By Sarah Beckett Ference, CPA Wire transfer fraud is a risk to any business. Here are 10 actions to take to help prevent your firm from falling victim to a wire fraud scam. Wire transfer fraud, typically perpetrated via business email compromise, is a known risk to all types of businesses, including CPA firms. When a CPA firm handles client money, additional risk ensues.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Sarah Beckett Ference
Tips for writing CAS engagement letters
column PROFESSIONAL LIABILITY SPOTLIGHT The pen is mightier than the sword. This saying is true for any professional liability claim dispute between client and accountant but especially when the dispute relates to client accounting and advisory services (CAS). Why? The nature of a CAS engagement, like any other consulting service, is determined solely by the agreement between the accountant and client.
Don’t let a bankrupt client bankrupt you
column PROFESSIONAL LIABILITY SPOTLIGHT When people lose money, CPAs get sued. A simple statement, and a reality in the world of professional liability claims. Another reality? When people lose a lot of money, as is generally the case in bankruptcy, CPAs get sued for a lot of money. In fact, client bankruptcy is a large claim red flag, especially if the CPA was the bankrupt entity’s auditor.
10 tips to help avoid wire fraud scams
By Sarah Beckett Ference, CPA Wire transfer fraud, typically perpetrated via business email compromise, is a known risk to all types of businesses, including CPA firms. When a CPA firm handles client money, additional risk ensues. In a typical wire transfer fraud scheme, the fraudster impersonates a trusted individual and sends a phony email to someone at the firm.
Are you prepared for the cost of a data security incident?
column PROFESSIONAL LIABILITY SPOTLIGHT Another day, another cyber incident. One does not have to search hard to find a news headline about the latest breach of consumer data or a warning about the ransomware threat du jour. Stories about sophisticated global cybersecurity attacks perpetrated by criminal enterprises or nation-states can be a riveting read for anyone who likes a good thriller.
Generative A.I. and risks to CPA firms
It may be tempting to explore generative A.I.’s capabilities and investigate how it may simplify your life, but there are more immediate practical concerns and considerations for CPAs. By Sarah Beckett Ference, CPA Note: This article appeared in the October 2023 issue of the Journal of Accountancy.
10 tips to help avoid wire fraud scams
Wire transfer fraud, typically perpetrated via business email compromise, is a known risk to all types of businesses, including CPA firms. When a CPA firm handles client money, additional risk ensues. In a typical wire transfer fraud scheme, the fraudster impersonates a trusted individual and sends a phony email to someone at the firm.
Generative AI and Risks to CPA Firms
By Sarah Beckett Ference, CPA “Write a 1,200-word article regarding how CPA firms can manage risk related to the use of ChatGPT and other forms of generative AI.” This easy ChatGPT request would have resulted in the production of this month’s column in a far more expeditious manner than writing one from scratch, but would it have been as informative or accurate?
Client acceptance: A liability gatekeeper
By Sarah Beckett Ference, CPA Download PDF It is often said that engagement letters are one of the best tools in the defense of a professional liability claim. That said, few CPAs would prefer to test the strength of their engagement letters through the claim process and would rather avoid the claim altogether. Even a successfully defended claim is stressful and takes time away from revenue-generating activities, not to mention the defense costs associated with the claim.
Oh BOI: The Corporate Transparency Act and CPA firms
Enacted as part of the 2021 National Defense Authorization Act and amending the Bank Secrecy Act, the Corporate Transparency Act (CTA) is intended to close a perceived information gap related to money laundering and other illicit acts. The CTA requires reporting companies to self-report information to the Treasury Department’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (Fin-CEN) about their beneficial owners and company applicants.
Small Actions, Big Fallout: Lessons from Large Claims
Unfortunately, seemingly benign actions do not always turn out to be so. Even small decisions or quick conversations may have significant — and expensive — consequences. Consider these real-life claims asserted against CPAs in the AICPA Professional Liability Insurance Program, and take note of lessons that were learned the hard way regarding a lack of engagement letters. The case: A CPA prepared tax returns and provided bill-paying services for a client.
Auditor independence threats and malpractice claims
All CPAs are expected to perform their professional responsibilities with the highest sense of integrity. Indeed, integrity is one of the hallmarks of the profession. In accordance with the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct (the Code), integrity requires CPAs “to observe the principles of objectivity and independence and of due care” (see paragraph .05 of ET sec. 0.300.040, “Integrity”).
Small actions, big fallout: Lessons from large claims
By Sarah Beckett Ference, risk control director at CNA Unfortunately, seemingly benign actions do not always turn out to be so. Even small decisions or quick conversations may have significant and expensive consequences. Consider these real-life claims asserted against CPAs in the AICPA Professional Liability Insurance Program and take note of lessons learned the hard way. Failure to search Case 1: A CPA prepared tax returns and provided bill-paying services for a client.
Generative AI and risks to CPA firms
“Write a 1,200-word article regarding how CPA firms can manage risk related to the use of ChatGPT and other forms of generative AI.” This easy ChatGPT request would have resulted in the production of this month’s column in a far more expeditious manner than writing one from scratch, but would it have been as informative or accurate? ChatGPT is an example of generative artificial intelligence (AI), and its popularity has soared since its introduction to the public in November 2022.
Succession and practice continuation agreements
In late March, a 44-year-old CPA-triathlete was getting ready for a morning run before a busy day at work. While getting dressed, he suddenly had a massive stroke. His wife was able to call an ambulance and get help quickly, but the CPA was in a coma for a week and hospitalized for several months thereafter. The CPA was a sole practitioner, and the April 15 tax deadline was approaching.
Bad billing practices can affect malpractice risk
Consider this: A CPA performed bookkeeping and tax services for a long-term client who was profitable and asset-rich but had challenges with cash flow. Despite the client’s untimely payment of invoices, the CPA rationalized the continuation of services, as the client did make payments periodically. Over time, however, the payments slowed and the client’s outstanding balance grew until it was too significant an amount for the CPA to ignore.
Fraud risk applies to all CPA firm services
Did you know that, regardless of the service provided, CPAs face professional liability claims asserting that they failed to detect a theft or fraud at a client organization? Did you also know that even if a theft or fraud is below an auditor's or reviewer's materiality threshold, the CPA may still be blamed for not detecting it? The disconnect between a CPA's professional responsibilities related to fraud detection and the public's perception of those duties has annoyingly persisted.
Idaho Society of Certified Public Accountants (ISCPA)
Consider this claim asserted in 2021: A CPA firm had a long-term financial institution audit client. The client discovered that one of its employees embezzled funds by misusing the company credit card and manipulating bank records. The client performed an investigation, determined that $2 million was stolen, and submitted a claim to its fidelity insurer. The fidelity insurer brought a claim against the CPA firm, asserting that the firm's audit failures allowed the fraud to perpetuate.
Malpractice claims in 2021 and future predictions
The tumultuous and unpredictable environment of recent years has resulted in increased stress for CPA firms and their clients. While uncertainty has been the norm, one constant remains: When people lose money, they often look for someone to blame, and CPAs can get caught in the cross hairs. This article examines the types of claims asserted against CPA firms in the AICPA Professional Liability Insurance Program in 2021 and predicts what future claims may arise.
Small actions, big fallout: Lessons from large claims
Unfortunately, seemingly benign actions do not always turn out to be so. Even small decisions or quick conversations may have significant, and expensive, consequences. Consider these real-life claims asserted against CPAs in the AICPA Professional Liability Insurance Program and take note of lessons that were learned the hard way. FAILURE TO SEARCH The case: A CPA prepared tax returns and provided bill-paying services for a client.
Frequently asked engagement letter questions
Last month's Professional Liability Spotlightcolumn focused on frequently asked risk management questions related to topics other than engagement letters (see "Professional Liability Spotlight: Frequently Asked Risk Management Questions," JofA, Aug. 2021). The top topic of questions asked of the Accountants Risk Control team at CNA, the endorsed underwriter of the AICPA Professional Liability Insurance Program, in any given year is engagement letters and deserves its own FAQ column.
Frequently asked risk management questions
The Accountants Risk Control team at CNA, the endorsed underwriter of the AICPA Professional Liability Insurance Program, fields thousands of questions annually from CPAs seeking risk management advice. We've summarized our frequently asked questions below so you can easily access resources to manage professional liability risk in your practice. Engagement letters are so important that they deserve a dedicated FAQ article, which will publish in an upcoming issue.
An evaluation framework for responding to requests
CPAs regularly receive requests for services and should understand the fundamental risk management protocols — client and engagement acceptance, engagement letters, adherence to professional standards, and documentation — to implement in order to mitigate risk related to the delivery of client engagements. But CPAs also face a variety of less typical questions and situations that may come from current or former clients or third parties.
Understanding the professional liability claims process
Facing a professional liability claim can generate strong emotions. If a CPA discovers an error on a previously filed tax return, emotions may include guilt about having made an error, as well as anxiety about how to tell the client. If a CPA is served with a seemingly frivolous lawsuit, anger and frustration often follow. Irrespective of the situation or emotion, when a claim arises, the first call a CPA should make is to his or her professional liability insurer.
The indirect impacts of COVID-19 on CPA firms
The world has changed dramatically in recent months. At the beginning of 2020, many CPAs were excited about the prospect of an “easier” busy season after dealing with the law known as the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, P.L. 115-97, last year. Financial markets were at an all-time high, and everything appeared to be smooth sailing. Then along came COVID-19. The travel and hospitality industry has all but disappeared. Commerce has declined dramatically.
A framework for maintaining ethics compliance
Defending a professional liability claim can be complicated. The plaintiff and CPA firm defendant often disagree about the scope of service, the amount of damages, the firm's compliance with the applicable standard of care, and more. Resolving these differences becomes more difficult if the firm's independence, integrity, or objectivity is brought into question.
5 Smart Strategies to Help CPAs Avoid a Lawsuit
5 Smart Strategies to Help CPAs Avoid a Lawsuit by Sarah Beckett Ference, CPA, CNA | August 20, 2019 Here are five ways in which CPAs can keep the discussion going and avoid lawsuits with clients: Level set expectations. Establish a “meeting of the minds” between the firm and client. Ask yourself questions such as, does the client understand the services it needs? Do they understand the type of services the firm can provide and how services may differ?
Minding the expectation gap in a CAS engagement
Client accounting services (CAS) is a diverse and growing area of practice for all sizes of CPA firms. Each CAS engagement may include a variety of services with differing degrees of complexity and strategic value to the client, customized to help meet the client's individualized needs.
Responding to a Client’s Request for Defense and Indemnification
Have you ever faced this situation? Your firm receives a request for proposal (RFP) from a new client. It sounds like a great opportunity, and the firm is excited to respond. The RFP includes the client's standard terms and conditions and a statement indicating respondents must agree to the terms. You review them; nothing seems out of the ordinary until you see a provision titled "Indemnification and Defense Requirements." What is this?
Think twice before suing for unpaid fees
Being stiffed stings. Feelings of injustice and frustration can compel even the most risk-averse CPA to initiate a fee suit or utilize the services of a collection agency. However, such actions can serve as a catalyst for a counterclaim for negligence or a regulatory complaint to be asserted against the CPA firm in response. The risk of a counterclaim or complaint is multiplied if the client or former client hires an attorney to help them respond to the CPA's action.
Which engagement letter reigns supreme?
In the defense of a professional liability claim, CPAs should know the critical role played by engagement letters. Engagement letters help define the scope of services, manage client expectations, communicate limitations of the service provided, and outline the CPA's and client's responsibilities.
There's No Substitute for Quality
Quality is not an act, it is a habit. This quote, often mistakenly attributed to Aristotle, sums it up well. Quality is something that can only be embedded through a CPA firm’s people and culture. It is not something on a checklist or completed prior to the issuance of a CPA firm report. It is a fundamental value and way of life for a true professional. The role quality, or lack thereof, plays in a professional liability claim cannot be over-emphasized.
Deflecting clients’ requests for defense and indemnity
Have you ever faced this situation? Your firm receives a request for proposal (RFP) from a new client. It sounds like a great opportunity, and the firm is excited to respond. The RFP includes the client’s standard terms and conditions and a statement indicating respondents must agree to the terms. You review them; nothing seems out of the ordinary until you see a provision titled “Indemnification and Defense Requirements.” What is this?
There’s No Substitute for Quality
Quality is not an act, it is a habit. This quote, often mistakenly attributed to Aristotle, sums it up well. Quality is something that can only be embedded through a CPA firm’s people and culture. It is not something on a checklist or completed prior to the issuance of a CPA firm report. It is a fundamental value and way of life for a true professional. The role quality, or lack thereof, plays in a professional liability claim cannot be over-emphasized.
The pitfalls of assuming management responsibilities
Defending professional liability claims is difficult when practitioners assume responsibilities beyond the scope of their engagement. The difficulty in defending against a claim increases dramatically if the CPA undertakes activities considered to be the responsibility of “management” and if the client, based on the CPA’s words and actions, believed it could rely on the CPA to perform what was generally understood to be an internal management function.
Independence is in the eye of the beholder
The independence of CPAs is the hallmark of the profession. As such, accountants put forth significant focus and effort to comply with independence requirements related to everything from investments to business and employment relationships to services delivered to clients. But being what accountants call independent in “fact” isn’t enough. CPAs also must be independent in appearance as well—a requirement detailed in various professional guidelines, including the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Sarah Beckett
Contact Sarah Beckett, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack