Current Cosmo cover girl Olivia Rodrigo spent her first two albums perfecting the breakup anthem, and on her third, most recent, you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love, she finally turned the lens on the scarier part: actually being in love. Her newest release splits cleanly down the middle. Side A, “girl so in love,” is all fluttering, brain-rotted infatuation, and Side B, “you seem pretty sad,” is the cold sweat underneath it.