Adjusting remedies after an agency responds to a court remand order may help address political and policy concerns with the bill One of the more contentious provisions of BAAJA relates to remedies. Tribes are frustrated that they will not be able to obtain judicial vacatur of violations of the NHPA – and some Democratic Senators have proposed giving tribes an exemption from the provision that prohibits courts from vacating agency decisions for NHPA violations. That request raises real challenges.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Eric Biber
Weighing the permitting reform bill
A summary of what I think the main changes to enviro law are, and the risks of uncertainty in how it is applied Based on the manager’s amendment, and assessing the bill as it stands, here is my key summary of what I think the major components of Titles I through IV do overall: Eliminate supplemental NEPA based on new information (though it is retained for changes in projects).
The revised permitting reform bill
Amendments announced over the weekend address some key issues, but leave others unresolved The manager’s amendments for BAAJA – the changes to the bill that the primary drafters support – came out Saturday morning. Given the short time frame (the first procedural vote is tomorrow morning), this will have to be a quick overview of those changes and their implications.
Is Permit Certainty Worth It?
The most problematic provision in the permitting reform bill is permit certainty. It’s not even clear it will accomplish what it sets out to do. I’ve written a bunch about the issues certainty provisions of the permitting reform bill. Apparently that provision was a demand of Democratic negotiators, seeking to protect renewable energy from the Trump Administration.
Podesta Is Right
Permitting reform bill asymmetrically makes it easier to grant permits than revoke them. That could have sweeping consequences. At the end of the last week, these comments from John Podesta, a major Democratic Party policy operative, got some attention. He called the permitting reform bill a “loaded howitzer” in the hands of President Trump, should it be enacted as it is currently written.
Addressing fire in the National Forests
Reforming National Forest management to improve fire resilience I wrote earlier about an article I co-authored with Dave Owen on reforming wildfire law. In particular, we identified changes to federal land management, federal air quality law, land-use law, and insurance law to address the interlocking legal and policy challenges wildfire presents. But the scope of our piece necessarily meant limiting the level of detail in our policy suggestions or recommendations.
An Overview of BAAJA
All my posts (to date) on the permitting reform bill before the Senate There’s a lot to ponder in the permitting reform bill before the Senate. I’ve tried to work through what I think the important issues are in Titles I through IV of the bill (which focus on environmental law).
Procedure Versus Substance
Drawing a false dichotomy between procedure and substance does not lead to good policy “If I let you write the substance and you let me write the procedure, I’ll screw you every time.” Former US Rep. Dingell In the prior post I criticized some of the positions of environmental groups in the debates over the Senate permitting reform bill. But advocates of the bill have also made problematic arguments.
Permitting Wars - Legal Planet
Environmental groups should engage constructively with permitting reform The permitting reform bill now being considered in the Senate has provoked fairly vicious fights between “abundance” advocates and at least some environmental groups. I think that there are valid critiques of many of the arguments that each side is making, and I think unpacking those critiques can be helpful in trying to find a path forward for environmental law.
How to Deconstruct Federal Regulation
Section 1401 of the Permitting Reform Bill is a stealth repeal of a wide swath of federal regulatory law, not just environmental law I want to write separately to emphasize how sweeping the permit certainty provisions of Section 1401 of the permitting reform bill likely are.
Improving permitting reform
Suggestions to make the permitting reform bill work better and avoid unintended results I’ve written a bunch about the Senate’s permitting reform bill. My basic takeaway is that I want this bill to pass, but that there are some serious flaws in the bill, particularly in the permit certainty provisions, that must be addressed.
A Major Problem with "Permit Certainty"
The permit certainty provision in the permitting reform bill appears to (inadvertently) change the basic standard for enforcement of most federal law I’ve flagged an additional issues from the permit certainty provision (Section 1401 of the bill) that I think are quite important and worth considering in assessing the merits of the permitting reform bill.
Unpacking the Senate Permitting Reform Bill: Disparate Treatment for Permits
Bill attempts to draw on discrimination law to address disparate treatment for permits, but provision has problems This post continues my review of the provisions of the Senate Permitting Reform Bill, focusing on the disparate treatment permit provisions in Title IV. My introduction to the coverage of the bill is here. My discussion of Title I, covering NEPA is here (for remedies) and here (everything else). My discussion of the Clean Water Act provisions in Title II is here.
Unpacking the Senate Permitting Reform Bill: Permit Certainty
Permit certainty provisions are problematic and unclear in their scope This post continues my review of the provisions of the Senate Permitting Reform Bill, focusing on the permit certainty provisions in Title IV. My introduction to the coverage of the bill is here. My discussion of Title I, covering NEPA is here (for remedies) and here (everything else). My discussion of the Clean Water Act provisions in Title II is here. My discussion of the Endangered Species Act provisions in Title III is here.
Unpacking the Senate Permitting Reform Bill: ESA
Changes to the Endangered Species Act are limited in scope This post continues my review of the provisions of the Senate Permitting Reform Bill, focusing on the Endangered Species Act provisions in Title III. My introduction to the coverage of the bill is here. My discussion of Title I, covering NEPA is here (for remedies) and here (everything else). My discussion of the Clean Water Act provisions in Title II is here. There are only a limited number of changes to the ESA under the bill.
Unpacking the Senate Permitting Reform Bill: CWA
Clean Water Act provisions have largest impacts on Section 404 permitting, and some on Section 401 certification This post continues my review of the provisions of the Senate Permitting Reform Bill, focusing on the Clean Water Act provisions in Title II. My introduction to the coverage of the bill is here. My discussion of Title I, covering NEPA is here (for remedies) and here (everything else). Water Quality Criteria: Section 1201 requires notice and comment for water quality criteria issuance.
Unpacking the Senate Permitting Reform Bill: NEPA
NEPA provisions are substantial in their changes, but (mostly) leave the core of the Act in place I’ve already written some about the Senate permtting reform bill, including the provisions on NEPA remedies. In the next few posts I’m going to take deep dives on Titles I through IV of the bill, which are the primary changes to environmental law. First, I’ll cover the changes to NEPA in Title I besides NEPA remedies (roughly in order as they appear in the bill) and what I think their importance is.
Permitting Reform Bill: NEPA Remedies
Efforts to tailor remedies for NEPA violations address an important issue, but may have misfired To me the most important change in environmental law from the permitting reform bill is the effort to restrict remedies for NEPA violations. I’ve written before about why I think this is important work to do, and why it is important to do it well. And there are good components to the proposal on the table (not just because it aligns some with an earlier suggestion of mine).
A quick overview of the Senate permitting reform bill
Senate bill has major changes for NEPA, some changes for Clean Water Act The bipartisan permitting reform bill – at least the Senate version – is out. You can see it here. My initial take on the bill is below, and I hope to do some more detailed examination of specific provisions soon. My focus will be on the environmental law side, not the transmission side, since that is the part I know better.
A summary of BACA
An overview of my analyses of Proposition 45 I’ve written a lot on the Cal Chamber sponsored initiative to dramatically change CEQA, BACA, which is Proposition 45 on this year’s ballot. Here are some key takeaways from what I’ve written, as well as links to the relevant blog posts. First, BACA will not just apply to CEQA. It broadly expands vested rights and imposes strict time limits for all permitting in the state for covered projects.
The end of endangered species habitat protections in California?
Not quite, but the combination of the Trump Admin and Prop 45 will drastically reduce protections. California likes to portray itself as an environmental leader, and in many ways it is. But in the context of one of the most important areas of environmental law – protecting endangered species – California is on the verge of eliminating most of its protections for the habitat of endangered species.
If Proposition 45 is passed, you may get blindsided by projects you cannot stop. You may want to prepare yourself. A lot of the debates over BACA, the Cal Chamber supported initiative to fundamentally change CEQA (Proposition 45 on the ballot) focus on the initiative’s impacts on CEQA. But from a local government and planning perspective, I would argue that far more important are the sweeping vested rights provisions in the initiative.
More on BACA and data centers
Considering the arguments in a recent op-ed arguing Prop 45 does not cover data centers A key issue in the debate over the Cal Chamber of Commerce CEQA initiative (BACA, or Proposition 45 on the ballot) is whether it includes data centers as the types of projects that are eligible for the CEQA exemptions and vested rights provisions in the initiative. I’ve written about why they may well fall within the scope of BACA. There’s an op-ed to the contrary (available here).
A better approach to wildfire on public lands
Why our proposal improves on Fix Our Forests This blog post was co-authored with Dave Owen, at UC Law SF. The draft article this blog post series is based is here. This is the seventh in a series of blog posts on our proposal to reform wildfire law in the United States. The first post is here. The second post is here. The third post is here. The fourth post is here. The fifth post is here. The sixth post is here.
Insurance Law and Wildfire
Providing a federal backstop for wildfire insurance in return for state and local reforms This blog post was co-authored with Dave Owen, at UC Law SF. The draft article this blog post series is based is here. This is the sixth in a series of blog posts on our proposal to reform wildfire law in the United States. The first post is here. The second post is here. The third post is here. The fourth post is here. The fifth post is here.
Land-Use Law and Wildfire
Creating incentives for local and state governments to manage development in high-risk areas This blog post was co-authored with Dave Owen, at UC Law SF. The draft article this blog post series is based is here. This is the fifth in a series of blog posts on our proposal to reform wildfire law in the United States. The first post is here. The second post is here. The third post is here. The fourth post is here. Any successful effort to address fire in the United States must address land-use.
Wildfire and Air Quality Law
Reforming how the Clean Air Act handles smoke from wildfires This blog post was co-authored with Dave Owen, at UC Law SF. The draft article this blog post series is based is here. This is the fourth in a series of blog posts on our proposal to reform wildfire law in the United States. The first post is here. The second post is here. The third post is here.
Wildfire and National Forests
Reforming federal forest management to address wildfire This blog post was co-authored with Dave Owen, at UC Law SF. The draft article this blog post series is based is here. This is the third in a series of blog posts on our proposal to reform wildfire law in the United States. The first post is here. The second post is here. Federally managed Forest Service lands comprise about 30% of all US forests, disproportionately in the western United States, where fire issues have been particularly severe.
The Challenges of Wildfire
Why wildfire management is so difficult to reform This blog post was co-authored with Dave Owen, at UC Law SF. The draft article this blog post series is based is here. This is the second in a series of blog posts on our proposal to reform wildfire law in the United States. The first post is here. Why is fire such a hard problem to solve? Understanding the answers to that question helped us develop proposals to improve fire policy in the United States. First, fire is dynamic.
Fixing Wildfire Law
The urgent challenge of reforming how we manage wildfire This blog post was co-authored with Dave Owen, at UC Law SF. The draft article this blog post series is based is here. Every year brings another reminder of why fire is at the top of environmental and natural resource issues for the United States, and how our legal system struggles to adjust to fire. The recent fires that destroyed hundreds of homes in Spokane, Washington are just the most recent example.
NEPA and Remedies
Trying to solve the difficult challenge of reforming remedies for NEPA violations Earlier this year, the Institute for Progress (a pro-permitting reform organization) published a series of proposals for changing remedies for agency violations of NEPA. There are good reasons to think about the problem.
NEPA and Remedies
The difficult challenge of trying to reform remedies for NEPA violations Earlier this year, the Institute for Progress (a pro-permitting reform organization) published a series of proposals for changing remedies for agency violations of NEPA. There are good reasons to think about the problem.
Whither Permitting Reform for NEPA?
Engaging with the key questions for NEPA in any permitting reform bill This interview by Heatmap News with a leading actor (Daniel Palken at the Arnold Foundation) in the permitting reform debates is informative and productive – both on the status of those talks right now, and on their history and why they are important. Here I just want to focus on one aspect of the interview where I have written the most before, and where I know the challenges are hard: Changes to NEPA.
The Limits of Implementation for BACA
Potential practical limits on the scope of the initiative to rewrite CEQA I’ve done a lot of analysis of the potential scope of the Cal Chamber initiative on the ballot this fall to fundamentally rework CEQA. However, I also want to highlight a range of constraints that I think will limit the practical impact of the initiative. In doing so, I do not want to minimize the substantial changes the initiative likely will have, both to the law and on the ground.
BACA and planning
Initiative to fundamentally rewrite CEQA will have important implications for planning in California A key question under the CEQA initiative on the ballot this fall, should it be enacted, is how it will relate to planning in California law. The question is an important one because planning has long been a key component of California land-use and environmental law. All local governments are required by state law to have general plans.
Ensuring Environmental Protections Without CEQA
The legislature could take steps to address the impacts on state environmental law of the enactment of BACA this November It seems likely at this point that the Cal Chamber initiative to significantly rewrite CEQA will pass this fall. A recent PPIC poll found over 70% support for the initiative. As I’ve noted earlier, a real concern with any change to CEQA is that key parts of California’s system of environmental protections depend on CEQA.
Trying to Create Permit Certainty
A new permitting reform bill does a good job of managing tradeoffs for a difficult problem Last month two Senators proposed another permitting reform bill, the FREEDOM Act. This is a revised version of a bill that was introduced in the House earlier this year, which I wrote about before.
Off the Road Again?
Trump Administration revocations of ORV Executive Orders won’t have direct effects on the ground, yet. Last month the Trump Administration revoked two executive orders over forty years old that directed federal agencies to restrict off-road vehicle use (ORV) on public lands in order to protect those lands’ environmental value. The revocation is, of course, controversial, and of a piece of a scorched earth approach to environmental regulation this Administration has taken.
In Harm’s Way - Legal Planet
Agency’s efforts to repeal harm definition for the ESA carries significant legal risks The Trump Administration has finalized a rule that would eliminate the definition of harm from the regulations implementing the Endangered Species Act (ESA). Harm is one component of the definition of take in the ESA, and Section 9 of the ESA prohibits take of members of endangered species.
BACA and unions - Legal Planet
The complicated dynamics of unions and CEQA may impact this fall’s CEQA ballot initiative In this post I will assess the labor provisions of the California Chamber of Commerce’s ballot initiative to drastically overhaul CEQA, which will be on the ballot in November. The quick summary is that those provisions turn out to generally codify current practice or law – and importantly, may not be locked-in against subsequent state legislative changes (in contrast to most of the initiative provisions).
BACA and Data Centers, Part II
The inclusion of data centers within this fall’s CEQA ballot initiative may make it much harder to regulate their construction This is the second of two posts exploring whether the California Chamber of Commerce’s ballot initiative to drastically reform CEQA might facilitate the construction of data centers in California. In the first post, I examined whether data centers fall within the scope of the initiative (and concluded they likely do so).
BACA and Data Centers, Part I
Ballot initiative may facilitate construction of data centers in California As I noted in my initial analysis of the California Chamber of Commerce’s ballot initiative to rollback most of CEQA, one important point about the initiative is how many different projects are covered by it – despite the framing that it only covers “essential projects.” One kind of development project that is particularly controversial right now are data centers.
Reforming CEQA Part 6
Providing for quicker, more expert dispute resolution This is the sixth in a series of blog posts on reforming the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). The first post, discussing different paradigms for CEQA, is here. The second post, discussing the conceptual framework for reform, is here. The third post, discussing designating a state agency to set binding, clear standards for CEQA implementation, and setting stricter limits on alternatives analysis, is here.
Reforming CEQA Part 5
Creating greater clarity for thresholds of signficance, and default methodologies and mitigation measures This is the fifth in a series of blog posts on reforming the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). The first post, discussing different paradigms for CEQA, is here. The second post, discussing the conceptual framework for reform, is here.
Reforming CEQA Part 4
Providing greater clarity on the types of impacts covered by CEQA This is the fourth in a series of blog posts on reforming the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). The first post, discussing different paradigms for CEQA, is here. The second post, discussing the conceptual framework for reform, is here. The third post, discussing designating a state agency to set binding, clear standards for CEQA implementation, and setting stricter limits on alternatives analysis, is here.
Reforming CEQA Part 3
Adding more binding clear standards for CEQA plus focusing alternatives analysis This is the third in a series of blog posts on reforming the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). The first post, discussing different paradigms for CEQA, is here. The second post, discussing the conceptual framework for reform, is here.
Reforming CEQA, part 2
Concepts for reforming CEQA as a backstop environmental law This is the second in a series of six blog posts on reforming the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). The first post, discussing different paradigms for CEQA, is here. What reforms might be needed in orienting CEQA around a paradigm as a backstop environmental law?
Reforming CEQA Part 1
Thinking about CEQA as a backstop statute The qualification for the November ballot of the California Chamber of Commerce ballot initiative rewriting CEQA does create an opportunity, if the legislature is so inclined, to strike a deal with the proponents and do an overhaul of CEQA. As I noted in the last of my series of blog posts on the initiative, there are real issues with CEQA and its implementation – but the ballot initiative is an imperfect tool to address those issues.
Is BACA Constitutional?
Limitations on judicial review in the initiative might violate separation of powers The California Chamber of Commerce initiative to rewrite the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) has strict limits on judicial review for challenges to agency decisions for projects covered by the initiative.
BACA makes the ballot
Initiative to drastically change CEQA appears to have enough signatures to make ballot It looks like the California Chamber of Commerce has enough signatures to put on the November ballot their initiative that would drastically change the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Eric
Contact Eric, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack