruction of Imagination: Consistent with our modernist turn a century ago, we do not often talk about "private, experiential worlds" as obstacles to communication that can be overcome. On the contrary, these private formats are to be celebrated, serviced, protected, even though, by definition, to what we're protecting and celebrating. They may be expressions of deep meaning or total gibberish (or something in between).
Instructing the Imagination
From The Instruction of Imagination, by Daniel Dor: Language cannot be a general-purpose communication technology. There is simply no such thing: had there been, we would never need to invent anything else. Every communication technology is functionally specific.
Getting People Wrong
Here, the author of How Traditions Live and Die discusses Asch's famous conformity experiments from the 1950s and a more recent version from the 1990s. If you are not familiar with the original experiments, this video will be helpful. Just to make this clear, since it wasn't to me on a first read, participants in a group all look at the same photo of an individual. Then they are all asked to identify that individual in a lineup, one at a time, aloud.
Flexible Imitation
In the third chapter of How Traditions Live and Die, we reach a helpful point where the author lays out three options for imitation as a force in social learning (and sides with flexible imitation, by the way, as do I). However, I would probably try to make a case for combining all three options.
Children Are Not Little Scientists
From Paul Harris's Trusting What You're Told, whose central argument is that most of what we know we learned from others.
Cracking Open Overimitation
Ibid. As I mentioned here, this book is arguing against many of the ideas put forward by prevailing theories of cultural transmission (with which I mostly agree). So, I will likely find myself occasionally using this space to quote from that book in order to argue back and sharpen my thinking—as I do here. There are a couple of issues to disentangle in this before we go further.
Looking Outside of Cog-Sci
Ibid. I think it's worth quoting this summary, especially because it can be found in a book that will go on to argue against many of these ideas. More importantly, though, one often finds in education writing a sort of despair that cognitive science is the only research tradition we turn to. Why not sociology, social psychology, anthropology, developmental psychology?
Stimulus Diffusion
Again from How Traditions Live and Die by Olivier Morin: Morin describes the Chinese porcelain model as "meager input" into European thinking at the time. Yet, in doing so, he cites Kroeber's 1940 article in American Anthropologist, Stimulus Diffusion, which speculates that the existence of such a model was much more than a meager input: Much of this relates—perhaps in a strange way—to what I had been thinking about over here.
Tradition!
A few choice quotes from the beginning of How Traditions Live and Die: 'Noise,' as opposed to 'signal,' is another way of framing this problem.
Overtly Intentional Communication
From this piece: Why is culture so much more pervasive in humans than in other species? On this social minds and epidemiological view, the distinctive, overtly intentional character of human communication plays an especially pivotal role. In overtly intentional communication—sometimes called 'ostensive' communication—communicators actively reveal their informative intentions to their intended audience. This aligns the interests of communicator and audience.
Social Institutions and Behavioral Change
From Robert Putnam's The Upswing: The high school revolution was fostered by the "high school movement" in the early 1900s and was marked by the creation of free public high schools, beginning in small towns of the West and Midwest, then spreading to urban areas across the North, and finally throughout the entire country. . . .
Minds Are Like Parachutes
One more set of quotes from Learning from Others: It's worth noticing, I think, how guide-on-the-side thinking in education goes very much against this natural grain. What the above tells us is something all of us already intuit—that people are more or less hardwired to learn from knowledgeable others (credulity is adaptive). Yet the whole purpose behind a guide-on-the-side orientation is to minimize this input. Why?
Facts Stimulate Reasoning
Again from Gelman's Learning from Others: From their earliest use, words—especially count nouns—seem to serve as "placeholders" for children. Studies conducted with children ranging from 13 months through the preschool years demonstrate that children treat objects that receive the same noun label as if they have common, nonobvious properties.
Most of What We Know
From Susan Gelman's article "Learning from Others: Children's Construction of Concepts" (emphasis mine). Generally, concepts for which cultural input is vital include at least scientific concepts (germs, hearts, and oxygen; Harris et al.
The Copying Instinct
The final quote I will share from this excellent book—in two images—presents evidence that humans copy each other so effortlessly, unconsciously, and automatically that they do so even when they are trying not to.
I Represent the 96%
Another quote from Two Heads. How much innovation (exploration) does evolution need from its organisms to keep them successful? About 4%.
The 'Natural Aesthetic' of Teaching
In this blog, I'd like to explore a connection among some of the ideas I have been quoting in this space. The center of these connections—and where we will start—is in Samuel Jay Keyser’s excellent The Mental Life of Modernism.
Learning From Others
From Two Heads: A Graphic Exploration of How Our Brains Work with Other Brains by psychologists (and spouses) Uta and Chris Frith, along with their son, children’s nonfiction author Alex Frith. Illustrations by Daniel Locke.
I Before We . . . Weird
Another quote from Hirsch's latest book: Child-centered, developmental education can easily lead to self-centered adulthood, and according to sociological research has done so. The movement in America between the WE sentiment and the I sentiment has been traced by Robert Putnam in a fine recent book entitled Upswing. The recent dominance of the "I" motif traced by Putnam has been aided and abetted by developmentalist, child-centered education.
Knowledge Is Neither King Nor Priest
Again from American Ethnicity. Dogma was out for our founders. Logic and reason were in. And that lending of ultimate authority to logic and evidence and practicality and to thinking for oneself, and to rejecting the taking of orders from a king or a priest, was how our nation began. . . . In the latter nineteenth century, our schools had begun to be influenced by . . . the religion of natural development and the superiority of hands-on experience.
Can You Tell Me How to Get to Central Square?
E.D. Hirsch’s new book American Ethnicity: A Sense of Commonality begins as one might expect Hirsch to begin: with a focus on background knowledge. But this quote is also a good example of the way teaching and explanation happen naturally and responsively in the wild. The example quoted is based on this research. A researcher goes to Harvard Square in Cambridge, Massachusetts (a major suburb of Boston) with a tape recorder hidden in his coat pocket.
But We Like Repetition!
Quoted in The Mental Life of Modernism. Consider this a companion to this post.
Disgusted by Repetition
Ibid. By the time we get to Schoenberg’s 1911 Sechs kleine Klavierstücke ("Six Little Pieces for the Piano"), the door on any sort of public aesthetic has been slammed shut.
The Delight of Knowing
Again from The Mental Life of Modernism. There are several things to notice in this quote: (1) People pass by this "puzzle" for months or even years without caring about it. (2) The observer's prior knowledge allowed him to decipher the sculpture’s meaning. (3) Once he (thought he) figured it out, only then was he motivated to learn more. (4) Telling people about the meaning was a delightful experience for both sender and receiver.
Guess What's in My Head
From The Mental Life of Modernism, by Samuel Jay Keyser: Understanding modern poetry like Graham's, then, is either a matter of pure chance—the reader happened to have made the same association at some point in time—or a matter of intellectual digging—the reader has been exposed to and engaged with this poet's work over a long period of time, either alone or with others in a classroom. In either case, being understood in the sense of having a conversation is not the poet's intent.
broken sp-404 x op-1, by J Fisher
released April 2, 2021 The Jeremy Fisher Show Producer: J. Fisher, Alpaca Fur Rug Composer: J. Fisher Lyrics: J. Fisher Mixing: J. Fisher, Alpaca Fur Rug Master: Alpaca Fur Rug Beoke Producer: J. Fisher, Alpaca Fur Rug Composer: J. Fisher Lyrics: J. Fisher Mixing: J. Fisher, Alpaca Fur Rug Master: Alpaca Fur Rug Makebeat Producer: J. Fisher, Alpaca Fur Rug Composer: J. Fisher Lyrics: J. Fisher Mixing: J. Fisher, Alpaca Fur Rug Master: Alpaca Fur Rug Rip SD Card Producer: J.
THEJEREMYFISHER | J Fisher | Deathbomb Arc
J Fisher's passion for meticulous, delicate sounds is equally matched by his giant vision for an entire sonic world. When making his Deathbomb Arc debut as a part of the Deathbomb Showcase: Global, he didn't just simply do a live performance. J Fisher created an entire episode of his own tv show. Here on his debut album, this vision is finally presented in full for all to enter and explore. This is a true testimony to the power of bedroom hip hop: no limitations except one's own imagination.
Smart growth: a sustainable strategy for urban development and regeneration
In today’s society, the built environment is shaped by a complex amalgam of policy, property-industry conventions and local opinion, and as such the current development of our urban realm is under extreme pressure. The government’s recent Localism Bill (and subsequent Localism Act) aims to address some of the issues and revive some of the sustainable development practices of old. However, it is not a panacea for ensuring quality and sustainable urban environments.
Immunolocalisation of oestrogen receptor-α within the testis and excurrent ducts of the rat and marmoset monkey from perinatal life to adulthood
The sites of action and the physiological role of oestrogens in the male reproductive tract are poorly understood. We have undertaken a systematic study of the immunoexpression of oestrogen receptor-? (ER?) in the male rat from late fetal life through to adulthood and compared the findings with results obtained in the marmoset monkey (Callithrix jacchus) from neonatal to adult life.
Quantifying alcohol-related emergency admissions in a UK tertiary referral hospital: a cross-sectional study of chronic alcohol dependency and acute alcohol intoxication -- Vardy et al. 6 (6) -- BMJ Open
Conclusions Alcohol was thought to be implicated in 21% of emergency admissions in this cohort. CAD is responsible for a significantly greater proportion of admissions due to alcohol than acute intoxication. Interventions designed to reduce alcohol-related admissions must incorporate measures to tackle CAD. Results 1152 (21.0%, 95% CI 19.9% to 22.0%) of emergency admissions were thought to be due to alcohol.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with J
Contact J, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack