Rob Breeding
As seen in:
Flathead Beacon,
Cody Enterprise
Twin daughter dad. Writer, teacher, outdoors columnist for @FlatheadBeacon. "They smelt of pubs, and Wormwood Scrubs, and too many right wing meetings"
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Rob Breeding
Retrieve, or Not to Retrieve
They say English setters don’t always care to retrieve. It’s been my experience that “they” are sometimes right. I’m two out of three on this fetching business. My first two English setters, Jack and Doll, were both fine retrievers, though they both came to that conclusion following different paths. Jack had a keen interest in birds on the ground, but in the early days of our hunting partnership, he seemed a little unclear on the concept. He found birds on the ground, but just didn’t pick them up.
Fall Bliss - Flathead Beacon
It was opening day last weekend. I had time for a short hunt. Work called, and while you might ask, “What kind of a hunter listens to that siren song on opening day?” I can only say reasons, but the weather offered cover. Surely, by now you’ve seen the chaos in the Southwest caused by record rains.
Dress-Up Season - Flathead Beacon
I don’t dress up for trick-or-treating on Halloween. I aged out of that action long ago. But if I did, I wouldn’t have to buy a costume if I wanted to go as a basic Bozeman/Whitefish/Missoula guy. That outfit is already in my closet. If you want or need a basic bro costume, Montana style, I suggest you visit Jonas Nichols Facebook page or his TikTok @jonas.rydell. He’s got all the Montana costumes covered — including outdoor influencer, old-school hunter and fake Montana cowboy.
They’re Onto Us - Flathead Beacon
Hunting season is finally upon us. I can tell because the leaves on the ash tree in the yard are turning red, despite a warmish, frost-free fall so far. That’s in my neighborhood, at least. Montana’s general hunting season opens Saturday, as does pheasant and quail season here, though the first week is for the youth hunters, so I’m obviously not eligible for another week. I’m hoping the ash will be full crimson by then. That blaze of glory each fall is my sign it’s time to let my dog loose on birds.
Speed to Burn - Flathead Beacon
The more we think we know, the more foolish we really are. And foolish, or at least impetuous, might be the best way to describe our understanding of North America’s fastest land mammal: the pronghorn. There was a time in the 1990s when scientists who study extinct animals began to spin a tale about why pronghorn are so dang fast; 60 mph fast. That speed seemed such a waste. Wolves top out in the 30s and coyotes creep into maybe the low 40s, so wouldn’t the high 40s be sufficient for speed goats?
Bearish on Montana Griz
Grizzly bears are doing fine. While the species is still listed as threatened in the Lower 48, we need to have a serious conversation about how to measure griz “recovery.” The Oct. 1 self-defense killing of a grizzly bear near Trego reminds us that our view of successful recovery may depend on how far we live from town. Grizzlies may never be fully recovered south of Canada.
Training Time - Flathead Beacon
I don’t really train my bird dogs. I’ve been lucky in that my three English setters have all taken quite naturally to hunting. Jade, the third of my line and the dog which will be my hunting partner again this year, started especially early. Jade was backing and pointing birds her first fall, at about 5 months old. Setter No. 2, Doll, managed most of Jade’s training. Doll was 10, and still an experienced, effective hunter, though she was slowing down.
Home is Where the Gas Money is
Hunting season is upon us. And hunting season means driving season, and that means hunting this fall will be a bit more expensive than a year ago. Things aren’t too bad if you’re filling up with gas. I checked the average cost of a gallon of regular this week: $4.48 according to AAA. A 350-mile highway drive, roughly the distance between Missoula and Billings, will cost a hunter in a 4×4 Ford F-150 with a 2.7 V6, $65.33.
Oryx on the Range
New Mexico’s oryx herd is apparently out of control. That’s gemsbok for those of you who are Safari Club fancy. Gemsbok are large African antelope with dagger-like horns, set loose in New Mexico by state biologists in a desert devoid of big game in the 1960s. Those biologists thought the animals would limit themselves to a single desert valley in the border region. They didn’t, and where those biologists imagined a small herd of a few hundred, there are now thousands of oryx, maybe 7,000.
A Summer with a Rooftop Rod Carrier
In May, I finally pulled the trigger on a purchase I’d mulled for a long time: I bought a rooftop fly rod carrier. This wasn’t exactly a need. The Huge Fly Fisherman likes to sneer on YouTube that the only folks who need a fly rod carrier are full-time guides, or folks who want to flex how accomplished fly fishers they are to any innocent bystanders they pass on the road. “Look at that rod case,” these bystanders say as I cruise past.
Pickled Peppers - Flathead Beacon
I’ve hunted doves, but it was many years ago and I’m not planning to again anytime soon. I’m not a huge fan of dove meat, but not hunting them mostly has to do with my proximity to good flights of mourning doves. There aren’t many around here, and dove is not the sort of destination hunt I’ll travel for. Dove breast is dark and filled with the flavor of muscles that push those birds to migrate hundreds, sometimes thousands of miles. Not everyone is a fan of that slow-twitch, myoglobin-rich meat.
When the Weather Turns
There’s always a day in late summer when the weather turns and the days of blistering heat give way to a hint of fall. It usually comes sometime in August. The sooner the better as far as I’m concerned. August is a contender in my least-favorite month contest. It’s usually hotter than I prefer, whether I’m roaming the Rockies on my summer break or back home, where the humidity makes me feel like I’m wrapped in a half-dozen damp wool blankets whenever I’m outside.
Tiger vs. Wild Thing, Part III
We’ve established what the Tiger Woods, John “Wild Thing” Daly meme represents. Tiger stands in for the established traditions of hunting and fishing. Wild Things are the rule-breakers. Instead of tweed or Gore-Tex, when the weather turns foul, they wear an old coat held together with camo duct tape. My two previous columns on the topic provide more clarity if you haven’t yet read them. Last week we graded anglers on the Tiger/Wild Thing spectrum.
Tiger or Wild Thing? Part II
Last week we established that the Tiger Woods/John Daly meme could be useful in examining strains of outdoor-loving humans. Tigers, the meme tells us, are the formal, sometimes highfalutin sort that usually follows the long-established norms of outdoor recreation. These norms sometimes mean how you do it is often more important than how successful you are. Wild Things (that’s one of Daly’s nicknames) are the rule breakers.
Are You a ‘Tiger’ or a ‘Wild Thing’? Part I
There’s a meme I’m quite fond of, and I suspect you’ve seen it too. It’s built on a photo of Tiger Woods and John Daly, staring down one another on the green, during a practice round. Woods, whose back is to the camera, is smartly attired in Nike golfing threads, including a white cap, a white long-sleeved shirt under a black sweater vest, and black trousers.
Streamers! But Where? - Flathead Beacon
It’s almost the first week of August, so of course rivers across the Northern Rockies are closing down for the season. It didn’t always use to be this way. Rivers would sometimes shut down, of course. It’s hot in August. But it wasn’t the annual, widespread thing it’s become. This could spoil my late-summer plans.
Moving Game Around
A few years back, I wrote about a float trip on the Stillwater River, a float that included catching a brown trout near where the Stillwater joined the Yellowstone River. It was a nice way to cap a great float with an old friend; someone I used to work with at the Kalispell Target before we both moved away.
Holding the Line
I recently treated myself to a pair of new fly rods. It has been a long time since I last upgraded, and while the old stuff still works fine, sometimes new is satisfying even if it’s only incrementally better. Your favorite fly shop is loaded with rods priced from a few hundred bucks to a few grand, and even the kit rods are better than anything I could get my hands on in the 1980s when I started fly fishing. Everything’s better now. My marginally better new rods have some practical advantages.
Blessed are the Bluegill
There are circumstances where bluegill are the perfect fish. They are pretty, hard-fighting, numerous, and sometimes, when you want a fish for a kid who needs something to do, bluegill are unrivaled. I was that kid this weekend. I recently ordered a pair of new fly rods, along with new reels and line. I picked out the parts I wanted and ordered them from various fly shops and manufacturers. The pieces have been trickling in for the last week.
One Box Short - Flathead Beacon
I’ve got plenty of flies in my vest. If I were smarter, I’d organize and consolidate them into fewer fly boxes and become a more efficient, ruthless fly fisher. Instead, I waste time rummaging through a multitude of containers until I find something I guess will work. Case in point, last week I was fishing one of my favorite pothole lakes. It’s managed as a put-grow-and-release fishery, and like a lot of potholes it’s full of scuds, so those stocker fingerlings grow fast.
Inspector Gadget
This has become my year of collecting fly-fishing gadgets. A hook threader is the newest doohickey hanging from my vest. I first heard of threaders years ago, while working in fly shops. Customers, usually older but not exclusively so, would ask for them. I don’t remember ever carrying these tools, and I’m not pleased with my younger self when I recall I sometimes made snide jokes after the age-challenged anglers left, in search of a more sympathetic establishment.
On the Road - Flathead Beacon
One of the benefits of being a teacher is summer travel. There’s often still much work to do, but most of it can follow you on the road. I love my summer reset. I’ve been away almost a month now, and there’s not much waiting for me back home other than Great Plains heat, humidity and an overgrown yard thriving in the rainy weather that started after I left. Still, it’s home and I’m ready to be back.
Desperately Contesting Corner Crossing
In soccer, nothing is worse than an own goal. That goes double for politics. There’s a difference in how athletes and politicians react to their mistakes, however. Most soccer players, burdened as they are with self-awareness, are anguished when they put the ball in their own net. Now consider your average politician’s reaction to a mistake. They deny. They project. They pretend and delude, convincing themselves that their own goal wasn’t a mistake, but an act of civic virtue.
The Slow Season - Flathead Beacon
Late May can be the slowest of seasons. Case in point: I was on The Blackfoot River the other day, but I didn’t bring my fly rod. Despite being fly rod free, I finally did a thing. For the first time, I attended a gig at the KettleHouse Amphitheater. Les Claypool, Primus frontman, performed with that band, and two of his side projects, Les Claypool’s Frog Brigade and The Claypool Lennon Delirium.
Geeking Out on Gear
I remember my first landing net. It was made from lightweight aluminum tubing, bent in that classic, teardrop shape. The netting was woven from rough, green plastic cord better suited for a gill net. A loop of elastic cord hung from the handle. I used that cord to attach the net to my cloth vest. It stayed tied to my vest and stretched out when landing a fish. The net hung awkwardly, heavy end down, and swung wildly as I fished. It also banged against my legs when I walked.
Inconvenient Fly Fishing
I’ve finally ended the chaos of fishing. I bought myself a rooftop fly rod carrier. Satisfying my “need” to end this chaos might be considered dramatic in conventional circles. I can say this much — not breaking down my setup after every fishing trip, then re-rigging the next time on the water is the mildest of inconveniences. I’ve just finished fishing or I’m about to be fishing at either end of this great imposition on my free time, so really, do I have anything to complain about?
Trout That Still Count
Last week I highlighted my favorite trout. To be clear, when I say “my favorite trout,” I’m also saying “my favorite fish” — salt or freshwater. This week, the rest of the best. Brookies — I’ve caught a handful of brookies through the years, though not too many. Brook trout are eastern trout, introduced to the West as people who’d left their fish behind decided they’d like to bring them along.
The Best Trout - Flathead Beacon
My daughter recently asked which is my favorite trout. I told her, “It’s complicated.” While that is my truth, this answer was inadequate and she demanded I choose. At her insistence, I meekly answered, “Cutthroat,” and moved on. That’s my usual answer when pushed — the westslope cutthroat trout to be exact. “It’s complicated” is most accurate, however. I can’t pick just one, but I have a list of contenders, as well as a few species of trout I love, though not quite as much as the top tier.
New Tech, Same Old Stupid
Every spring, new gear hits your neighborhood fly shop. It’s a good idea to ask questions to avoid doing something stupid once you’re on the water. Case in point: I visited a favorite tailwater earlier this spring and did a little nymphing. It went well. I caught a few nice trout, though upon more careful examination of photos of a pair of 17-inch brown trout taken from the same hole on back-to-back days, I suspect these were the same fish.
Thinking of Fall, Already
It’s not summer yet, but I can’t help myself. Fall is always on my mind. Especially a place I spent a good chunk of my time in November: shelterbelts. Shelterbelts are bird magnets, so despite some of the challenges they pose, you must learn to hunt them. Conifers provide thermal cover in winter when the bare twigs of deciduous trees are of little use. And the birds also appreciate the bare dirt beneath the trees and use it for loafing cover between feeding sessions.
What’s a Fly, Anyway?
Some folks grew up fishing. I envy them. The fishing of my youth was limited to a trip or two in the summer, and it was generally the same old thing. We’d go to the lake and fish Zeke’s Floating Bait for trout. Even when it worked, which was rare, it was still rather boring. My dad was set in his ways. Bait fishing for trout was his jam and he seldom tried something new.
The Power of Friendly
Most homes have dog rules. For some, in the proper climate, the rules mean dogs live outdoors. In others, with proper early training, they are allowed inside, but must stay off the sofa. In other homes, dogs rule the joint. That’s mine. The only rule I have is no dogs in bed, and I’d probably give that one up too if I weren’t such a light sleeper. My dogs sometimes wake me with just a vigorous stretch from their dog bed across the room.
Worm Lord of Fly Fishing
Long ago, in a fly-fishing life far away, I used to lean quite heavily on the Renegade as my dry fly of choice. I learned to fly fish on streams that lacked the kind of megahatches Montana is known for; hatches so thick everyone, including the trout, takes notice. Hatches where the insects rise like cumulus just above the water and the trout refuse imitations even slightly off from the real thing. No, on my home waters I don’t recall a hatch that captivated a river’s inhabitants that way.
Big Black Birds - Flathead Beacon
It’s spring break and I’m in the mountains for the week. I hope to fish on a nearby tailwater, but this time of year there are no guarantees. It snowed the day after I arrived. Fortunately, it was just a bit and is mostly melted off by now. During the storm one of my favorite birds stopped by. A raven flew into the yard and found a suitable perch in a birch tree. It stayed there some time, long enough for me to get distracted and turn away.
How’s the Weather?
I don’t know how the weather is where you are, but where I am, it’s been shorts weather. People who know me well know that I’m prone to pushing the limits of shorts weather well past the time most folks have given up dungarees cutoff abruptly above the knees. I might sport a stocking cap, a puffy coat, jorts, and my favorite winter wear, socks with sandals, this time of year.
Hunter Harassment Tragedy Incoming
I miss the time when I enjoyed social media. I yearn for those days before the media moguls who run these platforms decided money-making algorithms, rather than user preference, determined what we see.
Wolves at the Door
A long running joke in the West’s wolf saga is that reintroduction supporters will change their tune once endangered wolves/griz/pupfish/tortoises make their way to coastal cities. Then, those big-city elites will get a taste of their own medicine. This just goes to show how little folks in the interior West and the coastal cities know about one another.
Sing it While You Can
An old friend died this week. Fortunately, I had a chance to see him again just after he left. I’ve always been a fan of actor Robert Duvall. He played Captain “Gus” McCrae in television’s “Lonesome Dove.” That miniseries swept across the West from Texas to Montana and back again as McCrae and his former companion from the Texas Rangers, Captain Woodrow F. Call, (played by Tommy Lee Jones) leads a herd of stolen cattle north to the promise of a fresh start in pristine Montana.
Moving Fish Around
If you’ve ever caught a rainbow trout in Montana you’ve benefited from bucket biology. It’s true that redband trout, a rainbow subspecies, inhabit the Kootenai River, so if you catch one there, it could be a native Montanan. Elsewhere, Montana rainbows and brown trout were introduced to the state by bucket biologists.
Reeling in the Years
It’s easy for me to tell when it’s winter, but this has nothing to do with the weather. It was sunny and mild today. The weekend’s skiff of snow is a faded memory. So, it’s not the weather that reminds me it’s winter as weather has become an unreliable tool for determining seasons. Instead, I know it’s winter because I spent half the afternoon online, shopping for fly reels. I’m more obsessive about this bit of gear than most fly fishers.
End of the Season
I can be a little melancholy this time of year. It’s late January, and here at least, the bird hunting season closes at the end of the month. That’s Saturday. Three days away. I’ll be at work until the end of the week, so if I’m hunting again this season, it will have to be Saturday. I’m not yet sure if I’m going, however. We’ll see how the weather looks in the morning. The Arctic Express that rolled across the continent this week has been my foil. Saturday is forecast to be in the high 20s.
Some years ago, while a was visiting friends out of state, I came down with a severe case of stomach pain. I went to a clinic and the following morning, out came my appendix. Appendicitis isn’t to be taken lightly. That small, narrow pouch, about the size of your pinkie finger, attached to your large intestine, can grow inflamed, and if it bursts, can spread infection through your abdominal cavity. And that can kill you.
Life in a Hallmark Movie
I follow a jokester on social media and the other day she posted this: “Now’s about the time the big-city girl starts having doubts about the small-town Christmas tree salesman she gave up her career for.” Funny, and also a useful trope about the complexities of relationships, but I don’t mean boy-girl relationships. Instead, the Hallmark Christmas movie is useful to help understand our relationship with place, especially a small-town, rural place.
New Outdoor Paradigm
After the recent death of a Colorado woman attacked by a mountain lion on New Year’s Day, the behavior of outdoor adventurers in the West may change, permanently. Many of us share our favorite outdoor spaces with lions, in surprisingly close proximity. But lion attacks have been so rare we’ve never treated them as much of a threat. This latest death may change that. We’ve learned who the victim was in this case, Kristen Marie Kovatch, a 46-year-old resident of Fort Collins.
Best News of 2025
There were two major victories in 2025 for citizens who use and love public lands. The first was the bipartisan rejection of Utah Sen. Mike Lee’s lust for destroying the public lands legacy that is a fundamental element of freedom and prosperity in the American West. Lee thought he could slip destructive public-lands legislation into the budget reconciliation bill in the spring. Fortunately, the effort failed, epically.
Fall in Line - Flathead Beacon
Last week I wrote about lines. Insurmountable lines. Lines we dare not cross. I was inspired by that line about lines in the opening paragraph of “A River Runs Through It,” and that world of more than a century ago when lines weren’t meant as suggestions. These days we more often see lines as something to be tested, challenged. Is it a line at all, or just a foolish convention of the past? Norman Maclean told us there was no clear line between fly fishing and religion in his family.
The Line Between
In my family, there was no clear line between religion and fly fishing, because there were no clear lines. No clear lines between bird hunting and religion either, nor sports and religion. After a cursory glance this might not seem so. Before my mother’s family gave its blessing to her marriage, my father first had to promise my Sicilian grandmother and Irish grandfather that he would raise their grandchildren in the Catholic faith. Dad agreed, though I realize now he had his fingers crossed.
Living in the Past
I’m still on Cloud Nine a bit. I had such a good time on the Chukar Grounds last week, killing a limit of five before Thanksgiving, that I took the rest of the week off. “Why not?” I figured. “My brain is still brimming with thoughts of a day of nearly perfect shooting. No need to clutter that up.” I did go out again, the day after Thanksgiving, but weather had moved in.
Happy Thanksgiving from the Chukar Grounds
Bird hunting can be humbling and exhilarating, often compressing these extremes in a weekend or day, or even brief moments between shots. I was fortunate to return to the chukar grounds before Thanksgiving. A friend, whose guest room I commandeer when I hunt chukars, is moving to Spain after the first of the year, so I planned one last visit to his hunting lodge. He gave me clear orders: kill some birds for Thanksgiving dinner.
No Better Place to Begin
I wanted to make sure my children had it better than me, so I made sure they were born in Montana. My daughters know the place I grew up and they have some idea of what that place is like. It might not be the opposite of Montana, but it is very different. I will always have deep affection for where I grew up, but as the adult me began to emerge in my 20s, I had an uneasy sense I wasn’t living the kind of life I wanted to live. I felt excommunicated from nature in Southern California.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Rob
Contact Rob, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack