Caneel Bay as seen from the Northshore Rd on St. John. (Source photo by Amy H. Roberts) If you assumed the National Park Service was moving forward with its 2023 plan to rebuild Caneel Bay Resort on St. John, you may be in for a shock. The 2023 plan has been replaced, and the new plan lifts numerous constraints on prospective developers and removes all requirements for public access mandated under the former plan.