Writing intros to listicles is my most thankless task as a reviewer, and I always write them last, when I’m closest to being done with the assignment at hand and am nearly able to pick up a book or go swimming or not think of the stuff in the kitchen that I’m currently not eating. Attempting to discern trends feels to me for the most part to be the critic’s most tedious parlor game, akin to trying to discern messages from ashes.