Talk about kismet. This jewel box of a Manhattan penthouse is kismet’s kiss—a tale of unrequited apartment love with a gratifying denouement. In January 2013, the Lyford Cay Club, in New Providence, Bahamas, hosted a design weekend. Designer Hutton Wilkinson was slated to speak on the subject of his extraordinary late mentor and friend Tony Duquette. “I went to the lecture,” says New Yorker Andree Caldwell, “and a lightbulb came on.