Published by The Lawfare Institute in Cooperation With Thanks to its association with the attack on the U.S. Capitol, Parler, a social media network popular with supporters of former President Trump, became a household name just in time to vanish from the web. In that narrow window between Jan. 6 and Jan.
Grayson Clary
As seen in:
CNN,
Post Outlook,
The Atlantic,
The Christian Science Monitor,
Truthout,
Aeon,
Defense One,
WYFF-TV (Greenville, SC),
Lawfare,
War on the Rocks
and
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Grayson Clary
Full season
Oops! It looks like AdBlock or a similar tool has prevented this page from loading. Please disable the plugin for all Hudl.com pages and refresh your browser. 395 views | 4:26 | Dec 02, 2024
What the US Supreme Court’s next term holds for the First Amendment
If you like this post, sign up to get The Nuance newsletter delivered straight to your inbox! This past year, the U.S. Supreme Court’s docket was as crowded with First Amendment controversies as any term in modern memory. When the justices gather to kick off the next one at Monday’s “long conference,” things promise — at least for the freedoms of speech and the press — to be a bit quieter.
Clinton
Oops! It looks like AdBlock or a similar tool has prevented this page from loading. Please disable the plugin for all Hudl.com pages and refresh your browser. 30 views | 1:24 | Sep 21, 2024
A blockbuster term at the US Supreme Court - and the work still to do
If you like this post, sign up to get The Nuance newsletter delivered straight to your inbox every Sunday night! It’s starting to sound like we say this every year: Rarely does the U.S. Supreme Court’s term produce as many transformative decisions as this one did, from presidential immunity to the viability of the modern administrative state. The Court’s First Amendment caseload, by comparison, was something of a dog that didn’t bark. Longstanding precedents survived; the internet still works.
Congress’s crackdown on ‘terrorist supporting organizations’ threatens nonprofit news
Journalists covering issues of clear public concern often report on illegal conduct — not to reward or encourage it, but to inform the public. The First Amendment protects that core press function; still, officials with their own agenda have often tried to skew the news in a preferred direction by accusing the press of support for violence or lawbreaking they cover.
US Supreme Court won’t review decision that ratchets up legal risk at protests - Editor and Publisher
Posted Tuesday, April 23, 2024 6:00 am One of the First Amendment’s bedrock protections for a free press and free expression is the rule that an individual lawfully exercising their constitutional rights can’t be held liable for a stranger’s uncoordinated decision to break the law nearby.
SCOTUS won’t review decision that ratchets up legal risk at protests
If you like this post, sign up to get The Nuance newsletter delivered straight to your inbox every Sunday night! One of the First Amendment’s bedrock protections for a free press and free expression is the rule that an individual lawfully exercising their constitutional rights can’t be held liable for a stranger’s uncoordinated decision to break the law nearby.
In crowded week for free speech, justices hear 3 First Amendment cases
If you like this post, sign up to get The Nuance newsletter delivered straight to your inbox every Sunday night! It’s a refrain you’ve heard us emphasize before: The current U.S. Supreme Court has a remarkable appetite for free-speech controversies, and it’s difficult to think of a recent term that measures up to this one in either the volume or the significance of the First Amendment questions presented.
In blockbuster First Amendment cases, US Supreme Court seems splintered
If you like this post, sign up to get The Nuance newsletter delivered straight to your inbox every Sunday night! For readers of this newsletter, it likely seems like NetChoice v. Paxtonand NetChoice v. Moody — where social media firms challenge Texas and Florida’s efforts to control how the platforms curate user content — have been inching their way toward the U.S. Supreme Court since time immemorial.
In Texas, a disastrous ruling for journalists’ rights
If you like this post, sign up to get The Nuance newsletter delivered straight to your inbox every Sunday night! “If the First Amendment means anything,” Judge James Ho of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit wrote in a 2022 opinion, “it surely means that a citizen journalist has the right to ask a public official a question, without fear of being imprisoned.” Common sense, right?
Journalist Josie Huang reaches major settlement with LA County
If you like this post, sign up to get The Nuance newsletter delivered straight to your inbox every Sunday night! In a resolution that sets a new benchmark for reporters injured by law enforcement, Josie Huang — a reporter for NPR member station LAist 89.3, formerly known as KPCC — reached a $700,000 settlement agreement with Los Angeles County and the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department in connection with her unlawful arrest while covering a protest in 2020.
SCOTUS will take up First Amendment limits on retaliatory arrests
The justices are on a free-speech spree. In short succession over the last year and change, the U.S. Supreme Court has taken up a string of cases touching nearly every corner of First Amendment doctrine, from compelled speech and true threats to expression that aids or abets a crime.
RCFP, media coalition urge Supreme Court to make live audio permanent
For much of the U.S. Supreme Court’s history, the opportunity to follow oral arguments in real time was limited to the 50 some-odd members of the public able to squeeze into the courtroom. That changed in 2020, when the justices — adapting to the COVID-19 pandemic — shifted to telephonic arguments and let the press and public tune in. This week, the Reporters Committee and a coalition of 62 media organizations sent a letter to Chief Justice John G.
LA judge greenlights dangerous prior restraint in LAPD photo controversy
In a concerning ruling this month, a California Superior Court judge allowed the city of Los Angeles to move forward with a lawsuit seeking to claw back police personnel records that the city itself (inadvertently) provided to local journalist Ben Camacho.
How journalists’ rights fared at the Supreme Court this term
These days, as professors RonNell Andersen Jones and Sonja West have documented, the U.S. Supreme Court rarely turns its attention directly to press freedom and rarely thinks out loud about the impact its rulings will have on journalists. But questions important to the rights of reporters still routinely lurk beneath the surface of the court’s decisions, as its most recent term, which featured a remarkable roster of free speech controversies, starkly underlines.
As Congress weighs reauthorization, controversial spying tool turns 15
Last Monday marked 15 years since the enactment of the FISA Amendments Act of 2008, the bill that created one of the Intelligence Community’s most powerful (and most controversial) surveillance tools — the authority commonly called Section 702.
With weeks to go, Supreme Court mulls major First Amendment questions
If the U.S. Supreme Court’s current term ended tomorrow, its decisions in Gonzalez v. Googleand Twitter v. Taamnehwould suffice to call this year an important one for free speech, if mostly in the sense that the justices declined to rock the boat when it comes to the free flow of information online. But as the Court approaches the final weeks of the term, still sitting on its docket are major First Amendment cases that, together, could significantly reshape the law.
Arrests of journalists continued their decline in 2022, but 2020 still casts a shadow
This is the third installment of our newsletter series analyzing U.S. press freedom violations in 2022. You can find links to all four parts in this blog post. Last year, the number of reporters arrested in the course of newsgathering continued its sharp decline from a historic peak in 2020.
At the high court this week, an important case for immigration reporting
Last December, the U.S. Supreme Court agreed to hear a case that challenges the constitutionality of the federal bar on “encouraging or inducing” unlawful immigration. On Monday, the oral argument in those proceedings will offer a window into whether the justices believe the statute can be squared with the First Amendment — a question that could have important consequences for journalists who cover unlawful activity, at the border and beyond. As we’ve written before, the case, United States v.
The right to record keeps inching its way through the courts
As we’ve written time and again, every federal court of appeals to address the question agrees: The First Amendment protects your right to film police officers engaged in the performance of their public duties. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit joined that chorus last week, signing on to a consensus that the First, Third, Fifth, Seventh, Ninth, Tenth, and Eleventh Circuits have all already endorsed.
Supreme Court pushes Texas, Florida social media cases down the road
Most expect that the U.S. Supreme Court will eventually take up the question whether — and to what extent — the First Amendment allows states to regulate content curation on social media platforms. The justices, though, are in no particular hurry to settle the issue.
Government can't keep surveillance orders secret, district court rules
When the question of how far the government can go in commandeering private firms to assist surveillance exploded onto the public scene in 2015, high-ranking federal officials insisted that “democracies resolve such tensions through robust debate.” After the FBI’s bid to force Apple to decrypt the San Bernardino shooter’s iPhone fizzled without a judicial resolution, that debate petered out too.
Florida and Silicon Valley agree: Justices, hear this case
Often — shading into typically — the party that wins a lawsuit in a lower court would prefer that things end there. But not in NetChoice v. Moody, the high-profile First Amendment challenge to Florida’s content-moderation statute, where the platforms that largely prevailed below have filed a brief agreeing with the state that the matter deserves the Supreme Court’s attention.
Judicial Security and Privacy Act raises First Amendment concerns
Since the tragic 2020 attack on the family of Judge Esther Salas, in which a gunman killed Salas’s 20-year-old son Daniel Anderl and wounded her husband at their New Jersey home, Congress has weighed whether to make it easier for federal judges to keep their personal information out of the public domain.
At the Supreme Court, the makings of a historic term for internet law
If the U.S. Supreme Court decides to hear (as is widely expected) either or both of the NetChoice cases challenging state efforts to regulate content moderation on social media, that decision would be grounds enough to call the upcoming term a blockbuster for media law.
An unconstitutional law quickly collides with the First Amendment
That was fast. Our readers are already familiar with Arizona’s House Bill 2319, a statute enacted this summer that would have given police officers standardless discretion to decide whether they want to be recorded from within eight feet. The Reporters Committee had joined a coalition letter, spearheaded by the National Press Photographers Association, urging lawmakers not to pass legislation that would never survive contact with the First Amendment. No luck; the bill passed.
Another shot at challenging secret surveillance?
Almost 10 years after Edward Snowden shed light on the vast scope of the National Security Agency’s internet surveillance activities, it remains exceptionally difficult for anyone challenging those programs to get their day in court. Often, lawsuits are thrown out before they can reach the merits for lack of proof that the plaintiff in particular was monitored, or on the theory that litigating the case would risk exposing state secrets.
So you want to unseal a warrant
At the Reporters Committee, we spend a fair share of our time arguing that the public is entitled to transparency when the government seeks warrants, surveillance orders and other criminal-investigative authorities from the federal courts — but it isn’t a topic that usually makes for A1 news. That changed this month, as readers likely know, when the U.S. Justice Department obtained a warrant to search Mar-a-Lago for sensitive documents that may have been retained by former President Donald Trump.
In Colorado, another victory for the right to record police
Though the U.S. Supreme Court has never addressed the issue, a robust consensus in the lower courts holds that you have a First Amendment right to record police officers carrying out their public duties in public spaces. In a too-gradual game of dominos, appeals court after appeals court has signed onto that view, endorsing a result that should be common sense. Last week, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit joined the chorus in Irizarry v.
After SCOTUS surveillance decision, a Fourth Amendment in disarray?
When it comes to rights against government surveillance, the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2018 decision in Carpenter v. United States was greeted as an occasion for dancing in the streets.
In Supreme Court’s shadow, another important ruling for free speech online
The free speech and press freedom community has been holding its breath this week while the U.S. Supreme Court considers an emergency application for relief in NetChoice v. Paxton, the First Amendment challenge to Texas’s content-moderation statute. If the justices let the law stay in effect, the result will be a significant shift in internet law.
In one-sentence ruling, appeals court upends the First Amendment online
As readers of this newsletter know, the Reporters Committee has filed friend-of-the-court briefs in a number of cases where state efforts to regulate new digital platforms also threaten traditional press freedoms. So far, those statutes have run aground when tested against the First Amendment. Last week, though, Texas’s bid to enforce its vision of editorial fairness won a warm reception in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.
For data journalists, an important legal victory
In a closely watched decision last month, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit delivered data journalists an important legal victory, holding that scraping a publicly available website doesn’t violate the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act — the federal anti-hacking law. While the opinion won’t be the last word on the subject, it begins to dispel some of the ambiguities that (as we’ve written before) the powerful too often wield to chill investigative journalism online.
In Texas clash with Silicon Valley, traditional press freedoms at risk
Over the last year, several states have taken an interest in regulating the way that large social media firms curate content on their platforms — first Florida, then Texas, with Georgia potentially next at bat. The statutes passed in Florida and Texas were quickly blocked in federal court for infringing on the First Amendment rights of covered tech companies.
In bid to shed light on investigation of Sen. Richard Burr, a win for access
As followers of the Reporters Committee’s work know, we think it’s important that the press and public have access to judicial records that document the government’s efforts to investigate crime. Those materials — warrants, surveillance orders and the like — play a critical role in criminal justice reporting; they also reflect the exercise of important public powers.
In one week at the US Supreme Court, state secrets prevail twice
When the U.S. Supreme Court decided to hear a pair of cases that touch on the state secrets privilege this term — United States v. Zubaydah and Federal Bureau of Investigation v. Fazaga — the likely outcome was largely written on the wall.
In Arizona, another threat to the right to record law enforcement
As the Reporters Committee has argued in brief after brief, it should be uncontroversial that the First Amendment protects your right to document what law enforcement does in public. And in many jurisdictions, it plainly does, as the U.S. Courts of Appeal for the First, Third, Fifth, Seventh, Ninth and Eleventh Circuits have all concluded.
Supreme Court should ensure First Amendment rights have remedies
The Supreme Court’s free-speech docket this term features few obvious blockbusters, unless you have strong feelings on billboard policy. But in Egbert v. Boule, a case set for argument this March, the Court will answer a somewhat arcane question that could have important consequences for press freedoms: whether federal officials can be held personally liable for damages when they retaliate against individuals for exercising First Amendment rights.
At the Supreme Court, another hint of trouble for NY Times v. Sullivan?
Predicting which petitions for review will catch the Supreme Court’s attention is always a gamble, never a science. Still, some tea leaves — if rarely decisive — at least have some grounding in empirical reality and therefore reliably raise eyebrows outside the Court. One of those signals, albeit a very, very weak one, according to a Bloomberg Law analysis, is whether the Court calls for a response to a petition when the winning party below hasn’t filed one.
With Subpoena to a Photojournalist, Jan. 6 Committee Runs Needless Risks to Press Freedom
The raft of subpoenas issued by the House panel investigating the Capitol riot has prompted, in turn, a raft of suits hoping to block the demands. But alongside the predictable lineup of plaintiffs—former National Security Advisor Michael Flynn, or former White House Chief of Staff Mark Meadows—one stands out. In Harris v.
A brewing storm over pre-publication review?
Prior restraints — regulations that purport to prohibit speech before it occurs, rather than punish it after the fact — are “the most serious and the least tolerable infringement on First Amendment rights,” or so the U.S. Supreme Court has said. But for decades the government has asserted the power to require thousands of employees, even after they leave federal service, to clear any public writing with official censors in order to scrub it for information that could harm national security.
Spyware vendors face growing backlash, legal setbacks
Selling spyware is controversial business. And for good reason: Though marketed as a means of catching criminals or terrorists, hacking tools have also been turned against reporters, dissidents and other members of civil society. (For a deep dive on those abuses, check out the stories published as part of “The Pegasus Project,” a sweeping investigative collaboration.) Growing awareness of those harms has put more and more pressure on the industry — and on government regulators.
When spurious ‘hacking’ claims chill journalism
This shouldn’t be complicated: If someone shares a website with the open internet, you have a right to read what they published. After all, permitting public access is what publishing a web page is for in the first place. But events in Missouri this month highlight that too many legal threats still hang over journalists (and others) who point out a site’s newsworthy shortcomings.
For Facebook, a week in the limelight
It’s difficult to count the number of ways Facebook made headlines last week.
Media coalition urges Supreme Court to recognize the right to record
Every federal court of appeals to address the question agrees: You have a First Amendment right to record law enforcement officials performing their duties in public.
Courts in a deepening muddle over location surveillance
When the U.S. Supreme Court decided Carpenter v. United States three years ago, ruling that the Constitution requires a warrant when law enforcement seeks historical cell-site location information, the opinion was widely greeted as a watershed — one that worked not just one but a whole “series of revolutions in Fourth Amendment law,” as Georgetown law professor Paul Ohm put it.
Florida’s ‘deplatforming’ statute suffers early setback in federal court
Florida’s charge into the field of social media regulation is on hold after a federal judge concluded that the state’s deplatforming law — familiar to readers of this newsletter — likely violates the First Amendment.
California city backs down from misguided ‘hacking’ lawsuit against bloggers
Suppose you want to visit a website to learn what might be hosted there. No one sent you an invitation or rolled out a red carpet; on the other hand, no one told you not to click, and no password stands in your way. Can you visit the URL? Phrased that way, the question likely sounds ridiculous, but it was the crux of a troubling lawsuit that the city of Fullerton brought against a group of local bloggers before changing course in a settlement this month.
Florida statute purports to regulate ‘deplatforming’
It was a Florida law granting political candidates a right to reply to unfavorable press coverage that, nearly 50 years ago, prompted the Supreme Court’s declaration in Miami Herald Publishing Co. v.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Grayson
Contact Grayson, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack