In what circumstances can a plaintiff pierce the corporate veil and hold shareholders personally liable for the corporation's wrongful conduct? In its recent decision in Chanderpaul v. Caesars Convention Centre Ltd., 2026 ONCA 332, the Court of Appeal for Ontario affirmed that plaintiffs face a very high onus where they seek to pierce the corporate veil, but provided important guidance on the types of conduct that may attract personal liability.
Robert Staley
As seen in:
National Post,
Ottawa Citizen,
JD Supra,
Lexology,
Mondaq,
Fernie Free Press,
Law360 Canada
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Robert Staley
Court Reaffirms Limits on Norwich Orders in Crypto Asset Disputes
In Nivora Group LLC v. Ping et al., 2026 ONSC 2943, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice dismissed a motion for a Norwich order seeking third-party disclosure from two cryptocurrency exchanges in an alleged asset misappropriation dispute. The Court's decision stands as an important reminder that Norwich orders are exceptional remedies and cannot be invoked to circumvent the usual discovery process.
Ontario Court Of Appeal Clarifies The Test For Piercing The Corporate Veil
Bennett Jones LLP are most popular: within Insurance, Coronavirus (COVID-19) and Compliance topic(s) with Inhouse Counsel with readers working within the Business & Consumer Services, Healthcare and Technology industries In what circumstances can a plaintiff pierce the corporate veil and hold shareholders personally liable for the corporation's wrongful conduct? In its recent decision in Chanderpaul v.
Court Reaffirms Limits On Norwich Orders In Crypto Asset Disputes
Bennett Jones LLP are most popular: within Insurance, Coronavirus (COVID-19) and Compliance topic(s) with Inhouse Counsel with readers working within the Business & Consumer Services, Healthcare and Technology industries In Nivora Group LLC v. Ping et al., 2026 ONSC 2943, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice dismissed a motion for a Norwich order seeking third-party disclosure from two cryptocurrency exchanges in an alleged asset misappropriation dispute.
Inferring Materiality From Share Price Movement: Dziedziejko V Canopy Growth
Robert Staley’s articles from Bennett Jones LLP are most popular: with Senior Company Executives, HR and Finance and Tax Executives in Canada with readers working within the Advertising & Public Relations, Business & Consumer Services and Healthcare industries In Dziedziejko v Canopy Growth, 2025 ONSC 6766, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice concluded that materiality can be inferred from a drop in a public issuer's share price following the correction of an admitted misstatement,...
Inferring Materiality from Share Price Movement: Dziedziejko v Canopy Growth
In Dziedziejko v Canopy Growth, 2025 ONSC 6766, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice concluded that materiality can be inferred from a drop in a public issuer's share price following the correction of an admitted misstatement, justifying leave to commence a secondary market misrepresentation claim under the Ontario Securities Act.
Binance v. OSC : Court Of Appeal Addresses Scope Of Charter Review In Securities Investigations
Robert Staley’s articles from Bennett Jones LLP are most popular: with Inhouse Counsel in Canada with readers working within the Insurance, Healthcare and Law Firm industries In its recent decision in Binance Holdings Limited v.
Binance v. OSC: Court of Appeal Addresses Scope of Charter Review in Securities Investigations
In its recent decision in Binance Holdings Limited v. Ontario Securities Commission, 2025 ONCA 751, the Ontario Court of Appeal has clarified the limits of the Ontario Securities Commission’s (the OSC) powers under the Securities Act to require production of documents and the Charter protections available to entities responding to regulatory inquires.
Ontario Securities Act No-Reprisal Provisions Results In C$5.3 Million Award To CEO : A Warning To Regulated Employers
David Cassin’s articles from Bennett Jones LLP are most popular: in Canada Bennett Jones LLP are most popular: with Senior Company Executives, HR and Finance and Tax Executives with readers working within the Banking & Credit, Healthcare and Law Firm industries The recent decision in McPherson v Global Growth Assets Inc., 2025 ONSC 5226, (McPherson) is the first time the Ontario Superior Court of Justice has interpreted the protection from reprisal provisions under Ontario's Securities Act...
Ontario Securities Act No-Reprisal Provisions Results in C$5.3 Million Award to CEO: A Warning to Regulated Employers
The recent decision in McPherson v Global Growth Assets Inc., 2025 ONSC 5226, (McPherson) is the first time the Ontario Superior Court of Justice has interpreted the protection from reprisal provisions under Ontario’s Securities Act (Part ) (OSA). The protection from reprisal provisions came into force on July 1, 2016 and prohibit companies from reprising against an employee because the employee engaged in certain protected activities.
Sinclair v. Venezia Turismo : The SCC Clarifies Approach To Jurisdiction Against Multiple Defendants In Cross-Border Disputes
Bennett Jones LLP are most popular: within Compliance, Family and Matrimonial and Wealth Management topic(s) with Senior Company Executives, HR and Finance and Tax Executives with readers working within the Banking & Credit and Healthcare industries In Sinclair v. Venezia Turismo, 2025 SCC 27, the Supreme Court of Canada has provided important guidance on when a Canadian court can assume jurisdiction over foreign defendants.
Sinclair v. Venezia Turismo: The SCC Clarifies Approach to Jurisdiction Against Multiple Defendants in Cross-Border Disputes
In Sinclair v. Venezia Turismo, 2025 SCC 27, the Supreme Court of Canada has provided important guidance on when a Canadian court can assume jurisdiction over foreign defendants. Importantly, following Sinclair, a plaintiff wishing to sue multiple defendants in Canada must establish a real and substantial connection between the jurisdiction, the subject matter of the dispute and each defendant, not just the subject matter of the dispute as a whole.
Letter to the Editor: Blue blooded voter moves left in federal election
It was a wonderful Easter, the vestiges of winter still apparent in this area of the Deep South of the great white north, but new life is bursting forth! Our friend Pope Francis has had the grace to ascend to the next world in self defence after the visit of J.D. Vance. Now he will really have the resources to complete his studies on the origins of those unidentified anomalous phenomena he investigated back in Argentina. I hope he meets up with Qassem Soleimani and they bury the hatchet.
Chambers Global Ranks Bennett Jones Lawyers in 2025 Guide
|
By Melanie Aitken, Sabrina A. Bandali, Thomas A. Bauer, David Bursey, James Clare, Curtis Cusinato, Emrys Davis, Zirjan Derwa, Sarah Gilbert, Leonard Griffiths, Jehad Haymour, Jessica Horwitz, Randal T. Hughes, Dominique T. Hussey, Greg Johnson, Adam Kalbfleisch, David Little, David Macaulay Verified, Jonathan McCullough, John Mercury, Linda Misetich Dann, Shawn Munro, Anu Nijhawan, Mark Rasile, James Rumball, Raj Sahni, Robert Staley, Sean Zweig, Kevin Zych, Martin Valasek, Richard Swan, Karen Dawson, Christian Gauthier, Martin Ignasiak KC, James McClary, Kelsey Meyer, Matthew Flynn, Michael S. Shakra
|
bennettjones.com
Bennett Jones has been recognized in the Chambers Global Guide 2025, with 49 lawyers ranked across 19 practice areas. Clients in Canada and around the world trust us to navigate their most complex legal matters. Our inclusion in the Chambers Global Guide 2025 highlights our commitment to an exceptional client experience, deep industry knowledge and long-standing client relationships.
Considering Australian Securities Law When Drafting Arrangement Agreements To Acquire Australia-Based Companies
As a recent decision by the Australian Takeovers Panel (Panel) has confirmed, Canadian issuers looking to complete a merger or strategic transaction with an Australian counterparty in a Canadian plan of arrangement, subject to Canadian law, will need to give careful consideration to applicable requirements of Australian securities law.
Considering Australian Securities Law When Drafting Arrangement Agreements to Acquire Australia-Based Companies | JD Supra
As a recent decision by the Australian Takeovers Panel (Panel) has confirmed, Canadian issuers looking to complete a merger or strategic transaction with an Australian counterparty in a Canadian plan of arrangement, subject to Canadian law, will need to give careful consideration to applicable requirements of Australian securities law.
Considering Australian Securities Law When Drafting Arrangement Agreements to Acquire Australia-Based
As a recent decision by the Australian Takeovers Panel (Panel) has confirmed, Canadian issuers looking to complete a merger or strategic transaction with an Australian counterparty in a Canadian plan of arrangement, subject to Canadian law, will need to give careful consideration to applicable requirements of Australian securities law.
Robert W. Staley
Overview Robert Staley's practice focuses on complex commercial and securities litigation, securities regulation, shareholder activism and class actions. Rob has extensive experience in Canadian and cross-border securities regulatory and enforcement matters, class actions, takeover bid litigation, foreign corrupt practices, appraisal and share valuation remedies, derivative actions, arrangements and the oppression remedy.
Fintech In Canada Q3 2024
The Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) has once again extended the deadline for registered crypto-trading platforms to address trading in value referenced crypto assets (VRCAs). VRCAs, better known as "stablecoins", are crypto assets designed to maintain a stable or pegged value relative to a specified fiat currency or other asset. Stablecoins have become popular with crypto investors and are frequently used to facilitate the trading, borrowing and lending of other crypto assets.
Ontario court rules that directors cannot be removed by shareholder proposal
By Robert W. Staley and Douglas A. Fenton ( October 23, 2024, 2:37 PM EDT) -- In OneMove Capital Corporation v. Dye & Durham Limited, 2024 ONSC 5114, the court concluded that shareholders may not submit a proposal under s. 99 of the Ontario Business Corporations Act (OBCA) for the purpose of removing a director from office. Section 99 permits a voting shareholder to advance a “proposal” for consideration by shareholders, and such a proposal may include advancing a candidate for election to the board.
Ontario Superior Court Rules That Section 99 Of The Ontario Business Corporations Act Does Not Confer Powers To Bring A Proposal To Remove A Director
In OneMove Capital Corporation v Dye & Durham Limited, 2024 ONSC 5114 (OneMove), Justice Penny of the Commercial List division of the Ontario Superior Court concluded that shareholders may not submit a proposal under s. 99 of the Ontario Business Corporations Act (OBCA) for the purpose of removing a director from office.
Ontario Superior Court Rules That Section 99 of the Ontario Business Corporations Act Does Not Confer | JD Supra
[co-author: Emma Danaher - Articling Student] In OneMove Capital Corporation v Dye & Durham Limited, 2024 ONSC 5114 (OneMove), Justice Penny of the Commercial List division of the Ontario Superior Court concluded that shareholders may not submit a proposal under s. 99 of the Ontario Business Corporations Act (OBCA) for the purpose of removing a director from office.
Ontario Superior Court Rules That Section 99 of the Ontario Business Corporations Act Does Not Confer
In OneMove Capital Corporation v Dye & Durham Limited, 2024 ONSC 5114 (OneMove), Justice Penny of the Commercial List division of the Ontario Superior Court concluded that shareholders may not submit a proposal under s. 99 of the Ontario Business Corporations Act (OBCA) for the purpose of removing a director from office.
Ontario Superior Court Rules That Section 99 of the Ontario Business Corporations Act Does Not Confer Powers to Bring a Proposal to Remove a Director
In OneMove Capital Corporation v Dye & Durham Limited, 2024 ONSC 5114 (OneMove), Justice Penny of the Commercial List division of the Ontario Superior Court concluded that shareholders may not submit a proposal under s. 99 of the Ontario Business Corporations Act (OBCA) for the purpose of removing a director from office.
The Supreme Court Holds That Securities Disgorgement Orders Survive Bankruptcy
In ruling that a securities regulatory authority's disgorgement orders (a sanction stemming from misconduct) survive a bankruptcy discharge while its administrative penalties do not, the Supreme Court of Canada endorsed the principle that "every claim is swept into the bankruptcy and that the bankrupt is released from all of them upon being discharged unless the law sets out a clear exclusion or exemption." The Supreme Court's decision clarifies the differing treatment of administrative...
The Supreme Court Holds That Securities Disgorgement Orders Survive Bankruptcy | JD Supra
In ruling that a securities regulatory authority's disgorgement orders (a sanction stemming from misconduct) survive a bankruptcy discharge while its administrative penalties do not, the Supreme Court of Canada endorsed the principle that "every claim is swept into the bankruptcy and that the bankrupt is released from all of them upon being discharged unless the law sets out a clear exclusion or exemption." The Supreme Court’s decision clarifies the differing treatment of administrative...
The Supreme Court Holds That Securities Disgorgement Orders Survive Bankruptcy
In ruling that a securities regulatory authority's disgorgement orders (a sanction stemming from misconduct) survive a bankruptcy discharge while its administrative penalties do not, the Supreme Court of Canada endorsed the principle that "every claim is swept into the bankruptcy and that the bankrupt is released from all of them upon being discharged unless the law sets out a clear exclusion or exemption." The Supreme Court’s decision clarifies the differing treatment of administrative...
Bennett Jones Partners Lead Benchmark Top 50 Trial Lawyers in Canada 2024 Rankings
Bennett Jones has six lawyers ranked in Benchmark's Top 50 Trial Lawyers in Canada for 2024, more than any other firm. The Top 50 is an elite echelon that covers a wide range of practice areas across Canada, and captures truly the best of the best in trial law. Bennett Jones has also been ranked in the top category as a Highly Recommended Firm in British Columbia, Alberta, Ontario and Québec in the 2024 Edition of Benchmark Canada.
Ontario Superior Court Refuses To Enforce Crypto Giant's
In Lochan v Binance Holdings Limited, 2023 ONSC 6714 (Binance), the Ontario Superior Court dismissed a motion brought by Binance Holdings Limited (Binance), the world's largest crypto trading platform, to stay a proposed class proceeding in favour of an arbitration agreement users had to agree to before engaging with the platform.
Ontario Superior Court Refuses to Enforce Crypto Giant’s "All-but-inaccessible" Arbitration Clause | JD Supra
[co-author: Miranda Cooper - Articling Student] In Lochan v Binance Holdings Limited, 2023 ONSC 6714 (Binance), the Ontario Superior Court dismissed a motion brought by Binance Holdings Limited (Binance), the world’s largest crypto trading platform, to stay a proposed class proceeding in favour of an arbitration agreement users had to agree to before engaging with the platform.
Ontario Superior Court Refuses to Enforce Crypto Giant’s "All-but-inaccessible" Arbitration Clause
In Lochan v Binance Holdings Limited, 2023 ONSC 6714 (Binance), the Ontario Superior Court dismissed a motion brought by Binance Holdings Limited (Binance), the world’s largest crypto trading platform, to stay a proposed class proceeding in favour of an arbitration agreement users had to agree to before engaging with the platform.
Ontario Court Of Appeal In Buduchnist Credit Union Affirms Broad Jurisdiction To Address Breaches Of Mareva Orders
In Buduchnist Credit Union Limited v. 2321197 Ontario Inc., 2024 ONCA 57 (Buduchnist), the Court of Appeal for Ontario has affirmed that superior courts have broad and flexible jurisdiction to address breaches of interlocutory Mareva orders granted to freeze a defendant's assets pending trial. The Court of Appeal has also affirmed a broad approach to the assets captured by Mareva injunctions issued based on the Commercial List Model Mareva Order.
The Supreme Court Of Canada Recognizes Privacy Rights In IP Addresses
In a first-of-its-kind decision, R. v. Bykovets, 2024 SCC 6 (Bykovets), the Supreme Court of Canada has adopted a broad view of internet privacy—at least in the criminal and public authority context—finding that internet protocol (IP) addresses attract a reasonable expectation of privacy protected by section 8 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms (the Charter).
Ontario Court of Appeal in Buduchnist Credit Union Affirms Broad Jurisdiction to Address Breaches of Mareva Orders | JD Supra
[co-author: Asif Zalfackruddin - Articling Student] In Buduchnist Credit Union Limited v. 2321197 Ontario Inc., 2024 ONCA 57 (Buduchnist),the Court of Appeal for Ontario has affirmed that superior courts have broad and flexible jurisdiction to address breaches of interlocutory Mareva orders granted to freeze a defendant's assets pending trial. The Court of Appeal has also affirmed a broad approach to the assets captured by Mareva injunctions issued based on the Commercial List Model Mareva Order.
The Supreme Court of Canada Recognizes Privacy Rights in IP Addresses | JD Supra
In a first-of-its-kind decision, R. v. Bykovets, 2024 SCC 6 (Bykovets), the Supreme Court of Canada has adopted a broad view of internet privacy—at least in the criminal and public authority context—finding that internet protocol (IP) addresses attract a reasonable expectation of privacy protected by section 8 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms (the Charter).
The Supreme Court of Canada Recognizes Privacy Rights in IP Addresses
In a first-of-its-kind decision, R. v. Bykovets, 2024 SCC 6 (Bykovets), the Supreme Court of Canada has adopted a broad view of internet privacy—at least in the criminal and public authority context—finding that internet protocol (IP) addresses attract a reasonable expectation of privacy protected by section 8 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms (the Charter).
Ontario Court of Appeal in Buduchnist Credit Union Affirms Broad Jurisdiction to Address Breaches of
In Buduchnist Credit Union Limited v. 2321197 Ontario Inc., 2024 ONCA 57 (Buduchnist),the Court of Appeal for Ontario has affirmed that superior courts have broad and flexible jurisdiction to address breaches of interlocutory Mareva orders granted to freeze a defendant's assets pending trial. The Court of Appeal has also affirmed a broad approach to the assets captured by Mareva injunctions issued based on the Commercial List Model Mareva Order.
Supreme Court Finds The Premier's Mandate Letters Exempt From Disclosure
In ruling that the Ontario government is not required to turn over Cabinet mandate letters, the Supreme Court of Canada has adopted a broad and expansive view of Cabinet confidentiality. The Supreme Court's decision brings clarity to not only the scope of protection afforded to Cabinet records under freedom of information legislation, but more broadly to the constitutional sanctity of Cabinet secrecy. At issue in Ontario (Attorney General) v.
Supreme Court Finds the Premier’s Mandate Letters Exempt from Disclosure | JD Supra
[co-author: Miranda Cooper - Articling Student] In ruling that the Ontario government is not required to turn over Cabinet mandate letters, the Supreme Court of Canada has adopted a broad and expansive view of Cabinet confidentiality. The Supreme Court's decision brings clarity to not only the scope of protection afforded to Cabinet records under freedom of information legislation, but more broadly to the constitutional sanctity of Cabinet secrecy.
Supreme Court Finds the Premier’s Mandate Letters Exempt from Disclosure
In ruling that the Ontario government is not required to turn over Cabinet mandate letters, the Supreme Court of Canada has adopted a broad and expansive view of Cabinet confidentiality. The Supreme Court's decision brings clarity to not only the scope of protection afforded to Cabinet records under freedom of information legislation, but more broadly to the constitutional sanctity of Cabinet secrecy. Background At issue in Ontario (Attorney General) v.
Bennett Jones Partners Lead Benchmark Top 50 Trial Lawyers in Canada Rankings
Subscribe Stay informed on the latest business and legal insights and events.
Forty Bennett Jones Lawyers Recognized In Benchmark Canada 2023
|
By Gannon Beaulne, Jonathan Bell, David Bursey, Lincoln Caylor, Jeilah Chan, Alan Gardner, Laura Gill, David Gruber, Randal T. Hughes, Dominique T. Hussey, Martin Ignasiak KC, Justin Lambert, David McKinnon, Amanda McLachlan, E. Bruce Mellett, Kelsey Meyer, Munaf Mohamed KC, Michael Mysak, Jim Patterson, Ruth Promislow, Julia Schatz, Chris Simard, Michael C. Smith, Michaël Smith, Robert Staley, Richard Swan, Melanie Teetaert, Michael Theroux, Maureen Ward, Cheryl Woodin, Sean Zweig, Kevin Zych, Lamont Bartlett
|
bennettjones.com
Subscribe Stay informed on the latest business and legal insights and events.
COVID-19 And Annual Shareholder Meetings
To print this article, all you need is to be registered or login on Mondaq.com. As a result of measures designed to limit the spread of COVID-19, Canadian public companies are reconsidering typical approaches to annual meetings of shareholders. Many public companies are deciding to hold virtual or hybrid meetings this year. And some public companies are delaying previously-called meetings to permit electronic participation. What Are Virtual and Hybrid Meetings?
Supreme Court Denies Leave to Appeal Dismissal of Auditor Negligence Claim | JD Supra
Updated: May 25, 2018: JD Supra is a legal publishing service that connects experts and their content with broader audiences of professionals, journalists and associations.
Don’t Short the Truth
A recent decision of the Alberta Securities Commission appears to give short-sellers wide latitude to negatively comment on targets, and sets a potentially high burden on ASC Staff when seeking interim orders to address potentially damaging commentary. "Shorting" is selling a position before its price declines intending to buy it back when the price bottoms out.
Ontario Court of Appeal Affirms Limits on Auditor Liability | JD Supra
JD Supra is a legal publishing service that connects experts and their content with broader audiences of professionals, journalists and associations. This Privacy Policy describes how JD Supra, LLC ("JD Supra" or "we," "us," or "our") collects, uses and shares personal data collected from visitors to our website (located at www.jdsupra.com) (our "Website") who view only publicly-available content as well as subscribers to our services (such as our email digests or author tools)(our "Services").
Ontario Court of Appeal Clarifies and Reaffirms Dynex: Gross Overriding Royalties and Interests in Land | JD Supra
In a decision of critical interest to the holders of overriding royalties in the mining and oil and gas sectors, the Ontario Court of Appeal has clarified the test used to determine when a royalty interest constitutes an interest in land.
Robert Staley: This was not about Mike Duffy vs. my client, Stephen Harper
Commencing in mid-2013, I represented former prime minister Stephen Harper in connection with the RCMP’s investigation of Senator Duffy. So long as Mr. Duffy was facing criminal charges, my client, and anyone acting on his behalf, was prevented by the sub judice rule from making statements that could prejudice court proceedings, including statements speaking to the merits of the allegations.
Staley: Stephen Harper acted honourably in Mike Duffy investigation; now it’s time for other authorities to step up
Prime Minister Stephen Harper made available a comprehensive written record to investigators of how the Mike Duffy affair was dealt with. Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS Share Adjust Comment Print Commencing in mid-2013, I represented Prime Minister Stephen Harper in connection with the RCMP’s investigation of Sen. Mike Duffy.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Robert
Contact Robert, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack