John Early has played a lot of flagrantly narcissistic, psychotic gay guys. Elliot Goss of Search Party. Terry Goon of Stress Positions. A heightened version of himself in his and frequent collaborator/Maddie’s Secret co-star Kate Berlant’s comedy special, Would It Kill You to Laugh?. In season three of The Comeback, he branched out by playing a psychotic straight guy, then did it again in his recent stage debut: Wallace Shawn’s off-Broadway play, What We Did Before Our Moth Days.