To read Sonia Gandhi's memoir Belonging as a political document is to miss what to me is the real story: The story of a young woman who falls in love, leaves her native land, makes another country her home and discovers, through a series of devastating losses, that she now belongs, in a very real sense, to a land she had once regarded as alien, notes Prem Panicker. IMAGE: Sonia Gandhi's memoir Belonging on sale at a bookstore in New Delhi, November 10, 2026.
Prem Panicker
As seen in:
BuzzFeed,
National Geographic,
Substack,
Firstpost,
Rediff.com,
Mint,
Mint Lounge,
Yahoo,
The Quint,
Scroll.in
and
Cogito, ergo sum confusion. I write, edit, and teach writing. I write at prempanicker.substack.com , article archives at authory.com/PremPanicker
Articles by Prem Panicker
The things we carry, the things that carry us
THERE is a house in Kozhikode that no longer exists, except in my heart. Meledath House is where I spent my formative years. It was where I learned to walk, talk, read, write, to listen to stories and in time, to tell my own. I remember every nook and cranny of that house, the trees that surrounded it, the temple tank at its boundary where I learned to swim when I was four.
Calling the bluff
THE Bharatiya Janata Party organizes its politics around a fundamental idea: that the average Indian voter has the short-term memory of a fruit fly. (Aside: Fauna with the objectively shortest working memory are almost all invertebrates. Just saying.) On 6 August 2025, during the monsoon session of Parliament, the SIR exercise in Bihar was the flashpoint.
Six feet by nine feet, 24/7
This site requires JavaScript to run correctly. Please turn on JavaScript or unblock scripts
Why Do We Need Permission to Protest Against the Government?
Before protesting against the State, the citizen should not have to ask: Sir, may I protest, please?, asserts Prem Panicker. IMAGE: Security personnel stand guard outside the Election Commission of India headquarters in New Delhi, October 9, 2026, ahead of a protest planned by the Cockroach Janta Party seeking Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar's resignation.
The Republic of Small Protests
This site requires JavaScript to run correctly. Please turn on JavaScript or unblock scripts
Beyond Rs 54,282 Crore, CAG Report Finds Government's 'Savings' Rife With Red Flags
The Wire is run by a non-profit foundation and we need your support to keep our newsroom running.
What disappeared is not money, but accountability
THE real headline number in the latest Comptroller and Auditor General report on Union expenditure is not ₹54,282 crore, though it is what most media reports have run with. The revealing number is actually ₹27.35 crore, which is what the Union government says it “saved” under the Defence Pensions Grant during 2024–25. The devil, as always, is in the detail. Go through that section and you realize that pension payments amounting to ₹3,042.32 crore have not been included under the relevant head.
Permission to dissent, sir?
A box to protest in. Photo: Manas Ranjan Bhui for The Tribune INDIA’s Constitution guarantees the right to protest. But you have to apply for police permission first. Too often these days, the response to your application is in the language of settled fact: Permission for the protest has not been granted. There will be a line or two of boilerplate attached: “internal security”, “hardship to citizens”, and suchlike formulations.
The Active Voice
Image courtesy The Guardian DHARMENDRA PRADHAN resigned on Saturday. In the calculus of this government, that sentence should not be possible. Defence Minister Rajnath Singh said as much, in so many words, smirking as though he found the whole idea of accountability risible. For twelve years, the Modi government has operated on a carefully cultivated premise: that it cannot be questioned. Modi himself set the template by refusing to attend a single press conference.
Five Young Women and the Meaning of Democracy
This morning, my timeline brought me image after image of young women showing us what true courage looks like. One placed her body between a police baton and the boys it was descending upon. Another read aloud from her Class 10 textbook — issued by the government, no less — which says that democracy is preferable because it makes rulers accountable. Then she looked up and asked the question the textbook had equipped her to ask: Where is that accountability now? What a fine young lady.
Baseball Spy, Clown Show, Running Mecca
Non-paywalled link created for The Lineup subscribers Where Have You Gone, Jackie Bradley Jr.? Okay, I missed this one the first time around but what a story. Levin is a longtime colleague and I love that he got to tell this tale, which he does brilliantly: “Jesse Cole, the 42-year-old impresario behind the Bananas, has said that relaunching the Clowns is a way to honor one of Banana Ball’s forebears and preserve the legacy of the Negro Leagues. Robinson was thrilled.
Prem Panicker (@prempanicker)
Rudyard Kipling once wrote: For the strength of the wolf is the pack, and the strength of the pack is the wolf.” I keep going back to that line when thinking of France v Spain last night — the match billed as the final before the final, and which turned into the dampest of squibs. The essential difference was that France’s brilliance was individual; Spain’s was relational.
The Air, The Water, The Walls
GO to a village in Bihar where kala-azar is common, and the disease seems to be everywhere. In the blood, in the fevers, in the spleens swollen hard under children’s ribs. But Dr Soumya Swaminathan learned to look at the walls. The sand fly that carries the parasite breeds in the cracks of mud walls. Improve the housing, and the disease begins to recede on its own, no new drug required.
Craft Essay #7: The order of revelation
Illustration by Anna Parini, courtesy The New Yorker HE wakes up at nine and has a piece of toast for breakfast. He reads the local paper, then dips into a thriller. On more ambitious mornings, he reads Freud. He has a notebook to record random thoughts in: “Deep below the rational part of our brain is an underground ocean where strange things swim.” His wife wakes later.
Craft Essay #6: The Note on the Fridge
Image courtesy The Atlantic A MAN sits in his leather chair in the dark of the night, listening to the sounds his house makes around him, as old houses will. The spine of the house is a 60-foot beam hand-carved from an ancient Douglas fir. It has held the weight of the house, and of the unnumbered families that have inhabited it at various times, for over a hundred years. He sits there in the dark, listening to the groan of the beam that feels like a commentary on the whole of his life.
Craft Essay #5: The Opening Move
Discover more from Smoke Signals Words, words, some matter from the heart Over 2,000 subscribers Already have an account? Sign in On why the best first sentences are found before you sit down to write them — and what it takes to find them Edna Buchanan caricature, courtesy The New Yorker Bad writing makes me wince. Here is how I opened a column I wrote in August 1997, not long after my father died: I guess I need to start off this one with an explanation of sorts.
Craft Essay #4: You Don't Write Place
Discover more from Smoke Signals Words, words, some matter from the heart Over 2,000 subscribers Already have an account? Sign in On how the best travel writing refuses the aerial view — and why the cup of tea, the beer glass, the man with two names, and the ginger cat do what no landscape description can Paul Salopek in Varanasi. Photo: John Stanmayer.
Craft Essay 3(A): The Hand Knows
Discover more from Smoke Signals Words, words, some matter from the heart Over 2,000 subscribers Already have an account? Sign in On what happens when you copy out a passage you love, and why the instinct to do so is already the beginning of learning to write This image is AI-generated A reader, Sailee, left a comment on the second essay in the series that is worth responding to at some length.
Essays on craft #2: The shape of catastrophe
I was seventeen, maybe eighteen, when I began teaching myself to write by taking apart other people’s writing. Not in any systematic way, but through compulsive reverse engineering. I would read something that struck me, in a newspaper or a magazine, and then sit down and rewrite it. Not to “improve” it, exactly, but more to understand how it worked, the way you might disassemble a watch to figure out how it keeps time.
India's digital dream, hacked...
Earlier this morning, I posted a twitter thread about a Bloomberg Businessweek piece that had just won the Pulitzer Prize. The piece — “India’s Digital Dream, Hacked,” by Natalie Obiko Pearson and Suparna Sharma — is about the epidemic of “digital arrest” scams sweeping India. In my thread, I made the point that the structural choices were the argument, that the form enacted the meaning.
The encore: Tamil Nadu 2026
To my considerable surprise, an August 2025 essay I wrote on the emergence of Vijay got a fresh lease of life both here and on social media in the wake of the just-concluded TN elections. I opened that piece with an anecdote: When PT Barnum was pitched the ultimate act -- a man who would commit suicide in full view of a packed stadium -- his response was: brilliant, but what will you do for an encore? That, I wrote then, was Vijay’s problem after Madurai.
War In The Strait Has Reached A Condom Factory!
Karex, the Malaysian company that makes roughly one in five of the world's condoms -- about five billion a year, supplying Durex and Trojan among others -- announced this week that it is raising prices by up to 30 percent. The reason is the Strait of Hormuz. IMAGE: The US aircraft carrier USS George H W. Bush sails in the Indian Ocean in the US Central Command area of responsibility, April 23, 2026.
Even If US, Iran Signed Deal Today, Hormuz Strait Won't...
... won't reopen for up to six months. Until then, the Strait stays nearly closed. The world pays. And no one, including the man who started this, can say when it ends, notes Prem Panicker in his must read blog on the Iran War. IMAGE: A video grab shows Iranian forces seizing container ships MSC Francesca and Epaminondas in the Strait of Hormuz during an operation aired on state television, April 22, 2026.
Trump's Blinks Bought Time, But What It Doesn't Buy...
...is a way out, notes Prem Panicker in his must read blog on the Iran War. What the indefinite extension produces is a prolonged condition of not-war-not-peace, in which oil markets cannot stabilise, Asian refineries cannot plan, European governments cannot stop subsidising consumption they cannot afford, and the next flashpoint -- a seized tanker, a miscalculated drone strike, a Truth Social post that claims too much -- is one news cycle away.
Iran Ceasefire Hours From Collapse
Trump has made it clear: The US will not lift its blockade of Iranian ports until a deal is signed. The clock ran out on easy options some time ago. What runs out on Wednesday is the last formal opportunity before both sides take the hard option, warns Prem Panicker in his must read blog on the Iran War. IMAGE: Veterans with About Face and military families protest against the Iran war at the Cannon House office building rotunda on Capitol Hill in Washington, DC, April 20, 2026.
A War With No Exit Strategy, No Victory To Declare
Both sides have now revealed a preference for escalation over strategic defeat, and each new provocation narrows the space for the next pause. The Touska seizure, Iran's refusal to negotiate under blockade, Israel's strikes on Iranian oil infrastructure -- all of these add up to an increasingly untenable situation. This makes the wild card -- Trump and his motormouth -- more consequential than ever, notes Prem Panicker in his must read blog on the Iran War.
US Needs Iran Back At The Table FAST!
The question is whether the clocks allow enough time for two deeply mistrustful sides to get there, and whether the surface calm holds long enough for the paddling to produce something before the ceasefire ends on April 22, notes Prem Panicker in his must read blog on the Iran War. IMAGE: A girl holds a flag depicting former Hezbollah leaders Hassan Nasrallah and Hashem Safieddine as displaced residents return home after a 10-day ceasefire in Sidon, Lebanon, April 17, 2026.
Hormuz Blockade Is The New Battlefield
The clock on the ceasefire is running out. But everyone's already whispering about round two, possibly as soon as this weekend. What began with airstrikes and killed leaders has settled into something slower and, in a way, more measurable: A test of who runs out of patience first, notes Prem Panicker in his must read blog on the Iran War. IMAGE: An anti-US and anti-Israel rally at Enghelab Square in Tehran, April 15, 2026.
Will Trump Attend Islamabad Peace Talks?
The intriguing bit is that Trump is likely to attend the talks in Islamabad this weekend -- if he does, it will be the clearest signal yet that the US is ready to exit the war with some sort of win to show, since he cannot afford to go for the talks and return empty-handed, notes Prem Panicker in his must read blog on the Iran War. IMAGE: United States President Donald John Trump gives a thumbs up as he arrives at the Miami international airport in Florida, April 11, 2026.
Hormuz Crisis Hits India Hard
The cost of the war is being counted not in the corridors of power in Washington or Tehran, but in Firozabad's darkened furnace rooms, Howrah's idle casting sheds, and a barbershop in Kochi where the wait is suddenly, inexplicably, an hour long, notes Prem Panicker in his must read blog on the Iran War. IMAGE: A billboard depicting the Strait of Hormuz on a building in Tehran, April 13, 2026. The fragile two-week truce between the US and Iran staggers into its second week.
US-Iran: The Weekend Has Left The World In A More Dangerous Place
The ceasefire is still technically holding, to the extent that no overt hostilities have been reported yet, but the rhetoric has hardened dangerously. The week ahead will also clarify whether the Islamabad failure was a negotiating tactic or whether Washington has genuinely locked itself into a position from which the only exits are climb-down, escalation, or the slow bleed of a new status quo that nobody chose and nobody controls. Prem Panicker continues his must read blog on the Iran War.
Don't Expect Too Much From Islamabad Summit
The core issues to be settled -- access to Hormuz, Israel's aggression in Lebanon, the question of Iran's nuclear programme, sanctions relief and compensation -- are thorny enough to require weeks of patient negotiation. The most likely outcome of the opening sessions is that both sides take the measure of each other, establish what is and is not negotiable, and return home without having broken anything. That would count as progress. Prem Panicker continues his must read blog on the Iran War.
The Clock In Islamabad Is Ticking. And The World Is Watching Anxiously...
The delegations from the US and Iran head to Islamabad on Friday, carrying a ceasefire that is already fraying, a Strait that is technically open and practically closed, and a negotiating agenda that would challenge even parties actually negotiating in good faith, which these groups are not. Prem Panicker continues his must read blog on the Iran War. IMAGE: Iranians gather at night holding placards in Arabic expressing support for the people of Lebanon.
Pakistan Was Reading From Washington's Script
Original Article Posted By: Sofia, 4/8/2026 7:55:23 AM By all available indications, the White House drafted a face-saving note and handed it, ready-made, to Islamabad. Reminder: "WE ARE A SALON AND NOT A SALOON" Your thoughts, comments, and ideas are always welcome here. But we ask you to please be mindful and respectful. Threatening or crude language doesn't persuade anybody and makes the conversation less enjoyable for fellow L.Dotters. 1 person likes this.
Iran Ceasefire: Pakistan Was Reading From Washington's Script
By all available indications, the White House drafted a face-saving note and handed it, ready-made, to Islamabad. Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif was supposed to then post it in the guise of a plea urging Trump to extend the deadline by two weeks 'to allow diplomacy to run its course'. Trump would then graciously accept Pakistan's 'request' and declare a ceasefire. Sharif dutifully posted the message on X.
What Happens When Trump's Deadline Expires?
Trump may strike. He may announce productive talks and extend again. He may do both at the same time. Iran will not open the Strait on someone else's terms, so no matter what happens, that problem will remain unsolved. And the IRGC will still be collecting its $2 million toll from every ship bold enough to ask permission to pass. Prem Panicker continues his must read blog on the Iran War.
The US Rescue That Raises More Questions Than It Answers
The 'rescue' operation occurred within kilometres of Iran's underground tunnel complex at Isfahan, assessed by the IAEA and US intelligence as holding a substantial portion of the country's 60 per cent enriched uranium stockpile. Retired senior US military officers have highlighted that the mission's footprint -- hundreds of special operators, multiple heavy-lift aircraft deep inside Iran -- appears outsized for recovering a single airman.
Pentagon Purge Rocks Iran War
The purge in Washington does not pause the war. Strikes continue, Hormuz remains closed, and Brent crude is still dancing around $109 a barrel. For India, the command chaos in the Pentagon is another layer of uncertainty piled on five weeks of conflict that was already straining every buffer Delhi has. IMAGE: A woman carries a tarpaulin at a temporary encampment for displaced people amid escalating hostilities in Beirut, Lebanon, April 1, 2026.
Trump Won't Decide What Happens Next In The War
'The next two to three weeks will not be decided in Washington.' 'They will be decided in Tehran, in whatever calculation Iran makes about the costs of continued resistance against the costs of appearing to have yielded.' IMAGE: United States President Donald John Trump addresses the nation on the Iran war, April 1, 2026.
War In The Strait Of Hormuz Has Landed On A Tawa In Mumbai
The LPG squeeze on India's restaurant sector is the quotidian face of a deeper crisis. Prem Panicker continues his must read daily blog on the Gulf War. IMAGE: Long queues outside an LPG agency in Bhoiwada, central Mumbai, as residents -- especially women -- wait for cylinder delivery, March 31, 2026. Given his wild rhetorical swings, it is a wonder that Donald Trump doesn't suffer from chronic whiplash.
The Gulf War: What's Pakistan Up To?
Egypt, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and Turkey met in Islamabad in what analysts say is the formal opening of a new diplomatic formation that could reshape the post-war regional order. Their immediate goal is a ceasefire; their larger ambition is to ensure that neither Iran nor Israel emerges from this war in a dominant position. Pakistan's foreign minister then flew directly to Beijing and mooted a Chinese role as guarantor of any eventual agreement.
The Gulf War: Prem Panicker' Must Read Blog!
Prem Panicker's Must Read Blog On The Gulf War: The New Fog of War Has US Repeated Its Iraq Mistake? Hormuz Crisis Threatens Global Economy Iran War Exposes Washington's Strategic Chaos Iran Plays Hardball With India's Hormuz Requests Trump Is Caught Between Two Bad Options Iran Rewrites Rules of War Why Did Israel Kill Ali Larijani? Trump's War Has Crossed Energy Rubicon.
Does The US Plan To Continue This War For 'One Or Two Years'?
This weekend, Donald Trump has begun to say the quiet part out loud -- that he wants to take control of Iran's oil, a formulation more in line with his robber-baron style of international relations. Prem Panicker continues his must read daily blog on the Gulf War. IMAGE: A ship burns after Iranian explosive-laden boats reportedly attacked two fuel tankers in Iraqi waters, setting them ablaze amid the ongoing conflict, March 12, 2026.
Gulf War: US, Israel Didn't Expect This To Happen
The United States, which entered this war in expectation of a short, sharp win along the Venezuela model, is now preparing for deeper involvement in a conflict it does not fully control, without the allies it typically relies on, against an adversary that is not behaving as expected, in a global environment that is already absorbing economic shock. Prem Panicker continues his must read daily blog on the Gulf War.
Will Trump Send Troops To Iran By The Weekend?
Taking Kharg would give the US control over virtually all of Iran's oil exports and thus provide significant leverage, notes Prem Panicker in his must read daily blog on the Gulf War. It would also put American troops within range of Iran's remaining missiles, drones, and artillery on a piece of real estate that is just eight square miles in size, and just 15 miles from the Iranian mainland.
Trump's Pause Gives Iran NOTHING! Original
The pause gives the US time to breathe, to regroup, to move its expeditionary force into position without risk of interception along the way. It gives Iran nothing -- on the ground, attacks against its infrastructure continue apace. Prem Panicker in his must read daily blog on the Gulf War. IMAGE: A map showing the Strait of Hormuz and a 3D-printed miniature model depicting US President Donald Trump.
Will Trump's 5 Day Pause End The War On Friday?
'Was the five-day pause ever meant to hold, or was it simply another instrument of signaling, of positioning, of buying time in a war where even the pauses are tactical?' asks Prem Panicker in his must read daily blog on the Gulf War. IMAGE: An Iranian missile carrying cluster munitions flies towards central Israel, March 5, 2026. Some wars escalate in bombing raids, and erupting fires and body bags, others in signals. The last 24 hours was a mix of both.
Gulf War: Hormuz Is Becoming The Central Battlefield
The question is no longer whether the war will expand. It has. The next few days will tell us whether the war stabilises around Hormuz or whether the Strait itself becomes the trigger for a far larger rupture. What to watch for over the next 48 hours is simple: Any move by the US toward direct naval control of the Strait; any credible Iranian attempt to disrupt or mine shipping lanes and, critically, whether energy infrastructure in the Gulf continues to be targeted.
War Exposes Cracks in US-Israel Alliance
Alliances fight wars effectively only when they share an endgame. If Israel acted without US knowledge, then the military alliance is operating without real coordination at the level of strategic targeting. Neither picture is reassuring in a war that is no longer regional in its consequences. Prem Panicker continues his must read daily blog on the Gulf War. IMAGE: Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu speaks during a press conference in Jerusalem, March 19, 2026.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Prem
Contact Prem, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack