Most election disinformation in South Africa isn’t fake – it’s real footage with a false story attached, which does damage to our trust long before the count is complete, writes William Bird. Early this week, a video went round of presiding officers in Rustenburg handling envelopes after special-vote home visits. Without context, it looked like ballot tampering.
William Bird
Johannesburg
Director of Media Monitoring Africa, Ashoka and Linc Fellow, love monitoring and analysing media. Also love data and data journalism
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by William Bird
Misinformation, disinformation and the threat to electoral integrity
DIGITAL MENACE OP-ED Harmful online content around elections is changing, with institutions like the Electoral Commission of South Africa becoming a target in campaigns to discredit the credibility of the electoral process. Institutions such as the Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) have become the target of misinformation and disinformation campaigns in the lead up to the 2026 municipal elections.
OPINION | Anti-disinformation alliance is a robust antidote to fake news
Imagine opening your phone on election day to a video showing violent clashes at a voting station. The caption claims the station is in your ward, asserts that the South African Police Service and the Electoral Commission of South Africa (IEC) have lost control and advises residents to remain indoors. Fearful for your safety, you decide not to vote.
Real411 brings legal muscle to the fight against election disinformation
AI-generated deepfakes and election disinformation can discourage voters from participating and undermine democratic processes. South Africa’s IEC has a dedicated Disinformation Code of Conduct for political parties and candidates. Real411 provides an official public platform for reporting online electoral harms, including disinformation and hate speech.
Between brilliance and inertia — the dual reality of SA’s legal landscape
South Africa’s courts reveal a troubling divide: judicial brilliance can deliver swift constitutional justice, while crippling delays leave equality, dignity and accountability hanging in the balance. William Bird is the director of Moxii Africa, Ashoka and a Linc Fellow. Opinion This article is an Opinion, which presents the writer's personal point of view. The views expressed are those of the author/authors and do not necessarily represent the views of Daily Maverick.
Communications authority ordered to fast-track political broadcast complaints
Last week we (Moxii Africa) won an application for leave to appeal against the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (Icasa). There are three significant aspects to the victory. One of them will have a near immediate positive impact for political party election broadcasts, just before the upcoming local government elections. A bit of background.
When misinformation becomes a weapon — Afrophobia, social media and 30 June
Finding the truth At a time when misinformation and hate can spread rapidly online, public vigilance and responsible reporting are more important than ever. Illustrative image: A smartphone. (Image: Magnific) | Marchers during the protest against illegal immigration at Mary Fitzgerald Square in Johannesburg. March and March is demanding tighter immigration controls. (Photo: Luba Lesolle / Gallo Images) | (By Daniella Lee Ming Yesca) South Africa is entering a dangerous period.
Grok’s undress feature violates South Africans’ rights, and must be stopped now
DIGITAL DANGER OP-ED Moxii Africa (formerly Media Monitoring Africa) has issued letters of demand to the South African government and to X Corp to ensure Grok AI acts immediately to disable the ‘undressing’ feature of Grok, and any other feature that allows users to create and share non-consensual intimate images and child sexual abuse material.
World News Day — we need an information system that works for all
If you are in the media, news and journalism sector, you will be bombarded each day with increasingly urgent messages and information about how dire the situation is for news media and public interest content. Don't want to see this? Remove ads Just this week, the High-Level Panel on Public Interest published an open letter highlighting the critical need for urgent action on protecting public interest content.
SABC could face signal blackout by the end of 2025, but there’s hope
PUBLIC BROADCASTER OP-ED Illustrative Image: A general view of the South African Broadcasting Corporation (SABC) Head Office in JHB on April 10, 2019 Auckland Park, Johannesburg (Photo by Gallo Images/ Fani Mahuntsi) | Money (Image: Istock) | SABC logo (Wiki images) The SABC is on the brink of collapse due to outdated infrastructure and legislation, as well as its inadequate funding model. Yet work is under way to get the public broadcaster back on track.
Competition Commission finding back media’s fight for reliable information
The provisional findings of the Competition Commissions report on the Media and Digital Platforms Market Inquiry (MDPMI) have created a sensation in the media sector. The outcome affects not only competition between news media and social and search media platforms such as Google, Meta/Facebook and TikTok but may also ensure the public gets credible news and information from diverse and pluralistic media.
Zuckerberg, Musk and weaponising freedom of expression
FREE SPEECH OP-ED Mark Zuckerberg seems to be using a compelling freedom of expression argument not to deepen and protect freedom of expression, but to weaponise it instead. The announcement last week by Mark Zuckerberg about changes to the Meta platforms, first being rolled out in the US, has been widely criticised. They come while credible news media are being subjected to ongoing attacks, most commonly from Elon Musk, but also Donald Trump. Don't want to see this?
Solly Malatsi takes on a communications ministry stuck in the past century
DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES OP-ED We are behind almost everyone in the world in switching from analogue to digital. Our performance here is only slightly worse than our efforts to ensure universal access to cheap, fast, reliable internet. Our news media sector is facing the most extraordinary challenges just to keep afloat.
The 2024 Summer Reading Challenge is here, featuring 28 books with Tucson ties
After a brief hiatus, #ThisIsTucson's Summer Reading Challenge is back — and it might be the best one yet. If you've been a #ThisIsTucson reader for a while, you might know that the news organization, which is the Arizona Daily Star's sister site, curates a reading list most summers, centered around local authors and books with topics relevant to our area.
The 2024 Summer Reading Challenge is here, featuring 28 books with Tucson ties đ Original
After a brief hiatus, #ThisIsTucson's Summer Reading Challenge is back â and it might be our best one yet. If you've been a #ThisIsTucson reader for a while, you might know that we curate a reading list most summers, centered around local authors and books with topics relevant to our area. This year, we've teamed up with the lovely people at Tucson-loving shop Why I Love Where I Live to put together the ultimate summer reading list, packed with more than two dozen reads.
Real411 develops tool to track online incitement
ROAD TO 2024 ELECTIONS OP-ED There has, understandably, been a significant focus on the threat posed by misinformation and disinformation in the lead-up to SA's national elections on Wednesday.
FACT CHECK | Dare to compare: How to use WhatsApp to check if a political party ad is real or rubbish
With elections getting closer, political parties will likely make outragrous claims, whether it is via adverts on street poles or via social media. To figure out whether a claim is real or rubbish, Media Monitoring Africa has launched a simple WhatsApp AI bot called AdCompare to help voters get the truth, write William Bird and Thandi Smith. As we head closer to elections, we know parties will be going all out for our vote.
FACT CHECK | Dare to compare: How to use WhatsApp to check if a political party ad is real or rubbish
With elections getting closer, political parties will likely make outragrous claims, whether it is via adverts on street poles or via social media. To figure out whether a claim is real or rubbish, Media Monitoring Africa has launched a simple WhatsApp AI bot called AdCompare to help voters get the truth, write William Bird and Thandi Smith. As we head closer to elections, we know parties will be going all out for our vote.
Parties take note
ROAD TO 2024 ELECTIONS OP-ED The media matter. Journalists matter. It seems that we need to remind the political parties of their obligations under the Electoral Code – without credible media there can’t be credible elections. Each day closer to voting means tensions escalate and parties continue to campaign. Most involved will have had little to no sleep, so we can expect tempers to flare and patience to be thin.
As elections near, it’s time to ask political parties about use of AI
DIGITAL RISKS OP-ED Artificial intelligence is constantly evolving. Manipulating information has become easier than ever before. Those with nefarious agendas, or whose aim is distort reality to further a political agenda, to sow division, have the tools readily available to do just that. Artificial intelligence (AI) has been the buzz term of the year, understandably so as developments around it have been nothing short of astonishing.
Skills you need to fight mis- and disinformation
ONLINE HARMS OP-ED In this piece we look beyond the online harms to actions the public can take, and specifically the issue of media literacy. Media and information literacy has been a staple programme of Media Monitoring Africa (MMA) for 26 years, but it has tended to focus on children being equipped with critical media and digital literacy skills (read more about it here and here).
Tackling misinformation, disinformation
ROAD TO 2024 ELECTIONS OP-ED As we approach the elections on 29 May, with the IEC as a constant and ongoing vector for the polls, we have seen misinformation and disinformation about the commission being spread, with peaks relating to specific events and stories. There is no doubt that misinformation and disinformation pose a real threat to South Africa’s forthcoming general elections.
William Bird | IOL's malicious attack on Karyn Maughan undermines journalism | News24
Through a textual analysis of IOL's piece on News24 journalist Karyn Maughan, William Bird shows how the attack piece is ridiculous, does not hold up to the Press Code and undermines journalism. It's hard to know quite where to begin with the piece widely publicised across IOL platforms and social media accounts, that asks the question, Is Karyn Maughan South Africa's Leni Riefenstahl?
‘Unspeakably outdated’: SABC Bill slammed
The draft SABC Bill has drawn howls of condemnation from experts, who say it is merely a rehash of existing legislation.
AHF Products® Announces William M. Bird as Distributor of AHF Contract® Commercial Flooring in the Southeast
AHF Products®, a leader in commercial flooring solutions, has announced it is partnering with William M. Bird to represent the company’s comprehensive commercial flooring portfolio under the AHF Contract® brand. “Aligning ourselves with strong partners in distribution like William M. Bird is essential to our growth across our business, and this is especially true for the commercial segment,” said Fred Reitz, Vice President-Commercial, AHF Products®.
OPINIONISTA: Moti vs amaBhungane ruling – there is much to celebrate, but we need more
The response to the judgment in the Moti vs amaBhungane case has thus far been overwhelmingly positive, and media organisations, ourselves included, have welcomed the outcome. The ruling was important as a vindication of the importance of media freedom, of the need for journalists to protect their sources, to disallow efforts that seek to abuse the court system and to highlight the importance of journalists exposing wrongdoing. This piece by amaBhungane sets out the key issues well.
William Bird | Court victory reveals amaBhungane wasn't trying to be a law unto themselves
Following amaBhungane's victory over the Moti group on Monday, William Bird writes that when the media are unfairly challenged, we need to ensure that justice prevails. On 3 July 2023, amaBhungane achieved a significant court victory over the Moti Group (Mazetti). The victory is significant and serves to remind us of the critical importance not just of media freedom and due process, but also serves as a hard lesson to those who seek to muzzle the media.
OPINIONISTA: Moti Group’s interdict against amaBhungane is a travesty of justice
William Bird is the director of Media Monitoring Africa, Ashoka and a Linc Fellow. The Moti Group’s case against amaBhungane matters to every person in South Africa. If we let the interdict stand, whistle-blowers will be exposed to greater risk and the job of investigative journalists will be even harder. The recent interdict against amaBhungane by the Moti Group raises three critical issues. First, a travesty of justice.
PUBLIC BROADCASTER OP-ED: Mr President, please follow your mandate and finally appoint the SABC board
Here we are again. The SABC is in crisis, one entirely manufactured by Parliament’s portfolio committee on communication and the President of South Africa. It’s not just the SABC though. South Africa, it seems, is caught in a crisis spiral where seemingly the only things we are good at are being in crises, and mitigating them. It might be comforting for the government to always operate in a crisis these days, as it seems impossible for it to act without one. See Eskom, for an example.
COMPULSORY NPO REGISTRATION OP-ED: SA’s harebrained scheme to register NPOs will not solve terrorist financing concerns
COMPULSORY NPO REGISTRATION OP-ED South Africa’s response to the threat of being greylisted by trade body FAFT is to force the registration of all non-profits with the NPO Directorate. But this notion has far-reaching — and patently unconstitutional — repercussions. Rabbits were introduced to Australia in 1859 so that they could be hunted. Yep, a daft reason, but it was more than 160 years ago.
UNCRITICAL GAZE OP-ED: Ramping up the vamp — when the media uncritically reports on a child model at New York Fashion Week while ignoring the core issues
UNCRITICAL GAZE OP-ED The news that an 11-year-old South African girl will model at New York Fashion Week has raised multiple issues, including those related to churnalism, the sexualisation of children and the use of child models. Two weeks ago the news broke that a young South African girl was going to model for the New York Fashion Week.
William Bird | Attacks on journalist perpetuate disinformation strategies and threaten democracy
The current attacks on News24 legal journalist Karyn Maughan aren't just despicable for how they insult and demean and violate her dignity, they are despicable because they perpetuate and celebrate misogyny and threaten freedom of expression and our democracy, writes Media Monitoring Africa's William Bird. Sometimes our media are their own worst enemies– but without them, our democracy would be even weaker, if not failed.
OPINION | Krugersdorp rapes: Care and nuance needed in reporting on horrific attack | News24
The media need to do better when reporting the gang rape in Krugersdorp. Currently, some stories and headlines create more confusion and tension when dealing with an already heightened emotive situation, write Thandi Smith and William Bird. Many things can be true at the same time – rape, illegal immigration, robbery, assault, drug dealing - are all crimes that need action. Not all crimes are equal. Rape is a crime. It is one of the most egregious acts of violence and abuses of power.
WEEKLY TRENDS IN SOUTH AFRICA OP-ED: Disinformation in a time of Covid-19: Social media needs Rapid Information and Communications Task Team
WEEKLY TRENDS IN SOUTH AFRICA OP-ED It’s easy to feel despair when we remember the violence that erupted in KZN and Gauteng just over a year ago. There was a proliferation of mis- and disinformation around the unrest, and we also saw a combination of online harms that worked together to heighten tension and anxieties. We need a social media monitoring task team to mitigate these harms in the future.
CONSTITUTIONAL DEMOCRACY OP-ED: Current version of Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Bill better, but still has unconstitutional elements
CONSTITUTIONAL DEMOCRACY OP-ED Combating hate speech and hate crimes isn’t only about consequences, redress, and accountability. It needs also to be about prevention, moving forward and seeking to reduce hate crimes and hate speech — rudiments the Prevention and Combating of Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Bill must strive for. It seems apt, given the recent increase in xenophobia, that the Draft Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Bill should be before Parliament for public submissions.
RIGHT TO INFORMATION OP-ED: Constitutional Court to hear key case on rights of the visually impaired to access copyrighted works
“Equality is the soul of liberty; there is, in fact, no liberty without it” — Frances Wright. Last week we celebrated World Press Freedom Day, which focuses on the right to freedom of expression. This week the Constitutional Court will hear a case about a key component of freedom of expression — access to information.
MEDIA CENSORSHIP OP-ED: Freedom of expression is under threat in Russia’s war against Ukraine
The Russia-Ukraine war undoubtedly has, and will continue to have, devastating impacts on countless people. The list of human rights violations grows, and the deplorable actions of Russian forces, in violation of international and humanitarian law, should be condemned in the strongest terms. Media censorship as a tool of war Against this backdrop, the right to freedom of expression has not been spared from the casualties of war.
Disinformation in a time of Covid-19
As our last piece for 2021, we wanted to start with a big thank you! There are so many to thank, like our Real411 volunteer reviewers and the Real411 secretariat. But our biggest thank you goes to all of you who take the time to submit complaints. The Real411 system has received a little over 1,000 complaints this year – most of them Covid-19-related. One of our colleagues pointed out that this is a mere drop in the ocean of disinformation and digital harms.
DISINFORMATION IN A TIME OF COVID-19 OP-ED: Sorting the real from the rubbish and challenging those who stir the Omicron pot of fear
Week 41: Discerning the cred from the crud It was another busy week for Real411, with complaints received that ranged from the vaccine being the invention of the devil to how the water interruptions for maintenance and repairs in Johannesburg were really about enabling the government to flood the water system with the latest variant. These examples are at the extreme and are easy to disprove by applying basic logic.
South Africa: How to Rapidly Combat Digital Harms and Cybersecurity Threats
This week we look at speed as a factor of combating disinformation. We then look at disinformation as an issue of cybersecurity. Week 40: Acting on disinformation peddlers Disinformation spreads incredibly fast, and much faster than truth. It destroys democracy and causes public harm - and does so super speedily and efficiently. There are a number of evolving strategies, many of which we have written about previously, to help combat disinformation.
DISINFORMATION IN A TIME OF COVID-19 OP-ED: How to rapidly combat digital harms and cybersecurity threats
Week 40: Acting on disinformation peddlers Disinformation spreads incredibly fast, and much faster than truth. It destroys democracy and causes public harm – and does so super speedily and efficiently. There are a number of evolving strategies, many of which we have written about previously, to help combat disinformation. These range from counter narratives and disseminating quality, accurate content to shutting down services, removing accounts and downgrading posts so fewer people see them.
DISINFORMATION IN A TIME OF COVID-19 OP-ED: How disinformers use the fear of the unknown to cloud rational thought
This image shared on social media was also a story on Opera news (more about them in a little bit). It was reported and processed as complaint 1965 on Real411.org. It suggests a two-month lockdown, and warns that the public should stock up on alcohol presumably before the lockdown hits. Pick n Pay has denied that it is one of its posters and it doesn’t appear to have been used anywhere else. What the poster does is speak to the future.
DISINFORMATION IN A TIME OF COVID-19 OP-ED: Beware of fake content that exploits emotions and clouds rational thought
Week 38: Clouding rational thought Those who wish to spread disinformation often play on our emotions. It’s a tactic that is also used by salespeople. How many of us, for example, have been in a shop where we are thinking of making a purchase (usually an expensive one) and seeing us hesitate, the salesperson tells us how much interest there has been in the same item and how the one we are looking at is the last one?
DISINFORMATION IN A TIME OF COVID-19 OP-ED: The media (just about) got election coverage right, but challenges remain
Week 37: Free and fair elections and the media Last week, at the IEC’s announcement of the final election results, President Cyril Ramaphosa deviated from his prepared remarks to say the following: “I would also like to thank the media. The media were in many ways the heroes and heroines of this elections process. For they kept us informed of everything that was happening throughout the elections process.
South Africa: Disinformation in a Time of Covid-19 - Local Government Elections 2021
Last week we focused on the significance and importance of the partnership with the social media platforms. This week, as we vote in the local government elections, we look at the trends over the past two weeks. Real411 has been receiving complaints since March 2020. As we near 2,000 complaints, we look at what kinds of issues have been reported in this shortened election period, and pull out some examples.
WEEKLY TRENDS IN SOUTH AFRICA OP-ED: Disinformation in a time of Covid-19: Local government elections 2021
As expected the number of complaints have continued to climb since the start of October. Real411 averaged about 2.6 complaints a day in the first two weeks of October and 3.7 complaints each day for the past two weeks. Unsurprisingly we have also seen a significant spike in elections-related complaints, but interestingly, complaints relating to Covid-19 – usually the vaccine – continue to come in daily.
WEEKLY TRENDS IN SOUTH AFRICA OP-ED: Disinformation in a time of Covid-19: A historic partnership ahead of the municipal elections
Week 35: The significance of partnerships Last week the Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) released a press statement that focused on the announcement of a historic coming together of the IEC, civil society and the major social media platforms. What makes it so important and why should you care? This week we unpack a South African and African first.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with William
Contact William, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack