Stel dat Schopenhauer gelijk heeft en het leven één voortdurende slingerbeweging is tussen pijn en verveling. De enorme materiële overvloed van de rijke geïndustrialiseerde samenleving heeft weliswaar een pijnstillende werking (er is simpelweg minder fysieke pijn dan vroeger, toen we fluoride, anesthesie noch een zittend leven hadden), maar de oplossing van het ene probleem lijkt het andere alleen maar te verergeren.
Stuart Whatley
Verified
Senior Editor @prosyn | Co-author, "How to Think About Progress" (link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-031-68938-3) | @stuartwhatley.bsky.social
Articles by Stuart Whatley
Will Big AI save the world?
aidogeElon MuskFuturismHG WellsSocietyUS “The government knows AGI is coming”, the New York Times’s Ezra Klein tells us, “and we’re not prepared in part because it’s not clear what it would mean to prepare”. We’ve all heard of these prognostications by now. On one end of the spectrum are “Doomers” who warn that “the most likely result of building a superhumanly smart AI, under anything remotely like the current circumstances, is that literally everyone on Earth will die”.
Manifest tehnorealistov
»Preprečevanje staranja in zdravljenje raka bosta pravzaprav enostavna,« trdi David Sinclair, raziskovalec staranja na Univerzi Harvard. Podobno tudi Elon Musk še naprej zatrjuje, da bo kmalu peljal ljudi na Mars in da bodo robotski taksiji v množični uporabi. Velike korporacije so si zastavile cilje glede ogljične nevtralnosti, ki temeljijo na zelo optimističnih napovedih o tehnoloških možnostih odstranjevanja ogljika.
The techno-realist manifesto
“It’s actually going to be easy to cure aging and cancer,” insists David Sinclair, a researcher on aging at Harvard University. Similarly, Elon Musk continues to claim that he will soon land humans on Mars and deploy robotaxis en masse. Major corporations have set carbon-neutrality targets based on highly optimistic forecasts about the potential of carbon-removal technologies.
The Techno-Realist Manifesto
HAMILTON — "It's actually going to be easy to cure aging and cancer," insists David Sinclair, a researcher on aging at Harvard University. Similarly, Elon Musk continues to claim that he will soon land humans on Mars and deploy robotaxis en masse. Major corporations have set carbon-neutrality targets based on highly optimistic forecasts about the potential of carbon-removal technologies.
El manifiesto tecno-realista
“En realidad, va a ser fácil curar el envejecimiento y el cáncer”, insiste David Sinclair, investigador sobre el envejecimiento en la Universidad de Harvard. En la misma sintonía, Elon Musk sigue afirmando que pronto hará que seres humanos aterricen en Marte y desplegará robotaxis en masa. Las grandes empresas han fijado objetivos de neutralidad de carbono basados en previsiones muy optimistas sobre el potencial de las tecnologías de eliminación del carbono.
How to Think About Progress, excerpt
How to Think about Progress: A Skeptic's Guide to Technology Nicholas Agar, Stuart Whatley & Dan Weijers 250 pages, Springer, 2024 Buy the book » Writing during the COVID-19 pandemic, and amid another wave of hype about the potential of new technologies to solve humanity’s biggest problems, our goal for How to Think About Progress: A Skeptic’s Guide to Technology was to offer principles for thinking about the future.
How to Think about Progress
Overview Offers accessible philosophical skepticism about too much optimism on technological progress Accessibly written high profile thought pieces Challenges the popular suggestion that we seek technological fixes for the climate crisis and pandemics Part of the book series: Library of Ethics and Applied Philosophy (LOET, volume 42) How to Think about Progress is an interdisciplinary work exploring whether optimistic claims about technology’s potential stand up to humanity’s most difficult...
The delusion of having a meaningful job
aid workersCapitalismFaithImmanuel KantNietzschenonePhilosophyStoicism I suspect Montaigne was being coy when he complained of the “wild and useless weeds” that would encroach on his mind in idleness. It is to those wild shoots that Montaigne owed his genre-defining essais, and thus his lasting influence. Spontaneous growth testifies to fertile ground, which is certainly better than the alternatives. One alternative is a barren mind.
The Dream Economy
AUGUST 24, 2021 RICHARD BRANSON, the billionaire founder of Virgin Galactic, recently “made history” by becoming the first private citizen to launch himself into space (beating Amazon founder Jeff Bezos to the punch). But so what? The Soviets launched the first man into space 60 years ago. Among those advancing the technological frontier, Elon Musk is far more ambitious.
Should We Drop the War Metaphor?
Arguments Why we shouldn’t assume a war footing in addressing big societal problems, like COVID, for which we can’t define the terms of victory. By Stuart Whatley Nicholas Agar from July 8, 2021, 3:24 pm – 11 MIN READ Tagged COVID-19LanguagepandemicWar Although he abhorred war, Ernest Hemingway accepted that “once you are forced into it, for whatever reason it may be, you have to win it.” Left unspecified is what winning a war actually entails.
The Inflection Pointillists
JUNE 18, 2021 THE RAPID DEVELOPMENT of COVID-19 vaccines has inaugurated a new era of hope in technology’s potential to improve the world.
Project Syndicate Commentators’ Best Reads in 2020
Photo: Depositphotos.com/olegkrugllyak Daron Acemoglu Andrew Marantz, Antisocial: Online Extremists, Techno-Utopians, and the Hijacking of the American Conversation, Penguin Books, 2020. Although I did not expect to love this book when I picked it up, I found it to be one of the best recent accounts of how social media has come to dominate political discourse in the United States.
Opinion: Technology will not save us Original
Nicholas Agar is a professor of philosophy at Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand. Stuart Whatley is a senior editor at Project Syndicate. The views expressed in this commentary belong to the authors. View more opinion at CNN. (CNN)Nearly a year after the novel coronavirus first emerged, news that scientists have developed several effective Covid-19 vaccines has been widely celebrated.
After Cosmopolitanism
Like globalist, cosmopolitan has become a freighted term, not least for its anti-Semitic undertones. On the right, it is an epithet for bleeding-heart liberals who support looser immigration policies, foreign aid, and multilateral efforts to confront climate change. On the left (and the nativist right), it is used to describe the Davos crowd and footloose capitalists. But as the philosopher Martha C.
Living with Minimalism”
FEBRUARY 10, 2020 WHY DOES ONE spring clean, declutter, or otherwise slough off the collected detritus of bygone years? To free up space for more, newer stuff, of course. But minimizing one thing also can help to maximize something else: less work means more free time; fewer possessions means less upkeep.
Is Growth Moral?
Book Reviews Yes, economic growth is necessary. But does it produce a just society? By Stuart Whatley from December 10, 2019, 4:48 pm – 14 MIN READ Tagged EconomicsgrowthTyler Cowen Thorstein Veblen Thorstein Veblen’s The Theory of the Leisure Class has always been remembered more for the phrase “conspicuous consumption” than for its broader argument. Yet Veblen made a useful contribution to an ongoing debate about the ends and means of economic growth.
The Story of the Smallpox Vaccines and Its Lessons for Today
Pox: An American History, by Michael Willrich (New York: Penguin Press, 2011, ISBN 9781594202865) 400 pp. Cloth, $27.95. During the first years of the twentieth century, smallpox, that most feared of scourges, became known as the “fool killer.” One simply had no excuse for catching it anymore. Any physician worth his salt knew the clinical progression of the disease and the efficacy of vaccination in warding against it.
Don’t Let the Last Crisis Go to Waste
Arguments Democrats need a concrete plan for the next financial crisis; one that keeps in mind past mistakes and does not cow-tow to deficit hawks. By Stuart Whatley from November 15, 2018, 5:54 pm – 9 MIN READ Tagged DemocratsEconomicsFinancial crisisInequalityRepublicansTrump Administration Photo by how are things on the west coast? via CC 2.0 Now that Democrats have reclaimed the U.S. House of Representatives, the jostling over policy and political priorities has begun.
Who’s Afraid of Ocasio-Cortez?
Arguments Having subscribed to the doctrine of “disaster capitalism,” critics of Western democratic socialism fear a storming of the Winter Palace, simply because that is what they would do.
A Modest Proposal: Tax Worthlessness
Arguments How some economists are looking for ways to reduce the “material incentives” of pursuing lucrative but destructive professions. By Stuart Whatley from August 20, 2018, 4:25 pm – 12 MIN READ Tagged LaborleisurePhilosophy Photo by thetaxhaven via CC 2.0 “The whole of economic life is a mixture of creative anddistributive activities.
Dignity Included
There is a straightforward moral case for Washington, D.C.’s Initiative 77, a ballot measure that would raise the minimum wage for restaurant servers and other tipped workers from $3.33 to $15 per hour by 2025. Elise Gould and David Cooper of the Economic Policy Institute have marshaled ample evidence to show that the current tip-wage structure contributes to racial and gender inequities, poverty, and widespread wage theft.
Digital Capitalism’s War on Leisure
Last July, a paper by Mark Aguiar et al. made waves by attributing 23-46 percent of the 12 percent decline in work hours among predominantly low-skill males aged 21-30 to improvements in video-gaming technology. That hypothesis offended the sensibilities of anyone who believes that all those who are able to work should do so. But what if it misses a larger point about the changing patterns of work and leisure?
The Future of Leisure
Over the past few years, publications, consulting companies, and think tanks have been wringing their hands with increasing urgency over the “the future of work.” Politico Magazine recently dedicated an issue to it, whereas Quartz has dedicated an entire vertical. McKinsey and Co. routinely releases new reports about it. Even Nature has published a series of essays on the topic.
Quando la fortuna volta le spalle ai populisti
Niccol? Machiavelli credeva che si potesse diventare principe ?per virt? o per fortuna?. Nel secondo caso, i principi che detengono il potere ?con poca fatica diventano, ma con assai si mantengono?. Machiavelli avrebbe potuto cos? descrivere la premier britannica Theresa May e il presidente americano Donald Trump. Si sono entrambi convinti della loro principesca virt?, pur salendo al potere soprattutto per fortuna. Nulla togliendo alla lunga carriera di politico e pubblico funzionario, la May non ?
Il circo volante di Donald Trump
Innanzitutto, Trump ha scioccato tutti prendendo la sfacciata decisione di licenziare James Comey, direttore dell’Fbi, il quale aveva ventilato l’ipotesi che Trump avesse ostacolato la giustizia. Tale ipotesi aveva preso corpo quando, a febbraio, era emerso che Trump aveva chiesto a Comey (da cui aveva preteso una promessa di fedelt? a livello personale) di abbandonare la sua indagine sui presunti legami tra alcuni governi stranieri e l’ex consigliere per la sicurezza nazionale Michael Flynn.
Cozying Up to the Christian Right | The Baffler
Welcome to This American Carnage, your weekly slice of life from the country of Trump. Donald Trump’s first hundred days in office may be a disaster for the country, but for that pocket of conservative Christians worried about the ease of religiously motivated discrimination, it’s proving to be a breath of fresh air. Though uncertain, early indications suggest that the president will keep his slew of campaign promises to the Christian right.
The Philistine Factory | Stuart Whatley
“The life of observation, meditation, cogitation, and speculation pursued as an end in itself is the proper life of man. From reason moreover proceeds the proper control of the lower elements of human nature—the appetites and the active, motor, impulses.” Our epistemologically challenged, boastfully unlettered new president has, not surprisingly, thrown didactic statesmanship out the window.
Breadwinners, Breadlosers
Like a malevolent Mr. Magoo, Donald Trump continues to barrel incompetently, obtusely, and conveniently into economic windfalls. The United States Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) recently reported the lowest unemployment rate since 2007. At 4.6 percent, the American economy is at “full employment” by most economists’ standard. Trump will undoubtedly tout these monthly job numbers as they remain strong, or even improve, in 2017. (He will also, undoubtedly, withhold due credit to his predecessor).
Workaday Woes | Stuart Whatley
In Keep the Aspidistra Flying, George Orwell describes advertising firms as “the fungi . . . that sprout from a decaying capitalism.” The same might well be said for American equity funds, 90 percent of which underperformed the market last year. And yet, for most people then and now, gainful employment in utterly useless professions is considered a worthwhile aspiration, not least because it demonstrates a hearty work ethic, and thus strong moral fiber.
Like Uber-but for Dog Crap
Late Thursday afternoon, at the close of my workday, a strange subject heading appeared in my inbox: “Pooper. The latest app to push the boundaries of the sharing economy.” Although I read precisely none of the dozens of press releases that flood my inbox each week (I am a former newspaper reporter), seeing the word “poop” so close to “sharing economy” compelled me to click through.
Entertain Yourself
SOME SCHOLARS BELIEVE THAT BOREDOM is a modern condition — a byproduct of the standardized “clock time” ushered in by industrial capitalism, starting in the 18th century. Paradoxically, time-use studies in recent decades find increased boredom in leisure activities, a finding akin to the ubiquitous complaint of “busyness” in an era of unprecedented technologically driven productivity and automation.
Dangerous Designs on (AP) American History
Any city upon a hill invariably rests on a mound of bullshit, and the extent to which one knows it depends largely on one’s willingness to inhale through his or her nose. In this sense, we might simplify the ongoing debate over the College Board’s updated AP U.S. History framework as a debate over whether or not public schools should be cultivating future generations of mouth-breathers.
The Nuances of Nonbelief
The fact that alleged Chapel Hill shooter Craig Hicks is a professed atheist, according to mostly unrequited and pathetic overtures on his Facebook page, has overwhelmed media outlets with giddy fascination. It has also exposed troubling contradictions in how the media often covers religion—or, in this case, the lack thereof.
Show More
loading
Actions
Get in touch with Stuart
Contact Stuart, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack