Letter | AP Story Good government helps us to recognize our opportunities and to protect us from our threats By Joe Carbonari // May 15, 2020 “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.” Edmund Burke said it. JFK repeated it. It’s time it’s said again. Put another way, if you’ve been blessed with a good mind and some resources in life, you also have the responsibility to put it to work for others … not just for you and yours.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Joe Carbonari
Thanks, Montana - Flathead Beacon
After living in Montana for seven years and writing for the Beacon for several of those (for which I’m grateful), this will be my last column as I’m moving back to Florida. Here are some truths that have been deeply confirmed in my mind during this time. Life is too short, and each stage of life passes a little faster than the one before. Doing what you believe is right and good and is very important even when others disagree or misunderstand.
Brink of War? - Flathead Beacon
During Donald Trump’s campaign and presidency, his rhetoric has been loose and reckless and sometimes downright outrageous. Notwithstanding, Trump claimed during his campaign that he would not interfere in foreign affairs and opposed President Barack Obama’s bombings in Syria. It appears Trump’s actions now fall in line with his reckless speech than nonintervention promises. With talk of North Korea testing nuclear weapons, Trump has suggested a preemptive attack.
The Syrian Airstrike
President Donald Trump just attacked Syria with about 60 missiles without approval by Congress. Trump claims it was a matter of national security, but many Americans on both sides of the aisle are not convinced, and many Americans who liked Trump for his non-intervention foreign policy rhetoric are now baffled. In his inauguration speech, Trump said he was giving power back to the people, but this unilateral attack on Syria is anything but that.
Neil Gorsuch and the ‘Nuclear Option’
Judge Neil Gorsuch is qualified to be Justice of the United States Supreme Court, but most of the Democratic senators, including Montana Sen. Jon Tester, aren’t having it. Their opposition appears based mostly on opposing Trump. Republican leadership is entertaining the “nuclear option,” to change the Senate rules to allow a simple majority to approve Gorsuch’s nomination, rather than a supermajority. Is this the best decision?
Future of Health Care?
Trump could not “make the deal” with Congress. In typical political-diversion form, Trump denied that he promised to repeal Obamacare quickly, though he did throughout his campaign. Then, Trump blamed the Freedom Caucus (and others) on Twitter for preventing the repeal-and-replace bill from passing. Trump didn’t deliver. In Tweet format, Trump claims now that Obamacare will explode. Is that a good thing?
Lessons from the Election
Trump’s presidency may be under intense scrutiny, but the Democratic Party cannot assume its candidates will be better positioned to retake the federal government in 2020. The days of Hillary-Clinton-types being poised for the presidency are over. Bernie Sanders seems to get that, as he strongly urges reform within the party.
Repealing Obamacare
Republicans are trying to repeal Obamacare. Some want to replace and others do not. This is likely going to be the most notable task on their agenda for the next few years. With Trump’s election, Republicans know this is their chance to do something with Obamacare. They are working on a plan to garner enough votes to pass the House and Senate, and it doesn’t seem a repeal-only plan will pass. Meanwhile, Trump is doing what he can with parts of Obamacare that allow for administrative control.
Trump’s Wiretapping Accusations
Things keep getting stranger in D.C. President Donald Trump tweeted that he “just found out” that the Obama Administration tapped his “wires” during the campaign. FBI Director James Comey, and former national intelligence director, James Clapper Jr., emphatically deny such tapping. Trump is calling for a congressional investigation.
Montana’s Alcohol Laws
The sale of alcohol in Montana has been heavily controlled for decades, going all the way back to prohibition days. The consequences have been that only people with extraordinary amounts of money can buy state licenses. But two bills are being proposed this session to give easier access to businesses wanting to serve alcohol. First, that Montana so highly regulates the sale of alcohol undermines free market principles, based on supply and demand.
Are Trump Orders Constitutional?
Trump has been keeping his campaign promises, to his credit, but are his actions constitutional? Trump promised to ban Muslims from entering America. In that vein, Trump signed an executive order (EO) banning entrance of all people from Muslim-majority countries. Federal agents thus detained people, but some were lawful permanent residents of America. Lawsuits were filed immediately against the EO. Several federal judges granted temporary stays on deportation until the EO’s merits is determined.
President Trump - Flathead Beacon
Donald Trump is now president of the United States. He gave a short but energetic speech. What did his speech portray? After Trump exclaimed President Barack Obama’s transition of power as magnificent, President Trump symbolically planted a flag of demarcation between himself and past presidents. The flag was a war flag, not a truce flag. Far-right nationalism was his theme. It was a call to action, and his rally song was transferring power from Washington, D.C. to the people.
Legislative Session Begins
Montana’s legislative session is upon us. Republicans control the House and Senate. What might Montana expect to see this 2017 session? Everyone has pet issues. Those will determine how one perceives the legislators. Very few will consider the constitutionality of the bills and will judge mostly on how it benefits them personally. Good and bad will result depending on one’s perspective. For example, this Legislature will likely pass bills that expand police power but reduce taxes and regulations.
New Year Wishes - Flathead Beacon
Earth has spiraled around the sun one more time. The year 2016 was a spectacular political display. A wide variety of ethics and emotions were revealed through the process. As the dust has settled, I hope America will enjoy this Christmas and New Year celebration and reflect on how to bring America together. America has much to be thankful for. Despite our differences, we have a strong heritage of working towards equality, tolerance and acceptance. Love is long-suffering, kind and patient.
Truth in the Leaks?
Some may believe Russia influenced Donald Trump’s win with its hacking and leaking information about Hillary Clinton. If it’s true, it is disturbing that a foreign nation would attempt to affect our elections, but there is another important question. Is the leaked information true? In common law and statutory law, there is a defense to lawsuits alleging slander and libel; that is, truth. Assuming Russia took responsibility for leaking the hacked information, it may assert the “defense” of truth.
Russia's Influence on the Election
The CIA said that it believes Russia helped Trump win the election by releasing information about Hillary Clinton to Wikileaks. Assuming Russia released hacked information to Wikileaks, the CIA’s assumption is not supported by the facts and recent political history. Most people in America did not need Russia or Wikileaks to inform them that Hillary is untrustworthy and – stated more bluntly – corrupt. The movement Trump captured and used began during (and even before) the primary elections.
Trump's Cabinet - Flathead Beacon
President-elect Donald Trump chose Gen. James Mattis as defense secretary. Congress will have to waive the legal requirement that the defense secretary be a civilian at least seven years prior to being defense secretary. To protect our constitutional republic, Americans have determined that military leaders should not fill the role of civilian leadership due to the risk of becoming a military state.
Business and Politics
Morality and legality are not always the same. Two areas in which Donald Trump was deemed as “immoral but legal” were his filing bankruptcy and avoiding taxes. Bankruptcy has been considered not only legal but necessary throughout history and is contained within religious canons. It is (partly) designed to prevent rich, powerful creditors from enslaving others. Creditors know these risks and calculate potential losses this way.
How Trump Will Govern
The president of the United States is undoubtedly a sobering position. National interests are complex, security is precarious, consequences are far-reaching, and people are critical. Despite Donald Trump’s campaign rhetoric, he is changing tunes. What should we expect? There are two essential things that got Trump elected: his stance on immigration (i.e. building a wall), and “drain the swamp” promise (e.g. prosecute “nasty, crooked” Hillary).
Trump's Win - Flathead Beacon
Donald Trump handily won the electoral college, to many’s surprise. Notably, on Election Day, global corporate media admitted how badly their polls were off and “promised” to work better at poll accuracy. Trump met with President Barack Obama to ensure a smooth transition of presidential power and published a task list. What are three items we should welcome, regardless of our feelings about Trump? (1) First on Trump’s list is, propose a constitutional amendment to impose term limits on Congress.
Constitutional Stability
The Constitution creates a wonderful system with tremendous stability. The flux of political parties, politicians, agencies, and bureaucracies do not destroy the system. Virtually every presidential race in American history is described by the candidates, media and voters as “the most important election of our time.” 2016 is no different. Trump claims that if Clinton is elected, America will be destroyed. Clinton has used different language but has inferred the same.
The Bundy Verdict
The jury found the Bundy brothers and co-defendants not guilty on a variety of charges stemming from the so-called Oregon standoff. What can we learn? First, the prosecutors simply may have failed to prove the charges. Second, the jury could have nullified the charges, meaning finding not guilty despite the evidence. Third, the jury could have signaled to the government that it agrees with the Bundys’ protest. Oregon is not known for right-wingers. It leans liberal.
Wikileaks’ Revelations
Most voters have already decided for whom to vote. NBC released a recent poll showing Hillary Clinton ahead of Donald Trump by 11 points. This significant lead exists even with Gary Johnson and Jill Stein taking votes from Clinton. Perhaps nothing will give Trump better momentum because there are too few undecideds remaining. Clinton’s been in politics for decades. Whatever dirt exists on her can be revealed by many sources. After all, this is not her first run for a powerful national office.
Bullock and Gianforte
Montana will have another opportunity to elect its governor this November. Bullock is the incumbent, who is being challenged by businessman Greg Gianforte. Steve Bullock is an attorney and former attorney general for Montana. Bullock has worked in government a significant period of his career. Bullock barely defeated GOP candidate Rick Hill in 2012 for governor, skimming only 1.5 percent more votes than Hill.
Gary Johnson and the Debates
It’s no mystery that many Republicans and limited-government advocates dislike Donald Trump, though the reasons may be different. Voting for Trump is not only out of the question, but many anti-Trumpers are openly promoting Gary Johnson’s campaign, the libertarian candidate. Johnson’s support comes also from anti-Clintonites. Gary Johnson is the only other candidate who will be on all ballots. His popularity is rising, which is indicated by continued polling.
The Deplorables - Flathead Beacon
Clinton said she could “put half of Trump’s supporters into what [she] call[s] the ‘basket of deplorables.’� In truth, most Americans looking at the 2016 election are saying, our political leaders are what’s deplorable. This is why Trump became popular in the first place. Clinton attacked the wrong people. The constitutional history of the United States demonstrates how political power continually shifts to the federal government, away from state and local authority.
Plausible Deniability
A New York Post author recently wrote about Hillary’s “pay to play” scandal: “Unless you’re a high-ranking government official, it’s hard to get a meeting with any secretary of state. But during Hillary Clinton’s tenure, there was another way: pay up.” So how does Hillary’s less-than-honest reputation affect the election? Bernie Sanders became popular partly for his reputation for honesty. Clinton is a stark contrast and is right in the middle of appearances of impropriety.
Political Expression
Unfettered political expression is necessary to preserve a free society.
Distrusting the Government
Distrusting government is not new; but every generation carries potential energy to alter, amend or abolish the system when distrust builds over time. America is subject to this law of human nature like any nation. Government administrators hold the people’s political power in trust, but watch them closely because they have the power to take life, liberty and property. Naturally, the better these trustees administer government, the more people will respect, trust and obey them.
The Two-Party Stronghold
The 2016 election season is unique to American history. After the shakedown, Americans are stuck with a Republican and Democratic candidate that have masses of would-be loyalists not willing to vote for either one. Enter Libertarian Gary Johnson: the only other candidate who will be on every ballot across the nation. Politico opines that Johnson could realistically win.
Fixing America? - Flathead Beacon
Part of Trump’s success stems from very upset Americans who feel long-betrayed by politicians or dislike America’s cultural changes. How will this translate into America’s future if Trump is elected? During the RNC, Trump said, “I am your voice. I alone can fix it. I will restore law and order.” Many of Trump’s supporters literally believe this authoritarian statement.
The Kaine Pick - Flathead Beacon
Like Donald Trump, Hillary Clinton just picked a “safe” choice for VP, Sen. Tim Kaine. “Like Indiana Gov. Mike Pence, his Republican counterpart, Kaine brings a steady temperament and unpretentious personality to the campaign,” as USA Today put it. Now what? As much as some Republicans dislike Trump, they fear the thought of Clinton becoming president and thus will vote Trump.
Pence a Good Choice?
Either Trump or Clinton will become president of the United States. Trump is untested and controversial. He needs help to appeal to traditional conservative voters. His choice for vice president is such a way. Trump chose Gov. Mike Pence. Good choice? Pence appeals to traditional conservatives: his stance on abortion, homosexual marriage, foreign policy, economics, and immigration.
After Dallas - Flathead Beacon
Excessive police force is rising despite more public exposure of the problem. The most recent examples happened in Minnesota and Louisiana. While people in Dallas were protesting, a man shot and killed five police and injured others. The man who did this was gravely wrong for many reasons. We grieve for the families and communities. That said, many Americans are rightly growing very concerned over police abuse. The abuses where police kill are extreme highlights.
Coal Versus Clean Energy
Coal versus clean energy remains a hot topic in state and federal politics. Science and pragmatism must rule the day on the issue, not partisanship and emotion. America has been using coal energy a long time. Our grid systems largely rely on coal: it is plentiful and predictable. Government would be unwise to make use of coal difficult. It harms the consumers, which comprises most of American homes, businesses and government.
Leaving the European Union
The British people voted to leave the European Union. Their exit will take time but will be peaceful. Some have criticized UK’s exit, pointing to disadvantages it will cause, but the bigger focus should be the people’s will. The American colonies’ exit from Britain also had disadvantages. They lost Britain’s military protection and economic benefits and were vulnerable to foreign influence. But these disadvantages were not the primary concern to them.
Gun Laws - Flathead Beacon
The Orlando shooting prompted some politicians to propose a fix, including completely banning certain kinds of firearms. This is not the answer. First, the right to bear arms is a personal right under the Second Amendment, as the United States Supreme Court has solidly ruled. Second, common sense and human history demonstrate that an armed citizenry is necessary to defend against oppression: whether by criminals, terrorists or tyrants.
Trump, Foreign Policy and Terrorism
After the recent mass shooting in Orlando, Florida at a popular gay nightclub, Donald Trump seized the opportunity to express his reaction. Among other things, Trump stated that America’s safety from terrorism depends on closing the border to Muslims; told Obama to resign if he did not identify the attack as radical Islam; predicted this will happen again if we do not get “tough and smart;” and said he will be a president who protects America as a tolerant society.
Trump Endorsements
Vice president of the United States, a heartbeat away from the presidency, or maybe secretary of defense. Congressman Ryan Zinke is being considered for a high post if The Donald wins. Zinke is ready. He has endorsed Trump and is trying to sound sincere in service. He is clearly on the move. It will be interesting to watch. For Trump, Zinke would be a relatively safe running mate. Zinke has appeal. He has substance to back his charm. He understands power, its responsibilities, and its limitations.
Unpopular Candidates
Naturally, political candidates cannot appease the masses on myriad issues, but this election is worse than that. Both Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton have major problems with voters, the root of which stems from people’s distrust and even hatred for their candidacies. Trump is an unknown quantity and his rhetoric suggests that he may be dangerous internationally and authoritarian domestically. I heard a Christian pastor recently say Trump is not a candidate for whom a Christian should vote.
Federal Overreach?
The federal government has issued “guidance” on how public schools are to treat transgender students. President Obama’s administration stated that the federal government would pull funding from states that do not comply with this guidance. The federal government is overreaching its power and causing unnecessary division in America, not based on law but on ideology.
The Presumptive Nominee
Donald Trump is the presumptive GOP nominee since Ted Cruz and John Kasich have exited the race. First, some Republican loyalists still do not support Trump. By implication, either they will vote third party or for the Democratic candidate. It appears that these Republicans are suddenly abandoning the “lesser of two evils” rationale.
Trump’s Running Mate
The Washington Post named five most-likely vice president choices for Donald Trump if he wins the GOP nomination: 1) Marco Rubio, 2) John Kasich, 3) Joni Ernst, 4) Rick Scott and 5) Chris Christie. The National Review adds to those 1) Jeff Sessions, 2) Jan Brewer, 3) Scott Brown and 4) Sarah Palin. Who would be good for Trump –and America? Trump’s popularity comes largely from disenfranchised Americans who like him for no other reason than he appears anti-establishment.
Saudi Arabia’s Role
The federal government has kept secret 28 pages of a report on 9/11. The president indicates he is poised to release those documents, which supposedly will have severe repercussions on our relationship with Saudi Arabia. Saudi Arabia has responded very harshly, including threatening to drop its investments in the U.S. dollar. It’s been 15 years since the attacks.
The Unhappy Electorate
In our presidential primaries we are seeing surprising changes in our society. There is a wider and deeper sense of displeasure, particularly in the middle class, than was generally realized. Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders supporters include much of this. Together, this degree of displeasure suggests our country is changing and that our governmental system has been slow to adapt. The result has been too slow a recovery from the recession, and too many people left out. This problem will live on.
Looking Toward the Primaries
Talk politics. Yes, arguments may ensue. The risk, though, is worth it. Our primary elections are less than eight weeks away. Unfortunately, many voters really don’t have a clue. Friends and family are fair game. Help them understand. If they remain confused, just tell them how you think they should vote … in a quiet, understanding way. Donald Trump, Ted Cruz, and Bernie Sanders are all risky, but to different degrees and in different ways.
Sanders and Socialism
Bernie Sanders is an open socialist running for president and has notable success in this election. His followers are very motivated about his message. What does this mean for America’s constitutional future? Socialist states have a similar foundation to democratic republics: i.e. political power derives from the people, not the chosen few. But the constitutions of them are very different.
Same-sex Marriage in America
For a long time, religious beliefs have played a significant role in politics. In America, religious beliefs bled into statutes, both on state and federal levels. For example, past generations used religion to limit individual liberty, such as, keeping women from voting, different races from marrying, and alcohol from being consumed. But a different view of religion prompted liberty movements. What is the next religious push in America?
Supreme Court Nomination
President Obama has nominated Merrick Garland to fill the vacant U. S. Supreme Court seat. The U.S. Senate must confirm the nomination for it to take effect. The current court is ideologically divided as is the country. It is generally agreed that if Garland is confirmed the court’s balance, which has leaned conservative for the past few decades, will tilt in a more moderate-to-liberal direction.
State of the Race
Vox.com released an article discussing the rise of authoritarianism among Americans and its relationship to Donald Trump’s political success. Vox cites numerous political science studies and theorizes that Trump’s success correlates to a large number of Americans (mostly identifying as “conservative”) who are apparently desperate for a dictator-like leader to stop social changes perceived as dangerous – by force.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Joe
Contact Joe, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack