China’s chess grandmaster Ding Liren, right, and India’s chess grandmaster Gukesh Dommaraju square off at the start of the FIDE World Chess Championship in Singapore on November 25, 2023. On the contrary, Carlsen concluded, Ding seemed “permanently broken.” Ding agreed that something was very wrong. “It doesn’t seem like I’ve been playing the way I used to,” he told Singapore’s Straits Times newspaper in the lead-up to his title defence against Gukesh Dommaraju.