The 1878 · https://the1878.news/news/inside-united-weekly-review-monday-16th-november-188335 The big news at Old Trafford this week was evidently the dismissal of Michael Carrick and the hiring of his successor, Mauricio Pochettino. 16.11.26, 19:17 4 Minute Read The big news at Old Trafford this week was evidently the dismissal of Michael Carrick and the hiring of his successor, Mauricio Pochettino.
● Author of 24 books ● Chief @ManUtd correspondent for @The1878news ● Producer
● linktr.ee/FergieTheLostTapesWayneBarton
Articles by Wayne Barton
Mis-shapes, Mistakes, Misfits
You have to have a long memory to remember the last time Manchester United lost a home league game after leading at half-time. It was May 1984 and Ipswich Town; briefly, that record looked like being the latest to tumble in Monday night’s chaotic game against Bournemouth. Although United were able to get a 4-4 draw from the evening, it was still an underwhelming result, especially on the back of poor Old Trafford results against Everton and West Ham recently.
Ratings and Reaction : Tottenham 2-2 United
For the second week in a row, Manchester United needed a late equaliser to snatch a 2-2 draw on the road – though this time around it was even more chaotic than seven days earlier. Matthijs De Ligt scored a header deep into injury time when Richalison thought he’d won the game for Spurs with a goal in added time of his own. Though it was definitely a point gained, United will surely reflect on the circus of events which led to a game which was controlled to one which was almost thrown away.
Ratings and Reaction : Nottingham Forest 2-2 United
Manchester United rescued a draw from an unpromising situation at Nottingham Forest in a game where they took the lead and fell behind – and still might have ended up winning it in injury time. Ruben Amorim celebrated a year in charge of the club by naming, for the first time, an unchanged line-up. However, this was also Sean Dyche’s first home game as Forest manager in the league, so it was to be anticipated that the hosts would be buoyed by the occasion. And why wouldn’t they?
Ratings and Reaction : United 4-2 Brighton
Manchester United won their third consecutive Premier League game in an entertaining encounter against Brighton – Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo were the stars, but United still managed to give their fans a bit of a scare before they got over the line. Ruben Amorim named a predictable enough side, recalling Leny Yoro in place of last week’s hero Harry Maguire, and bringing Benjamin Sesko back into the attack.
Reaction and Ratings : Liverpool 1-2 United
After a wait of almost a decade, Manchester United have won a league game at Anfield, and not only could it not have come at a better time for manager Ruben Amorim, the manager was able ton claim almost complete vindication in the decisions he made before kick-off.
Order Signed Copies Of ‘Manchester United After Munich’
I am pleased to offer, for a limited time, signed copies of my next book Manchester United After Munich. THIS COMPELLING AND MOVING STORY OF MANCHESTER UNITED’S REJUVENATION AFTER THE MUNICH AIR CRASH REVISITS AN ERA THAT IS FUNDAMENTAL TO THE CLUB’S PLACE IN THE MODERN GAME. The 1958 Munich Air Crash that ripped the heart from one of Britain’s greatest ever teams.
Reaction and Ratings : United 2-0 Sunderland
Ruben Amorim saw his team win comfortably after a week where he admitted he was under pressure after poor results, and growing speculation that a defeat at Old Trafford could have left him facing the sack. Benjamin Sesko scored his first home goal after Mason Mount had also vindicated the manager’s selection with an early opener.
Reaction and Ratings : Brentford 3-1 United
Brentford inflicted a deflating defeat on Ruben Amorim’s Manchester United, scoring two early goals and finishing the game off in injury time, in an encounter the visitors never looked like winning. It says much about the league that had United won they would have done into the afternoon’s fixtures comfortably in the Champions League race. This was, however, their third defeat in just six league games this season.
“It was the best feeling ever to win the FA Youth Cup For Manchester United” : Lee Lawrence
Lee Lawrence played for Manchester United through the 90s, over the turn of the century, and even won an FA Youth Cup with the club. He never played for the first team. His connection to Old Trafford is permanently secured thanks to his place in the historical lineage and prestige of that competition. Every week he is kind enough to join us on the Talking Devils podcast to talk about the modern day team.
Reaction and Ratings : United 2-1 Chelsea
Manchester United picked up a crucial victory over Chelsea in an eventful, rain-sodden evening at Old Trafford. Following the capitulation last week at the Etihad, United supporters were hoping for a strong response this week, but were left to contemplate an uninspiring team selection. With Senne Lammens and Kobbie Mainoo on the bench, and Harry Maguire and Luke Shaw starting, the whisper around the South Stand was that it didn’t look like a team capable of winning the match.
Reaction and Ratings : City 3-0 United
Manchester United, and Ruben Amorim, suffered a damaging and chastening defeat in the Manchester Derby. Phil Foden’s first-half opener was followed by two second half goals from Erling Haaland, as United offered very little resistance on a day when Amorim really needed a result. A minute’s applause was held prior to the game after the shock news that former world champion boxer, Manchester’s own Ricky Hatton, had died earlier in the day.
Red Reign In Moscow : Part One – July - Talking Devils
As part of the launch of this website, I wanted to share a book, for free, on these pages. Seven years ago I wrote a season review of the European Cup win in Moscow in 2008. I wasn’t happy enough for it to be published and have decided I will rewrite it. That said, there is a 125,000 word draft that would otherwise have gone unread, so I’m going to share it here. I hope you enjoy. Prologue Manchester United’s young hopefuls trudged off the San Siro pitch on the evening of 2nd May, 2007, well beaten.
On This Day : The Dramatic Story Of Manchester United’s Name, And Their Last-Ever Game as Newton Heath
On this day in 1902, the team that would become known as Manchester United played their last-ever game as Newton Heath. The story is packed with the sort of drama that the future club would becone synonymous with. In early 1902, after years of trying to win a financial battle for survival off the pitch, Newton Heath were close to the brink. Bankruptcy and closure was a fate that had impacted other fledgling football clubs. Perhaps Newton Heath were lucky on two counts – the first, their locality.
Ruben Amorim : The Wrong Man, At The Wrong Time, For The Wrong Problems At Manchester United?
It’s a question, not a statement. But it’s worth asking, after yet another catastrophic defeat, if Ruben Amorim is the wrong man at the wrong time for Manchester United. There has been a catalogue of errors in management, from the football to the operational side of things, since 2013, and so many have been repeated in that time frame.
The new deja vu
Ruben Amorim has Manchester United supporters believing again after a bumpy Christmas period was followed by a draw at Liverpool and a penalty shoot-out win over Arsenal in the FA Cup. The message from the manager and his captain Bruno Ferdnandes has been clear - we want to see this at Old Trafford too.
Football, Taught By Matt Busby
Released March 2025 Delve into the DNA of Manchester United • Contains newly unearthed, never-before-seen images of Sir Matt Busby as well as never-before-heard interviews with Busby, Sir Alex Ferguson, and other key figures in Manchester United’s history • Provides the most complete and rounded picture of Matt Busby – the man and the manager – ever written, from an author widely regarded as the best Manchester United historian alive today “An extraordinarily detailed exploration of...
What you can expect from 'Unheard: 1999', our special Treble podcast
The story of how Manchester United won the Premier League, FA Cup and Champions League in the space of 10 days in May a quarter of a century ago has inspired many retellings and different accounts, with so many familiar threads often revisited. Roy Keane’s return from injury to captain his side to an incredible fightback in Turin with one of the greatest, most selfless individual performances in the club’s history. David Beckham’s road to redemption after the 1998 World Cup.
When United dropped to the second division
Skip to Main NavigationSkip to content At the same time, United were playing in the Manchester derby at Old Trafford. That game has gone down in infamy; abandoned with minutes remaining, the result stayed, City having just taken a one goal lead. The hosts could have won - it would have been academic due to the result at St. Andrew’s. The big question always asked is: how could such a thing happen?
Aston Villa Vs Chelsea: Prediction, Kick-off Time, TV, Live Stream, Team News, H2h Results, Odds - Evening Standard
Chelsea must have an immediate response as they travel to face Aston Villa in another daunting trip. The Blues were thumped 5-0 last time out in a hapless display, and now face a Villa side who are closing in on a top-four finish.
Chelsea XI Vs Leicester: Confirmed Team News, Predicted Lineup And Injury Latest For FA Cup Tie - Evening Standard
Rebirth of the Blues: The Rise of Chelsea Football Club in the Mid-1980s Rebirth of the Blues: The Rise of Chelsea Football Club in the Mid-1980s Save Rebirth of the Blues: The Rise of Chelsea Football Club in the Mid-1980s for later
Story of new UTD Podcast about 1958 Munich Air Disaster
So said Jackie Blanchflower in 1998, as he reminisced before the 40th anniversary of the Munich Air Disaster. This is the tone struck in the latest episode of the UTD Podcast, Unheard: Memories of Munich, which is out now. Blanchflower, alongside fellow Munich survivors Bill Foulkes and Albert Scanlon, features in this intimate and emotional account of the darkest day in the club’s history.
The Boys Who Became The Busby Babes
In commemoration of the forthcoming 65th anniversary of the Munich air disaster, here is a look at the Busby Babes through a lens you may not have studied. The Babes were immortalised; everybody knows the names, most know their positions and what they brought to the first team, but few know the journeys of the individuals as they graduated into the first team. This feature takes a look at those who perished, and the pathway of the players into the United first team.
Order Signed & Personalised Copies Of New Duncan Edwards Biography
I’m pleased to offer, for a very limited period, the opportunity to order signed or personalised editions of Eternal, my biography of Duncan Edwards, which is published on February 16th.
MUFC 40s Quiz
Random Sports Quiz Recently Published Quiz Scoreboard More to Explore Top Contributed Quizzes in Sports Explore More Trending Topics
And They Danced Underneath The Lights - A Love Letter To Old Trafford
Matt Busby was known as a charmer; a man of charisma, who left people in his company spellbound by the sheer rhythm of his diction. Journalists would be captivated by his missives – his staff would elevate him as a demigod, and his players would treat him as such, with reverence and fear in the same approach.
Top 50 Manchester United Players Of All Time : 10-1
Finally, the last in our series, the top 10 Manchester United players of all time as ranked by United author Wayne Barton. For 50-41 click here, 40-31 click here, for 30-21, click here, and for 20-11 click here. After the announcement of number two, the different members of TalkOfTheDevils.co.uk will list their own top ten.
Top 50 Manchester United Players Of All Time : 20-11
The fourth instalment of our Hall of Fame series. 20 Jaap Stam 127 appearances, 1 goal 1998-2001 3 Premier Leagues, 1 FA Cup, 1 Champions League, 1 Intercontinental Cup We are at that stage in this list where minor details become the dividers. This list has attempted to do a fair job of taking into account all facets of a contribution — ability, longevity, impact on the club, performance and trophies won.
Top 50 Manchester United Players Of All Time : 30-21
The third instalment of our Hall of Fame series. 30 Eddie Colman 108 appearances, 2 goals 1952-1958 2 League titles Having featured in the 1953 FA Youth Cup winning run, Eddie Colman – a lad so ‘Salford’ that he lived on Archie Street, the road which was used in the original opening credits of Coronation Street – did not have quite the typical path to the United first team.
Top 50 Manchester United Players Of All Time : 40-31
The second instalment of our Hall of Fame series. 40 Harry Gregg 247 appearances appearances 1957-1966 It is a sporting crime that Harry Gregg never won a medal while playing for Manchester United; injury robbed him of an FA Cup winner’s medal and a league winner’s medal. Harry’s contribution to the club extends beyond medals.
Goodbye, Cristiano - It Didn’t Have To Be Like This
Endings in football – in any sport, or, to that point, in any area of life – are rarely perfect. In football, you can take a quick look at any number of great players or managers and how things ended for their careers and you’d probably quickly wish you hadn’t.
How Cristiano Ronaldo Has Destroyed His Manchester United Legacy With Piers Morgan Interview
On Saturday I had the privilege of spending time in the company of my friend Tom Clare. You may not know Tom; but most people connected closely with Manchester United do. Tom describes himself as ‘just a fan’. Well, he’s ‘just a fan’ who was fortunate enough to know many of the Busby Babes as closely as we might know our gardener or window cleaner; he grew up in an era where the connection between players and supporters was much more intimate.
Ten Hag’s Gamble Does Not Undermine Incredibly Impressive Start As Manchester United Manager
Erik ten Hag’s start to life as Manchester United manager has certainly been eventful; and, following the reassuring nostalgic narrative that nothing the club does ever comes easy, even a win against Real Sociedad wasn’t enough to secure qualification into the knockout stages of the Europa League, with a playoff now set to follow. No defeats are wanted but in football they are inevitable.
The Future Is Orange - Why Ten Hag Is A Better Philosophical Fit For Man Utd Than Van Gaal Was
As Manchester United attended training today in Perth to prepare for their last friendly game in Australia, a group of supporters made a point of cheering and encouraging Harry Maguire. The United captain was subjected to a strange torrent of boos in the Melbourne friendly against Crystal Palace; but the response in Perth was more befitting and what one would expect of any supporter of the club in any corner of the world.
Ten Hag Begins Work As Manchester United Seek Complete Fresh Slate
So Manchester United’s season is now officially over. Of course, we suspected that it was effectively over in November, when the club made the decision to appoint an interim manager, and that was again more or less confirmed to us when that interim manager, Ralf Rangnick, told reporters that his request to sign one of three strikers in January was denied.
Anfield Disgrace Was A Fitting Footnote For The Worst Post-War Manchester United Team
There used to be an attraction at Walt Disney World called ‘The Great Movie Ride’. Four carts bound together, each holding around twenty people, would be driven around a track by a host who would talk about the movies. During the ride you would lurch from one dangerous moment of trepidation to another. At one point the host would say, ‘At least it can’t get any woise’ (Brooklyn for worse) – and then you’d turn the corner and they would say ‘it’s woise’.
Things can only get better for Manchester United
If you’re reading this and you’re a Manchester United fan then I’ve got some good news for you. It’s basically the title of this piece. As United plodded their way through the dismal 1-0 defeat at Goodison Park on Saturday, most of us were left scratching our heads.
Reaction and Player Ratings : Manchester United 1-1 Leicester
It’s been a tumultuous couple of weeks even without a game to perform an autopsy on; Harry Maguire’s treatment by England fans, the heavily-speculated managerial interview(s), transfer speculation, and a new contract handed to a player while the club is still under the guide of an interim manager.
Something is rotten in the state of Manchester United
“Playing performance doesn’t really have a meaningful impact on what we can do on the commercial side of the business,” Ed Woodward said in May 2018, a time we recognise as right at the start of Jose Mourinho’s tailspin. Almost four years on, as Deloitte published their ‘richest clubs’ list, United were down in fifth, with Manchester City in first.
Reaction and Player Ratings : Manchester United 0-1 Atletico Madrid
Manchester United are out of the Champions League after another abject Old Trafford defeat, this time against a resolute Atletico Madrid who enjoyed exhibiting their unique variety of gamesmanship. Ralf Rangnick’s side put on one of their familiar performances, with a strong first half but a frustrating second, as the club failed to progress to the quarter finals of this competition for the first time since 2014.
Exclusive : Frank O’Farrell made My Dream Come True, Says United Legend
Manchester United legend Sammy McIlroy has paid tribute to his former manager Frank O’Farrell, who has passed away aged 94. O’Farrell was manager at Old Trafford from June 1971 to December 1972. “It’s very sad news,” McIlroy told TalkOfTheDevils. “He gave me my debut in 1971 and I’ll always be grateful for the belief he showed in me and the help he gave me at the age of 17. I’ll always have great memories of him.
Reaction and Player Ratings : Manchester City 4-1 Manchester United
Manchester United suffered a shameful surrender in the derby as City showed their quality which was much greater. Kevin De Bruyne and Riyad Mahrez both scored twice; United equalised from 1-0 through Jadon Sancho but their second half performance was as pitiful as anything ever served up by this squad – and by the reputation of them from their track record, that is some going.
Exclusive : Meulensteen “United Must Press High To Get Result Against City”
Former Manchester United coach René Meulensteen says that his old team must adapt their style if they are to get a positive result in the Manchester derby tomorrow. Former manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer had a good record against Pep Guardiola, recording some famous wins, but the 2-0 defeat to City in November was a horror show which contributed hugely to his sacking.
Reaction and Player Ratings : Atletico Madrid 1-1 Manchester United
Perhaps it’s a sign of the times – perhaps we’re all getting caught up in the micro-analytics that surround every Manchester United match. Every passage of play, every half, every player, every managerial decision, all of these factors are under scrutiny in a way that seems much more tedious than ever before.
Reaction and Player Ratings : Leeds 2-4 Manchester United
Manchester United took all three points in a chaotic game at Elland Road; Leeds pulled back a two-goal deficit, only for Ralf Rangnick’s two substitutes to get on the scoresheet, and take the Old Trafford side back into the top four. The conditions – very windy and very, very wet – were always likely to make a high-octane affair a very unpredictable one.
Reaction and Player Ratings : Manchester United 2-0 Brighton
Manchester United are back in the top four, the singular objective presented to the squad by the manager Ralf Rangnick for the remainder of this season.
Reaction and Player Ratings : Manchester United 1-1 Southampton
The front of Old Trafford was covered in a new advertisement for Tezos, one of those block-crypto-pseudo-nobody-seems-to-quite-know things. Front and centre there is Cristiano Ronaldo, smiling, and not quite looking like himself, ominously looking soullessly out on to the forecourt where the statues of Sir Matt Busby and the Trinity Statue face each other.
The Paradox Of Wayne Rooney
The career of Wayne Rooney remains one of the fascinating in British football history. Dubbed ‘the White Pele’ early in his career, the expectation was that he would go on to do things beyond his peers. He certainly did that. He won every trophy available with Manchester United – joining a list of players smaller than you might originally think – and broke the goalscoring records of club and country. And yet there remains the argument he didn’t reach his full potential.
Reaction and Player Ratings : Burnley 1-1 Manchester United
Manchester United took a first half lead and had two goals disallowed and yet still failed to win against a Burnley team rooted in a relegation battle. Ralf Rangnick dropped Cristiano Ronaldo but was left to call on him when a decent first half performance gave way to a progressively abysmal second. Burnley, with one win all season, were playing their 5000th game – and Turf Moor has been the venue for many classic visits of Manchester United in the past.
“We can do things in the transfer market that other clubs can only dream of” - Evaluating Ed Woodward’s Reign at Man Utd
You knew things were going to be different the moment Sir Alex Ferguson retired. In the era which followed, there have been five managers at Manchester United, six if we’re including interim, seven if we’re including Michael Carrick. But this has been Ed Woodward’s era of control, an era which officially ends as from today he is succeeded by Richard Arnold. So, how did he do? “We can do things in the transfer market that other clubs can only dream of,” Woodward boasted in the summer of 2014.
Show More
loading
Actions
Get in touch with Wayne
Contact Wayne, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack