This philosophy book is 408 pages long, with the main text being 343 pages divided into 11 chapters. The authors, philosophers and substance dualists Brandon Rickabaugh and J.P. Moreland (figure 1) cover a cornucopia of arguments for substance dualism, as well as respond to objections against it. For reasons of space, only a small fraction of these arguments and objections are discussed in this review. J.P. Moreland, Wikimedia | CC BY SA 3.0 Figure 1.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Peter Line
The mind-brain debate A review of Minding the Brain: Models of the mind, information, and empirical science by Angus J. Menuge, Brian R. Krouse, and Robert J. Marks (Editors), Discovery Institute Press, Seattle, WA, 2023
The book is a collection of 25 chapters (three available online only), involving 25 different authors, with some contributing to more than one chapter. It is 488 pages long (plus 100 online pages) and said to be organized such that it loosely groups chapters in the first two units with those written by philosophers, and the last two units with those written by scientists. The Introduction by the three editors includes brief, but useful, overviews of all chapters.
Yunxian 2 cranium changes human evolution tale (again)
The Yunxian 1 and 2 fossils are human crania (skulls) found in terrace deposits of Northwestern China’s Han River in 1989 and 1990. They were named after the area, Yún Xiàn (Yun County, now Yunyang District), Hubei province. The crania were found crushed and deformed to varying degrees. The less damaged cranium, Yunxian 2 (fig. 1), was ‘virtually’ reconstructed in 2005. In 2010 Vialet et al. confirmed assignment of the Yunxian 2 cranium (~1,050 cc cranial capacity) to Homo erectus.
The myth of ape-to-human evolution
©123rf.com/anolis01, ©123rf.com/theartofphoto The public is frequently led to think that the evidence of humans evolving from an apelike common ancestor with chimps is simply overwhelming. The claim is often made in bombastic, even intimidating terms, such as in this example of ‘elephant hurling’ tactics by a prominent evolutionist: “There are now tens of thousands of hominid fossils in museums around the world supporting our current knowledge of human evolution.
Homo bodoensis
LAYERS OF FAITH CONFERENCE DENVER, COLORADO WEDNESDAY, JULY 9 - SATURDAY, JULY 12, 2025 This article is from Creation 46(2):54–55, April 2024 ‘The muddle in the middle’ illustration: frimages | EnvatoElement In September 2023 a news story broke about Homo bodoensis, a proposed new species of human ancestor recently named by scientists.1 In a research paper nearly two years earlier, Mirjana Roksandic et al.
Genetic research on the Denisovans
This article is from Journal of Creation 38(1):3–6, April 2024 In 2008 a scrap of human finger bone was discovered in Denisova Cave, an isolated cave in the Altai mountains of southern Siberia, and its mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) was sequenced in 2010.1 The mtDNA analysis of the finger bone (Denisova 3—a proximal fragment of a juvenile manual distal phalanx; see figure 1), allegedly from a layer dated to between 48 and 30 ka ago, reported that Neanderthals and Denisovans differed from modern...
'The Human Lineage'
This article is from Journal of Creation 37(3):36–41, December 2023 A review of: The Human Lineage, 2nd edn by Matt Cartmill and Fred H. Smith John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, NJ, 2022 This is the second edition of The Human Lineage by the authors. The first edition was published in 2009. Matt Cartmill is Professor of Anthropology at Boston University and Professor Emeritus of Evolutionary Anthropology at Duke University.
Developments in paleoanthropology no. 4
This article is from Journal of Creation 37(3):93–101, December 2023 Evidence Homo naledi buried their dead, made engravings, and used tools The previous paper in this series discussed newly found evidence, presented by paleoanthropologist Lee Berger, indicating Homo naledi used fire in the Rising Star cave system, South Africa.1 On 5 June 2023, at the Richard Leakey Memorial Conference at Stony Brook University, Berger announced that he and his team had also discovered evidence suggesting H.
Lucy at 50 has not aged well
This article is from Creation 46(4):20–23, October 2024 © Izanbar | Dreamstime.com The world-famous ‘Lucy’ was discovered in Ethiopia in 1974. The official name of the ~1-metre-tall partial skeleton (fig. 1) is AL 288-1, dated to allegedly ~3.2 million years ago (Ma). It was classified as Australopithecus afarensis. Even 50 years later, evolutionary experts such as Zeresenay Alemseged and Bernard Wood believe it is still the best candidate as ancestor of the genus Homo.1 A.
Developments in paleoanthropology no. 3
This article is from Journal of Creation 37(1):80–86, April 2023 New dates for Sterkfontein Australopithecus fossils On 27 June 2022 Granger et al. published new dates for the Sterkfontein Australopithecus fossils from South Africa.1 They used a method known as Cosmogenic Nuclide Burial Dating.2 In a nutshell: “The new ages are based on the radioactive decay of the rare isotopes aluminum-26 and beryllium-10 in the mineral quartz.
Revisiting Homo floresiensis
This article is from Journal of Creation 36(3):82–91, December 2022 The hobbit was never expected in any evolutionary narrative; it was incorporated ad hoc and patchily into an evolutionary story after its discovery. In late October 2004, newspaper headlines, such as “Lost race of human ‘hobbits’ unearthed on Indonesian island”,1 brought to mind J.R.R. Tolkien’s Middle-earth.
Ancient Chinese skull
This article is from Creation 46(1):46–47, January 2024 Wu Xiujie (IVPP) However, this does not suggest that more branches (or species) need to be added to the false evolutionary human family tree. Rather, it indicates that the ‘archaic’ humans (e.g., Neanderthals, Denisovans, Homo erectus) and ‘modern’ humans were interbreeding with each other. An ‘ancient’ juvenile human fossil skull (HLD 6) discovered in Hualongdong, China, in 2019 is puzzling evolutionary theorists.
Developments in paleoanthropology no. 2
This article is from Journal of Creation 36(1):89–98, April 2022 Browse our latest digital issue Subscribe This paper continues the theme begun in 2021 of discussing some of the fossil finds and/or developments in paleoanthropology from a creationist perspective. This includes the naming of a new species, Homo bodoensis, as well as the discovery of a juvenile skull, attributed to Homo naledi, from the Rising Star cave system of South Africa.
Dragon Man
This article is from Creation 44(1):41, January 2022 Browse our latest digital issue Subscribe On 25 June 2021, an international research team announced a proposed new human species from China, which they named Homo longi.1 The specimen is a well-preserved cranium (skull), called the Harbin cranium. It was first unearthed in the province Heilongjiang, meaning ‘Black Dragon River’ (the exact location is uncertain), so its owner was nicknamed ‘Dragon Man’.
Developments in paleoanthropology
This article is from Journal of Creation 35(3):116–124, December 2021 Browse our latest digital issue Subscribe This paper discusses some of the more recent fossil finds and/or developments in paleoanthropology from a creationist perspective. This includes a newly described Homo erectus cranium from South Africa, updates on Homo naledi, the controversy over a femur associated with Sahelanthropus tchadensis, and troubles for Australopithecus sediba.
DNA from Denisova cave
This article is from Journal of Creation 35(3):5–7, December 2021 Browse our latest digital issue Subscribe Демин Алексей Барнаул/CC BY-SA 4.0 On 23 June 2021 a study published by Zavala et al.
Homo erectus with stone tools
This article is from Journal of Creation 34(2):55–61, August 2020 In early March 2020 Semaw et al. published a paper titled “Co-occurrence of Acheulian and Oldowan artifacts with Homo erectus cranial fossils from Gona, Afar, Ethiopia”.1 The paper raises issues regarding Homo erectus that are important to address from a creation point of view.
Objection to bipedal apes sinking human evolution theory
by Peter Line Published: 17 April 2020 (GMT+10) A Focus item by me titled ‘‘Bipedal’ ape sinks human evolution theory’ (Creation, Vol. 42(2):11, 2020) raised objections from an evolutionist (see letter by Daniel P. below). As Focus items are of necessity very brief, I follow up the letter by first explaining my position in more detail before responding to Daniel on the main issues raised in his letter. Daniel P.
‘Out of Africa’ theory problems are growing
This article is from Creation 41(2):22–25, April 2019 Browse our latest digital issue Subscribe The favoured story of evolution is now struggling by Peter Line iStockphoto Most visitors to the American Museum of Natural History look in awe at the allegedly pre-human ‘apemen’ (a.k.a. ‘hominins’ or ‘hominids’), including those in the ‘Our Family Tree’ display (fig. 1).
Paleoanthropology in Australia - creation.com
This article is from Journal of Creation 32(3):88–96, December 2018 Browse our latest digital issue Subscribe by Peter Line Robust human fossil remains have been found in Australia, at sites like Kow Swamp and the Willandra Lakes region. Their identity in relation to specimens of Homo erectus, and their role in human ancestry, has been a controversial one.
Making sense of ‘Homo naledi’
This article is from Creation 40(4):36–38, October 2018 Browse our latest digital issue Subscribe by Peter Line Homo naledi skeletal material from the Dinaledi Chamber of the Rising Star cave system, including composite skeleton, centre, representing multiple individuals. Photo: CC Lee Roger Berger research team 1 / Wits University. In the field of human origins, a 2015 announcement caused a sensation.
What is Homo luzonensis?
Ape or man? by Matthew Cserhati, Peter Line, Joel Tay Published: 7 November 2019 (GMT+10) Figure 1. Map of Southeast Asia showing Wallace and Huxley lines as well as the location of CallaoCave (X) and Tabon Cave (+). From time to time the media is abuzz with news of yet another human fossil discovery. Each time researchers hope for more clues with which to try to piece together the alleged evolutionary picture of our origins.
New A. anamensis cranium undermines the human evolutionary tree.
by Peter Line Published: 6 September 2019 (GMT+10) Editors’ note: this article uses technical anatomical terms. The take-home message is that this new find does not in any way contribute to a believable story of human evolution from the apes. The media has been drooling over a newly reported australopithecine fossil cranium alleged to be an ‘ape-man’ (i.e., hominin) in our family tree. However, the evidence is strongly against the australopithecines being a human ancestor.
The incredible human brain
This article is from Creation 40(3):14–17, July 2018 As powerful evidence for a Designer’s existence, look no further than inside your head The human central nervous system (CNS) consists of the brain and spinal cord, including roughly 100 billion nerve cells, and about 10 times more neuroglia, or supporting cells. The nerve tissue outside the CNS is called the peripheral nervous system.
The incredible human brain
nerthuz/123RF Stock Photo Figure 1. The two hemispheres of the human brain. The human central nervous system (CNS) consists of the brain and spinal cord, including roughly 100 billion nerve cells, and about 10 times more neuroglia, or supporting cells. The nerve tissue outside the CNS is called the peripheral nervous system. It delivers sensory information to the CNS, as well as carrying commands from the CNS to organs, such as muscles and glands.
An overview of the Denisovan puzzle
As ancient DNA analysis has become increasingly common, the identity of the mysterious Denisovans has gradually been revealed, through knowledge of their genome, as well as from more fossil bones being identified as belonging to this population. Although a complete picture is not yet available for the Denisovan puzzle, pieces are starting to fall into place. Here, an overview of this fascinating subject is given from a non-evolutionary viewpoint.
Fossil evidence for alleged apemen—Part 1: the genus Homo - creation.com
by Peter Line This overview analyzes the fossil evidence for the alleged apemen within the genus Homo. The differences in morphological features of the fossil species included in Homo, excluding the invalid taxon Homo habilis, are believed to represent, among other factors, genetic variation within the one human kind. Homo habilis is believed to represent a collection of assorted fossils that either were human (e.g. Homo erectus) or were australopithecine apes.
Review of 'Sapiens’ by Yuval Harari
A review of: Sapiens: A brief history of humankind by Yuval Noah Harari Vintage Books, London, 2014 by Peter Line The book Sapiens: A brief history of humankind is written by Yuval Noah Harari, an Israeli historian who lectures at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. From his book Harari makes clear his belief that: “As far as we can tell, from a purely scientific viewpoint, human life has absolutely no meaning.
The myth of ape-to-human evolution
This article is from Creation 41(1):44–46, January 2019 Browse our latest digital issue Subscribe Being popular doesn’t make an idea scientifically plausible ©123rf.com/anolis01, ©123rf.com/theartofphoto The public is frequently led to think that the evidence of humans evolving from an apelike common ancestor with chimps is simply overwhelming.
Hyped hominin - creation.com
With the headline of a news item reading “Cranium of a four-million-year-old hominin shows similarities to that of modern humans” one might have expected a sensational finding. The study being highlighted examined the thickness of the cortical and spongy bone layers making up the flat bones in the roof of the skull.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Peter
Contact Peter, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack