Rules be damned … Elizabeth McCracken.Photograph: Christopher Lane/The Observer Trope, POV, backstory, character arc. In the 30 years since I was a student of that benign, pipe-smoking, elbow-patched man of letters Malcolm Bradbury, the private language of creative writing workshops has taken over the world.
Storyteller. Mentor. Swimmer.
Associate Professor of Creative Writing at the University of Southampton.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Toby Litt
Everything Will Swallow You by Tom Cox review – a cosy state-of-the-nation yarn
Microsoft Cares About Your Privacy Microsoft and our third-party vendors use cookies to store and access information such as unique IDs to deliver, maintain and improve our services and ads. If you agree, MSN and Microsoft Bing will personalise the content and ads that you see. You can select ‘I Accept’ to consent to these uses or click on ‘Manage preferences’ to review your options and exercise your right to object to Legitimate Interest where used.
Everything Will Swallow You by Tom Cox review - a cosy state-of-the-nation yarn
A feel for the social fabric of our times … Tom Cox.Photograph: PR Ursula K Le Guin had her Carrier Bag Theory of Fiction; I have my comfy cardigan theory. What Le Guin proposed is that human culture, novels included, didn’t begin with technologies of harm, such as flints and spears, but with items of collection and care, such as the wicker basket or, nowadays, the carrier bag. And so, if we make them that way, novels can be gatherings rather than battles.
A Writer's Diary
This site requires JavaScript to run correctly. Please turn on JavaScript or unblock scripts
Stay away from pain
IRAQI INVASION OF KUWAIT Yes, today I went to the library and managed to take four books out instead of just two. Isherwood, My Guru and His Disciple, Ben Jonson, Complete Poems, Ezra Pound, Selected Poems and still Ovid’s Metamorphoses. Already addicted by Isherwood’s prose. Look what those weeks off have done to my handwriting. Jitka comes in, does some housework, waters the plants. It’s obvious that, during moments of stress, she has come in here and cleaned.
The gift of pure attention
Milena not around. Went in to Czech lesson. Charles and Jill. For a soda. Then for a drink with Charles. “It’s hard to set up in any society that you didn’t grow up in.” I don’t know if today is Thursday or Wednesday.
Bring the House Down by Charlotte Runcie review – the joy of the hatchet job
Microsoft Cares About Your Privacy Microsoft and our third-party vendors use cookies to store and access information such as unique IDs to deliver, maintain and improve our services and ads. If you agree, MSN and Microsoft Bing will personalise the content and ads that you see. You can select ‘I Accept’ to consent to these uses or click on ‘Manage preferences’ to review your options and exercise your right to object to Legitimate Interest where used.
Bring the House Down by Charlotte Runcie review - the joy of the hatchet job
As a young arts journalist, Charlotte Runcie was lambasted by a standup to whom she’d given a bad review.Photograph: Sophie Davidson When Jesus is pressed to condemn the woman taken in adultery, he says, “He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her.” No one does, and a lesson in critical generosity is learned. Judge not, that ye be not judged. Is giving an artist a one-star review an act of abuse – casting the first stone?
What Goes Around Comes Around?
My son recently told me this story… Happy December. May it be filled with stressful-that-brings-joyful-experiences… Amy <3 Tell me something good…or stressful :) I had a super fun time drawing the story for you.
Nobody’s Empire by Stuart Murdoch review – Belle and Sebastian and me
Microsoft Cares About Your Privacy Microsoft and our third-party vendors use cookies to store and access information such as unique IDs to deliver, maintain and improve our services and ads. If you agree, MSN and Microsoft Bing will personalise the content and ads that you see. You can select ‘I Accept’ to consent to these uses or click on ‘Manage preferences’ to review your options and exercise your right to object to Legitimate Interest where used.
Nobody’s Empire by Stuart Murdoch review - Belle and Sebastian and me
Finding faith … Stuart Murdoch.Photograph: Katherine Anne Rose/The Observer I will leave it to the Belle and Sebastian obsessives, of whom there are many around the world, to figure out which details in this debut novel by the band’s lead singer and main songwriter are made up. As far as I’ve been able to work out, just a few names have been changed, of people and cafes. Apart from that, Nobody’s Empire could as well have been published as a recovery memoir.
The Watermark by Sam Mills review – a time-travelling romp - NewsBreak
Exploring the outer limits of imagination … Sam Mills. Photograph: Andrew Gallix Sam Mills’s virtuosic new novel is – when defined in the strictest terms – a romp. By that I mean it’s an adventure story that doesn’t ask you to take it all that seriously. The Count of Monte Cristo is the definitive romp: a tale of repeated imprisonment and escape, of thwarted romance, of daring disguises and, in the end, of triumphant human grit and ingenuity.
On Slo-Mo
Here’s an exercise and an explanation. Next time you’re on a bus journey, along a crowded high street, get your phone out, point it sideways, and take exactly ten seconds of slo-mo video. Do this while the bus is moving, so you get a tracking shot. Press the camera up against the glass. Hopefully it isn’t juddering too much. Aim to catch the people on the pavement. As you’re 10 filming, 9 8 7 6, look at the street, 5 4 3, not the screen, 2 1. When you’re done, 0, watch the video back immediately.
On Vulnerability
The lyrics I’ve been thinking about are — You end up like a dog that’s been beat too much Till you spend half your life just covering up From ‘Born in the USA’. There’s a lot to say about this song (in relation to America now), and about Bruce Springsteen generally (in relation to lots of things), but I’d like to focus on failure. Self-confirming failure. First, an aside — Last week, I did not go and see Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band live at Wembley Stadium.
On the Key to Writing a Novel
I was twenty and had just finished university. I’d written two short stories. Maybe three. One day, I decided to write a novel. The main reason for this was because I saw myself as a poet, and I thought that in order to support themselves poets needed to write novels. Hah. I moved to Edinburgh, found a bedsit up four flights of stairs, got a narrow-lined A4 pad. But although I’d just finished an English Literature degree, I didn’t really know to go about writing anything longer than four pages.
On The Pages of the Sea
Today is launch day for a wonderful first novel. The Pages of the Sea by Anne Hawk. It’s published by Weatherglass Books, who have put out some other amazing books — Cold New Climate by Isobel Wohl is perhaps my other favourite. I think this will come to be seen as a really significant debut. It’s a great and loveable novel of childhood, separation, cruelty and curiosity. A book to keep alongside To Kill a Mockingbird and Wide Sargasso Sea and The Bluest Eye.
On Performative Vulnerability
Sometimes it’s hard to tell whether or not I’m lying to myself. That would make a good opening sentence for a short story. Sometimes he found it hard to tell whether or not he was lying to himself. But lots of readers would say, Oh, it’s too clunkily introducing an unreliable narrator. Maybe so. Yet what about those moments when one becomes too clunkily unreliable a narrator to and of one’s own self?
On Chills
I get that shiver up the back of the neck only rarely. Last night at the Proms, in the last few seconds of Mahler’s 5th Symphony, with the Halle Orchestra, conducted there for the last time by Mark Elder — zing went the string of my spine. I can’t explain it. I’d been standing among the prommers for an hour and a half. The Albert Hall was very stuffy. A young woman in front of me had fainted, been held up, fainted again during the Adagietto, been led away. The playing had been wonderful.
On Creative Writing Courses
It’s now a decade since Hanif Kureishi dismissed Creative Writing courses as a waste of time. In the aftermath of his comments, the Guardian asked a number of writers — Rachel Cusk, Philip Hensher, Joyce Carol Oates, me — to respond. What I said then remains my best defence of Creative Writing — particularly as part of continuing education. But there’s more to say.
On the Time of Originality
Whilst I was in Paris, I went to the Musée Rodin. I have wanted to go for years. It was even more amazing than I had expected. Since getting back home, I have been reading again Rainer Maria Rilke’s ‘The Rodin-Book’ of 1903 and 1907 — translated by William Tucker and published by Quartet Books in 1986. Along with David Sylvester’s Interviews with Francis Bacon, Osip Mandelstam’s ‘Conversation about Dante’, and Virginia Woolf’s Diaries, this is one of my sacred texts.
On Pattern in Writing
I have been puzzling over this for years. And I think I’ve gone as far as I can by myself. I need your help. This is a question for you. Everyone knows what a patterned fabric looks like. Patterned cloth or hide seems to be a universal human product. But is there an equivalent in writing? (In prose, not poetry.) About a decade ago, I wrote something which seemed a way to approach the question. Stripes were an obviously doable pattern in writing.
On What's Worth Looking At
There is too much of everything. Or rather, It’s only at rare moments — the best moments — that there is exactly the right amount of world in the world. The rest of the time, it’s just overwhelming. That’s how it feels to me. That’s how it feels today. Politically. Ecologically. Aesthetically. A few weeks ago, I asked whether or not you’d like there to be 10,000 new novels by your favourite writer. The example I gave was Lee Child, who I know is probably not your favourite writer.
On the Writing Advice I Give to Myself
This is from a file I’ve added to over a number of years. Get up early and start work as soon as you can. Don’t shower. But maybe brush your teeth. Write something before you are fully awake — before you have listened to the radio, checked your email, showered. Checking email makes you nervous/fractious. Learning the news makes you depressed. Showering makes you feel you’re in public. Be the creature in the cave. Growl. Don’t expect to make good decisions when you’re exhausted.
On Background Noise
Some builders down the road are cutting paving stones with an angle grinder. This is the third day. I know because I’ve walked past, and the young man has paused so I don’t get dusty. There’s a lot of dust on a lot of cars. My room is at the back of the house. The noise isn’t as bad here. It’s not as distracting as the summer we had the Polish builders two gardens along, shaping hundreds of kitchen tiles. They liked listening to happy hardcore and Capital FM. And they loved shouted conversations.
On Free Indirect
Did you do your homework? Looks at you over the top of his glasses. Tuts. Don’t worry, you can do it now, or after reading this, or sneak shyly away at the end of class. Yesterday, I asked you to read George Saunders’ story ‘The End of FIRPO in the World’. The aim was for you to identify what is the narrator’s language, what Cody’s and what is shared between them. Plus, what belongs to someone else. I suggested printing the story out and using highlighter pens or underlining.
On Free Indirect
What I’m going to write here is, I hope, a backup to other online resources — taking a usefully intuitive approach, rather than a grammatical one. It’s a beginner’s guide. Forgive me if you already know this stuff. I don’t often point students towards Wikipedia, but the entry there on Free Indirect Speech is a good start. The first thing I’ll say is — To use Free Indirect at all, you have to use it confidently. This is because as well as being about word choice, it’s also about rhythm.
On and On and On
When I started this year’s Diary, I knew it wouldn’t be the same as the first couple of years. I decided to make each entry a mini-essay of sorts (I’ll come back to this), and to title it ‘On Whatever’. When I say I decided, that makes it sound more calculating than it was. More accurate would be, My instinct was to… I put a few Ons in Subject Lines of some drafts, and then sensed how I felt about them when I was away from them. Again, this wasn’t a plan; this was just how it happened.
On the Desktop
Exhausted today. I stayed up until 5am — very glad of the result, and very glad to see the Green Party get four seats. Perhaps it was a climate election after all. Right now, I am sitting looking at the desktop of my admittedly old laptop. In the the bottom right corner, in the sidebar, is an icon of a metal waste paper basket full of scrunched up paper. That’s the trash. On the rest of the screen there are dozens of icons of cardboard folders containing numerous icons of cardboard files.
On Monsters
I wrote this quite some years ago, for a panel at the Institute of Contemporary Arts. It seems appropriate for today, General Election day, as we prepare yet again to be monstered. What is a Monster? In contemporary fiction, a monster will inevitably be: Post-Marxist Post-Freudian/post-Jungian Post-Cinema Post- or maybe Mid-Genetics Which, let’s face it, isn’t very scary.
On 'The Reader'
After yesterday’s post, about making the reader cry, I had this response — Isn’t that saying that “the reader” is generic and that all readers are robotic and respond to the same literary manipulative stimuli? — from the writer Steve Finbow, my friend and former workmate. Which, I replied, was a good question. But that wasn’t really my answer. My answer is this — In order to say anything at all about writing in general, I have to generalise.
On Making the Reader Cry
If you have tears, prepare to shed them now… So says Marcus Antonius in Shakespeare’s ‘Julius Caesar’. Which seems, to contemporary ears, a tactical error. If you are intending to make a person cry, you shouldn’t announce it to them immediately beforehand. Isn’t that just like saying — I’m now going to tell you the funniest joke you’ve ever heard. Most people’s reaction is surely going to be — Let me be the judge of that.
On Ten Thousand New Lee Child Novels
The other day, I got into a conversation that wasn’t about Artificial Intelligence. But I’d like to report on what was said during one of my discussions/arguments concerning the inevitable topic of the moment — Will all of us be replaced by AIs? I was speaking to a very successful and established musician. Let’s call him Casey. We were in a recording studio. Guitars were present. But in the past couple of months, Casey had been getting deeply into collaborating with AI. He loved it.
On Exclamation Marks
I associate them with my father. In any postcard he sent, from Cornwall or France or Corsica, there were guaranteed to be four or five. Rain! Pétanque! Cheese! If a holiday was going really well, one might end every single blue felt tip sentence. And sometimes, if a meal or sunset had been particularly great, there would be three in a row!!! Perhaps this is why I’ve generally reacted against using them. This is fairly extreme.
On Daley Thompson's Life Advice
Last night, I was very lucky to attend the world premiere of director Vadim Jean’s new documentary, Daley: Olympic Superstar. (Leigh went to university with Vadim, and they’ve stayed good friends, which is how we got the invitation.) Daley is great. Very moving and inspiring and, at points, enraging. BBC2 will be screening it on July 16th at 9pm. That’s about ten days before the Olympics start. When I was at school, Daley Thompson wasn’t my athletic hero.
On Going Back into the More Distant Past from the More Recent Past
Apologies if you think this is a bit basic, but it’s something I often get asked about in writing workshops. I’m writing a novel in the past tense, but I want my character to have a memory from when they were a child. What tense do I use? That’s one way of asking it. Another is — How do I do a flashback within a flashback? This may seem a little like the very fair question — Why aren’t science fiction novels written in the future tense?
On the Seven Deadly Sins
Let’s be clear – I’m not casting the first stone. The first draft of this was called ‘Nine Ways I Have Written Badly’. Kafka said (and I’ve quoted it before): There are two main human sins, from which all the others derive: impatience and indolence. It was because of impatience that they were expelled from paradise; it is because of indolence that they do not return. Yet perhaps there is only one major sin: impatience.
The Complete Guide to POV
For this, I only have one example. But I only need to have one. I was lucky enough to see Thomas Morris read this story, ‘All the Boys,’ at the 2015 Cork International Short Story Festival. At the time, I knew it was in a POV I’d never heard used as the basis for a story. I also knew it was a bloody great story. (If you want to do a compare and contrast, with an equally great story, read it alongside Kevin Barry’s ‘Beer Trip to Llandudno’. It’s on the Times website, but behind a paywall.
On Writing Anticipation
This is a more recent story, less constrictive than the previous ones, and written for The Verb in 2016. The broadcast went out from a glass box in the Royal Festival Hall, so the commission from Ian McMillan and the producer was — write a story that takes place in a box. I decided to write about a Jack-in-the-Box. When I was little, I had metal one that played Pop Goes the Weasel. What I remembered most about it was not the wonky sound but the plasticky colours.
On Writing a Very Flat Story Using Only the Letters Without Ascenders and Descenders
I’m sure someone else has come up with something like this, but as far as I know, Flatglish, like yesterday’s Japanglish, is my own invention. My Flatglish story was broadcast in November 2007 on Radio 3’s The Verb, presented by Ian McMillan. And, again, I was writing in response to a very difficult writing challenge. This challenge was mine.
On Writing a Story that Can Be Read Backwards as Well as Forwards
This was one of the trickiest of the very difficult writing challenges set me by poet-presenter Ian McMillan and the producers at Radio 3’s The Verb. They asked me to write a reversible story — one that worked just as well if you read it last line to first. Rather than the mirrored letters in a palindrome (‘Mr. Owl ate my metal worm’), this works with complete sentences.
On the Subtle Differences Between the Definite and Indefinite Articles
I wrote this in October 2007, for Radio 3’s The Verb, as a bit of fun. But also to illustrate how subtly different the same piece of writing might be if all you changed within it was the indefinite to the definite article. This was the third of the very difficult writing challenges set for me by poet-presenter Ian McMillan and by the producers of the Verb. I’ll be really interested to see what anyone comes up with for this one.
On Writing a Story Based on a Paradox
This was the second story commission from Radio 3’s The Verb. I wrote it around July 2007 To be honest, I can’t remember what the restriction they gave me was.I think it might have been, Write something based on an unresolvable paradox. What I can remember is that I had the idea for this story, or at least the idea for the paradox, when I was at boarding school — so, between eleven and thirteen years-old.
On Telling a Story Without Using any Verbs
I wrote this in June 2003, for Radio 3’s The Verb. It was the first of a number of very difficult writing challenges that the producers set me — only one of which has been published, and none of which (I think) have been rebroadcast. I’d like to share them, in the next few days. Mainly as a writing challenge for you. I don’t know if these funny little forms have gone any further, but I’d like them to. Privately, I call them ‘Verbals’.
On Creative and Critical Writing
I’ve had some very thought-provoking responses to yesterday’s entry. All of which were welcome. One of which was about overgeneralising. I hope it’s understood, because these are notes I write day by day, and it’s between the covers of a writer’s diary, that I’m not laying down rules, or saying everything is always such and such a way.
On Creative Writing PhDs
We were in a small, dull university meeting room with a long table. Opposite me sat the PhD candidate and their supervisor. Myself, the internal examiner, the chair and the candidate had just completed an intense two hour viva — an exhausting, exhaustive oral examination that’s the end-point, the Boss Level of the entire education system. Our coffee was cold. I stared at my cup and saucer. The chair — to whom I’d delegated this task — had just told the candidate that their PhD had not passed.
On Politics
I find Politics dangerously embarrassing. Dangerously, because my embarrassment about it often makes me quietly leave the debate (any debate) to others. Dangerously, because everyone should involve themselves in politics (because politics has always already involved itself in them, not least in the formation of them as them (and, somewhere, as part of many bigger Thems)). But why embarrassing?
On Creative Writing MA Courses
‘Hello – how are you? – thank you for coming. Could I ask your name? And you’re interested in Creative Writing, are you? Good. Great. Well, what would you like to know?’ This is me, being open. We are sitting across from one another in one of the — for me anyway — cosily Stalinist halls of the Royal National Hotel in Bloomsbury. Between us is a table covered with prospectuses and brochures. On the covers of the prospectuses and brochures are contented-looking students, asking questions, writing answers.
On Artificial Intelligence
I haven’t found the quote I needed, but I’m going with this anyway. However scrappy or badly expressed. Somewhere, some time ago, Peter Buck, guitarist in R.E.M., said something like — Listen back to us and everyone else, we were the only band in the 1980s with a bearable drum sound.
On Fixing a Sentence
I let through a sentence yesterday I wasn’t happy with. Not that I think everything that appears in the diary is ideal, smooth or even finished. But this one caused me annoyance and shame. What I wrote was — How great a writer is judged as being depends almost entirely on how much of a deformative influence they become on their successors.
On The Anxiety of Influence
I was just lying in bed, thinking something a bit like this — King Lear is without doubt the greatest thing I’ve ever read. And then — How could anyone ever write something that good again? Immediately, I was deep into Harold Bloom territory. I don’t know how many people still read Bloom.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Toby
Contact Toby, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack