When a Lancaster County detective asked John Stoltzfus how he killed four unwanted Sheepadoodle puppies in October 2023, he told them, “We have a way of doing it. We took good care of them,” according to charging documents. Now, after two years and two failed attempts to get Stoltzfus into a diversionary court program, his attorneys say Stoltzfus humanely, painlessly and instantaneously euthanized the puppies in a manner consistent with Pennsylvania law.