Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Les Zig
Collingwood’s road to mediocrity is paved with renovation
Now that the grand final is decided, we all look ahead to trade week, and – as a Collingwood supporter – I look forward to Collingwood's great renovation. Not a rebuild. God forbid they rebuild their list – with Tasmania coming in, a dearth of top picks, and little to trade out, they don't have the license to rebuild without it becoming some protracted minefield. So it's a renovation. Get in some older players. They might only be there a year or two.
Collingwood cannot afford to waste Nick Daicos like it did Nathan Buckley
Les Zig Consider this scenario: Collingwood wins a premiership; they have this freakish generational ball-winning machine on their list; the further they move from the flag, the harder they try to stay relevant through stopgap recruiting. They acquire role-players from other clubs. Their drafting is mixed and - courtesy of a lack of top-end picks - speculative. Some of the players look okay, but will any of them be elite? As the years pass, the playing list grows increasingly problematic.
Collingwood cannot afford to waste Nick Daicos like it did Nathan Buckley
Consider this scenario: Collingwood wins a premiership; they have this freakish generational ball-winning machine on their list; the further they move from the flag, the harder they try to stay relevant through stopgap recruiting. They acquire role-players from other clubs. Their drafting is mixed and - courtesy of a lack of top-end picks - speculative. Some of the players look okay, but will any of them be elite? As the years pass, the playing list grows increasingly problematic.
Mason Cox’s misunderstood career: The big Texan who defied the odds
There are not many AFL players who’ve been as maligned as Mason Cox – media, punter, and his own supporters alike tearing into the big Texan. What I saw was a guy set up to have the most difficult assignment imaginable. He came into a game he’d never heard of previously, and nor did he have any parallel sporting background, e.g. coming from something like Gaelic football, which would have similar skills. He’d been a basketballer – tall and gangly and sometimes awkward, but always eager.
The familiar tale of Collingwood's good-but-not-good-enough list - and the key mistake they seem set to make again
What the Brisbane Lions have proven with their back-to-back premierships is how the introduction of youth can reinvigorate a list, as well as chart a positive course into the future. But as a Collingwood supporter, I dread that the Magpies won’t learn from this, and instead double down on Moneyball recruiting in an attempt to remain relevant. Already they’ve been linked to Sydney’s Jack Buller, ex-Richmond mid-season draftee Jacob Blight, and Sydney’s Ollie Florent.
The Nick Daicos haters are embarrassing themselves - and every argument they make is flat out wrong
Originally, it was fun to watch the Nick Daicos bashing. He never won the hard ball. He played for frees. He avoided contact. Then there were the comparisons with players in your own team who were better than him. They might very well be. But they weren’t naming and comparing to stimulate football discussion, or critique the merits of each player in question, but just to smash Nick because … well, I don’t know, really.
The Rankine case is further proof that the AFL stands for absolutely nothing
What exactly does the AFL stand for? Not a lot, apparently, outside of posturing and trying to be seen to be doing the right thing while never actually doing it. After days of investigation, Izak Rankine has been handed a four-game penalty.
The ten reasons Collingwood's season is slipping away - and how they can turn it around
There’s an old saying: “death by a thousand cuts.” That means instead of one big thing being the killer, it’s a lot of little things. At Collingwood, it’s neither one big thing that has mortally wounded their 2025 campaign, nor one thousand. Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Reddit Email Share It’s just ten. Just five rounds ago, the Magpies were ten points clear of their nearest rival atop the ladder. They looked the team to beat, although their form had been tapering since the bye.
There are holes everywhere in Collingwood's best 23 - it's time for McRae to work out who's in it
Two months ago, Collingwood sat on top of the ladder and looked unassailable. In the last five weeks, they’ve dropped three games – two of them by narrow margins, which used to be their specialty – and have sunk to second on the ladder. With upcoming games against a Hawthorn side battling for a position in the finals, and a formidable Crows side over in Adelaide, the Magpies’ grasp on the top four has grown tenuous.
The AFL's policy of rewarding mediocrity and punishing well-run clubs is farcical, unfair - and it doesn't work
Imagine this: the best university graduates went to the worst posts. Of course, it’ll never happen. The best university graduates seek the best posts. Those posts seek the best candidates. But it’s inverted in the AFL: the best young talent goes to the worst teams. Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Reddit Email Share We do this under the pretense that we’re helping improve those clubs, but are we? Really? There’s two interesting premises at work here.
AFL's craving for perpetual motion has killed off illegal disposals, and the game has become an eyesore of imprecision
The AFL continues to quietly murder the game while the footballing public sleeps. They’re doing this through their unspoken, unacknowledged mandate to keep the ball in motion, whatever the cost. Because, this is the thing: the AFL don’t want the play stopping. Every new rule and/or interpretation they’ve ever introduced is designed to keep the ball moving. Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Reddit Email Share Let’s rewind: the deliberate rushed behind.
Walsh should hang his head in shame - targeting Nick Daicos is the kind of pseudo-toughness AFL could do without
On Thursday night, during the Collingwood and Carlton clash, Sam Walsh and Nick Daicos engaged in a tussle. Presumably, this began because opposition sides have decided the best way to put Nick off his game is to physically intimidate him. At one point, Walsh grabbed Nick and slung him to the ground. It was an interesting motion.
'Beautiful man loved by all': AFL world in mourning as former Tiger, Magpie dead at 42
The AFL world is mourning the death of former Richmond and Collingwood player Andrew Krakouer. Krakouer, who played 137 games at the Tigers between 2001 and 2013, suffered a suspected heart attack in Perth on Sunday. He was 42. Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Reddit Email Share Krakouer, the son of North Melbourne legend Jim, is perhaps best known for his career resurgence at the Magpies after being delisted by the Tigers at the end of 2007.
Pies pity party: Collingwood fans are the biggest whingers in the comp - and it might be softening up their team
Collingwood has enjoyed – or endured – an infamous history built around their woeful grand final record between 1959 and 1990, and then in the 2000s. Grand final losses in 1960, 1964, 1966, 1970, 1977, 1979, 1980, 1981, 2002, 2003, 2011, and 2018, often come with some qualification. “If only Maynard wasn’t blocked”, and “If Rocca/Carman hadn’t been suspended”, or, “If Rocca’s goal had been paid”, or “Harmes tapped the ball in from out of bounds”, etc. There are others. Many others. Too many others.
McRae's trade first strategy is a recipe for Magpie disaster
After missing the finals this year, and with some of their best players another year older, Collingwood, and coach Craig McRae, have already flagged how they intend to navigate the upcoming trade period. “I say to the list mismanagement, ‘I don’t want picks, I want players’,” McRae said in a recent interview.
The Perils of Editing Poetry
Welcome to our weekly column offering perspectives on lit mag publishing, with contributions from readers, writers and editors around the world. Editing is a noble but thankless pursuit. When you read a great book, everybody lauds the author. They’re such an amazing talent. If you read a bad book, often the criticism is that it’s been “poorly edited.” The hapless editor is a selfless workhorse flogged mercilessly, unsatisfactorily rewarded, and rarely praised publicly. I’d know.
Much ado about nothing: Hinkley-Ginnivan incident has been completely overblown
Astonishing backlash launched at Port Adelaide coach Ken Hinkley after the post-game scenes last night. So he made a plane motion and aimed a few slights at Hawthorn’s Jack Ginnivan. And now the football world’s in an uproar. “It’s not a good look.” Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Reddit Email Share That’s what so many have said. You can’t have coaches responding to players, can you? Um, why not?
Why the defending premiers struggled to fire: Ten things to hate about Collingwood's 2024 season
Here’s a big question for the reigning premiers: how exactly can a side that played finals in 2022 and 2023, and looked all ready to fire again, simply putter their way through 2024 – and why? Below are my ten reasons Collingwood’s 2024 has been underwhelming.
AFL News: New GF medal to honour Barassi, Houston ban confirmed after bizarre 'Vegemite lid' defence
2045 Reads Ron Barassi will become a permanent fixture of grand final day, with the AFL set to introduce a new medal to honour the Australian Rules champion. One of the most important figures in the game’s history, Barassi’s passing at the age of 87 in September 2023 prompted calls for an award to be renamed after the legendary player and coach, with many suggestions that the premiership cup itself be named after him.
AFL News: More drama at Dees with star demanding trade, Sheezel under injury cloud, Blues battered and bruised
Melbourne premiership utility Alex Neal-Bullen wants out of the club despite being under contract until the end of 2026. According to a report in The Age, the 28-year-old is keen to return home to Adelaide and is worried that the Demons are not going to be competing for another flag in the near future. He had inked a three-year extension last year but the new father is reportedly keen to be closer to family.
A year without benefit: Pies stagnate in premiership defence with future uncertain
Barring a miracle, Collingwood’s ill-fated premiership defence has come to an end. It’s a season that’s spluttered from Round 0, given false hope briefly, imploded spectacularly, and then attempted a near-impossible resuscitation. Now, with the loss to Sydney, it’s over.
The tough path forward for the Pies as flag window closes... and the obstacle set to make rebuilding even harder
Did anybody expect Collingwood’s 2024 to unravel as spectacularly as it has? While some (particularly among Collingwood diehards) will say that injuries derailed 2024, and they’ll be back next season, I’m not so sure. The profile of Collingwood’s list shows an aged top end: Scott Pendlebury (36), Jeremy Howe (34), Steele Sidebottom (33), Mason Cox (33), Jamie Elliott (31), Brody Mihocek (31), Tom Mitchell (31), Will Hoskin-Elliot (30), and Jack Crisp (30).
More than just a 'relief ruck': Why Cornes - and Collingwood - are wrong about Mason Cox
Last week on Channel Nine’s ‘Footy Classified’, Sam McClure posed that Collingwood were missing Mason Cox, prompting colleague Kane Cornes to reiterate one of his recurring criticisms: just how little Mason Cox statistically contributes to the Pies. Although he polarises football fans, I don’t mind Cornes. I think he has the courage to speak his mind, whereas many other journalists play it safe.
'Apathetic, without system and lacking intensity': The 'biggest question' no one has bothered to ask about 'comeback king' Pies
Sitting back a fortnight ago, watching Collingwood’s comeback against North Melbourne from a nine-goal deficit, I was one of the few people who just wasn’t that excited. Nine goals down. Overrunning a young North Melbourne team, almost certain to win the wooden spoon, why not feel the exhilaration everybody else – or at least every other Collingwood supporter – did? What an accomplishment! Right? It was just the latest in Collingwood’s litany of miraculous wins.
AFL News: 'Just cannot accept that': Dangerfield learns Tribunal fate after heated exchange,
1409 Reads Geelong captain Patrick Dangerfield has been cleared for his dangerous tackle on Sam Walsh on Friday night, after a tense hearing that featured several terse exchanges between the Cats star and the AFL’s appointed lawyer. Dangerfield conceded a free kick in the opening minutes of the Cats’ loss to Carlton, after tackling the Blues star from behind and pinning his arms, with Walsh taken forward in the tackle and hitting his head on the ground.
The Father-Son equation has been around for decades, but it's suddenly become a problem because Collingwood is benefiting
So everybody is complaining because father/son selections have advantaged Collingwood. Oooh – Josh and Nick Daicos, as well as Darcy Moore. How important were they to Collingwood’s 2023 premiership campaign? Darcy Moore was the inspirational captain. Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Reddit Email Share Nick Daicos would’ve won the Brownlow if he didn’t miss six games with injury. Josh Daicos won Collingwood’s Best and Fairest -and just in case you missed it, he did it in a premiership year.
Some of Collingwood's tactical decisions don’t seem entirely logical: Questions for the Pies Moving Forward
Collingwood’s done an admirable job of remaining competitive despite their wretched run with injuries. But while they’ve been forced to think laterally, some of the decisions don’t seem entirely logical. Here are five points that have sprung to mind over the last fortnight. Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Reddit Email Share It was a strange decision to start the season with Charlie Dean in defence.
The great time-wasting travesty: It’s never Collingwood’s fault that they ultimately aren’t good enough
I’m so tired of hearing about the Matthew Nicholls saga, and honestly, I’m so tired of hearing about it from Collingwood supporters. So let’s set the scene: Collingwood is 19 points up against Walyalup with just seven minutes remaining. A pack forms twenty metres out from Walyalup’s goal. Umpire Nicholls blows the whistle for a ball up.
'Murky decision-making, novice administration and unaccountable governance' - how the AFL has fallen
What an appallingly run competition the AFL is. Nobody really talks about it. We all love footy, so the AFL must be doing great. In reality, if the AFL was a suspect we’d dragged in for interrogation, questioning would uncover a record that would condemn them as, at the very least, dubious. Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Reddit Email Share Where do we start? Most recently, we have the debacle surrounding Charlie Cameron’s sling tackle when Brisbane played Melbourne.
Stuff the excuses - Collingwood are making the same mistakes as always after success, and it's time to act
The funniest thing about Collingwood’s 0-3 start to the 2024 season is that, apparently, they’re immune to criticism. They won a flag, you see. That’s what I heard SEN‘s Mark Fine tell one caller who bemoaned the Magpies’ lacklustre effort against Sydney, and then lamented the flag unfurling had been too early. Some commended Fine for the stance in shutting down an ungrateful malcontent, and for pointing out that a club like St Kilda would be delighted to so much as have a flag to unfurl. Not me.
'The level of delusion is something else': Eddie McGuire's defence of his disastrous coaching succession plan is ridiculous
I unwittingly caught part of Eddie McGuire and Jimmy Bartel’s podcast last week. Fifteen minutes in, McGuire, yet again, went into defending Collingwood’s infamous succession plan – the deal that he spearheaded as club president in 2009, signing Nathan Buckley to a two-year apprenticeship under Mick Malthouse for 2010 and 2011, with Buckley taking over in his own right in 2012. McGuire said Caroline Wilson always referred to it as ‘the disastrous succession plan’.
One flag isn't enough, the Pies should stuff their face
One week on has given me time to reflect on such an improbable flag for the Pies. “Improbable?” I’m sure some would scoff, before pointing out that Collingwood finished minor premiers, and sat on top for the bulk of the season. Yes. Improbable. What does finishing on top really mean?
Show us some dare, some verve, imagination, theatre! An open letter to the AFL
Dear AFL, As we leave another season behind and club begin to enter into list management for next year, we yet again face the patent absurdities behind the competition’s equalisation policies. Since the national draft and salary cap have been taken seriously (well, by some) – let’s say this began in 2000 – there have been a spate of dynasties: namely Hawthorn and Geelong have won four flags, and Brisbane and Richmond have won three. Four clubs have won fourteen of a possible twenty-three flags.
The grand final ticketing debacle once again proves the AFL doesn't give a rat's about the fans
Back before the internet, people had to line up outside ticketing agencies to get their seats for big games. That’s what we did for the 1990 grand final – camping outside Northland for over a week to ensure we got in early. I was part of my brother’s posse – about thirty or so fanatical Collingwood supporters who would attend games weekly and occupy the (half-forward flank) hill at Victoria Park. My brother had meticulously drawn up a roster stating who’d mind our spot in the queue and when.
Maynard incident reaction proves the AFL still doesn't get that accidents can happen
It always shocks me whenever anybody tries to use precedent as a defence in the AFL. If the league has proven anything in the last few years, it’s that they have no template for any facet of the game. The biggest example, in this regard, is the Tribunal. How many sling tackles have been penalised and how many have been overlooked? How many bumps have been pinged and how many have been cleared?
What's the best way to reward the AFL's minor premier? Give them the power to choose
Years ago when the then-VFL was just 12 teams, the competition employed the McIntyre Final 5 system for the finals. The breakdown was simple: WEEK 1 The Minor Premier gets a week off. Qualifying Final: Second plays Third. Elimination Final: Fourth plays Fifth. The loser is eliminated. Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Reddit Email Share WEEK 2 Second Semi Final: The Minor Premier plays the winner of the Qualifying Final. The victor goes into the Grand Final.
Kane Cornes' crusade against 'flopping' Magpie isn't just disgraceful - it's dangerous
Kane Cornes is fast developing one of the most bombastic reputations in journalism. Last year, following Collingwood’s Round 1 win over St Kilda, he criticised Jack Ginnivan’s post-match behaviour fooling around with a GoPro. How dare he! Who was Ginnivan, with only a handful of games under his belt at that time, to celebrate so arrogantly? Cornes led a crusade against Ginnivan’s behaviour, which I could respect if not for one simple fact: it lasted all of four weeks.
Dear Brian Taylor: it's time to cut your anti-Collingwood bias out
Dear Brian, You came to Collingwood as part of the recruiting wars with Richmond in the 1980s, a genuine star and our first real key forward since Fabulous Phil Carman back in 1975. The 1980s were heady times. We went from grand finalists (1980 – 81) to the New Magpies administration (1983) vowing success to almost filing for bankruptcy in 1986. But that year was also a turning point for the club with Leigh Matthews assuming the mantle of senior coach.
The AFL must do more to protect Jack Ginnivan
I’m sick of watching the treatment of Jack Ginnivan. We’re now two years into this malfeasance. I’ll pause briefly to let the flogs counter with such witty repartee as, “He deserves it”, and, “He’s a git”, and all that juvenile condemnation that has no relevance to the reality of the situation.
Constant rule changes have made umpiring in the AFL impossible - and the game is suffering
I am so sick of watching deplorably umpired games. The footballing fraternity has always qualified umpiring as such a hard job, that a few mistakes are to be expected. How about instead of making excuses, we start looking at the cause? The AFL. Interpretations change so drastically that we never know what we’re going to get from quarter to quarter, let alone game to game, week to week, or even year to year.
AFL News: De Goey makes his choice, Kennett breaks silence on Hawks racism report
Jordan De Goey has ended months of speculation about his future at Collingwood by finally signing a five-year deal to remain at the Magpies. A restricted free agent, De Goey had attracted heavy interest from rivals St Kilda and Essendon, but despite a last-minute stand-off between club and player over behavioral clauses in his contract, will remain at the Westpac Centre until the end of 2027. The contract is reportedly worth up to $800,000 per year.
The Collingwood lament: If only...
The Collingwood juggernaut rocks on. Unfortunately, it’s the Collingwood hype juggernaut. Within a single quarter of the grand final being played, people began texting me that it would’ve been a better grand final had Tom Papley been penalised for a push in the back against Darcy Moore in the Sydney-Collingwood preliminary final, implying then Collingwood would’ve won, and would’ve offered Geelong a tougher contest in the grand final.
Let Nick Daicos Keep the 35
Collingwood’s Nick Daicos has now officially requested that he be allowed to keep wearing the number 35 – the number his father, Peter, made famous through a glorious 250-game career from 1979–1993. That man who inherited the number from him in 1996 was Simon Prestigiacomo, an unglamorous key forward transformed into a dour full back. Presti, as he was known, was a battler early in his career, but under Mick Malthouse’s tenure (2000–2011) evolved into one of the premier defenders in the league.
AFL Awards: Daicos named Rising Star, Dockers gun named AFLPA MVP, Curnow claims Coleman, every award
Collingwood’s Nick Daicos has been unsurprisingly confirmed as the winner of the 2022 AFL Rising Star Award, also claiming the gong of the AFLPA’s Best First Year Player. Daicos, the son of Magpies legend Peter, was a unanimous choice for the gong, polling a maximum five votes from all 12 judges after what has been described as one of the best debut seasons in recent memory.
The history Collingwood risks repeating in pursuit of Daniel McStay
Collingwood’s commitment to securing Brisbane’s Daniel McStay baffles me. McStay is a solid but unspectacular contributor playing third fiddle behind Eric Hipwood and Joe Daniher. This season McStay’s kicked 22.11, and has gone goal-less in eight of his 19 games. He’s never topped 30 goals in a season in his 158-game, nine-year career. Is he really the missing piece in the Collingwood puzzle? Collingwood’s surprised everybody by finishing the home-and-away season fourth.
The Jack Ginnivan fiction reaches a new, disgusting low
Sydney Swans fans booed Jack Ginnivan on Sunday. Ginnivan had been subbed out with a hamstring injury. When the coverage crossed to him sitting disconsolately on the bench, the Sydney fans roundly booed him. Given the Swans had one of their club legends effectively booed out of the game, it’s an astonishing collective choice of behaviour. I want to write that the bigger surprise is the continued vilification of Ginnivan, but it’s not. Unfortunately, it’s not at all.
AFL News: Lethal Leigh blasts rulemakers for tearing game apart, Wines back Hinkley, Edwards hits 300th
Leigh Matthews believes the fabric of the game is being attacked and was left feeling “sick” and “disturbed” and found it hard to sleep after the controversial Jack Ginnivan incident on the weekend. The AFL legend on 3AW on Tuesday night blasted the rulemakers over the decision to call play on after the Collingwood star was hit high in a tackle from Essendon’s Mason Redman early in the Magpies’ nail-biting win.
The vilification of Jack Ginnivan
The media’s vilification of Jack Ginnivan, leading to the AFL’s scapegoating of him, has been shameful. But both organisations are great at this: the media at determining a narrative, and the AFL at kneejerk responses that are stopgap attempts to quiet the uproar, rather than legitimately explore whether an issue exists, and then find a resolution.
AFL NEWS: Noble defends youngster's shocker after 'family bereavement', Stewart to face Tribunal over bump
North Melbourne coach David Noble has revealed much-maligned youngster Tarryn Thomas was struggling with the death of a family member during the Roos’ loss to Adelaide. Thomas came under fire for poor body language throughout the match on Sunday afternoon, finishing with only three disposals in his first AFL game after being shockingly omitted before the Kangaroos’ bye last week. The 22-year old then was involved in an exchange with a fan on Instagram which quickly spread on social media.
AFL's new challenge: the media's rampant cesspool of bullying and vilification that threatens to become a tsunami
The latest Jordan De Goey saga has thrown up an interesting juxtaposition. There are those who believe that De Goey has messed up, and that the media has been just in exposing and condemning him. And there are those who assert that De Goey has committed no wrongdoing, and that the media have been exploitative and opportunistic.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Les
Contact Les, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack