Fermi gases and liquids display an excitation spectrum that is simply connected, ensuring closed Fermi surfaces. In strongly correlated systems such as the cuprate superconductors, the existence of open sheets of Fermi surface known as Fermi arcs indicate a distinctly different topology of the spectrum with no equivalent in Fermi-liquid theory. Here, we demonstrate a generic mechanism by which correlation effects in fermionic systems can change the topology of the spectrum.